We had a very enjoyable experience here on a Saturday afternoon. The store has a great atmosphere…read moreappropriate for a cheese shop. We sampled three delicious cheeses in order to help decide on our purchase. They have an excellent selection and so hard to choose! Samantha was so sincerely friendly and eager to make our time there a pleasant one and not just a business transaction. We look forward to going back for lunch as they have a great selection of sandwiches with various cheeses. We went yesterday and today were excited to make "elevated" grilled cheese sandwiches with one of the cheeses from our purchase. They came out as delicious as we hoped for!

Unfriendly woman at counter, with a personality like dead wood. I tried being friendly, bought an…read moreoverpriced coffee, and browsed the rest of the store. How she makes any money is beyond me. The place is cute, but the service left me never wanting to go back.

I found Duck Island on a whim after a long hike and fell in love with the mini salted junior…read morebaguette and their raspberry coffee cake. I literally bought one mini baguette, took a bite outside the store and walked right back in for 4 more. It is THAT good. The texture and flavor was simply perfect, and having to warmed with a schemer cutter was heavenly. Now it's important to note that I live at least 30 minutes away, and returned 3x since my first visit to try their breads. TBH, it doesn't even matter what you get! They are ALL the BEST versions of whatever bread it is! I literally walked out today with 6 loaves of bread and as a carb-a-holic, I am here to confirm that Duck Island has THE BEST bread in NY. PS I am literally gnawing on a piece of sesame something (looks like a branch of leaves - so pretty) as I'm typing this. Just amazing!

I stopped by on 3/22/2026 to get a slice of Pizza Rustica (Italian Easter Pie)…read more Pizza Rustica is fattening AF! This is because it was created to break the Lenten fast. It is traditionally served on Easter Sunday or Monday in Naples at room temperature. Duck Island Bread Company makes an addictive one. The filling is cheesy, salty and hearty, and the crust is buttery and flaky. I enjoyed my slice with a glass of Pinot Grigio to counteract the richness of the pie. The bakery has an Instagram page, which I follow, and a Rewards program, which I am a member of. The service is quick, and the interior has an Upper East Side vibe.

I can't believe it took me over a year to find out about this place. What a great little store…read more Tons of imported goods from Italy. Michael the owner was super nice . I ordered a Broadway parm hush was delicious. Had chicken cutlet , fresh mozzarella and arugula and pesto. Also tried the imported Wagyu pastrami which was insane. Melt in your mouth . Will for sure add this spot to my rotation.

Me and my brother saw this place on yelp with no reviews, photos, nothing. We gave it a shot;…read morethinking it was new shop and it was. They have sandwiches, pasta, and more. We decided to get their sandwiches, the "liberian job" and "truffle wagyu ruby" were amazing that I had to walk back and tell them how good it was. Come down and give it a try.

One thing I love to do is review food, and Amelia's Bakehouse is a new favorite of mine…read more I went in today and tried several things off the menu, including a turkey and Brie sandwich, four empanadas (three buffalo chicken and one Smashburger), two warm chocolate chip cookies, and a hot latte. They were even nice enough to throw in a few extra things on the house. Everything was so good -- super flavorful, tasted homemade, and fresh. Mike helped me with my order and was very detailed and helpful when describing each item. The ambiance was warm and cozy! I can't wait for my next visit.

Been here multiple times & it does not disappoint! Food items ordered:…read moreTurkey Brie on a regular croissant: 4.8 All American empanada: 4.3, with hot sauce: 5/5 Almond joy iced: 4.5 Sweater weather iced: 4.5 All the food was well balanced, sweet & savory with a good crunch! The empanada paired with the hot sauce was amazing! The staff were nice - there's seating inside & outside, though small. A good place to stop before and/or after shopping.

So so tasty, fantastic gf spot. Service was slow, but worth it. Dot cakes were the only miss from…read moreme. I got the breakfast burrito, sesame bagels, chicken parm sandwich, cake bites and vanilla cupcake. Best thing were the bagels!

I never needed to shop for a dairy-free birthday cake before and didn't realize how challenging it…read morecould be. I found some recommended bakeries that would have taken me over an hour drive (/r LongIsland), but i decided to give BNB Plainview a shot. I called and asked about the dairy-free selection and they were incredibly helpful. Encouraged, I swung by during my lunch break and was very impressed with their dairy-free selection. Didn't realize that their entire menu was gluten free and tree-nut free (I have n=1 friend who would have appreciated this). I also liked that they separated the vegan and non-vegan items (we were fine with eggs so went non-vegan). The same person I spoke with on the phone greeted me and I went with her recommendation of the non-vegan chocolate mousse cake. While waiting, I had a gluten-free multigrain bagel (toasted) with cream cheese. It was really good! I was pretty shocked because I expected it to taste like cardboard to be honest. Now the mousse cake. I held my breath as the birthday girl ate the first bite. She loved it! Guess what. I loved it too! Well if I ever need a nut free, gluten free, or vegan baked good, I can take a short drive to Plainview for BNB. I may also return for a bagel.

