The food here is consistently great! I think the food quality dipped a bit during the pandemic, but that happened to every restaurant and they've definitely bounced back! However the hostesses seem to struggle a bit each time we try to call in pick up orders. read more

Got the beet salad and lemon orzo soup. Sat at the bar. Great service. Unique menu. Soo funny all the menu names. Got this amazing grape smash drink. Very similar to a Mojito. Salad great. We loved this place. read more

a good place to get a solid burger. Beer is good, vibe is good, service is efficient and friendly. tater tots are really good, PJB burger was surprisingly very good cheeseburger was good (tho I think I would prefer American cheese) lots of tvs showing sports games, the bar is lively but not chaotic. read more

We wanted something different & Red's Place filled the bill. I would called a comfortable & cozy place. Their French Onion Sliders got us in the door and didn't disappoint! The bread picked up the nuances of a warm soup and the onions were well caramelized & tasty. I opted for the 5 mushroom sub and was extremely tasty & satisfying. They had a crab burger & great sides. Nice choice of beers & other beverages. All in all another visit in the future is looking good! read more

If we're talking colors, I'm not big on red. I'm more of a purple fan myself, but since we're talking about Reds, capital R, I can say that Red is great. I had to wonder what came first, the name or the matching walls as we slid into a rounded booth that made me feel like a mob boss about to make a deal instead of an order. The table kept slipping around, probably because we kept bumping it in an attempt to lean closer and hear each other. The waitress brought over two mason jars and filled them out of a milk bottle. My mate asked for a straw, and we were given two, already unwrapped. A moment of silence passed for the turtles, ended by me blowing bubbles into my icy water. The waitress kept pace with our refills. (Considering how muggy it is out, this is very much appreciated.) We are on vacay, so my mate broke his diet to order a Porks and Rec with a side of tots. They were the first thing he touched, practically melting into the booth. And no, it was not because of the weather, or because he hasn't had potatoes in ages, because I stole a tot out of his tiny fryer basket, and dear gosh, they're good. Crispy, crunchy, with a punch of salt, and what I swore to be the slightest tickle of sweet. (Don't quote me on that, as even though he agreed, we were a bit weary from our hike.) The sandwich itself was served on a very soft ciabatta, nice and bubbly. The pork had been perfectly braised, offset by the fresh veg and herbage to make it still taste fresh. I myself decided to be the Fun Guy (girl, but I'm poking fun at all their delightfully punny titles here) and order a sandwich with a side salad. I'm always curious how a side salad is interpreted by restaurants. It's always feels like pulling ingredients out of a hat. They picked cucumber, a few slivers of onion, and halved tomatoes. They also pulled arugula out of the hat a few times, making for what should have been a bitter salad, had it not been balanced by the strawberry poppy vin's sweet notes. If you're gonna get a salad, get that dressing. My sandwich I had asked for, ironically without arugula. The garlic aioli wasn't visible upon it's undone display, top bun taunting me with it's pickled red onions. I kept going back for them until my mate pointed out I should assemble my sandwich. I took a quick taste of the thick wedge of mozzarella, which was chewy, without the pull that would have otherwise distracted me from a mildly leaky sandwich. (Thank goodness for proofreading because my phone almost said moldy, so let me just re-emphasize how fresh this place is. Fresh, good food. Okay, carrying on...) The basil balsamic dripped from the thin portobello at the gentlest of tugs, making for a juicy patty, and very wet fingers. Pretty sure I stained their fabric napkin, so sorry Red. (Even if you are a grandpa ghost, because I did get curious and look up the name origin after all, your food deserves respect.) So if you are vacationing in town like us nature junkies, trek over and fill up on good food. read more

See all

Visited 9/24/2024 for dinner! Let me start by saying your hostess deserves a raise that girl was busting her butt off. We waited for a table for about 20 min. Not the greatest table back by the bar. At one point I had a crowd of women hitting my seat and talking loud which took away from my date with my husband. So we started with a couple of appetizers- the onion soup rolls and the dip with ricotta cheese both of these were good. The onion soup rolls were a bit on the dry side. I ordered a chicken sandwich but got an eggplant sandwich. I'm not fond of egg plant. I asked the hostess to grab our waitresses and mentioned that I got the incorrect sandwich. The waitress said I could have swore you said Farm To Ciabatta Sandwich - I didn't want to correct her, but I had asked her when ordering and I pointed to the sandwich and said this one which was the Cluckwork Orange and I asked her if it was good with the artichoke hearts and she replied yes! No big deal she corrected it immediately and she was a ok waitress. The sandwich was slapped together quickly because she came back with the correct sandwich in less than 5 minutes. Unfortunately the sandwich wasn't good which wasn't her fault. We order dessert and I had asked for coffee. I should have told the waitress to forget the coffee because she paused and looked over at the kitchen and then said yes, I have coffee. So I received a cold cup of coffee. We ordered cheese cake which wasn't very good. It had an odd after taste. So unfortunately I am giving a 2 star review because of the sandwich, cold old coffee and dessert. For the sandwich the bread wasn't toasted and it was slapped together so quickly, the cold coffee and dessert. Lastly when I got home I was in the bathroom for a long time and was totally sick so it had to have been the sandwich or dessert because my husband had the appetizers. He had one bite of cheesecake so it could have been that? Not sure but something made me super sick which was not great especially being on vacation. read more

