Sauce is the best! Fast and friendly service, best location in my book. Friendly manager, checked on us and carried a conversation. Nutty idea pizza is the best read more

If you need things that are specifically gluten free, this is not the place for a single person to go. If you have an autoimmune disorder that you're not allowed to have nightshades this is not the place to go. They do not have anything to fit a specialized diet. Hit up MOD Pizza. read more

Love this place. Awesome Caroli's and Pizza. Download coupon for extra savings. They also have specials during the week.

Yummy and homemade thick style noodles! The raviolis were amazing too! Our waitress was great too. No wait time read more

Roma Evans - a plate of pasta and bread on a table - Italian Near Me - Evans, Colorado

See all

My MIL ordered a couple of pizzas for us on 12/16/20. She said the person taking the order had to ask for her card three times. When we got the pizza home, we all attempted to take a slice and the toppings slid right off and we were just left holding the limp crust. It might have been funny had we all not been so hungry. Taking pizza from a four year old is not pleasant but we reassured her we would order more from blackjack pizza but that she'd have to be patient while they made it for us. My husband and I returned the pizzas and he said he was told that we should have let the pizzas cool for a while before eating them. Cool for a while?!?! Dumbest excuse for an inferiorly made pizza that I ever heard. If you go to a restaurant and order a hot meal, do you sit there letting it cool for a while before you eat it? No, you don't---You eat your meal while it's hot, otherwise you might as well just order a salad. On the plus side, they did refund the cost of the pizzas to my MIL's credit card. read more

Great service and great pizza! Great for kids too. They give the kids a bit of pizza dough to play with.

Had this yesterday. Bbq chicken add gorgonzola and banana peppers. It was small and undercooked. It was light on bbq sauce and had white onions instead of red. The additional toppings were minuscule and mostly in one place. Was better the last time I was here, don't know what happened. What was there was tasty, but SO stingy and poorly executed. read more

Their pizza is always delicious! The bbq chicken is the best one in my opinion. Friendly and nice staff always make our experience enjoyable. read more

The pizza we ordered for take out was not ready I. The allotted time as stated when the phone order was placed. The pizza had less than acceptable amount of toppings. Will not eat at any of their locations again. read more

For those of you who are curious if Roma is good: In my opinion their best quality is their marinara sauce. Anything it touches turns to gold. They have thick pasta noodles that are more delicious than other places And I like to order their margarita pizza because it smells and tastes so good. When you get quality it's nice to taste the simple things. Unfortunately I don't have any photos of this food because I am too excited to eat it. Going in for all you can eat pasta today. One way you could improve in my opinion is to use fancier cups for drinking. They are like the buffet style ones. (: read more

Went on a Tuesday night when they advertise all you can eat spaghetti for $4.50. NOT impressed. Gave me a plate of spaghetti that didn't have enough sauce so we asked for more. When we went to leave they had charged us an extra $1.50 for the little bowl of sauce they gave us. Waitress claimed it was considered a side order even though we explained that the plate of spaghetti did not have enough sauce but she kept arguing with me about it. Makes no sense to me. I could have eaten 10 plates of spaghetti if I wanted because it was all you can eat - I ate 1 plate and you are arguing about giving me a little bit of sauce! Not too smart - you've lost a customer over $1.50! read more

Roma Evans - Italian Near Me - Evans, Colorado

Been there a couple of times & they have great food & their customer service is great . Sure do miss not being able to come in to Dine there but hopefully sometime soon you will reopen again . Looking forward to coming out there again to eat at your restaurant. read more

I bought 5 buckets of spaghetti and spent $214. When I got home and separated out the noodles and sauce, I noticed I got enough sauce to barely fill a regular jar of spaghetti. Called the store and told them they shorted me two meatballs and I got no sauce. On the phone they were great. No problem come in and we will take care of you. I arrive and they try to charge me another $24 for the shorted meatballs and sauce. The girl said the "kitchen" is weird about the sauce. It was two young kids with hats backwards running the show in the kitchen. The food is always great but the attitude of service is severely lacking. I would not return to this location. They gave me a couple of bread dipping sauces and I left with not near enough sauce for the 20 helpings of spaghetti I bought. I ended up calling the location on 59th and 10th and they were amazing. I bought extra sauce and bought more meatballs and sausage because of the service. I threw out the couple of dipping sauces Evans gave me out of fear of them contaminating the food after the silliest altercation for no reason. All I wanted was what I paid for. $214 of spaghetti with meat and sauce. Nothing more. read more

I was really confused when me and my wife went In there to eat on a trusday and received, my bill and I seen a convince fee on my ticket? What is this all about? Pretty disappointed about this. Sure we won't me going back. And I loved this place. read more

This is for the service. I was in last week, and I was having a bad day. Broke my mug at work, was coming down with a sore throat, etc. Well as I was getting ready to pay, I realized that my day was a bit worse than I thought, I had forgotten my wallet at work. So I offered my phone as hostage, and Kayla was understanding, and took me at my word that I'd be back after work to pay my tab, she didn't even take the phone. She made a horrible day, slightly better, I cannot say enough good things about her. read more

