Prohaska&#x27;s Oh Sugar

33

376

738

2 years ago

We stopped for a treat last Saturday evening as we were driving by. My wife and I split the small peanut butter cup Sunday with whipped cream and a cherry. It was loaded with peanut butter and nuts and we both enjoyed it very much. There are seats inside and outside. This is a good place to stop on a summer evening. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Norma P.

5

87

128

2 years ago

My husband and I stopped for a sundae which was delicious...we had a small peanut cup sundae which was the perfect size to share. A really nice place for an ice cream treat...will definitely return!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ann M.

3

157

94

1 year ago

The selection of ice cream here is amazing! They have Perry's and also soft serve. The service is excellent. Any time we've ever been, the servers are very friendly and patient. The portions are very generous! There are picnic tables outside and a fish pond. It's located on Lockport Road just a little west of the Erie Canal. Check this place out-guaranteed you won't be disappointed! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dana D.

0

6

0

10 months ago

Always love the ice cream here. So many flavors and choices. They give HUGE scoops for a decent price. My son loves the koi pond.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dom L.

0

1

3

11 months ago

$9 for a milkshake full of plastic. This is 3 of 5 pieces of little plastic sucked through my straw. Disgusting read more

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Plastic sucked out of straw - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Plastic from milkshake - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - $9 milkshake full of plastic - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Business owner information

Jeanette P.

Hi Dom. I am sorry you had this experience at my shoppe. It is…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Danielle L.

17

37

0

1 year ago

The waffle cones here are homemade and amazing. Warning a small is alot of ice cream!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deb B.

0

5

0

11 months ago

A+++ we love Oh Sugar!!! Great prices, huge portions! The staff are always friendly and it's always clean.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dana M.

107

283

1710

5 years ago

The small ice cream comes in a pint container. The medium comes in a quart container. I was not brave enough to try the large, but suspect it may just come in a 5 gallon bucket! Lol Regular Perry's ice cream, but SO many flavor choices, as well as creative sundaes, milkshakes, and more. They only had outdoor window service when I visited, but it looks like a nice place. The folks working were very sweet and patient when it took me a full 5 minutes to find a flavor combo (because people who are able to choose 1 out of all of those are just weird). Great little place and worth a try! read more

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Literally a pint of ice cream for a medium. - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - This is a small. The medium comes in a pint container. I can't even imagine the large. - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sara P.

66

337

585

4 years ago

Cute little ice cream shop on Lockport Road! Their colored overlarge Adirondack chair always catches my eye when I drive by, so when visiting friends nearby we took the opportunity to stop by! The good thing is the ice cream was good and the place was cute, the bad news is my husband thinks we need to stop there everytime we drive by now... wait did I say that was a bad thing? They have a huge selection of ice cream particularly their Perry's hard ice cream flavors, wow! so many! They also appeared to have a couple Hershey's hard ice cream flavors too. They also had a large variety of soft ice cream flavors and a variety of options to make with both, like floats, sundaes and flurry type concoctions. Our friends recommended the waffle cone. My husband got the butterscotch soft serve in a waffle cone. Note, their soft serve only comes in one size, it was a good amount, but no baby options here. It was really good, in fact although my sundae was good, I was disappointed I didn't pick quite as well as him on this visit. I got a Reese's peanut butter sundae. It was good, just not quite as good after trying his. Be aware that they give very large portions. 2 Scoops for example is a huge amount of hard ice cream. That does make the one size soft serve option interesting in my opinion. Overall the place is cute. They have both indoor and outdoor seating options. They have chalk for the kids (and adults) to play with, and an outdoor pond with fish for both kids and adults to enjoy! I think we will be back here frequently and think you should check it out too! read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Catalina A.

3

90

123

3 years ago

The ice cream varieties were amazing, the taste of everything we tried was amazing & better yet... the prices and amount you get is tooooo good to pass up. The workers are very kind and moved the line pretty fast. read more

Business owner information

Jeanette P.

Hi Catalina. Thank you for the 5 star review! We appreciate you!…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rick P.

0

14

0

2 years ago

Very good and friendly service. Had an ice cream Sunday that was very good and large for the very reasonable price.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristie S.