Enjoyed dinner at Reds last night with my family. Service was great, our server was very personable and kind. Our meals included the burger, a flatbread, the crab cake burger (crabby patty) and Caesar salad/flatbread combo. Everyone enjoyed their meals, big portions and flavorful. The menu has something for most everyone and the clever names are fun. I definitely recommend! read more

Stopped in for lunch when we got to Ithaca for the weekend! Prompt service and cold beer right away. Had the PB & "Jellousy" burger which was cooked perfectly. Highly recommend! read more

We have been to Reds several times. The food is usually good. Prices are on the higher end. Manger has a bad attitude and does not care about customers. We usually tip 20% on up depending upon service. Our experience was so bad that we all got up and left. Horrible Customer Service. We will never go back! read more

The hostess wasn't overly friendly, but luckily we were undeterred (everyone can have a bad day). The bartender took our orders and was so incredibly kind and welcoming. This place had great vegan and vegetarian options, and lots of seafood options for those who don't eat burgers. If it had been later in the day, I would have tried a cocktail, but next time! read more

I was visiting Ithaca New York from New York City,and found this restaurant on yelp. It had some pretty good reviews. My husband and I had burgers. I had the aurora burger my husband had the pb jealousy. And a flat bread. The temp of the burgers were perfect. And very juicy. You need a napkin to control this and it was not greasy. My only gripe was the French fries need some seasoning or salt and the flat bread was over baked very crispy almost like a cracker. However the flavor was good.The decor is that rustic industrial look. The staff was pleasant without being overbearing and intrusive The crowd was that of young college crowd .The good thing is that they weren't roudy it was a Thursday night however . Overall it was a good experience read more

Red's Place - Aurora burger - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

Very delicious flatbreads. Me and my friends got three kinds and they were all amazing. The crust has a good crunch, the cheese is filling and melted, and the balsamic vinegar complements everything. I ordered loaded cheese fries without bacon and wouldn't quite recommend that option -- something's obviously missing. The fries themselves were a little bit too dry and potato-y for my taste. The crabby patty that I tried on another occasion was too salty. The service, on other hand, was perfect. Would recommend. P.S. I think impossible burgers would be a great fit for their menu. Here's to hopin' read more

Red's Place - capresse flatbread loaded cheese fries - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This has really become one of my favorite places to order from while here in Ithaca. All their sandwiches and burgers are unique and all delicious. But for me their real star is the Mac and cheese. The portion is huge for the price and it is topped with chicken tenders. If you have a chance, try it out ! It's very solid American food. read more

Red's Place - Take out. Broccoli added at home. - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

I adore reds place! It's always a safe option for lunch or dinner. I always order their mini French onion soup bread bowls as an appetizer. Every sandwich I've tried has been very tasty and same with the soups. The last time I was there, soup of the day was Tom kha and while less traditional, it was still quite delicious. read more

Food was excellent! We were in for lunch on a Tuesday just after they opened. Nice and quiet! I had mahi on top of green salad, mixed greens. My boyfriend had pastrami and it was delicious! Great atmosphere and service! read more

Attempted to eat here last night and was pretty disappointed by the staff's eagerness to go home for the day. They are supposed to be open until 11:00pm; however, we arrived at 10:25pm and were promptly turned away. Confusing and unprofessional. read more

Red's Place - Maui mahi sandwich and loaded steak fries. - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

