As sad as I am to review this, I definitely think that it needs to shine some light on the business. I've been to Prime pizza in other locations many times so I know the quality of the pizza as well as what they are known for. I'm a big fan of sliced à la cart pizza as you can try a bunch of different options. We ordered cheese slice, vodka, slice, a few white slices, a few Sicilian slices, garlic knots, the vodka pasta, and a handful drinks. Everything came out initially very quick. But not hot so that kind of knocks it down a point. About 10 to 15 minutes later the pasta came out with the garlic knots and the staff let us know that they were out of forks so we couldn't eat the pasta. So we can just let it sit there and get cold because we didn't know what to do, we weren't sure if we should go get forks somewhere else. A little confused that they wouldn't just tell us that they're out of forms to behind with so we could just not order the pasta. Then about 10 minutes later, they came up to us and said that they grabbed forks. But then we're back in the same predicament of having cold pasta and cold pizza. The garlic knots were also served lukewarm at best, I completely understand that they're busy and clearly needed to work out some kinks, but this left and not so great taste in my mouth. The overall bill was quite pricey for what it was, we were totaling and around $80 for everything not enjoy the pasta or garlic knots at all. The pizza definitely had potential, but needed to be warm. Hopefully Prime pizza can work out the kinks. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Really enjoyed my experience at Prime Pizza, definitely the best pizza in Brea as of now. It is a legit NY style shop that has a lot of good offerings. I always judge a pizza shop by their execution of a plain cheese or margherita pizza. They did a great job! Crispy thin crust, oily cheese (in a good way), everything you would want in a good NY slice. My personal favorite slice there though is the grandma corners they do. I'd go with the Sicilian which has pesto, tomato sauce, and ricotta. It is a small shop with not a ton of seating, but they do have some outside spots to sit and eat. read more

See all

I'm not sure what the hype is about but then I realized the hype is all coming from Prime Pizza itself when you figure those reviewers on IG are probably paid. It was decent pizza - a lot like NY and NJ slices but not quite. The crust is close but the toppings don't have the flavor and quantity of NYC. It's nice to have a slice when you just crave some pizza and don't want a whole one. Here you need two to even start getting satiated. I might try the other flavors or the square pizza since I live in Brea and sometimes need my pizza fix. Reserving judgement for now.... read more

Prime Pizza - Two slices, one cheese one pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Not so good, extremely greasy, and undercooked. Had the vegan cheese, regular pepperoni, and gluten free crust. Feels as if they sprayed it in some kind of oil which is concerning if dairy butter im allergic. Wasnt expecting that, and cannot seem to find any info on ingredients or standards for this restaurant chain. Nothing stands out, and I wouldn't eat here again sorry for saying that but I have to be honest. Long order times, they do not take orders over the phone, and even called to make sure my order was correct. Their app also doesn't let you customize anything Exactly how you'd want it. Example : supreme pizza, vegan cheese, gf crusts . Annoyed trying all the combos, and took forever to get someone to pick up. Order was also later than their expected time given glad the other reviews share that input... Ambiance is tiny you pretty much have a hard time parking, and no where to sit to eat. Don't think this "NY" pizza really belongs here in Oc. Would like to be proven wrong though..... read more

We enjoyed a few delicious slices at Prime Pizza for the first time today and we were very satisfied. Service was friendly and quick but the pizza was the real star! Incredibly delicious New York style pizza. Only down side is there is very limited outdoor seating. This wasn't an issue at all for us, but may be something to consider if you are coming at a very busy time. read more

Prime Pizza - Vodka Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

We are all human. Ordered a full pep and half sausage, but got a half and half. Pizza is still great tho. Just sad we didn't get what we ordered. read more

Prime Pizza - Order full pep and half sausage. Only got half and half - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Tried prime pizza for the first time, I really loved the butter chicken pizza it was very crispy yet soft and the flavor of the sauce was exactly what butter chicken tastes like. There could have been a little more chicken though. For the white slice I also like the crust but this one was bland and I couldn't taste any ricotta or the roasted garlic sauce. Overall would come back to try other flavors! read more

