The five stars is for the pizza and sweet heat wings! YUMMY!…read more This is a pickup location with a small parking lot. You can call in your order or use their app/order online. Their pizza's are not the typical round pie, they're rectangular, taste great, look delicious and never disappoint! You get a nice crispy crust, the center dough is not too doughy, nicely charred pepperoni, their sauce is not overly sweet and the cheese is perfection. I order my wings extra crispy, they're always great, my own gripe is the price. I think their pizza and wings are the most expensive in the area.

I decided not to cook for lunch and pizza sounded great. I usually get the same order but decided…read moreto switch it up today. I got a medium cheese and pepperoni pizza with an order of fries. I ordered delivery since I was in a bunch of meetings today and didn't have time to pick it up. First off, delivery was great and got here on time which was great. The box had these cool Buffalo Pizza stickers that I love. So cool! The food was great! It had been awhile since I had Picasso's so it was good to see the quality was still there since last time. The pizza was cooked perfectly. Next time I might get the thicker crust but still good! The fries were great. Crispy and salty to complete the meal. The food here is great and I think this is a pizza that should be in anyone's takeout rotation. We will definitely be back for more!

Deep dish chicken wing pizza is awesome a game time Staple in our house. Meat lovers is another…read morefave freshly made pizza and the best ingredients we're very pleased with them

Their pizza is amazing. Never had anything bad. I don't know what else to say, other than....get…read moreyou some!

Had a great slice! Absolutely loved everything about it. The dough was great and I loooooved the…read morecrust! Pepperoni had great flavor and added a welcomed hint of spice to my sweet slice. The bacon was REAL bacon and gave it the savoriness I was looking for, while the ham just rounded it all out. Place was closing when I arrived and had a table or two to dine in but it's def more of a take out spot. I'll be back! No pic bec I was very hungry. Also had plenty of parking. Loved that I could see the kitchen from the seating area.

Sub roll was so over toasted- it was rock hard! Crappy. Then…read moreto top it off, I found a hair in my sub. Brown, curly hair..... wavy of sorts. Don't people wear hair nets or hats when they're preparing food? Nasty.....in the garbage it went! Wasted. Totally turned my stomach....ugh. The friends who ate the pizza we brought to their house said it was really bland, no flavor. Be aware when you're ordering .... the chicken fingers at this pizzeria-- they are not chicken fingers - they are chicken tenders and super small for the price. This place used to be one of our favorite pizzerias, the food WAS always amazing. Just super letdown. Not sure where all the good chefs/cooks went? Unfortunately , our business will not be returning.

Another great pizza spot for the books…read more I'm honestly surprised how different Buffalo pizza is compared to Jersey and NYC. You'd think they would be pretty similar, but Buffalo definitely has its own style. I'm a truck driver and was hauling a load from Buffalo to North Carolina, so finding a good pizza spot where I could get a 53-foot tractor-trailer close enough was a challenge. Somehow I got lucky and found a nearby no-parking bus stop for a very quick stop. If you look at my picture, you can actually see my 18-wheeler peeking out from behind the bushes. I ran inside, ordered two pepperoni slices for $10.98, and was surprised by how huge they were. I was expecting NYC-style triangles but got big rectangular slices instead. The crust was crisp underneath with a soft, chewy interior, the sauce-to-cheese ratio was really good, and the crispy cup-and-char pepperoni was easily the highlight. The sauce had a slight sweetness without being overpowering. I also asked for ranch but ended up with Bleu cheese instead, and honestly I'm glad I did because it was really good. The place was clean, the service was quick and friendly, and the pizza was excellent. If I'm ever back in Buffalo, I'd definitely stop here again.

It's been quite some time since I've allowed myself a delicious treat and pizza was on my mind…read more Not just any pizza though , pizza that hits the spot and delivers on crispy cup and char pepperoni and dough that doesn't disappoint. So one pie it was. After placing my order at the window, my slices were handed over nice and hot, knowing that I did not want a hot cheese mess in my lap while driving I went home and immediately went to work on these slices. Only being able to eat one of the two my hankering for pizza was satisfied shout out to that incredible bleu cheese for making those last few bites even more amazing. This is still top-tier elite level pizza for Buffalo.

