Just before Christmas I went to dinner with my family at Rodney's in Irwin. We went on a Monday just after 6 pm. It was busy but we were seated right away. Our server was great! The portions here are huge and hearty! You get a lot of bang for your buck. What we ordered: -Stuffed Banana Peppers - these were HUGE and were really tasty! Definitely found a new fav appetizer -Fettucine du-Marie alfredo with jumbo tiger shrimp & scallops - I have to admit that I have not had an alfredo that is better than my homemade sauce, BUT this still hit the spot. The seafood portions were generous. -Side Caesar salad (comes with the pasta dish) - really big portion for a side salad which was nice! I liked that they added hard boiled eggs. Pretty good for a side salad. -Winter lemon drop cocktail - refreshing! Love a lemon drop -Complementary bread - yummy & loved that it was toasted -Pork chop & fried jumbo shrimp - my family's orders. I tried one of the fried shrimp and it was good! -Not pictured but my dad got the black angus strip - he ordered it rare but said it was a little overcooked. He said it was just good. He is a steak snob though. Overall this is a good spot for a solid meal if you find yourself in Irwin! read more

See all

If you find yourself in Irwin, PA and want a meal that never disappoints, Rodney's is the place to go. Every time. Let's start with the fried portobello mushrooms--they are absolutely out of this world. Perfectly crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and packed with flavor. Honestly, they're worth the trip alone. The portions at Rodney's are no joke either. The club sandwich is huge--stacked high, fresh, and exactly what a great club should be. And the Italian sandwich? Completely packed. Every bite is bold, hearty, and overflowing with classic Italian deli flavors. The atmosphere is a charming blend of an elevated restaurant and a cozy diner--comfortable, unpretentious, and welcoming in the best way. The staff is friendly and relaxed... maybe a bit too relaxed at times, but honestly, that's part of the charm. It never took away from the experience; if anything, it made the meal feel even more easygoing and enjoyable. Rodney's is one of those reliable hometown staples where you know you're going to get a great meal, generous portions, and a laid-back vibe. A true Irwin favorite. read more

Handsome husband and I went here because we had a gift card. The fried zucchini and Reuben were decent but I don't really get the hype. Your typical standard American fare/ food menu selection. For two people with more eclectic palates, there was nothing too exciting on the menu to entice us to return. read more

Rodney's Restaurant - Fried Zucchini - American Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

See all

We had a fantastic lunch today. We made a reservation for 12 and they were able to accommodate a last minute change to 15. The service was extremely fast considering our group size. We arrived around 1115 and were done eating by noon. The food was very good. The fish sandwich and pierogis were the popular choice since it was a Friday during lent. Both were delicious. I ordered a chicken salad - the grilled chicken was seasoned well and cooked perfectly. The salad was a great mix of veggies and accompaniments. We had a long table in the back room, so it was quiet for our group. Great option! read more

We went for lunch and it was good. I had the Reuben and fries and liked it. This place always seems to be busy which is a good indicator. I was surprised how many cars were there when I pulled in at 1:30 in the afternoon. Although, our service was quick and they were well staffed. read more

This was our first visit to Rodney's, and we went on the recommendation of some trusted friends. It was a weekday early-evening visit, and we were able to get right in. The service was split between two waitresses, and they did a pretty good job. I really liked the atmosphere of the place, and found it very clean--even the bathroom! The food was good, with only a couple things we found issue with. For meals, we had the Chicken Marsala which was good. Wife had the Chicken Milanese, which was good, but was very dry. It was supposed to come with the lemon butter caper sauce, and the only thing there really was on it was the capers with a hint of lemon in the background. The sauce was nowhere to be found. It was good enough to try again next time, though, but we'd ask to possibly go a little heavier on the sauce. She had to ask for a cup of sauce to go on the pasta that came with it, that was also found to be very bland and dry. Once it got hit with some spaghetti sauce, though, it was good. Both of us had a French Onion soup, and it was pretty decent. Daughter had a steak hoagie, and found it to be mostly bread. Probably wouldn't get that again. Other daughter had the Firecracker Chicken sandwich, and loved it. Youngest had a small pizza to herself, and loved it. Guest with us had a Spaghetti with Meatball, and loved it *eventually*, but had to ask for more sauce as the pasta was pretty dry once it was mixed up--it definitely needed more sauce on it. Overall, we want to go back and try some other things. We also want to get a chance to try the dessert menu--it looked phenomenal! read more

