I decided to give this place another shot after they reached out and apologized which honestly went a long way. It showed they actually care about their customers and their reputation. My first experience (a Friday night pizza order) wasn't great, so I figured maybe it was just an off night. This time around, we ordered lemon pepper wings, garlic knots, and a half-and-half square pizza: pepperoni on one side and meat lovers on the other. The lemon pepper wings were the standout, really flavorful and easily my favorite part of the order. Not too greasy at all. The pizza was a big improvement too. The crust edges weren't burnt to a crisp and everything tasted fresh and well put together. That said, I wasn't a fan of the sausage on the meat lovers side, so I'd probably skip that next time. One thing I really appreciated was how accurate their pickup timing was. I showed up exactly when the order was supposed to be ready, and it actually was, no waiting around. Overall, they definitely redeemed themselves. I'd come back again and I'm glad I gave them another chance. read more

See all

I highly recommend Prime Pizza for extremely consistent flavor and quality. It's definitely one of my go too for delivery. They put their pizza always arrives hot. They use extremely high quality fresh ingredients. I've never been disappointed other than one time and that totally was due to the delivery service I ordered from. You won't be disappointed this I promise you. Enjoy Michael read more

Just wanted a pizza delivered, which is 1 of 2 things pizza places have to do, the other of which is make pizza. We ordered it over 2 hours ago, and still haven't received it. Sure, it's Oscar night, but make sure you staff accordingly. read more

You can order any flavor by the slice (not just cheese and pepperoni)! They reheat the pizza in the oven and it was quick and delicious. The pizza is on the thin side so if you like that I highly recommend. The employees were polite and the restaurant was clean. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Stopped by and the pizza was delicious!!! The crust had a great chew, the sauce was flavorful, and the toppings were fresh. Every slice hit just right. We got the limited Earl Sweatshirt collab pizza "Heat Check", and I'm stilllll thinking about it The vibe is chill and perfect for a casual bite with friends or a quick lunch. Service was friendly and everything came out at a good pace. Definitely a solid spot for pizza in the area, will be back to try more! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Truly saves lives! Went here New Year's Day and it didn't disappoint as our first meal of the new year. Technically was waiting for a breakfast burrito from a spot down the block but couldn't wait much longer so our taste buds stopped us at Prime. Just walking past this joint will make you stop. A cute tiny location that makes a big splash in your day. We walked in and immediately could smell the cheese and pepperoni scents. We each ordered two slices and some cookies. My gosh were these slices huge. I couldn't believe how big it was compared to my hand. And because we ordered slices they were warmed up so nice and crispy crust at the bottom. Just the way you should have pizza honestly. I tried their other staples like the margarita and vodka truly chefs kiss. Simple yet satisfying. And it was so good we still had room for cookies. Perfectly soft yet crispy edges. If you want a good pizza slice that will keep u coming back for more Prime is the spot. It hit our spot for sure. Plenty of street parking. We even go a spot right in front. Solid walk by type of place. Grab a slice and keep your adventures going because there isn't much seating inside. read more

See all

Good pizza, fast delivery and was on time nice and hot. We had a family picnic and it was perfect. The gluten-free option was alright, a bit hard, had a humorous name. The slices are big; we each had two slices and walked away full. read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

(Used to be a 5) I never thought I'd be writing this review, which honestly makes me sad. I've been a loyal Prime Pizza customer for over 5 years. My boyfriend and I ordered weekly for about 3 years when we lived near the Brentwood location, and when we moved to Larchmont, we were excited to keep that tradition going with the Fairfax location. Prime was our pizza spot....reliable, flavorful, and made with care!! Unfortunately, over the last year the quality and attention to detail have become horrendous. And what's frustrating is that this wasn't a one off. We loved Prime so much that we gave them chance after chance to redeem themselves. Every time, it was just as bad, if not worse. Issues we've consistently experienced: * Flavor completely gone * Pizza cut wrong * Order directions ignored * Completely wrong pizzas showing up * Vegan pizzas arriving when we didn't order vegan * Garlic knots forgotten * Random ingredients added without asking We even tried calling the store directly to confirm order directions, and the food still arrived subpar. I know Prime has expanded a lot, and maybe that's part of the problem but it's genuinely sad to see the love and care disappear from the pizza altogether. We gave it one last try today (totally on us, since it had been a few months), and somehow it was still bad. Random olives appeared on some slices?? At this point, it's time to give my money to places that still care and pay attention like Hot Tongue, Triple Beam and newbies Sonny's, and Fiorelli's. You used to be so good. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

