the ice is immaculate i dont even need the food just give me the ice. the fried motzerella was good too but the ice was sooo gooood read more

Prometheus Pizza - my ice - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

Excellent start to finish. Starting walking or driving to Prometheus. Modern meets trattoria ambience. Meatballs are fantastic. Great bread and pizza. Do not sleep on the starter entrees (we enjoyed the roasted chicken). Service was relaxed and enjoyable (on a midday evening). We will be back! read more

A true delight. This place is serious about what they do. All the flour is milled right down the road, especially for this purpose. The ambience is nice and clean, but focused on the food. The bathrooms are a wonderful surprise - like a little side quest during your visit. We enjoyed the Basta! and were quite impressed. Service was quick and friendly. I firmly believe this is the best culinary experience in town. Truly experts in their field. I did not partake in the wine, but do want to note that they show a wonderful amount of restraint in their selections. You would do well to show up here with an open heart, open mind, and open wallet. read more

I should have listened to the name. Prometheus, after all, is the Titan who stole fire from the gods and was punished eternally for it--forever pushing suffering uphill. That myth turns out to be less branding inspiration and more mission statement. Because eating at Prometheus Pizza feels exactly like that: effort without reward, ambition without triumph, a rock of expectation rolling endlessly up a hill of mediocrity. Opening a pizza place is a bold move. Pizza is democratic. It's joyful. It's one of the few foods that can be both cheap and transcendent, messy and holy. When you open a restaurant devoted entirely to pizza, you are promising something special--flavor, balance, maybe even love. Prometheus wants to make that promise. It just doesn't keep it. The space itself leans hard into minimal Italian theater: red-and-white striped tablecloths, just enough décor to say "trust us, this is authentic," and not enough to distract from what's on the plate. The bar, however, is expensive and very aware of itself. This is the kind of place that charges confidently, as if price alone might generate quality by association. The pizza arrives and immediately feels... tired. The crust lacks personality. The sauce is restrained to the point of shyness. The toppings seem carefully portioned in a way that suggests cost control rather than culinary intention. Every bite tastes like potential that gave up halfway through the process. Not bad enough to be dramatic. Not good enough to matter. And that's the real problem. This isn't disastrous pizza--it's worse. It's forgettable pizza delivered with a sense of importance it hasn't earned. The kind of meal that feels like a press conference rather than a conversation. Prometheus aims for artisanal but lands in something closer to bureaucratic. The flavors are safe, muted, overly polite, as if afraid of being accused of trying too hard. There's something oddly political about it all. The menu speaks in lofty language. The prices imply excellence. The experience delivers compromise. It feels less like a fine meal and more like a corrupt politician shaking hands, promising transformation, and delivering a slightly warmer version of what you already had. Pizza should not feel like a negotiation. I wanted to like Prometheus Pizza. I respect ambition. I respect effort. But pizza demands joy, confidence, and generosity--and this place feels cautious, pretentious, and oddly detached from the very food it claims to celebrate. In the end, Prometheus doesn't steal fire from the gods. It rents it briefly, dims it slightly, and charges you extra for the privilege. read more

Felt this was a rather solid pizza joint. No frills, nothing fancy, small place but the service was attentive. I like how they leave bottles of water on the table so you can just refill yourself. Pizza was good, not going to blow your socks off or make your eyes roll back but it's decent. Didn't care for the sage sausage felt like I was eating a breakfast sausage vs other sausage crumbles. We had pepperoni and a classic cheese. We found the plain old fashioned cheese the best of the 3. Ranch was home made but $3 for a dipping cup is comical. Quality ingredients. read more

See all

Great stop on your evening walk through the town. Located a street over from Main Street that gives it that inviting neighborhood vibe. Well prepared pizza and salad, but the super star for me is their Granita! Definitely one of the most refreshing desserts you can have on a summer day. It's not on the menu, the respectful and polite staff highly recommended it. They were on the money, the dessert will end your meal on a high note. This is now a must visit spot every time I'm in Fredericksburg. read more

