Most importantly: This is a bowling alley! We didn't realize that. We knew there was bowling, but thought it might just be a little side option with the actual focus on the restaurant; like Lucky Strike. Nope. If you want a traditional sit-down restaurant, this is not your destination. BUT! If you want amazing food and an overtly friendly staff, this is you need to be. I'm just passing through Idaho, but if they're all like the folks in this place, I'm definitely coming back! Great atmosphere and great food! My family had a wonderful time. read more

Haven't been there yet but thinking about it for dinner today just traveling through looking for a good pizza

Good pizza. Tasty recipes and quality ingredients. Delivery was fast and the pizza was nice and hot when it arrived. Our favorite pizza in town. read more

Pizza is great. The crust especially. We had the loaded pizza and it was fantastic. Lots of toppings, homemade crust, good sauce. Service was friendly and quick. It's inside a bowling alley but separated by glass walls so not as noisy. Lots of TVs if you want to watch a game or something while you eat. We'll be back any time we stay in burley which is at least 2-3 times a year! read more

Omg ! Hangs down best pizza around! When I come to visit my family here, I must stop and indulge in this delicious cheesy pizza !!

One of the better pizzas I've had in a while. It was simple but done right with a nice balance of sauce and cheese. The edges of the crust had a good char but weren't burnt. Everyone working there seemed in a good mood and made the place feel warm. Definitely a neighborhood gem. read more

Puder's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Burley, Idaho

The pizza I had was great! The waitstaff was very friendly. It's inside of the bowling alley but this actually made the atmosphere really fun and enjoyable. read more

Pizza is actually really good!!! Great place to bowl and have some pizza and other foods while you bowl.

They have so many different choices of food to choose from. They service is great. Really clean and welcoming.

After a long 750 mile drive we were tired and hungry for a good meal, a couple of beers, and then bed so we'd be well fed & rested for the next day's 650 mile journey back to Seattle. We were somewhat hesitant to try a small pizza joint in a bowling alley nonetheless, but what a pleasant and tasty surprise we had at Puder's Pizza. We ordered the 12" Loaded pizza along with some onion rings and both were served within 10 minutes, and piping hot. The rings were nice and crunchy, & my wife immediately started devouring them quickly. The pizza crust had perfect flavor & texture and the toppings were also nicely cooked and the flavor combination hit the mark. We finished it all and lumbered back to hotel to hit the rack and get ready for the next leg of our trek home. So the next time you're in Burley, don't hesitate to give Puder's a try. I don't think you'll be disappointed. read more

Puder's Pizza - 12" LOADED & onion rings. - Pizza Near Me - Burley, Idaho

Great delicious Pizza and great prices, you can bowl too and great music - great service fast - Thank-you read more

Puder's Pizza - Yummm - Pizza Near Me - Burley, Idaho

The pizza here is so yummy! Plenty of toppings and cheese is on point! If you order to go they have coupons on the to go menu! Enjoy...

best pizza i have ever had in my life i would go there if i had to for the rest of my life

I love the energy of the environment this place gives me. The food is usually great, we did go one night when they were super busy and the pizza wasn't as tasty as normal. Service was great even though they were crazy busy with many parties going on. Strongly recommend going there for good food and fun. read more

Pizza was pretty good. People were friendly and courteous. Took my food to go. Wings were only ok.

Pizza was great! Nice crust, fast friendly service and reasonable prices! Will definitely stop in again while traveling by! read more

We were on a road trip to visit family in NW Idaho. We stopped in Burley to fuel up and let the kids stretch their legs while we grabbed a bite to-go. We found Puder's on Yelp and tried it based on reviews. So glad we got food from here instead of the chain pizza joint across the way. Cheese pizza was hot, fresh and delicious. Also had a Chicken bacon ranch sandwich that was so tasty. The wait time was not long at all and very reasonable for our order. It was perfect because our kids needed a quick break from driving. They rode their scooters around the wide open parking lot to the bowling alley. My husband says the gentleman he talked to when he got our order was friendly. We highly recommend Puder's! Delicious, fresh food and friendly service. read more

Sunday 630pm barely any customers and still can't get a simple pizza order right..ridiculous.