I haven't ordered a whole round pizza from Prime until last night. I've only had the square slice, which I enjoyed. . I bought 3 (cheese, pepperoni and sausage, pepperoni and jalapeno). The cheese was a plain cheese...no frills, all good; however, the other two were woefully under topped. Multiple slices only had 1 piece of pepperoni and the minimal sausage and jalapeños on the other. Spent a total $100 for basically 3 cheese pizzas with a lack of toppings. Waste of $$$ for what you get! I'm sure others are ok with what they get; at that price? No! Please try harder, Prime! read more

If you're looking for the best pizza in the area, look no further than Prime Pizza. This spot is hands-down one of the top places in Los Angeles for pizza by the slice. They serve true New York-style pizza--thin, foldable, and with that perfect crispy crust that keeps you coming back for more. Every slice here is straight-up fire . The flavor, the texture, the quality, it all hits. I've got to put Prime Pizza at the top of the list when it comes to by-the-slice pizza joints in LA. Trust me, this is the real deal. Anybody who doesn't like this place can't be trusted! read more

Prime Pizza - Cheesus - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Stopped by prime pizza earlier today to pick up food for the UFC fight. I ordered a vodka pizza, pepperoni and cheese. All of them were delicious. Big shout out to the manager "Dan" for the five star service getting me in and out of there quickly and being more than accommodating! read more

Prime Pizza - The Grandma Pie with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Prime Pizza totally hits the spot - I love the variety they offer and the vegan options. Classic pizzas with a slight twist. I am not a crust person, but the Sicilian has a super crispy but airy crust - super satisfying. Appreciate the employee for throwing in an extra garlic knot. It's the little things that make you happy and wanting to come back. Definitely looking forward to trying all the pizzas (vegetarian-friendly) on the menu one day to really pick my favorite. Only meh thing is the restaurant is tiny, so definitely a to go spot more than an eat in spot. read more

Prime Pizza - Sicilian Pie - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

Service was horrible and food took forever. Didn't taste as expected. Took over 2 hours to get my pizza.

One of my friends recommended this spot! The pizza we ordered was the gluten free grandma pizza, which was good. The service was good, not bad. The place is a little small, I do recommend you take-out or order these pizza pies from your home. read more

See all

Zero flavor in sauce and cheese. Crust was a tooth breaker. Very sad. Weird that they are listed on best pizza in LA but there's not one good pizza nor Italian restaurant here so go figure... read more

Definitely not worth the hype... this was my second time trying Prime and I have to say that I was sorely disappointed. Setting aside that I showed up to pick up my order at the time I was told to come only to find out that they hadn't made my pizza yet, and setting aside that my wings were sitting there the entire time that I waited for my pizza to me made and cooked, the pizza was undercooked, EXTREMELY oily (see picture), and overall not very good. The first time I went, I tried the BBQ chicken pizza, which I would rate a 7 out of 10, but this time we ordered a full pepperoni with meatballs added to 1/2. The first thing that I noticed when I got home and opened the box was the excessive amount of oil all over the pizza and in the box. The second thing that I noticed was there was only meatballs on 3 out of 8 slices - so 3/8th pepperoni and meatball is the same as 1/2? Umm, nope! When I grabbed a slice, I literally had oil coating my hand and fingers, which was a huge stomach turner for me. I had to get a wad of paper towels to dry the oil off the pizza, off of my hands and off my plate, by which time I was already turned off by the pizza. I was able to eat a couple of slices before giving up and turning to the wings.... Because the wings had been sitting while I waited for them to make my pizza, they were cold and dried up, which just added to the frustration. I have to say that for $73 I would expect to get my pizza the way that I ordered it, a lot less grease, and wings that should have been fresh and hot. I would put this on par with Mulberry Street Pizza, which isn't a compliment by any stretch. Needless to say, this was my second and final time ordering from Prime. I'm am truly baffled by the hype of this place - it's sub par, greasy, salty pizza that left me feeling pretty gross. Ugh. **** Follow up - I received the attached "canned" response from Prime. Nothing personal about it, and instead of sending me a direct message through Yelp, they decided to throw a pre-written response asking me to follow up with them through their website. That's the furthest thing in the world someone wants to do after having a bad experience and having already taken the time to write a detailed account of what happened. Especially after being up all night sick to my stomach. Thanks for the cut and paste reply, Prime.... You need to do better all around. read more