This is a tough one. The positive: service was great. The server was friendly and attentive. The spring salad was one of the best salads I've had in a long time. I also appreciate the use of local grains, etc. Sadly, I was disappointed with my sandwich. I mean, don't get me wrong, I ate all of it, but it was listed as focaccia. This was a very different type of focaccia. It was almost like deep fried toast and on the small side for $20. The husband reported the calzone as just okay. I thought it looked good and was a decent size. Overall we spent $91 with tip for two drinks, a salad, a calzone, and a sandwich. I would maybe go back to try the pizza. read more

Prometheus makes really good pizza. The storefront location has a great patio and the service was friendly. You can create your own off their extensive list of toppings. The crust is referred to as Neapolitan/New York-ish style which is accurate (thin on the bottom , crusty on the end) and tasted great. We started with a caesar salad and then shared a couple of pizzas The "spaghetti western" was very tasty with a hot honey drizzle that is a winner. We also had one with pepperoni and basil that was good but could have used a little more red sauce. There are a few good looking sandwiches on the menu that we will have to come back and try. Good list of beers and wine. read more

See all

The experience was great. Audrey was our waitress and she was amazing . She was very knowledgeable about the menu and offered great recommendations. The pizza choices were so unique. Thank you for making this such a great experience. read more

See all

I am not a "wannabe" food critic or writer. I just know what tastes good. Ordered the Spaghetti Western pizza. It was sooo damn good we almost ordered a second one. Strongly recommend this place. read more

We fell in love with this place. The mushroom pizza, customized with red sauce, sage sausage, and Kalamata olives, was out-of-this-world good. Truly one of the best pizzas we've ever had! They also have a fantastic wine list and amazing service. We will definitely be visiting again soon!! read more

Prometheus Pizza - Mushroom, sage sausage and Kalamata olive pizza with red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

We stumbled in for pizza on the first evening of our vacation and were so pleasantly surprised to find an incredible natural wine selection, including tons of bottles available to take home! The hostess was extremely knowledgeable and helped us pick the perfect wines to pair with dinner. We ordered the 1-800-SHRM pizza and the Farm-to-Table Salad, and both absolutely exceeded our expectations. The pizza was packed with flavor and wonderfully mushroom-forward. The salad was phenomenal! The ingredients were incredibly fresh, and the contrast between the crunchy vegetables and breadcrumbs with the creamy ricotta was perfection. And the dressing? I could've eaten it by the spoonful. We were so impressed that we came back the very next afternoon just for drinks. The bartender happily walked us through the wine list and chatted with us about natural wine. They had so many unique bottles, including a great selection of natural wines from Texas. This ended up being our favorite spot in Fredericksburg and is now a must-visit every time we're in town. We can't wait to come back! read more

Heard nothing but great things about Prometheus Pizza and have tried their pizzas at pop ups in Austin too! Stopped in the brick and mortar and loved the space. It was quiet in there for an early lunch on a Monday but as we left, lots of people came and were sitting out front in the cute patio. Got a Caesar salad and the Roxanne pizza. Enjoyed both but especially the pizza that had crunchy kale on top. Oh and get a side of Zippy Ranch! Overall, coming back again soon. Highly recommend their Neapolitan pizzas! read more

Prometheus Pizza - Caesar - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

The food and service here was great and worth coming back for. We were just visiting Fredericksburg for a couple days, but wished we had stayed a week after hiking and swimming. You definitely need more days to explore all the places to eat and shop here plus relax afterwards! lol We felt welcome from our first step into the restaurant. It is a casual place that felt like going to a friend's for dinner. Simple decor like this vintage wine map of Italy. Our server was very friendly and attentive. It was the perfect spot for us... not too loud nor too crowded. We shared a pizza which was large enough for a family of 3 (our little guy ate 1 big slice while the hubby ate 2 slices). I could not finish two slices and thoroughly enjoyed the hot tea. Ohhhh, the tea was SO good. I'd definitely recommend trying their tea, if you like tea. read more

Prometheus Pizza - Wall art. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

See all

Always an amazing experience, great wine list and service is top-notch. One of our favorite patios and Fredericksburg.

Phenomenal food. Everything we had was packed with flavor and so so good. The sandwich was next level.