Elite 24

239

250

1551

6 years ago

Hubby and I passed Oh Sugar on Mother's Day and turned around to check it out! It's a cute ice cream shop you can drive up to and order or go inside when the Pause order is lifted. The menu is huge. I ordered a small snickerdoodle sundae and added hot fudge to it. I would say there was 1 (homemade) snickerdoodle cookie in the sundae, leaving a lot of plain jane vanilla soft serve. I would recommend adding some cinnamon or nutmeg to the sundae to help carry the snickerdoodle taste throughout the sundae. Hubby ordered a large peanut butter cup sundae with spanish peanuts added. It was good. We will def be back to try some cupcakes (when they have them) and some other desserts they offer. read more

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - an empty parking lot - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Menu - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - a bunch of sticky notes attached to a building - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - a variety of sweets - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - the price of the ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Snickerdoodle sundae size small. - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Helpful 8

Thanks 0

Love this 5

Oh no 0

Drew K.

0

2

0

2 years ago

The ice cream was very good with large portion sizes. Very nice setup and great outdoor seating.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Denyel B.

Elite 21

99

51

72

5 years ago

We made our first visit and it won't be our last! The staff was kind and welcoming. Our desserts were delicious and there was so much to choose from including 30 flavors of custard!!!! We ordered three desserts and it was $11! It's cute on the inside and adorable on the outside with a few seats to choose from. We had an ice cream tailgate to further distance ourselves and ate while we watched the sunset. read more

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Dirt n worms! - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - Dirt n worms in front of the shop! - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - A milkshake and a scoop of cake batter for the boys! - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Frank W.

0

15

1

3 years ago

Best ice cream in Niagara county!!! Jeanette and her staff deliver the best service! Don't visit if your looking for a small treat - their motto is "we dish ice cream like aunts and uncles, not moms and dads". I highly recommend making a trip for a great treat!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Patricia D.

0

1

0

5 years ago

There is a sign at Oh Sugar that says, "We scoop like your Aunt and Uncle, NOT mom and dad!" They are not kidding! The ice cream cones are HUGE. If you order 2 scoops, beware, it's like a 1/2 gal of ice cream. Everyone that works there is so nice. Great bang for the buck! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dawn O.

0

3

0

4 years ago

Love it here but this weekend we stopped in at 9:52 pm...walked up to the door and they said they were closed even though the sign said 10pm bummer! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Harold L.

0

2

0

4 years ago

"We don't give you servings like Mom and Dad; we give you servings like Aunts and Uncles." Truly, the serving sizes are gigantic. Not like the weighed and measured servings on that place on Transit Rd. The variety of ice cream delicacies and flavors is almost limitless. I love their hard ice cream, but you can get soft ice cream (and in various flavors) too. The place is really catching on and for good reason. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristi S.

25

1

6 years ago

Very disappointed in our order. We ordered 3 soft serve ice creams and 1 hard. When asked what size we wanted we asked for 1 large soft serve, 2 medium soft serves, and a small hard ice cream. If they only offered one size soft serve they shouldn't have asked in the first place. The soft serve that was supposed to be a large was the smallest out of all them and the small hard ice cream was the largest. Biggest waste of $15, never will go back there again. Tried calling about 10 minutes after I left to talk to someone about my complaints and no one answers even though they're all standing around. At least my hard earned money went towards color changing spoons--what a joke. Below shows their medium soft serve (the one with rainbow sprinkles) versus their large soft serve (plain). Just wish I included the hard ice cream in the picture for a size comparison. Keep in mind while slightly melted the plain "large" soft serve is missing ice cream in half the container. read more

Prohaska's Oh Sugar - "Large" soft serve versus "medium" soft serve - Desserts Near Me - Lockport, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Prohaska's Oh Sugar

5129 Lockport Rd
Lockport, NY 14094
Directions
(716) 280-1716
Call Now

Hours

What time does Prohaska's Oh Sugar open?

Prohaska's Oh Sugar opens at 6:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Prohaska's Oh Sugar opens at 4:00 PM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Prohaska's Oh Sugar close?

Prohaska's Oh Sugar closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Fri 6:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat-Sun 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Prohaska's Oh Sugar take credit cards?