See all

My wife and I are NY slice fanatics but have never been here. Heard all the hype, barstool rating, etc. Decided to try it a few weeks ago and opted for a massive Sicilian pie based soley on the pics. We were not disappointed at all. Easily the best Sicilian pie we've had in the last 10 years and it's not even close. We got a pie with half meat lovers and half pesto and ricotta. 8 big slices for $32.00. Great price considering what we got. This hit all the requirements. High quality ingredients. Excellent flavor and balance with the pesto and grandma sauce taking center stage. Seasoned so unbelievably well. But the big winner was the perfect, and I mean perfect chew on the dough. Crispy around the edges. Damn this was really good. We picked up and brought home. Did a very quick reheat on high for about 5 minutes. They were busy inside filling orders and the staff was great! Excellent service! I posted a few pics to review. We will easily put this joint into our rotation. And that's dangerous considering we live in the neighborhood. Can't wait to try other food here starting with the NY slices. Enjoy! read more

See all

Ordered a slice of pepperoni and the barely had enough cups on it. 6.5 to be exact! Spaces were empty on the slice which could have contained some more cups. Pure representation of NY slices! read more

Prime Pizza - A disappointing "Pepperoni Slice" with only 6.5 small cups! This does not represent a real NY slice. The food is good but lacks toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Had pizza on my mind for a couple hours so I decided to put my craving to rest. My criteria for choosing a spot was limited to the following: pizza by the slice, ideally Detroit style, and somewhere quick. Prime pizza not only fulfilled but exceeded my criteria! Ordered one square of spicy pepperoni ($6) to eat on the spot. They gave me two squares and said "one square was kinda small so we threw another one in". So nice! Topped my squares with some red crushed pepper and took a huge bite. The pizza was SO GOOD. Crispy on the edges and outside, and light and fluffy on the inside. The sauce to cheese to cupping pepperoni ratio was ideal, I couldn't have asked for anything different. The pricing is extremely fair, the Prime pizza-ers are friendly, and it's a cute little storefront. I LOVE PRIME PIZZA! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

I ordered online and my pizza came with a few slices folded over which was weird. Maybe they ran out of larger boxes. However the pizza was really good I loved the thin crust. Not too much sauce so it wasn't soggy. read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

This place has yet to disappoint me. It's good, especially when I ask them to make it well done. I prefer my pizza a little crispy.

This was my second time eating here. If you have ever experienced the nostalgic buttery crust of Pizza Hut from the 80s you are in for an absolute treat! The crust alone made me bookmark Prime Pizza after my first time eating here! They have a great selection of pies, slices, etc. The fresh Arnold Palmer is very good. Service is always speedy. I really like this place! The crust on the square slice is TOP TIER!!!!! read more

See all

I laugh at the delivery time listed on Yelp.....45-75 minutes, lmao, good luck with that - try closer to 2 hours. Not the first time either, however it will be the last time I order from this place it's an absolute joke. read more

Great pizzas of all kinds All absolutely delicious and fresh Garlic rolls yummy The Arnold Palmer and lemonade drinks also delicious The staff extremely friendly! Salads also great Definitely a place to repeatedly go to read more

Wow Gluten-free pizza of my dreams only time I cheat on my diet! The ranch is impeccable and the iced tea does not have sugar. I'm a very happy girl. read more

A great NY slice in LA! The playlists are top tier as are their slices. The friendly staff are eager to help you out and let you know any specials. We ordered the pepperoni slice / spicy pepperoni squares and garlic knots. The slide was the perfect balance of flavors and texture. The crust holds up nicely when you go in for a bite. There's no need to worry your toppings will slide off. I do wish there was a bit more pepperoni on the slices but not too shabby. The overall prices are pretty reasonable and definitely a bang for your buck. Decent amount of seating allows you to eat your slice or take it to go. read more

See all

The best Pizza in L.A. I've visited 2 locations (Staff is always cool AF). Dtla and in the Valley-- MUST visit. The pizza sauce, the crust, the cheese... ‍ read more

Ordered online and my pizza arrived looking like someone threw it down a flight of stairs, or two. For $30, not worth it. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

The pizza is great and Carlos, the one who answered the phone, is phenomenal! He gives great customer service!!