I arrived to pick up my order when I was told to do so, but still had to wait 15 minutes. Not a big deal...stuff happens. When I finally got my order home, I cut open the caroli to realize they had given me the wrong order. Frustrating...but we all mistakes. When I called, I was told that I could come pick up a new one, but when I arrived they said they had found my original order. I protested that it had now been over an hour and would like a new caroli and/or my money back, but I was told that I had to take the old one because it was "still warm". In fact, it was burnt on the bottom from resting on top of the oven for so long. In the end, I just threw it away because it was so dry and overcooked. Everyone makes mistakes. A good business admits and corrects them. A bad business pretends like they never happened. I will be spending my money elsewhere from now on, and I suggest that you do the same. read more

The service was excellent, the prices were good, the portions were large, the food was pretty bland. We tried 3 different carolis (their recipes, we didn't create our own), cheese bread, and pepperoni bread. The cheese bread had a heavy olive oil taste, and very much lacked butter and garlic. The carolis were stuffed with so much cheese it over powered any flavor from the other ingredients. The pepperoni bread was supposed to be on garlic bread, again you can't taste garlic or spices. The sauce was very thin, so when you dipped your caroli, it just wet it without giving it any more flavor that it needed. Overall, I probably won't go back if it were my choice but I'd try it again if a friend wanted to go. Everything needs more garlic and spices. So if you want great service and 'okay' food this is your place! read more

Roma Evans - Pepperoni bread - Italian Near Me - Evans, Colorado

After a long day spent at UNC getting our daughter ready for college we were all starving. We definitely had pizza on our minds so we decided to stop at Roma's and the minute we walked in we felt so welcomed. Our server Russ was especially good to us! And the food was delicious!!! We live in Thornton but we will be making a lot of trips to Greeley for our daughters college and this is one place we will always go to! Thanks Russ for your service! read more

I eat here a few times a month. The food is always prepared properly and tastes great. The service is always superb. Allison, Chrissy, Tiffany, Savannah and all the rest are great. I always recommend this Roma. read more

We love the original down off of 8th Ave so we figured we'd try this one since it was close. We ordered a large pizza for over $20. When we went to go pick it up, the toppings were skimpy!! Hardly any sauce and our crust was burnt. We tried calling and no answer. I wrote an email to the restaurant and had no reply. Expensive crappy food and terrible customer service. read more

I really enjoy this place. The pizza and carolis are consistently good. Any of the specialties with cream cheese are really really good and my boyfriend loves the nutty idea with the cashews , which is pretty good. Before you go check the website for deals and coupons. read more

This has a always been one of our favorite places to eat. Love the food and the waitresses there are great. We usually find it a really relaxing place to eat. The last 2 times we have been there we haven't even been able to talk to each other due to a kitchen manager, Mike, who is there and seems to be doing nothing but messing around. He is extremely loud and really ruined our meal time. I hope this is an issue that will be addressed as I would hate to have to stop eating here. I really want to go back to a 5 star rating! read more

Was in the mood for Italian and thought we'd try Roma. I'm not sure if this would be considered "authentic" pasta and I've just had "Americanized" pasta my while life but we were not impressed by the pastas. We each had the Trio and the pasta was mush, more like the texture of overlooked homemade eggs noodles. Staff was extremely friendly and on top of it. Maybe the pizza is better, which we will try next time. read more

After a bad experience at the 10th street location last week, I'm much more impressed with this location. Much friendlier service. Might actually come back. read more

2/13/16 The service and food is excellent at the Evans location. So glad we found you thanks to our friends who moved to Greeley...Ana!!! Everything we ordered was perfect! read more

We went on Valentine's Day. They messed up my order so no dinner for me. I watched everyone else at the table eat, and they were finished eating before my correct order arrived. I do not recommend unless you enjoy missing dinner. read more

Went here with my husband the other night and got white pizza! It was amazing! The cheeses and sauces are great! He got a calzone (caroli) which he loved as well! Later at work a coworker got the Cannoli and it was amazing! We will be back!!! It has a five kind of feel to it which is fun to me! read more

Roma Is a great place for pizza and beer only if you were looking for on authentic Italian place forget it the pasta was like old frozen grandmas noodles with Ragu the meatballs were very good aside The salad before the dressing was bag salad sprinkled with a measly topping of mozzarella with two little sorry looking pepperonis and their signature Italian dressing which sets most Italian restaurants A part was simply Wishbone Italian dressing how offensive !!!!!!!!!! This place has the nerve to masquerade as an Italian restaurant when they don't even carry Pepperoncinis , When I asked for them with my salad the waitress looked at me like I was a Martian !!!!! But the biggest offense of all was when I asked for meat sauce with my pasta she said they simply do not have it !!!!! Unacceptable for any restaurant that claims to be Italian the meat sauce is a prime ingredient in authentic Italian food, The garlic bread was soggy and smothered with margarine not even real butter frozen garlic bread would have been better. So to the people of Roma in Evans Colorado you really do need to do a better job with your pasta dishes it's pathetic maybe the people out here in the dirt in the sticks do not know any better or simply cannot get any better you have a very nice restaurant and could be packing it out day in and day out with a few changes I am a food lover first and a lifelong food critic I do not take pleasure in talking bad about restaurants but when something is not right it's simply an opportunity to make a good thing excellent, with that being said the price point of the items were right on the menu was clear the ordering was easy , read more

I'm not a hater but maybe the cooks shouldn't smoke so much weed before they show up for work so they can tell the difference between sun dried tomatoes and roasted red peppers, and cooked vs raw pizza dough..Roma's failed me!!!!! Combined with a shitty attitude from the waitress, I walked out. I'll stick to the better location! read more

Good pizza, made an order and forgot coupon at home so they charged me an extra 20$ I am very disappointed