We love Prometheus Pizza and we love Miles! We have driven by for the last 9 months wanting to come try this place out and it does not disappoint! I did not know it was Neapolitan style pizza so that was a pleasant surprise. They have a nice patio out front but it is cute inside so we sat indoors. Miles was our server and made wonderful recommendations! We had the calamari to start and it was lightly breaded with fried jalapeños and zesty house made ranch on the side. Delicious. For pizza we told Miles what we like and asked him to surprise us with two pizzas. He ordered us the Call: 1-800-420-SHRM & the Basta! Both delightful in their own right... we cannot decide which we loved most. 1-800-420-SHRM is refreshing and light. Basta! Is savory, sweet, and has a touch of spice. Dessert.... Tiramisu was dense and decadent. I wanted a second one all to myself. 10/10 we recommend read more

See all

The best place for a quick lunch or leisurely meal, whatever your speed. The team is kind and attentive, the food delicious, and a wine list that's intentional and varied. A can't miss in downtown Fred! My favorites are the house focaccia and the mushroom pizza (call 1-800-420-SHRM). Best part is if you find a wine you love, grab a bottle to take home. read more

Prometheus Pizza - Excellent wine selection. Chris brought us options, and we chose a Texas red blend and a fun Sicilian for our group. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

See all

This was such a cute place! I had the spaghetti western pizza and it was fantastic! The flavors were so bold and I loved the hot honey flavor. It was the perfect ratio between sweet and spicy. The crust was really good as well. It was kind of like a wheat looking crust. The size of the pizza was perfect as well that can be shared between two people. read more

Prometheus Pizza - Spaghetti western pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

We had an incredible dining experience here! From start to finish, everything was phenomenal. The service was attentive and warm, making us feel right at home. We started with what was easily the most flavorful salad we've had in a long time--bursting with freshness and perfectly balanced. Our entrees were equally delightful; you can truly taste that everything is made with fresh, from-scratch ingredients. It's rare to find a place that puts this much care into every component of the meal. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a top-tier meal made with real quality! read more

Prometheus Pizza - Steak Frites and Pistachio pesto rigatoni - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

Just alright, the dough had a weird flavor. Not a lot of choices in the area. I would not go back.

We liked our meal at Prometheus. We sat at the bar and ordered one of their pies with red sauce- crust and flavor was perfect. Pasta was good only bad side was we were sitting under a vent and the bartender had the window open on a cold night so our pasta got cold fast. Service was great up until time to get our check- we waited around patiently and our server the whole time was too busy chatting it up with another couple at the bar so we asked someone else to close us out. We enjoyed having a hot drink with dessert. Lost one star because both the plates we were given to eat our pizza on were dirty. read more

Food was delicious! The service was exceptional Ximena gave us the best service ever!!! Great flavor! Great everything overall!!!

One of mine and my husband's favorite places to eat when we visit Fredericksburg. A cozy southern/Italian atmosphere. Kind and friendly service. The pizza is always very good and quick. My husband loves tiramisu and says this the best one he has had! read more

Prometheus Pizza - Tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

See all

So happy this place is here. Amazing food, great wine selection, super nice waitstaff. I know you're not supposed to just look for places that are like what you're used to when you go out of town, but a lot of the local food is somewhat lacking. This fills the gap. We had 2 different salads, a cheese and pepperoni pizza for the children, a sausage and hot honey pizza for the grown folks, a dozen oysters, and a chicken Parmesan sandwich. Everything was fantastic. The place is beautiful inside. The bathrooms are clean, the music isn't too loud, and everyone was comfortable. Definitely get in here asap. read more

Prometheus Pizza - Chicken Parmesan sandwich, sausage and hot honey pizza, both fantastic - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

See all

Great staff, great food, great ambience! Will definitely come back here. Grazie Mille! read more

Amazing food and atmosphere!!! The meatballs were to die for and we got the chicken parm sandwich and the pineapple express pizza which were both so yummy. Everyone here was so nice and helpful I would come here again and again. read more

Great pizza!! Very unusual. We generally like off the wall type anyway. We had the Rueben pizza and will get it again . Great service and cute bistro ambiance read more

Prometheus Pizza - Rueben pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

We had such a great experience at Prometheus. We sat outside, which made the evening even better, and enjoyed a really nice bottle of wine while we relaxed. The Greek salad was fresh and absolutely delicious--perfectly balanced and super flavorful. We also shared pizza and pasta, and both were really good. Everything tasted fresh and well-prepared, and it all came together for a really enjoyable meal. It's a great spot for a relaxed dinner with good food, wine, and a nice atmospher read more

The OWNER waited on us and was so nice and informative. Such a relaxing environment and felt exactly like Italy. The food was 10/10

Food was so delicious!! We got the fried mozzarella brick and it was so good! Next got the Greek salad and it was the best I've had in a really long time. Finished with the Galatea pizza and the Pineapple Express special pizza! Both were phenomenal. Service was excellent. Come during lunch and dine with Dylan. read more

Prometheus Pizza - Pineapple Express and Galatea - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

See all

Very cool pizza selection. Tried 3 different kinds and each was delicious. They even have their own specialty ranch.