I used to love Caesar salad until I eat it at this place. not sure how anyone can screw up a Caesar salad dressing... pizza was better than Little Caesars at 6 times the price? read more

I used to only order the square pies, but I've been ordering their round pies lately. It's a big pizza, and I always freeze the leftovers. My favorite is the White Pizza (5 stars) because I love the cheesy combination of fontina, mozzarella, ricotta, and Parmesan with strong garlic flavor. When I was pregnant, I ordered the Veggie (4 stars) pizza to feel less guilty when I had a pizza craving. It that included kale and radicchio in addition to typical veggie toppings like mushrooms, red bell pepper, and garlic. The Arrabbiata (5 stars) is a good base to add toppings or eat as is. It's better than the Cheese pizza because I like the spicy tomato sauce and addition of red onions. I've add pepperoni to it. The Pepperoni (4 stars) and Cheese (3 stars) pizzas are both garnished basil. The Gluten Free Grandma Pie (4 stars) is also good too, and it's better in texture than other gluten free pizzas I've had. They're available in square pies with customizable options. I've tried it with vegan cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onion. I like that they have half and half pizzas, and the toppings are easy to customize. The service is 4 stars. I've only placed pickup orders. The pizza has been ready on time most of the time, and it's always very hot. read more

See all

Classic New York Slice in the heart of Burbank. In store Oregano, Parm and Red Chili and even Garlic Powder for you freaks out there. Picked up a Pepperoni and a Sicilian slice, both delicious, sauce leans savory, great cheese pull on both. Highly recommend. read more

Great pizza and great workers. A casual small pizza joint. I ordered food to be delivered by uber eats and my delivery guy royally messed up my order. Only brought me salad. Who orders *only* salad from a pizza place?? Anyway, I end up going to the store to get a whole new order. It's the holidays, my whole family is visiting and now we've been waiting about an hour and are hangry. I get there and start chatting with the manager about everything. He ends up remaking the pizzas and gives me an extra one and cookies for the inconvenience. Was able to feed everyone and have leftovers for lunch tomorrow. They're great. I've always loved their food but they really went above and beyond and saved my night. Will definitely be ordering from them more often. read more

Thanks for getting back with me and trying to make things right. Unfortunately UBER refuses any refund after 48 hours. After much complaining I found out that the money has already been dispersed to you. The $20 instore credit was nice and used right away. Was still out $15 as that pie cost about $35. Next Supreme was perfect though. Thank you. People know this, even if you have been in contact with the restaurant right away, after 48 hours Uber will not assist at all. read more

Prime Pizza - Supreme pizza. Two top slices and two of the bottom view. Very disappointed that they would send this out the door. - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Great pizza. My kids and I do the pizza review like Dave Portnoy and we all gave it 8.0 and higher . I give it 8.1 personally. Portnoy also gave it a 8.1 so understand this is good pizza... Hard finding a tasty pizza place in LA. Thin crust style, great under carriage and crispy on the crust. Highly recommend. Can't say much about the other items on the menu but the pizza is well worth it. Oh man I ate too much.... read more

I heard Prime Pizza was rated very high in quality, so I had to give it a try! There's only a few seats inside, so be prepared to eat elsewhere if it's a busy night. While there was many coming in and out the weekend we visited, we were able to grab three spots. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza because I strongly believe it can determine how good a pizza spot is. Each slice comes out to $4 which is alright especially for LA. We waited for about 5-10 minutes for our slices to be ready. Between the regular slices and the square slices, the regular definitely and clearly takes the cake. I would describe the pizza as super thin overall, including the crust. This gave for a light, but flavorful taste. It was not heavy on the marinara sauce nor the cheese. While portion-wise, I'd call a slice pretty decent, I would definitely order more than one in the future because of how light a slice was! read more

Prime Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA IN ALL OF LA! I have been gluten free for 10 years and this is by farrrr the best I have ever had. First time trying prime pizza as you can tell I am blown away. I think this might be the gold standard of gluten free pizza. read more

Great pizza! Service was excellent! I would highly recommend. Lunch special is the way to go. read more

Prime Pizza - Lunch Special (Spicy Pepperoni) - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

The garlic knots are incredible, super garlicky, and delicious! The pizza is alright though, I've had better NY style pizza at some other spots around the area. Service is quick and prompt too, and pizza is ready on time! read more

Prime Pizza - Super - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

I got my pizza delivered. It came cold but it was still delicious. I just wish they sealed out the box better. Some taste a sticker to know it wasn't tampered with read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all