Yes, Prohaska's Oh Sugar takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Prohaska's Oh Sugar have catering options?

No, Prohaska's Oh Sugar does not have catering options.

Indoor Amenities

Does Prohaska's Oh Sugar allow dogs?

Yes, Prohaska's Oh Sugar allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Prohaska's Oh Sugar have parking?

Yes, Prohaska's Oh Sugar has parking options. Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Is Prohaska's Oh Sugar wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Prohaska's Oh Sugar is wheelchair accessible.

Does Prohaska's Oh Sugar have free WiFi?

No, Prohaska's Oh Sugar does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Review Highlights - Prohaska's Oh Sugar

“There are picnic tables outside and a fish pond.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Desserts 377 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Prohaska's Oh Sugar

5.0(2 reviews)

1.6 mi

This ice cream venue is awesome! They have many options, and we often go with large groups and I…read morehave yet to hear any complaints. The service is flawless. You are always greeted with a smile and patience with the many choices! There are outdoor seating areas, as well as indoor. Very close to the Erie Canal. Portions are generous!

Excellent cupcakes with unique frosting flavors. My favorite is the cookie dough. They also had…read moreMonster's Inc cupcakes (Mike and Sully). My son has requested them for his birthday party. My children ages 2 and 5 loved the Super Swirl and Fireball flavored ice-cream. I had a hot fudge sundae with twist soft serve in a waffle bowl. YUMMY!!!!!!

Frey's Tasty Treat

4.4(45 reviews)

3.2 mi

Our favorite custard in all of WNY! Whatever their custard recipe is it's the perfect blend of…read morecream & fat. Love their flavors of the week & Dole whip flavor options. Service is always quick, staff is great. They have a nice green space in the back with picnic tables, a wooden train, a Buffalo.

The ice cream is very good with lots of different options. The Sundays are one of my favorites. We…read morealso love the dole whip with there new flavors every week. The service is so good most of the employees are very polite teenagers that are locals that we recognize most times. The ambiance is great for a hot summer day to sit outside or for the kids to play at the play ground. I would recommend.

Blueberry!!!

Cake Batter!!!

See all

Harris Farm Market

4.6(15 reviews)

12.3 mi

We visited Harris Farms just for their ice cream stand which is a walk up window on the right hand…read moreside. There are picnic tables to the right side of the window in the lawn for seating. It was raining when we visited so we took our sundaes to go. The staff was friendly and efficient. They happily answered the questions we had prior to ordering. We both ended up ordering peanut butter sundaes made with hard ice cream of our choice. He opted for peanut butter cup and I chose queen of hearts. Both were dressed with peanut butter sauce & hot fudge, pretty much "crusted" with smashed peanut butter cups and topped off with whipped cream and a cherry. The cost came to just under $14. It was a perfect after dinner treat and helped to brighten a rainy day!

Workers were not very friendly and my milkshake tasted like they put milk in a cup. They should put…read moremore emphasis on customer service.

Treat options May 2026

More treats May 2026

See all

Menu pricing May 2026

Hoover's Restaurant

4.0(95 reviews)

6.5 mi

•$$

There was an awesome selection of ice creams and similar items. They also have a large food menu,…read morewe got the fried cheese curds (one of my favorites). The portion size for the platter was huge. Lots of seating inside and a large parking area. Everyone seemed friendly enough.

My 2nd review for Hoover's. It may be just the start of spring but I'm here for the fall vibes. The…read morepumpkin ice cream is definitely one of my new favs. I recommend.

Inside

Watermelon sherbet

See all

Candie's Ice Creamery

5.0(1 review)

26.0 mi

Delicious!! I have no idea how they flavour the soft serve but it was great! I had butter pecan in…read morea waffle cone, my GF had a double scoop of chocolate peanut butter in a cup. All in $10!

Brownie's Custard Stand

3.6(38 reviews)

12.9 mi

Friendly service, good prices and a wide selection of Perry's ice creams. They also have dogs,…read moreburgers, fries, etc, but that's not what I was there for. I ordered the flavor of the week, espresso caramel custard twist. It was a great combination that I've never seen anywhere before and it was nice and creamy. The large size was $5.25 including tax (sorry, no picture; I was excited to eat it). Though very friendly, the service was a tad slow and my custard had a little hollow section in the middle. I'm guessing they have some new employees that are still learning the ropes. I would visit again... Maybe later in the season. To note, there is an extra fee when using a credit card. They have seating under a roofed patio as well as some tables behind the building in the yard underneath some trees.