Awesome surprise! Was in town working for the week and discovered this place in a Bowling Alley! They sure delivered! Thanks!

So good!!! In from out of town and was a little worried my special request (no bun) would be looked at weird. This is the most beautiful hamburger I've had the pleasure of devouring! It was hot, delivery was prompt, picture perfect, very flavorful. So glad I ordered from them instead of a chain. read more

Puder's Pizza - Farmer burger - Pizza Near Me - Burley, Idaho

Delicious pizza and yummy crust. If the crust isn't good then no matter what toppings you add to your pizza it won't help. They have a fresh salad bar with lots of toppings and dressing choices read more

Great pizza with homemade crust. Enjoyed the Loaded (for the meat eaters) and plain cheese.

Delicious pizza and cheese sticks. You have to try the peach dessert pizza! Great customer service.

For being a pizza joint within a bowling alley, Puder's is pretty good, fast and good value. I was tempted by the little caesars that was close by, but I felt the yelp find would be more interesting than LC. Yes it was, the pizza has a fresh fluffy crust and the toppings were generous. The cheese a little basic and the sauce acceptable, perhaps a little salty, but brought the pizza together to be a solid meal. Ultimately, I'm glad I gave Puder's a shot, however, i feel that next time I'd order a special pizza rather than build my own. All in all a good meal and good price. read more

Puder's Pizza - Pepperoni pineapple jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Burley, Idaho

Love their pizza! Best in burley. The owners are amazing in the community and I love showing them support in return.

I was on the road and I live in a big pizza town so I'm ready for anything. There are a couple world class pizza joints on every neighborhood here so I admit to some snobbery. It's a high bar. I've been back home a while but I promised myself I'd review Puder's. I ordered a club sandwich and the biggest pizza on the menu. Too much is better than not enough. The sandwich was a masterpiece. I know, it was a sandwich but it was so obviously put together by a person with high standards that appreciates food. Sandwich perfection. Very happy, . Then I started in on the pizza. I was not initially as impressed. Of course I was lingering in post sandwich perfection exuberance so that happened. Then I had another and I began to notice the same thing. Meticulous assemblage of fresh ingredients, and in the middle of no where. All due respect, it's Burley, ID and we're talking about a lot of moving parts involved in pizza construction. I'm just sayin'. Anyway, I had another piece and I began to zero in on the sauce. So I had another piece. Very distinctive, I believe it's sun dried tomato in the sauce. So so so good. I was so hungry and tired. Yelp is great for zeroing in on these local gems. Bravissimo Mr. Puder. Well done. Much appreciated. One little bit of advice sir, your prices are low. In Chicago that food would cost me almost twice your price and I would pay it. I really liked your food. Thanks. read more

Recently was in town on a Sunday when most things are closed, and remembered this place. Ordered a custom pizza and a everything pizza. I love how cheesy it was and had great flavor. Medium pizza seemed more like a small but still I would order pizza from here again. read more

By far the best pizza I have had in Burley idaho! Everyone who works at this place really cool! Their prices are right, and again, the pizza is amazing! I would highly recommend this outfit to anyone in town, or just passing through. It kind of throws you off the first time, cuz they're in a bowling alley, and for that matter, if you show up on a monday, they have good deals on games! read more

It was recommended to us by a fellow traveler here at the new Hampton Inn in Burley. Delish! Great recommendation. Pizza was delivered piping hot, and they even brought us paper plates and napkins. Hotel had some coupons, which got us a Large 2-topping, cheese sticks and a pound of wings. Pizza was very good, over and above expectations, but the Wings... oh the Wings!! I'm not usually a wings fan, but these were crispy on the outside, and you have 4-5 choices of sauces (although Buffalo wasn't one of them). We got the BBQ because we didn't want anything too spicy (kids). Very Good. Did I mention that the wings were good? haha... read more

I got cheese fries and fries were raw. So that was disappointing. Got a pepperoni pizza, might as well been a cheese.