Decide whether you want to dine at Red's Place and support its brand of treatment. I am a 70-year-old, disabled, decorated, former U.S. Air Force Reserve colonel, who served in various critical settings and capacities during OPERATION IRAQI FREEDOM and OPERATION ENDURING FREEDOM. I am also a black man. On the evening of Tuesday, July 9, 2024, my white girlfriend and I were dining in Red's Place, 107 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY. It seems we were the wrong racial representation Red's Place wanted to project. First, the manager asked us to leave. Then she said she would seat us outside in the brutal heat. Finally, she placed us in a booth, which we decidedly avoided when we originally entered Red's Place. In response to my review, I am certain the manager will offer excuses, justifications, and explanations. She will even cite that she granted us a complimentary drink. Despite her refutations, the fact is we were removed from our desired seating area--where we were enjoying our meals and each other and were receiving exceptional service from our wait-staffer--to a booth we did not want and to wait-service we did not receive until bidden. When confronted, the manager immediately said "don't pull the race card on me," which suggests my complaint of racist treatment was not her first. Is a racially hostile environment the norm at Red's Place? Decide whether you want to dine at Red's Place and support its brand of treatment. read more

Ate there on consecutive nights, first night food and service where excellent spurning a visit the following night where service was rude and impersonal. Food wasn't as good as the night before. read more

Popped in for lunch on the patio. Very good experience. Let's be clear - the french onion soup bowls are what's going to make me remember this joint. It was an appetizer for the flavor gods. I love love love french onion anything, and these were so damn tasty. These little bread rolls of love were the ideal vessels for the french onion soup and melted cheese. I really want these more often - damn I live 4 hours away. The fried chicken sandwich was very tasty with the honey, mustard and pickles. Definitely would circle back here - mostly for a beer and those french onions bowls. read more

See all

This place did not disappoint!! First time being the the FLX area for my hubby and I. First time in Ithaca! We really loved the vibe here! The staff was very friendly and polite. Our waitress Olivia was great! Her personality made our experience so much better! Everything on the menu sounded so good, but we were in the mood for burgers after hiking Taughannock state park. Just looking at the food that was being served to the others around us just made our mouth water even more. Great prices for great portion sizes and the quality is 10/10! Hubby had the angry pig, and per his words "oooohh this is really good". I haven't had everything on the menu but the by the looks of everything, anything you're in the mood for will probably hit the spot lol! I had the breaking baaaaaad burger. I was skeptical at first because I'm not a fan of tiziki sauce, but this place flipped it upside down and made me like it. The burger was so juicy and tender. The lamb patty cooked to perfection! My hubby and I both had the lemonade which they served in cute mason jars. Totally went with the restaurant theme.Excellent! I'm so happy we made this choice to come here! Definitely coming back here when we're in the area again! read more

See all

Food was ok and service ok and ambiance cold. I wouldn't go back there. My salad with the flat bread was wayyyy too salty. After I fish eating I had to drink a jug of water. read more

I had a terrible experience here. I ordered two pesto flatbreads for take-out; one gluten-free, one regular. When I arrived home, I saw that neither of them were marked "gf". I called Red's and asked if they could help to differentiate the flatbreads, as they both looked very similar. I have an allergy and can't take chances. The person who answered the phone didn't know how to differentiate them. She conferred with another staff member who said the gf flatbread should have rounded crust. Neither of the crusts had rounded edges. I asked if the gf crust was thinner, and I was put on hold. I was then hung up on. I waited for several minutes and didn't get a call back. I called back repeatedly and was sent to voicemail. Finally, after calling back numerous times, I reached another employee who directed me to the manager. I explained that I had been hung up on and wasn't helped to differentiate the crusts. The manager was incredibly rude and defensive. He justified my being hung up on by explaining that the business was "slammed" tonight. He then explained that the gf crust was zucchini-based and green, completely different from the regular crust. None of that information had been given to me when I initially called. He asked condescendingly if I'd ever ordered the gluten-free flatbread before. It's not my job to know how your gluten-free flatbread looks or to have ordered it before; it's pretty universal to mark takeout orders with GF. I understand that people make mistakes, businesses get busy, and not every employee may know the ins and outs of differentiating gf crust. But what is totally unacceptable is the way I was treated. Being hung up on, and then gaslit by the manager. How hard is it to apologize, assist me, and own up to a mistake? I'm a local and had been to Red's multiple times (non-takeout) in the past. Definitely do not expect good service if you try to order takeout. Be sure to be an expert on how different crusts look beforehand. I will not be returning. read more

Very solid spot to get some food. Fair pricing and good food to match - I've been here a couple times and it does get quite busy especially during peak hours on the weekends. Crab cake was tasty. Service can get tougher when people start to pile in. read more

