We stopped here after visiting the Ohio State Reformatory. James was our waiter and he was so nice and accommodating. We took his recommendations; my hubs had the lasagna, and I had the crab pizza. He enjoyed his lasagna, said it was very good. I had never heard of crab pizza before, let me tell you, it was to die for! I stuffed myself until I could not eat anymore! That was so different and creative. It was delicious! I will be dreaming of that pizza for years to come!! Do yourself a favor and go try it! read more

Fantastic family owned restaurant, they only had one chef tonight but yet for my family of 6 it only took 40 ish minutes, not to mention it was packed. The food was amazing some of the best chicken Alfredo I've ever had. With an unbeatable price, highly recommend. read more

Reindeer Grill - Chicken Alfredo - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Moderately busy on a Fri eve. Got seated quickly. Completely ignored for 10 min as servers walked past multiple times. Place was dirty with debris on the dirty carpet. Food may be good but we'll never know... read more

Food was great. I had the crab soup which was tasty and loaded with crab. Then I had the crab balls. They were good also. We were given free garlic knots which were so good we placed another order. Two of my friends had chicken Ceasar salad. They got the small ones and it was huge with tons on chicken. My other friend got the small pasta and still had plenty for leftovers. The service was fine. But the cleanliness of the restaurant was the problem. There were about 4 teenagers working and kept walking by a piece of pizza on the floor. Under our table was a lot of food (not from us). Never saw anyone cleaning around the tables. Also just an fyi, not a judgement, there are bible verses on the wall and a bible in the bathroom. No alcohol either. read more

Small hometown diner with limited menu but unlimited flavor! A favorite go-to for a nice night out.

The chicken pot pie and the lasagna were good! My friend with the lasagna said the beef had good flavor. My alfredo was soooo much sauce about 1:1 sauce noodle ratio. it wasn't too bad but hard to get through with how heavy and buttery it was. The light portions were also huge so i recommend maybe splitting a light portion! the server was hilarious and great but forgot a few things here and there. but that was okay because we didn't mind asking. the garlic knots to start were my favorite!!!! read more

See all

I'd give zero stars if I could. Terrible service. When we came in there was an older man who told us that 'service clearly wasn't their priority''. I should have listened to him. We got a table pointed to us to sit at and then were ignored for 20 minutes while the same staff walked past us multiple times. We just left at that point as we hadn't even been brought water. read more

Good pizza and Italian. Servers were extremely friendly sland helpful. Cozy atmosphere.

Pizza is great. Love the garlic twists. Service was frustrating. We had 4 kids with us and had to ask repeatedly for refills, to order etc. read more

Jamie was a great server, she chatted with us and told us everything was homemade. We got a pizza and it was excellent as were the complimentary garlic knots. Pull on the cheese was insane! Don't hesitate to come here. The lasagna is cooked to order as well and looked really good. read more

Reindeer Grill - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

See all

Reindeer Grill is a very good place to eat with friendly staff. I've never had a bad lunch or dinner there! However, don't go if you're wanting to be out in less than an hour. Typical wait time between being seated and receiving your food has never been less than 35 mins. This isn't bad for dinner but I think hurts their lunch crowd. If you have the time, it's a great place! read more

Solid American fare with a twist. The she crab soup is fantastic and the salad was very good and fresh. Had the salmon for dinner. It was cooked well but I thought it was too salty. Decently priced, great service read more

This is a destination restaurant. On a road trip researching places to eat I came across pictures of the Cookie Monster. Those pictures don't do it justice. If there is a competition of best desserts in America you can't be a judge in that contest without trying this. So good. read more

Reindeer Grill - Cookie monster, coconut shrimp, extra cheese medium pizza - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Beef lasagna to die for scratch made with delicious garlic bread knots. I loved hot hot and fresh the lasagna was cheese was good quality and the portion size was perfect read more

Reindeer Grill - Menu front cover - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

See all

Nice little diner and very sweet, kind, and friendly staff. Food is good, par for a diner type restaurant. Now, the feedback for hoping to get this to the owner to improve. Lots of improvement needed in the service department. They lacked severely in attentiveness from the beginning trying to get attention of someone to seat us, all the way to having to chase someone down to get the bill. A lot of waiting happened. If I could give a negative number for service and attentiveness throughout the stay, I would. We were there yesterday around 2 pm and I did hear one of the staff tell another patron, that they were sorry for the slowness but they were a little busy. There is no excuse for this slow of service, especially when though most tables were full, no one was waiting for a table. Please, please, pay attention to your patrons, they are what keeps you in business. Treat others the way you would want to be treated!!! read more

