I have come to this restaurant several times over the years and realized I never wrote a review of them. This is a high-end restaurant that serves fantastic food. The restaurant is very upscale and without even asking for my 30th wedding anniversary they put me in my wife in a private room to enjoy our time together. The wait staff is fantastic and very professional. The food is well prepared, fresh, and of extreme tasty. One recommendation is if you order sides know that one side is enough for two people. Our waiter Moses was nothing short than a professional, and did everything in his power to make our dining experience as pleasurable as possible. I would highly recommend this restaurant but understand it's a bit pricey but well worth the money. I had the surf and turf with a 10 ounce filet mignon with a lobster tail and it was delicious. My wife also had the filet mignon and she was equally delighted with her meal. If you're in Key West, this is definitely a place to come and eat for a special event. read more

Checks all the right boxes for a traditional steakhouse experience. Dimly light room, cocktails executed well and steak cooked to perfect temp with good flavor. read more

See all

Restaurant was empty 9/3 , we went for my husband's 60th birthday. Took awhile to get a drink which they gave us on the house for the wait. We both ordered the $64 filet mignon which was tasteless now I have a do over for a good birthday dinner read more

Amazing appetizers, the crab cake was absolutely mega and the highlight of the starters. The steak, unfortunately, was disappointing. It was a good cut, but lacked flavor and didn't stand out the way you'd expect from a high‑end restaurant. The bartender, however, was phenomenal. The dirty martini was one of the best I've ever had. The restaurant was clearly short‑handed, but our waiter hustled nonstop and did his best while the kitchen was backed up. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Appetizer - crab cake (jumbo and tons of crab meats) - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

My wife and I have been here a few times when traveling to Key West. They are clearly known for their steaks, which is exactly what we went there for. Steak was amazing & huge - I honestly didn't need the sauce, as the ribeye melted in my mouth. My wife ordered the same and as you can guess, same result. Service was over the top - fun, happy, on point and we were never without anything of need. I know when you go to KW, you need to eat fish, but there are times that a awesome piece of beef is required. This is the place for that!!!!! Give them a try! read more

See all

5 star dining. Excellent service! Had a great visit with top service. Excellent meals. I had the yellowtail snapper special with asparagus. It was special. The rest had surf and turf. Lava cakes for desert. They all loved it. The best steak they ever had was mentioned all evening. It doesn't get any better. Fun times, great spot for a special evening. Will be back for sure. Parking under the restaurant- $20 for 3 hours time. Have to download the parking mobile app which was easy. Park mobile is the app name. Overall it's a great spot. Nicely decorated inside. It's a winner. read more

See all

Review of Prime Steakhouse - Key West Unfortunately, my most recent visit was a major disappointment. I ordered a steak that arrived significantly overcooked. To make matters worse, I was never given a proper steak knife -- only a butter knife -- which made the already tough steak even harder to eat. The bartender/server Pavl was rude and clearly tried to rush us through the meal, which only added to the frustration. This stood in sharp contrast to previous visits where the food and service were much better. It's disappointing to see the experience drop to this level. I hope management takes the feedback seriously, because the restaurant is capable of better. read more

Given from Chicago I thought I'd stop by a " steak " restaurant in Key West and I wasn't disappointed. I was by my self so I grab a seat at the bar to watch the Bear game. Only 4-5 seats to view the game at the bar. Bartenders Mike and Nick were outstanding. I started with the cream of mushroom soup which was excellent. Had the surf and turf for dinner. Meat was cooked as ordered. Ambience has that old school feel and can tell my regulars come here. I'll be back. read more

Highly recommend this place. It's off the beaten path but has a quiet romantic ambiance. It's very different from the other Key West restaurants that are loud and seem very "busy". The menu has a great selection of fresh seafood, steaks and wine. The service was spot-on. I highly recommend this place. read more

Terrific - the only way to describe Prime. A truly professional waitstaff. The food is exceptional! Wow good steaks! I had swordfish with a delicious artichoke cream sauce, and I've never had better. Big portions - my buddies had steaks and they were huge! Many couldn't finish them, but they left with bags, not leaving the remains on the plate. 100% recommend you try this spot! Best steakhouse in the Keys! read more

BEST CRAB CAKE! Worth every penny and did not disappoint - huge lumps of crab with amazing flavor. The ribeye was very good as well but nothing outside of a normal steakhouse experience. Unfortunately the bone in filet was ordered medium and came out nearly blue - beyond rare. The service was decent and the inside is a typical steak house vibe. If you go and don't get the crab cake - expect the rating to be a 3. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Crab Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

Joan our server was excellent . The Tile fish with lump crab meat was a hit . And the filet and deep water oysters were to die for. Thanks for making our 31st anniversay a great memory. . read more