Had the best meal at Prometheus, we had this a suggested by at least 6 different people in Austin and it did not disappoint. I could not get over the dough used for the pizza so flavorful and gave such an elevated taste to the pizzas! Highly suggest this place for anyone visiting Fredricksburg! read more

See all

Total surprise. We were desperate to avoid any more German kitsch and figured even fake Italian would be a cut above faux German. In fact, the food was exceptional , as was the service, and the ambience was great. Calzone with kale was just brilliant. Mixed flour crust (?), high quality cheese, and good sauce. The winter salad was also memorable. I wanted to go home immediately and imitate all the touches (roasted squash, Spanish almonds, Etc). Great place in any town. read more

They have the best pizza!! The service is always great and the place is always clean!

Such a cute restaurant. Pizza was delicious and sandwich was good. Service was great and they were very attentive. Cute partial area too read more

Prometheus Pizza - Such a cute little Italian restaurant off of main. Pizza was delicious. Sandwich was good. Service was great. - Pizza Near Me - Fredericksburg, Texas

Excellent 'Roxanne' pizza! Had a uniquely authentic and original taste - combo of ingredients were aligned well. Crust was authentically Italian and tasted great! Servers were very attentive and cordial and the ambience was soft and comfortable. Great playlist...reminded me of Sirius xm, 'The Bridge' or soft 70's! Very agreeable blend of great food and atmosphere. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch and ordered 2 chicken parmigiana sandwiches, tea, and a side salad. The side salad was good! I enjoyed whatever they mixed it in. The sandwiches came and were enormous lol. We would have shared if we'd have known how big they'd be. The chicken was very fresh and tasted freshly breaded and lightly fried. The bread was a lot.... We took off 90% of it even though it was tasty. I'd have ordered the meal as an entree no bread with a salad and been super happy. Service was great! The place is cute and has outdoor seating that's dog friendly. Staff were very personable and made the place feel quaint yet upscale. We'd go back and try the pizza! What we saw delivered to other tables look and smelled amazing. read more

See all

Fredericksburg isn't usually some place you go to get pizza, but if you've been at the wineries, antique shops, or lavender fields and feel that hunger coming on, Prometheus has the best pizza in town bar none! My husband and I would frequent their food truck and were thrilled to find out they opened an actual brick and mortar. The lovely pizzeria has the cutest, vintage feeling outdoor dining area with great views, or a nice quaint indoor dining if that's what you prefer. The weather was perfect the day we went so we sat outdoors and ordered a custom pizza with picked onions, Kalamata olives, and fresh basil. The crust is so insanely perfect with a nice char along the edges, the sauce is light but bold, and the cheese has this wonderful salty, brininess to it. We also ordered the olives which came with some citrus peel, it was such a nice fresh, bright flavor! The olives are so cute and small, and they do have pits in them so they bring you a little dish to place the pits. We love tiramisu so ordered it for dessert and we were so glad we did! The flavor was flawless! It tasted like it had toffee and sea salt in it, though the waitress would neither confirm nor deny, LOL!! It was absolutely wonderful. And to finish off our meal she brought out small glasses of a lemon flavored sake to wash it all down. They are still in the "soft opening" phase and we were told that for those visiting they were giving the small samplings as an after dinner drink as a thank you. It was the perfect touch! This will always be a stop for us when in Fredericksburg, even if it's just to pick up a pizza to bring back home with us. I love everything about this place, especially the decor, even the bathroom is fun and vibrant! Check them out, you won't regret it. read more

See all

Amazing food. Beautiful ambience. Excellent service. If you're ever in Fredericksburg make this your dinner spot! read more

See all