Perfect spot on a hot day! They have a lot of topping choices but I just got a simple twist with…read morered white and blue sprinkles! The custard was great. There were a good amount of picnic tables to eat and we will be back when we are in the area!

See all

Look at all those flavors

De Dee's Dairy

4.7(201 reviews)

10.7 mi

They were very welcoming and nice. Portions were huge very tasty. It was a great selection and we…read morehad a great time and extremely pleasant visit

ORDER A BABY. This is a baby sundae. I tried to use a nickle for scale but it isn't doing it…read morejustice. It's huge. Billy Fucillo level 'Hugeeee'. My fiance ordered a small and immediately said 'Is that mine?!' Yes sir. Mistakes were made. Always delicious and always massive and finally an ice cream spot I like to go back to because the value for the money is amazing. But don't forget, if you only want a small, order a baby!!!

Baby cones - Chocolate/Vanilla twist and vanilla with rainbow sprinkles.

See all

Sprinkles Creamery

4.7(13 reviews)

21.1 mi

A sweet little spot with a lot of variety. They have an excellent selection of custard and hard ice…read morecream with non dairy items. Each week they serve a different treat. Great little place and affordable.

Ice cream was good but the amount they give has gotten smaller and smaller might just go to Dave's…read morein Batavia more often

Menu

Menu 3/3

See all

Hours

Sweet Jesus

4.2(119 reviews)

16.1 mi

•$$

I kept reading the hype about Sweet Jesus so on my last visit through Niagara Falls, the hubby and…read moreI decided to stop and get a sweet treat. Our consensus was that this place is definitely over-hyped. Neither of us was a fan of the ice cream here, and it's one of our favorite desserts. It has a weird consistency that doesn't even taste all that creamy, and the plain vanilla has zero flavor. The ice cream had a very light and fluffy texture that was unappealing, sort of like Cool Whip versus real whipped cream. I prefer my ice cream very thick and creamy. The flavor comes from the toppings, which were also a little bit boring. There are lots of weird sounding flavor combinations that they call "cone builds" that have sauces and toppings that are over the top, but we opted for a cone with cookie crumbs and cookie dough for me, and Oreo for him. The cookie crumbs were very stale and the cookie dough just tasted like regular old cookie dough topping, nothing special. I also thought the ice cream shop was very dirty. It didn't seem very clean or sanitary and if that sort of thing bothers you'd I'd recommend skipping this place. The toppings were falling all over the counter, which was an absolutely gross mess, and our cones were given to us already dripping and sticky (yuck). The prices are high but then again, that's to be expected since this location is right on the main tourist drag in Niagara Falls. It's right at the end of the street by the falls, so you can walk over and eat your ice cream and look at the water. We paid like $22 CAD for two mediocre ice cream cones. This is a one and done place for me for sure.

A Bit of a Letdown This Time Around…read more We've had Sweet Jesus before--mostly at mall locations--and we've usually really enjoyed it. But this time around on Clifton Hill, it just didn't wow us. We went with milkshakes: I got the Birthday Cake, and my wife got the Mango. Hers was okay, but my Birthday Cake shake was super underwhelming. It was way too liquid-y, the cake bits had an odd texture, and the overall flavour was just bland. Normally Sweet Jesus is known for bold, indulgent treats, but this one fell flat. Also the cardboard straws are TERRIBLE. Broke a couple just trying to get them through the plastic lid. The location didn't help either--Clifton Hill has gotten way more crowded than it used to be, and this spot became chaotic pretty fast. Might've just been an off visit, but based on this experience, we'd probably stick to the mall locations next time.

Sweet baby Jesus this is so good

Soft serve ice cream - $5 USD / $7 CAD

See all

Flour and Frost Batavia

5.0(1 review)

29.9 mi

Excellent bakery! Look no further if you need cookies, cakes or cannolis! I provided our theme for…read morethe shower and it was like she jumped into my brain bc the dessert were exactly how I pictured them to be.