Great value and delivery service was top notch they even made sure to call in advance and confirm the location and room of my hotel and bring some plates and silverware. Pizza was great not out of this world gourmet good but really solid classic pizza that blows away any chain pizza options. It's a must eat if you are wanting pizza in Burley ID. read more

This pizza is amazing. It is always evolving into even better pizza, Justin (owner) continues perfecting it. Service is great and they are doing some up grades. I have no problem recommending this establishment to anyone! read more

Pizza was great and the place was very clean and staff was friendly and helpful. Connected to bowling alley

Best pizza around so far just wish they had more salad options like burnt lemon grill but pizza wise the best!

Headed home on the highway after a three-week road trip, we were disenchanted with the fast food choices. Our daughter was craving pizza, but we were pretty sure there wouldn't be any pizzerias close by because they usually take a little longer than people have to wait for food. So we looked a couple of miles off the highway and found Puder's. It had a pretty high score so we tried it and it was DELICIOUS! The pizza was crispy on the outside, soft and cheesy on the inside, and filled with really high-quality ingredients. It totally hit the spot for a hungry family on the road, and with courteous service to boot. You wouldn't have guessed the pizza would be so good, because the place is a total dive located inside of a sad little bowling alley where nobody's wearing a mask but there are more MAGA hats than you can shake a stick at. So next time you're craving pizza in Burley, Idaho, double-mask it, put your head down, and make a bee-line for the pizza counter. You will be glad you did! read more

After a long day of driving we decided to order take out. Delivery was fast and friendly. We ordered a mushroom, Canadian bacon pizza. It was good but nothing special. We ordered a wonderful chef salad It was pilled with chicken, ham and veggies. Overall a great experiance. read more

Exit 208 off I-84. Stop your vehicle, exit now. I do their pizza, and just order on sight, then stroll around outdoors with my dogs while it's prepared. Iconic neon bowling sign. Massive parking lot. This has become a destination for me. Yum read more

Have been in Burley for a couple weeks for work. Since I am in the office 12 hours a day I don't have the time to go seek out restaurants. I have eaten enough Mexican food and Jack in the Box for a lifetime. I had some free time so I came to Puder's due to the Yelp reviews. I have to say it was delicious! The pizza was great. Sauce had a nice tang to it, there were plenty of toppings and the cheese was good. I am more of a thin crust guy and even though this is super thick crust it is very flavorful and was crispy where it needed to be crispy. I only ordered a small today but this pizza would clearly make a good meal. I also ordered a jalapeño bacon cheeseburger. This was also good. The meat was a bit bland but wasn't super fatty. There could have been more jalepenos but they don't know I like spice. There was also plenty of chopped up bacon. The buns were grilled with butter and tasted delicious on their own. I ordered cottage fries as my side and they were great! My wife had a ham and cheese sandwich and it also was delicious. She chose Texas Cheese Fries for her side. That was the only drawback to the meal. They were not very good. Fries were too soggy and cheese over cooked. We ate the toppings off of them. Now to be fair we came between lunch and dinner so there was literally nobody else in the building so who knows if they are better when this place is jumping. As others have noted the cashier seemed bored and inattentive when we ordered. This was definitely due to it being slow time because after I chatted her up a bit she perked up and was friendly. I will come back for sure. I would recommend any pizza and/or the ham and cheese with cottage fries. I am sure the other sandwiches are just as good but haven't had them yet. The others we came with had wings and said they were delicious. One ordered a half chef salad and said it wasn't worth the price. Oh well I am not a rabbit and rarely eat salad. If you are stopping in Burley definitely eat at Puder's Pizza....yes it is in a bowling alley. The cashier asked if we wanted to bowl and I asked her what would I need a bowl for. She laughed at me and pointed to the lanes behind me... read more

I order from Pudders quite often. The pizza is pretty good. It's better than the chain stuff from the hut, and worlds better than pizza that is hot and ready. The bbq chicken is probably my favorite followed closely by the Hawaiian. You really can't go wrong with any of their pizzas. read more

Again, best pizza in Burley! We order 10-15 pizzas for deliver and they do a fantastic job! They cater to us and give us lots of plates, cheese, ranch, and jalepenos! read more