See all

If I could give this place and their owner 0 stars I would! Do NOT use them for wedding catering unless you want poor service, missing food, and NO accountability from a very angry and insecure owner. The catering staff did not provide the requested dietary restricted meals to my 5 guests who needed them, many people had plates served to them that were missing sides, and possibly worst of all was the fact that the catering staff never cut my wedding cake and instead left it sitting out until 10 PM, having wasted $300 worth of cake. You would think as the owner that hearing this would make you upset, but instead I got called a liar and was told that I am just looking for things to nitpick to get money back. Luckily I'm the type of person who never deletes anything and who always has documentation to back what she says, that I was able to prove I am not a liar and I was issued a slight refund for my inconvenience. After spending over $5000 for Wedding catering getting $430 back is just a drop in the bucket when the experience is this awful. If anybody is looking for catering in the Irwin/new Stanton/Greensburg area I urge you to steer clear of Rodneys. read more

Stopped by for some takeout on a road trip. I was able to order online and pick it up on time. The food quality was great, with perfectly cooked fish along with creamy mashed potatoes and veggies. Would recommend this dish. While we didn't eat there, the inside of the restaurant had many patrons and it looked clean. The parking lot is large. read more

Rodney's Restaurant - Citrus Salmon - American Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

Great food, especially at the price. Katie gave us excellent service. This was our first time, and we will definitely be back!

This restaurant was quite a nice surprise. We just thought it was another Italian restaurant in an area that seemed to have quite a few. When pulling in we saw the parking lot was packed & worried for a minute that we wouldn't get a table. No problem! We were seated promptly in a back room that appeared to be used mostly for large groups. Another surprise. A special Monday night pasta menu with 4 choices for only $11.95. I ordered the angel hair pasta topped with hot sausage stuffed banana peppers. So good! I'm not always a fan of tomato sauce since I prefer my husband's. This was really good. The banana pepper and hot sausage added a nice kick to the meal. I started with a bowl of French onion soup that was loaded with big pieces of onions. Only complain here was the melted cheese did not cover the top of the bowl. No room for dessert. Topping to the meal, excellent service all while they were also setting up for a huge group that was coming in as we were wrapping up. 2024-54 read more

See all

The first time we drove to Rodney's the parking lot was so full we went home. This time, we made a reservation. We were a little early but were seated right away. The dining room is cozy but not crowded which I really liked. I had the lobster pot pie which had a tail in it! The meat was tender and flavorful. The mashed potatoes were a little lack luster but the pot pie was the star of the show. We also had Cajun Chicken Tortellini and French onion soup. Since it was a special occasion we made sure to save room for dessert. We had red velvet cheese cake which was good and crème brûlée which was fantastic! read more

See all

A new favorite. We've known of Rodney's for a while but now, after learning of their gluten free selections, including some desserts, it will now become a regular staple. Everything that our family has had there has been bountiful and tasty. That includes the extensive cocktail menu and desserts. The service is also top notch. Definitely suggest the coconut shrimp and calzones. Give them a try! Definitely worth it. read more

I've eaten here many, many times it's a local place to eat. Food is good sometimes better than others. It's close so I probably go there because of the convenience. Servers have always been very good. read more

I haven't been to Rodney's in years and after tonight's dinner, I am sorry I waited so long. We were a party of 20 and all the food came at the same time and all the meals were hot. My Fettuccine Du-Marie was fantastic and everyone else enjoyed their dinners as well. Can't wait to go back. read more

I wish I had read the reviews before going. Welcome to Costco restaurant complete with tacky 80's music. There is only one choice for glasses of wine, that is the house wine, otherwise order a bottle. High priced and not worth the trip. I went for lunch to give it a try before doing dinner. I was not brought a glass of water, the bread was a hoagie they obviously make there sandwiches with. It was not even cut up, and no dipping oil. Instead you received butter in small plastic cubes. I ordered the ravioli, and salad would be extra. No homemade dressings to pick from, if I did order the salad, with my meal it would have been $4.00 extra. The grated cheese was not fresh, and left on the table in a glass dispenser, diner style. The ravioli came dry, and the sauce didn't even cover them. Desert choices where all mass produced except for the "apple dumpling'. I ordered the creme brulee and it was stone cold. I have eaten at three other amazing restaurants in this area, folks in town recommended Rodney's. I have no idea why. This was one of the most sub par dinning experiences I have had in a long time. I have to go take a bubble bath to recover from this awful dining adventure I stupidly did. Go to Abruzzi's you will not be disappointed. read more