Solid food, solid beer, solid burgers. Red's is the place to go in Ithaca for burgers and you'll find a good reason here for that. There are lots of burger selections, from typical ones you can get at any shop, to more specialized burgers, to even college-themed ones to give your buddies good-lived memories with a side of heart disease. But jokes aside, great energy and place for hangouts or a burger craving. The beer selection is fantastic, and you'll be able to get anything from a light lager to a fruity, complex IPA, even from the draft. read more

Stopped in for a drink while we waited for our table across the street to open. Beer selection was great! Ordered an app, the "red's pot of gold" which was chibbata and tomato oil, and it was excellent! Actually rivaled pastabilities spicy oil. Service was excellent and prices were on point. Thanks!! read more

A place near our cabin with live music all day long! The cheese curds and brownie sundae are amazing! Nachos r large but could use salsa! No complaints for the end of a long day meal. Reasonable prices and cold beer with the option of keeping the glass which we did of course! read more

The Brussels were fantastic, sweet and savory. The caramelized onions were delicious!! read more

Red's Place - Brussels - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

My boyfriend and I loved this place! The burgers were a little slow to come out - slower than most restaurants BUT they were so fresh and hot when they got to our table. A sign that they were made fresh to order for us. They were so good! They ranch here is also delicious. Our server was awesome and the overall vibe was so cool. We will definitely be back! read more

Red's Place - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

Food, service, and beverages always good. Great, dependable option in Ithaca. Friendly, not fussy, but not too basic.

Solid three stars. Nice beer menu. I might have just been here on an off day. I was so psyched about the Pesto Pesto Flatbread (chicken, Asiago, mozzarella, wild mushrooms, and pesto). But it was soggy, maybe even under baked. Disappointing. But don't give up on the place cuz of my mediocre review; it clearly has a loyal clientele. read more

Red's Place - Pesto Pesto Flatbread and Juice Bomb IPA - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

We sat at the bar and had a very attentive bartender. All the food we ordered was delicious and we thought the prices reasonable.

Great food. Low key place. Try the pastraminator, aurora burger and the gramps. Mac and cheese looked huge and amazing (but we didn't order that this time ) read more

Had dinner with friends at Red's Place on Saturday, 10/21. The wait was long because it was a Saturday night, but after we ate, I realized why. Everything we ate was outstanding. Wings - crispy and tasty. The French onion soup bowls - wow. I now need to learn how to make them at home. Bang bang shrimp was very tasty. My crab cake sandwich was huge with tons of crab meat. Service was attentive and friendly. Prices were quite reasonable. Everyone in my dinner party agreed it was a great meal. Well done, Red's. We will be back. read more

We were in town visiting and met our cousin here for dinner. It's very low key, low lit, and the waitress let us just take our time figuring out what to order. After the food arrived she pretty much let us just spend time visiting and catching up as we ate. We shared the so cheesy dip which is melted parmesan, mozzarella & fontina, artichoke, arugula dip served with corn tortilla chips. It was quite tasty and more than plenty for three people. My spouse had the clam down which was steamed little neck clams in white wine butter sauce, garlic, parsley & diced tomatoes served with grilled bread that she thought was pretty good. I had the thai sliders that were bigger than I expected, pretty spicy, but with a side of sour cream I could handle the heat! Overall it was a nice experience. Meter parking is steep, but there's a lot just around the corner that's reasonable. read more

This was my third visit to Red's Place and it did not disappoint. I ordered the Farm Salad which is a delicious mix of greens, fresh peas and chopped bell pepper, and peppered bacon and smoked Gouda cheese. I have had it before to-go so I was excited to try it in person. The portion is really generous too for a good price ($13.50) so I was able to eat a good amount of it and still have some to eat for lunch the next day. I also ordered the 1911 Raspberry Cider which I enjoyed as well, there seemed to be a decent variety of drinks to choose from. Looking forward to trying more off of their menu if I can bear to stray from my favorite salad next time!! read more

Red's Place - The Farm Salad - New American Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Only had 2 apps and beers , had the clams ( not much flavor ) and the French onion soup on like muffins , really not for us , they are on the sweet side . read more

An excellent selection of taps, a bartender who filled all orders with aplomb, a french onion burger to die for (I possibly will on account of BP) and that they let me wait out a horrendous rainstorm in their "lobby" - this place can't be beat. In a food town, they provide everything you need! read more

Good portion was small. The waitress was not in the welcome mood. The food taste was regular. read more

Food price / quality (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is pub style. We split the roasted Brussels sprouts and a chicken pesto flatbread, which were both excellent. They offer a balanced and well chosen selection of draught beers. The prices were good as was the service. read more

Good burgers. Quick service. Good prices. Bar seating available. Parking one block away.