I'm really on the fence about this place. Service was decent but took a very long time to get our meals. I got the lasagna and it was very good. However, my partner got the crab cake and it wasn't cooked very well and he actually felt ill later. My friend had a turkey wrap and she said it was just ok. Her husband had the lasagna and said his was very good also. So I guess if you have plenty of time and stick to the lasagna, you're good read more

Reindeer Grill - Lasagna - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

We were driving through town looking for a place to grab a late lunch and Reindeer Grill ended up being perfect spot. Metered parking was available right outside and when we arrived there were a couple of empty tables. We were able to seat ourselves and check out the menu. Our server came over quickly to take our drink orders. We ended up trying the chicken fingers, cheeseburger, and mozzarella sticks. The chicken fingers were solid and came with bbq or honey mustard plus fries. The fries were hot and crispy. The burger was decent as well and the mozzarella sticks were very good. Service was fast and friendly. I'd recommend stopping in if you need a no frills meal! read more

Went here for a dinner meeting. Staff was great and the food was excellent. Can't wait to come again.

A really great place to eat. The location, atmosphere and food are perfect for a nice lunch destination.

Literally looks like a Christmas thrift shop when walking by it but the food was amazing! Our server went above and beyond for us and even gave us her recommendations when my husband and I couldn't decide on what to order. My husband had their Philly Mac n Cheese and I ordered the beef stroganoff. Both were incredible! If you aren't starving or have a smaller appetite, definitely order the smaller option! I had enough leftover for 2 more meals. read more

Reindeer Grill - What was left of my husband's Philly Mac n Cheese - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

See all

Our first visit was for a relatively early Tuesday evening dinner. A very wholesome place with some inspirational scripture on the walls. The color palette and decor are reminiscent of a country store. The menu looked fairly good. Notably missing were adult beverages. With that I ordered Iced Tea while the rest of my family had water with lemon. Delicious garlic knots magically appeared with a side of sauce. They feature a crab soup on the menu so I really wanted to try that. My wife ordered the chicken bacon hand tossed pizza and a small Caesar salad while I decided on the single crab cake dinner and their crab soup. As we planned to split the Caesar I substituted their vegetable medley for the Caesar that accompanied my crab cake. My mom and her partner also split a Caesar and each had a bowl of the crab soup. Their small Caesar was fairly large and very tasty! The only possible improvement would be to use larger croutons. The crab soup was amazingly delicious! A hint of sherry and Old Bay topped a heaping pile of crab in my cup! My crab cake was pretty darn good for being in north central Ohio! It came with a huge heaping amount of battered French fries. What nearly stole the show was the vegetable medley! Well prepared, seasoned, and delicious! My wife really enjoyed her pizza! The small bite I had fell in line with the rest of our meal...beyond yummy! Looking forward to visiting again soon! read more

See all

For the past six months I've wanted nothing more than to hit up the deli for a salad on our road trip, only to find that our intended destination was closed for an event. Ravenous, we found the next closest eatery. My salad got a major upgrade. We walked in to seat ourselves at a booth, greeted by a soft spoken waitress who brought us waters while we read over the menu. She returned to take our order, and then again to bring complimentary garlic knots. Vampires beware, these things pack a hot punch as butter oozes onto your finger tips. They come with a side of marinara, doing their best to warm you from the freezing cold air. He stepped out to grab a hoodie and I went to find that the religious tones of the place follow you into the bathroom, with a bible ready in case you're in for the long haul. The afformentioned salad arrived as a substitute to the offered fries for my crab cake. It came with a packet of honey mustard, but after a cranking of pepper, I was so distracted by the freshness of the shredded lettuce and sharp onion with juicy tomato and bell pepper that I neglected to dress it. There was a sprinkling of cheese and baby croutons. I devoured it and moved on to the star. This hockey puck sized beast was low on breading, high on taste. I didn't sense any goopy filler that people try to fool you with. It had the consistency of albacore tuna with a sweet, undersea tone that made me feel like my tenner wasn't going for something chincy. It came with a tartar sauce. Better than that shake shake squeeze stuff from the grocer. My mate got beef stroganoff. The mushrooms were delicately caramelized like steak, the onions jammy. In fact, they were the stars of the show over the, still respectable, beef. The sauce was downright great and the egg noodles were properly cooked. I'm taking the lead from Bob Ross and calling this lunch a happy little accident. read more

See all

Food, service, ambiance-- all great! Lots of crab (fresh daily from Maryland) dishes. I had the chowder. Delicious, as were the complimentary garlic knots. Hubby enjoyed quesadillas. read more

This was our first time dining here. This is a small, quaint diner with kitschy decor (lots of bible verses on the walls). Our meals were well-prepared and delicious and prices were very reasonable. Unfortunately, the men's restroom was out of order and the service was very slow and inattentive (it was busy due to a 7K road race that brought a lot of visitors to the area). I would visit again the next time I'm in Mansfield. read more