Came here on their opening day. The staff was great and had a good conversation. I tried their…read morecannoli bambolini which is a donut filled with cannoli cream. It was good and a reasonable price of $3. Then I got a small scoop of their pistachio gelato which is imported from Italy. That was amazing and it was $4. Good dessert place and they have some specials coming in for the holidays.

What a wonderful new addition to the area. The staff is friendly and welcoming. I tried a few…read moresamples and left with some amazing things. They have four flavors (raspberry, Nutella, custard and cannoli cream) that they will stuff into the bomboloni when you order. They also have Italian donuts, croissants, cannoli, cookies and gelato! I will definitely be back for more delicious goodies!

The family wanted Bagel Master on Sunday! We got two French…read moretoast bagels with Egg and cheese. One SEC on a roll. Two coffees and 1 hot chocolate. Very delicious!!! We are addicted to their breakfast!!!! The service was amazing. They told me over the phone that they were very busy and my order would be ready within 40-45 min. I got there within 45 min and my order was waiting for me. Very happy with the service.

They will get your order wrong every single time. Wanted…read moresunny side up eggs? Too bad your getting an omelette. They'll toast your bagel dark, doesn't matter if you wanted toasted or not. They're stingy with avocado--THAT THEY UNCHARGE YOU FOR--, mayo, and cream cheese. Its literally a waste of money to order here because they'll give you the wrong thing EVERY SINGLE TIME. EVERY SINGLE TIME!!!!! DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. They literally cannot follow directions. Idk if they're just dumb or high but they literally cannot fill full an order to order!

We cannot say enough wonderful things about Broadway Gourmet and their incredible team! We had our…read morebackyard wedding on September 5, 2026, and from start to finish, they helped make our day absolutely perfect. We worked closely with Desiree to create our perfect menu, and she truly helped bring our vision to life. She was so accommodating, attentive, and willing to work with us to make everything exactly what we wanted. We also had several guests with gluten allergies, and the team was incredibly accommodating and made sure everyone had delicious options to enjoy. Broadway Gourmet went above and beyond with the setup and preparation. They came the day before our wedding to prep their display tables and work stations, helped us set everything up on the wedding day, and even stayed late to accommodate the preparation of food for our after-party. Their staff was absolutely amazing and played such an important role in keeping everything running smoothly. The bartenders especially kept the party going all night! And, of course, the food was DELICIOUS! Our guests could not stop talking about it. In fact, so many of our friends and family came back the next day specifically to take home leftovers--which we think says it all! Having a backyard wedding came with a lot of moving pieces, but Desiree and her team made the catering portion completely seamless and stress-free. They went above and beyond to make our wedding day special and truly brought our vision to life. We are so grateful to Broadway Gourmet for being part of our big day. We would highly recommend them to anyone looking for amazing food, incredible service, and a team that genuinely cares about making your event perfect. We will absolutely keep them in mind for future events! - The Bensons!!!

I called ahead to place an order for the French toast bites and a bacon, egg, and cheese on a…read morerainbow bagel. The lady took my order and said it would be ready in 10 to 15 minutes. I arrived within 10 minutes, walked in, and my order was already waiting for me! Since they have a designated area for pickup orders, I didn't have to wait at all. The French toast bites were delicious, crispy on the outside, soft on the inside and having the Nutella on the side was amazing because it kept them from getting soggy. The bacon, egg, and cheese was absolute perfection, and you could tell the bagel was extremely fresh! My iced coffee tasted delicious, too. We will definitely be returning! ¡Llamé con anticipación para pedir los 'bocadillos de tostadas francesas' (French toast bites) y un sándwich de tocino, huevo y queso (bacon, egg, and cheese) en un bagel arcoíris! La señorita tomó mi pedido y me dijo que estaría listo en 10 a 15 minutos. Llegué en 10 minutos, entré ¡y mi pedido ya estaba esperándome! Como tienen un área designada para pedidos para llevar, no tuve que esperar nada. Los bocadillos de tostada francesa estaban deliciosos: crujientes por fuera, suaves por dentro, y el hecho de poner la Nutella aparte fue excelente porque evitó que se ablandaran. El sándwich de tocino, huevo y queso estuvo en absoluta perfección, ¡y se notaba que el bagel estaba súper fresco! Mi café helado también estaba riquísimo. ¡Definitivamente volveremos!