See all

It's still a 5 star experience. The food is exceptional and each time I come I try something different. This time, I had the she crab soup instead of an appetizer. It was thick with shredded crab. Very creamy and the best I've had in years. My husband had the filet mignon with a baked potato; the potato was huge and came with onions, cheese, bacon and sour cream. We had the key lime pie for dessert. The service was outstanding and by the time we left, there wasn't an empty table in sight. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Key lime pie - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great ribeye steak! Nice quiet place in key west for date night dinner with good service! read more

Prime Steakhouse - Ribeye steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Everything was perfect. The service was excellent. The food- AMAZING. Bone in ribeye was cooked to perfection. Hash browns and spinach were seasoned well and delicious. The snowy grouper with crabmeat was the best seafood dish I've ever had. Can't recommend this one enough. Be sure to dine here when in Key West. read more

Nice ambiance right by the marina. Great food, I had the shrimp scampi special and my husband the steak

We celebrated our anniversary here tonight. They really went all out to make us feel special. Service- by Andre... outstanding! Food- atmosphere- is absolutely amazing! read more

Prime Steakhouse - Filet, Ribeye, truffle Gouda mac n cheese. - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

This is the most accurate definition of a great dinning experience They are in there own category in Keywest Great staff, delicious cooked steaks fantastic sides and To die for desserts A must if you need to feel rewarded 5 Star all the way read more

Prime is my favorite restaurant for special occasions and date night in Key West. It is beautifully appointed great food. Great service great staff I highly recommend. Ales served us and we felt like royalty. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Special table for our anniversary dinner - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

One of the very best steaks I've ever had the same quality and taste or even better than Capital Grille. Fire grilled on the outside and melts in your mouth on the inside. We shared the bone in ribeye and it was a flavor explosion. We also asked them to only use butter on our sides and they were very accommodating as we do not do soybean or seed oils. An excellent experience read more

We enjoyed a Birthday dinner date at Prime Steakhouse tonight. Brendan was our wait staff and he was INCREDIBLE! He checked in on us throughout our meal, made great food recommendations and overall just seemed to care that we had a good time. We ordered the crab cakes and Brendan warned that it would be the best we ever had, he was right! Thank you Brendan! read more

If I was going for a rating off my meal it would be three stars. My grouper had bones, was small and 1/2 was a bit undercooked. My asparagus was cool and plain. I asked for a sauce and improved it.... Everyone else in my party had amazing meals .... The macaroni and cheese was next level yum.... Drinks were goodly. We enjoyed sitting on the patio, our waiter did a fine job. celebrating an event your treated to a yummy dessert with a sparkler atop. If I came back it would be for steak. (And some more macaroni and cheese) Although a chef at a fine dining should be able to do fish too. read more

Holy smokes. So good! Our waiter Alex (pronounced Alish) was amazing. Very attentive and knew what he was doing. We started with a dozen oysters. They were fresh and delicious. Alex brought us a ton of horseradish as requested, so that was awesome. We both had wedge salads, as we do at every steakhouse we go to. They were delightful! And then we each had the bone-in 24 ounce ribeye, with some creamy horseradish sauce on the side and they hit the spot. We took a slice of the Keylime pie and a piece of the lava cake home with us and both were excellent. We would definitely eat here again! read more

Prime Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

Enjoyed a birthday dinner with amazing food and cheesecake. Our waiter was attentive and helped me celebrate my big day. I highly recommend the Prime Steakhouse! read more

Prime Steakhouse - Fresh Catch of the Day - Oscar Style - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The food was good, not knock your socks off, but we enjoyed our dinner. We started with a few of the different oysters they offer (I don't remember which ones we tried), but honestly I couldn't tell the difference. Maybe some folks are more attuned in that world. I got the filet, my guy got the bone in ribeye. I liked his steak better. I did add the blue cheese to the filet which I recommend if you're into that. The sides (mashed potatoes and creamed spinach) were okay, but I've definitely had better! My reason for the 4th star was our server. He was phenomenal! Very friendly and personable and it really elevated the experience! He even brought us a complimentary slice of key lime pie for celebrating a special occasion. All in all we were happy with the evening. read more

See all

Prime 951 is a luxurious destination for steak and seafood. The ambiance, whether you choose outdoor or indoor seating, is truly pleasant and enhances the overall dining experience. read more