Great pizza with great service! Wonderful family friendly environment will return. Also the salad was fresh and tasty read more

Reindeer Grill - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

First time visiting the city and the restaurant. The metered street parking in front of the restaurant seems to be free after on 4 pm on weekdays. The food was great. We got the garlic knots as a complimentary and it was delicious. Chicken wrap was very good to. They do have desserts but not on the menu so please make sure you ask. read more

See all

We were in town to see a show, took a chance on this little restaurant and were really glad we did! Clean facility, friendly staff and very reasonably priced! We had salad, pizza, a turkey club & onion rings - all delicious! We will definitely go again next time we're in Mansfield! read more

We live in the area and thought we would try out Reindeer Grill, the menu looked great from a quick scan online before deciding to go. We anticipated, reindeer decor and a local foodie chef. We were very disappointed, you can smell the grease when you open the door, the decor is lacking, tables unclean but told to sit anywhere and food was simply awful. My husband ordered fish and chips and said it had been in the freezer too long before frying. I ordered a hamburger which was not what I imagined ordering based on the menu on line, it was a thin burger, simple, no fuss and could be the same anywhere. If you want a unique, variety of food options without the smell of grease don't try Reindeer Grill. read more

My FAVORITE place to get a Double bacon BLT highly recommend. I've never had anything bad from there. Service is a bit of a hit and miss though. read more

The food is so good! Try the lasagna! They also have great wings and mozz sticks :) my only critique is that I wish their bathroom was cleaner. read more

Very nice place, very nicely decorated. They have a very varied menu with everything from pizza and pasta, to sandwiches and salads. The portions are ENORMOUS, each plate is enough for at least two people. I got the beef lasagna and it was very good. The garlic knots are addicting. The staff is friendly and attentive. read more

Food is great. Atmosphere is welcoming. Definitely worth the drive from wherever you are.

The food was delicious, and there were so many options! The service was great. Our server was very helpful and friendly!

Food is great. Ambiance so so and service is a bit slow but food makes up for it. Try the garlic knots and crab cakes.

The food was outstanding and the service was great!! We enjoyed the cream of crab soup, it was so delicious

Do not eat here unless you want bad service. The people waiting on you taking your order are more interested in rushing to take your order, not repeating it back to you to get back to talking and playing on their phones. My order came out wrong! I ordered a double cheeseburger with only ketchup, mustard and pickles and fries. I received a double cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato and mayo with fries. After they tried to correct it and they brought another burger out it was a single cheeseburger with ketchup, mustard and pickles. At that time I hollered "can we get the check please!" As he came over and it was explained to them that both times the order was wrong. He went back to the register and brought the bill trying to charge me for the entire order. I stated, "I'm not paying for that!" Bill was adjusted but still would not recommend this place! Also all of the empty tables were dirty when we walked in and they did not wipe the seats off that had food all over them for our table. read more

This place seemed promising with how its website advertised it, but honestly I wasn't too impressed. The food was edible and tasted okay, but everything, especially the pizza, was SUPER greasy. It was honestly mediocre for the price you pay (like a $21 entree that really is only worth probably $10). Unfortunately I wouldn't recommend this business. (In the photo, you can see that the pizza was shiny with how greasy it was). Also, our waitress seemed a bit irritated that she had to serve us and just wasn't the friendliest, and the decor was very outdated and rather awful to the eye. read more

Reindeer Grill - Philly Steak pizza - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

Stellar cuisine. Ordered Seafood Alfredo and sheesh, I was impressed! Bay scallops inside were sweet. I normally shy away from the texture of shrimp tails, but these shrimp were spectacular. Perfect size and adequately cooked. I ordered the regular portion and I'll admit I've made many meals of it. I chose to go here for my birthday and the staff handled my family with respect & kindness. I appreciate that, especially with a large group. Best part was the birthday cookie monster. Fresh baked M&M cookie straight out that oven topped with icecream and Hershey's hot fudge. Perfect way to celebrate my evening. read more

Reindeer Grill - Cookie Monster - American Near Me - Mansfield, Ohio

See all

Great food, great prices! We ordered a chicken bacon wrap, bacon cheeseburgers, garlic knots and a kid's pepperoni pizza. Cost wise, it's on par with Panera, but MUCH better food. We ordered our food to go, and by the time we got home (30 minutes later), the fries were still delicious! We can't wait to dine in the next time and try something new. This is definitely going to be in our rotation even we go out to eat from now on. *I would have taken photos, but it was too good to stop eating for a photo op* read more

Great food. We've NEVER had a bad dish and the service is always nice. It's just a clean, small, cute little restaurant. Parking has also been easy. read more