Drove through their large parking lot for 20 minutes until we lucked into a place to park. Though we arrived a few minutes after our reservation time, we still had to wait another 15 or so minutes until a table opened up. Since we only had about an hour until we had to leave to go to a concert, we modified our order to get something that the kitchen could get out quickly. We ordered a fried zucchini app and a pecan crusted chicken salad. The app came out first and was tasty, but the very thinly sliced zucchini was a bit overwhelmed by the ample breading. The pecan crusted chicken salad was also very tasty. We especially liked the flavor of the numerous mandarin orange pieces included. Service was excellent, and as a result of our judicious ordering, and our server's attentiveness, we left the restaurant right on time. We hope the next visit we will have adequate time to explore some of the delicious sounding items on the menu, read more

Rodney's Restaurant - Drink menu. - American Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

The food is always delicious. Friendly service always. A lot of choices to pick from on there menu. Inside the restaurant is always clean and there are plenty of parking places. read more

So the score is for the food. We all enjoyed what we had. I had a steak Stromboli and it was pretty big, I had to take half home. It was stuffed with meat and vegetables. Needed a bit more cheese however. Daughter got a meatball calzone and it was same size. I tried a bite and it was really good. Son got a grilled chicken salad, less fries. Came out in a huge bowl. Another got chicken croquettes, a senior meal of I've ever seen one. She liked them and took some home. I felt prices were decent as well. Negatives: hearing out soon to be server complaining to hostess about our group of 6 being given to her, while we were all standing by her. Also negative was the fact we waited an hour and fifteen minutes for the food to come. Drinks left unfilled too. read more

See all

Fresh food. Excellent service and friendly environment. We are regular customers and not had any bad experiences. Highly recommend for fresh homemade food. read more

Made a reservation for nine at 11 o'clock in the morning of today Sunday arrive 10 minutes early very little communication from management. Many tables were seated before us at 6:15. She told us it'll be a few more minutes could not specify how long this is the second time our dance party has been delayed being seated we left. She told us the table was seated for two hours where we were to be seated. Do not go there with parties of eight or more. And I was disappointed because I heard it's very good there . The attitude of the manager was dismissive and "I don't tell people to leave their table, but I will if I have to" Good for her she didn't have to cause we left read more

We've been to Rodney's a few times now and have to say consistently good food is the trick here. The menu has some features and changes seasonally. Servers have always been friendly, happy and helpful. Just some of the entrees we've shared is stuffed banana peppers over angel hair pasta, braised short rib, chicken parmigiana bourbon bacon pork chops and scallops. We really recommend this restaurant. In addition, for Easter we ordered the ham and kielbasa with sides and dessert. Our family loved this catered dinner and I would order more from Rodney's for future family meals. Please don't forget to save room for dessert! read more

See all

You know if you're still thinking of restaurant a week later and the fantastic service I thought I owed you review! First time going and will for sure be back. Bri, our waitress was fantastic with suggestions from appetizers, meals and to the drink choice! She made us feel like we were the only ones in the restaurant. The food came out quickly, hot, FANTASTIC! I was all around pleased with everything! Looking forward to coming back!!! read more

This restaurant recently told their frequent patrons they are no longer allowed to stay more than 2 hours. These are people who have been patrons of this establishment for over 30 years spending lots of money, hosted family events etc. Along with their recent decline in food quality & rise in prices, service has always been good. However, since the owner directly approached locals- who don't just sit at the bar, they order food, drinks, appetizers- a formerly great ambiance & happy atmosphere, has now become highly disappointing. I will NEVER return read more

It was fine, service was fantastic though. I guess I'm a snob but it was just ok. I can't say I remember it

Food and service are very good. Mussels in tomato sauce appetizer is my favorite. I live near by and go there often

I've had very Good food consistently and they have decent prices. Servers are very nice and attentive too.

Amazing! Service and food ! So comfortable ambiance is relaxing. Prices very good . Must try pizza next time.

This place is an excellent restaurant. The food is delicious. If you're gluten-free, they have a pizza and pasta highly recommend.

Food was excellent. We had lasagna and chicken flat bread. All very good. Our server was very pleasant.