See all

This is for the owner of Prime Key west after getting back to the hustle and bustle of Massachusetts As I reflect on my time in key west two things stand out our trip to dry tourtugas, Fort Jefferson national Park and Prime Steak House Key West From beginning to end Brenden our server was AWESOME Filets cooked to perfection all the wonderful sides sautéed mushrooms Baked potatoes with all the fixins Roasted Asparagus Killer drinks and to top it off yummy key lime pie Brenden not only healed me a cab that gentleman even paid for our fare Brenden made for an unforgettable beautiful experience Thank you TEAMSTERS read more

This is another place which we always visit when in Key West. I mean when you have great seafood and tropical fruits around you for a week, sometimes you just need a big ole piece of beef! Now, I know they have other great items on the menu, so to start the night we began with a glass of Riesling and a bourbon for me ( hey you cant take the southern gentlemen out of me even in the keys!) The appetizers were a plump juicy shrimp Cocktail and the king of southern Florida seafood 3 XL stone crab claws! Yummy and delicious. So....She finished off all but 1.5 bites (2 if the bites are smallish) of a 16oz Delmonico and I completely destroyed a 12oz hunk of wagyu ! Washed down with a bottle of Brunello di Montalcino. Now while I can say of this food was delicious, it didn't beat the service. We were given out own private little nook to enjoy our evening and our waiter...I have had this guy on 3 separate occasions was top notch. I wish I had his name, but I swear that next time I will get his name! You won't be disappointed with your meal here, I give it a big recommendation read more

Prime Steakhouse - the menu for the prime steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Key West, Florida

Valentines Day. Tony was our server. Oysters for our appetizer which were amazing. We both had filet, Char's was 10oz & well done (which is what she wanted- yuck), mine was 16oz on the bone Med rare, cooked to perfection. Been coming to Key west for 14 years. Been coming to Prime for 3 years and it gets better every time! Great job Prime! read more

Beef is not prime, just the name. Service was ok albeit a bit abrupt and authoritative rather than welcoming and helpful. Im not sure I would visit again but if you want a decent steak, I wouldn't say no to this place. read more

This place is DELISH! Service was great from The time we walked in to when we left. We arrived within an hour of closing and never felt rushed at all. Moises the waiter was great. Very clear and articulate with the specials for the day. He gave us time to decide on our order without rushing back. I ordered the Pan seared chicken and we also had the catch of the day, the sword fish and it was delish. The bread was so good. The butter was so good. Everything was so freaking good and I highly recommend this place if you are in key west. It was tucked away so you'll find yourself parking behind it and find the staircase to the 2n floor & enjoy yourself. read more

See all

We had dinner and it was amazing! Our waiter Moses gave great recommendation for each of us after asking what our likes were. Great ambience and food! read more

See all

Wow. I travel a lot and this place has great steaks! The service was great. We reserved the bar because our trip to Key was was a spur of the moment. I had the delmonico ribeye with the sautéd spinach and mushrooms with an Old Fashioned. Excellent all around. read more

This place was OUTSTANDING! Food was all delicious and service was supreme! I don't ever leave reviews and I felt the need to because it was the good! read more

Prime's service and quality are unmatched! They were so accommodating for my large party of 11, and our server was incredibly attentive and friendly. Drinks came quickly. And the food was top tier. I tried the crab cake, carpaccio, and oysters Rockefeller for appetizers - all of which were delicious. And I received a perfectly-cooked rare filet for my entree with a side of broccolini and mashed potatoes. Everything was cooked to perfection and tasted so dang good. I highly recommend this for a date night or dinner with customers. The food and service are well worth the price. read more

See all

Increased my review from 4 to 5 stars. Have been back many times since my initial review. The service, location, food, and ambiance are all amazing. Most recently had the best crab cake and NY Strip I've ever had. If you want an upscale steak dinner you need to come here. read more

See all

I took my husband here for his birthday. He loved it! The steak was delicious and the sides were equally amazing. Our server was so nice! And the cheesecake at the end was a really nice treat! I highly recommend this place. read more

Excellent service and the food was stellar! We went here on a rainy night but we're still able to sit outside since the seating is covered but honestly it's not much of a view. The steak was cooked to perfection and every side we shared was delicious. We did the garlic mashed potatoes, smoked Gouda macaroni and cheese, and the broccoli au gratin which was the best I've ever had. Desserts were ok nothing special _ the espresso cheesecake was more cream cheese than espresso. Overall a great meal. read more

Terrible racist service from the hostess. Wouldn't go back to this place. If you want a steakhouse go to Vivas Argentinian steakhouse

This was probably the best restaurant we've been to in Key West. Food was top-notch and surface was great. Our server not only had a great personality but excellent suggestions. We had the filet mignon and lobster tail, surf and turf. And as you can see from the pictures below, everything was amazing not only looks, but in taste. And the oysters Rockefeller are the biggest oysters. I think we've ever had! read more

See all