Craving a dense, thicker-style crust pizza, I knew I could count on Good Guys Pizza to satiate it!…read more I placed and paid for my pizza online around 4:15pm for a 5:00pm pickup on a Saturday. I arrived closer to 5:15pm to a packed parking lot. I wish the parking lot was a little bigger but, somehow, I still managed to find a spot! I walked in and was next in line and after giving my name, my order was brought out and I was out of there, quite literally in and out, which was probably a good thing as I had a good parking spot. For my order, I ordered a small (13", six slice) cheese, pepperoni, sweet pepper, and mushroom pizza. This pizza was just as delicious as I remembered. I really love how Good Guys Pizza cook their pizzas with more cook time on the bottom, making their pizza a bit sturdier and golden on the underneath. And that thick, crispy, crunchy crust, *chef's kiss*. Good Guys Pizza is VERY generous with their toppings, each slice I pulled out had awesome cheese-pull, and there was plenty of red sauce. A note about their red sauce, if the typical-Buffalo "sweet" style isn't your favorite, I think you'd be good with Good Guys Pizza's red sauce as it comes across a bit more balanced, with maybe a slight lean towards "spicy". There was plenty of pepperoni buried beneath the heaps of mushrooms and sweet (green) pepper slices! I added a drizzle of hot honey and I thought it was an awesome complement! Good Guys Pizza cooks up a thicker-dough pizza that satisfies the biggest appetites, which this pizza was no different, but I appreciate it not being greasy, it sat well. The price I paid for my pizza was very reasonable, especially seeing how much prices everywhere have risen in 2026, a nice treat for my wallet. Good Guys Pizza retains one of the top spots in my favorite pizza shop list! They've been a favorite of mine since 2018 and it really impresses me how consistently good, they are - The quality, the portions, the prices, the customer service, all of it is great! The only reason I don't come here more is the fact it's so far from my house, but, once in a while, I have to just make the trek and get my Good Guys Pizza-fix.

Made a stop at Good Guy'S pizza. We ordered various pizzas and also a fish sub. Delicious food not…read moreskimpy on ingredients, not cheap but I guess you get what you pay for.

Great service. Very good pizza, bready crust. Tasty sauce. We ordered the Buffalo Chicken Wing…read morepizza and it was delicious. The restaurant is part of the Lancaster Village community center, and you can only access it from an interior door. I'm not too familiar with Lancaster, but I did like this pizzeria and I would stop by again for a slice..

New pizzeria in the village of Lancaster. The staff is very nice and attentive. We ordered a slice…read moreof regular cheese pizza just to try it and they gave us a piece with sweet sauce to try because we asked how the sweeter sauce was. Both were pretty good. The sweet sauce was a bit much for me but I'm sure others may love it. The regular sauce had the right amount of spice and acid and I enjoyed it. The crust was crunchy and had decent flavor but a little too doughy for me. It couldve just been that slice, so I'd try a whole pie next time.

I love a good occasional NY slice of pizza. I stopped in for a Sunday slice for lunch, they have…read moreplenty of sitting space and a nice big tv to catch the Bills on. Atmosphere was great! I got a slice of mushroom and cheese and my husband got the stuffed steak and pepper pizza. Slices were massive and we left full and happy. I love when a pizzeria has Parmesan and chili flake shakers as well. They also had oregano and salt and pepper too. Very good place, will be back!

Heard this place had the best NY Style pizza in Buffalo. My sister and I both got slices of cheese…read morepizza and we both agreed that there was just too much cheese. Also, the place just feels dirty overall. Sorry to say we won't be back.

I walked in this place and it was very clean! This is hands down the best pizzeria! I had a…read moretraditional and a sweet pizza. The perfect amount of sauce grease and cheese! Nothing dry about the pizza at all. The sweet pizza had a perfect amount of sweetness and wasn't overly sweet at all! The traditional pizza had a perfect amount of sweetness and a hint of tart from the red sauce in which is how I love my pizzas in both aspects! The service was amazing as well. The person who took my order was very insightful on the product. I will try the taco pizza next time as he recommended! Def check out this spot! Perfect pizza no burntness soft crust and dough!

I don't have photos, but I want to leave a review... a handful of times each year, we order a few…read moreparty packs for an event we host. Tonight we did the same. When the order was delivered, there was a mix up on the size of one of the pizzas. The staff at the pizzeria was quick to hear me out on my complaint, and do what they could to fix the situation. The delivery driver was also very friendly and apologetic. The pizza from Tony's has always been one of my favorites and we will definitely continue to order from there for events in the future.