We were 6 who dined at Rodney's for our grandson's birthday this week. Our waitress Alexis was amazing. She had 7 tables seated that she was waiting on simultaneously. She was professional and very friendly and despite the rush she was at our table 5x filling glasses and making sure we were happy with the food, and the service. The food was amazing and there was so much of it we had 4 boxes to take home with us for the next day. Thanks Rodney for your choice of such a hands-on pleasant employee. We all enjoyed ourselves thanks to Alexis. read more

Highly recommended! Great food selection and excellent staff! Atmosphere is exactly as I'd expect, top notch experience! Great lunch and dinner menu, want to try everything they offer! Looking forward to returning soon! read more

Rodney's Restaurant - Spaghetti w/ MB - American Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania

See all

About 2.5 years after my last review, I am writing an updated review, and I am now rounding up my rating to 5 stars! Rodney's is one of my mother-in-law's favorite restaurants. She ordered food for our entire family from their to-go menu. The food was ready for pickup on time, and at home, my in-laws seemed to enjoy the taste of their entrees. Here are reviews for my and my husband's foods: Soy Glazed Salmon - 5 stars - The salmon was a good size, was cooked nicely, and had a sweet soy glaze. It was served over flavorful brussels sprouts, carrots, and potatoes. Veal parmesan - 4 stars - Veal tenderloin medallions were breaded and topped with tomato sauce and provolone cheese. I liked that the breading was not soggy. Sides - 4 stars - Both my husband and I ate house salads for our appetizers. The salads contained fresh lettuce, cheese, olives, and tomatoes. Containers of dressing were on the side. Rodney's other menu items include wings, sandwiches, steaks, pastas, pizzas, calzones, and strombolis. Prices are moderate. read more

Food was decent in flavor but way overpriced. Everything was an additional price and when you're charging $4 dollars for a kids cup of chocolate milk that says all you need to know about the price for this place. I spent more on sodas and milk for my kids then I did on the kids meals themselves. $4 bucks for a Pepsi and my kid couldn't get a refill if they were dying on the floor asking for it. Kraft mac & cheese, soggy fries, tiny little wing dings, all overpriced and underwhelming. The only thing I would go there in order again was the pizza which actually was a pretty decent price compared to everything else. Now I know why I haven't been to this restaurant in 20 years and probably won't return for another 20. Sorry not sorry ‍ oh and they charged a 20% gratuity because we had a party of eight which we were not informed about until the bill came. I don't have a problem with paying a gratuity, but it is nice to know ahead of time. And service was mid which is typical when you're already being charged the gratuity because the servers don't typically care. read more

This place clearly is popular as the restaurant was packed, which leads to the initial downside... We weren't seated until 6:15 for a 6pm reservation. Under normal circumstances not the biggest deal but we had a baby in our group. Once we were seated, it was 6:50 before we received our first course and then every subsequent course came too fast so the timing was just completely out of sorts. The apps were fine as we just had some standard fried food. The side salad was pretty abysmal and was about 50% cheddar cheese and I wasn't a fan. I went with the seafood aglio olio and despite perfectly cooked and plump shrimp, the dish had no flavor. It needed a higher quality olive oil, more garlic or frankly, something else as it was wayyyy too bland. The highlight of the night was the rice pudding for dessert, but not enough to warrant a higher rating after one visit. read more

The food was delicious! Lisa,Jaime and JoLynn gave great service. They made sure our tea was extra hot. The atmosphere and environment was very comfortable. read more

Excellent food!!! Fine service. Had a large party (16) that Rodney's was quite able to accommodate!!! Super!!!

I love Rodney's and have been going there for many years. Having said that the whole bar area/ food section area and bathroom that I was in,smells like very strong urine and I think I know the reason why. They're using a dirty bucket and mop to clean their floors. It all needs to be bleached and cleaned with a fresh bucket,mop and scented bleach. Long Horn in Greensburg has the same problem and has for years. I like both places and I hope they fix it. read more

Wonderful food and friendly service. I would go back. The coconut shrimp was the best I have ever had! It was lunch time and it wasn't overcrowded. read more

Food was good as was service but one person in our party who is 90 years old ordered a Reuben and didn't tell us until after that it was terrible and had no sauerkraut on it! We definitely would've sent it back had we known. The Italian food and pork chops were good but how do you not know how to make a Reuben? Arby's makes a Reuben! His fries were also hard and he ate very few. I did notice they looked very overcooked. I had fettuccine de Marie I think it's called. The scallops were a little soft but overall I thought it was good. read more

Great for lunch. Fast and friendly service. Food was good, especially sauce with Stromboli...would have bought some to go. read more

Rodney's Restaurant - My 1/2 BLT and cup of wedding soup - American Near Me - Irwin, Pennsylvania