Prime Pizza - Butter chicken pizza and white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Shame on us for being "influenced" Over 90 minutes, charged by toasttab, the guys in the shop then go sorry. Your order #537 doesn't exist. Attached here for proof. No offer on anything but a refund. Not looking for a handout. But offer a slice for the wait with kids there. Less than 10 negative reviews. This is my most scathing one. read more

Prime Pizza - An invoice. - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

There are different types of pizza restaurants and this one is more a very casual quick bite to eat type. There is not a lot of places to eat except for a couple of tables out side. Customer service was good. The workers were very polite and were good at dealing with the busy moment they were having when I came in the evening. The pizza itself is good. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side and has average amount of flavor. The crust and cheese all went well and as a whole you can tell they are using quality ingredients. I have had a decent amount of New York style pizza and this is decent. While it is not my top choice, I also wouldn't deny a piece if someone offered me some. Service 9/10 Food 6/10 Overall 7/10 read more

We place an online order got there 5 minutes early they told me that the eta is 5 more minutes. I waited until 13 past the time I was told. It was my first time so I was patiently waiting on the bench with the many other people. The place is a take out place with a couple of our door tables. Definitely dont plan on eating here. The pizza on the tables looked so cold and not inviting. Our pizza came out hot but by the time I got home I had to put it back into the toaster oven. The spicy pepperoni is yummy and very spicy the other pizza was ricotta cheese and pesto I think it was okay. The pepperoni was on for me as long as it is hot and the crust is slightly crispy. read more

See all

This was honestly one of the worst ordering experiences I've had. I placed an online order at 4:45pm and set the pickup time for 6:30pm. That time came and went. Then another hour passed. In total, I waited over two hours and only received half my order after you guys said I wouldn't be getting my second pizza. No call. No update. Nothing. What's unacceptable is that they kept taking online orders the entire time while they were clearly drowning and hadn't even fulfilled earlier orders. If you're that backed up, shut off online ordering. Don't keep stacking orders you can't handle and leave customers sitting around wondering what's going on. Multiple pick up orders for later times were being handed out when earlier orders weren't even fulfilled. Being busy is not an excuse for poor management. This wasn't a small delay -- this was complete operational failure. The staff offered no transparency and no real accountability. If you can't fulfill orders in a reasonable timeframe, stop taking them. I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Love this pie. You never feel gross after eating it like at other places that use lower quality ingredients. Prime has become one of our family staples. read more

Took my buddy to the Grand opening of Prime and was the first 10 in line, it was his first time having Prime and he not disappointed. Prime was one of my go to spots when I was in LA. It's as good as I remember. Shout out to everyone at Prime that was there. I can't wait for the Rancho location, as it's 10 minutes from my crib. read more

See all

I really enjoyed their pizza. The crust is a win for me. So good and crispy. It's definitely my type of pizza and definitely will come back. Amazing staff and service. Not a whole lot of eating and seating space though, but lots of parking. I was too full to get the churro knots or the garlic knots, but will get them next time. read more

Prime Pizza - White and vodka - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Cool, modern, clean vibe and branding! The pizza was very unique in that the crust was super light and airy on the inside and crispy on the outside. Kinda like if you air fried focaccia. Overall thought it was different than other pizza spots and definitely yummy! Good spot to hit up if you're craving some quality pizza but don't want to get too full after one slice. Keep in mind there is only outdoor seating! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza options tonight - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

This location just opened this month so I came to check it out. They had a line outside of people ordering pizza so I figured it was going to be worth it. I ordered the chicken Parm sub, Sicilian and spicy pep square pie, ceaser salad, and lemon pepper wings. Everything was so delicious I'll definitely be back! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

I have literally waited decades for a neighborhood pizzeria, that makes legit NY style pies. Growing up in Jersey, just outside NYC, I had three amazing pizzerias I could walk to. That all changed when I moved out here. Don't get me wrong, I love living in SoCal. I mean it was 75 degrees today, while the high was 36 in my hometown. But I miss the pizza. With that said, I've been counting down the days Prime opened their Brea loc, since I live only 15 min away. So, I rolled up on opening day for a coupla slices to go. One plain and one pepperoni. Since seating there is limited, I told them not to heat them and I took them to go. 5 min in the toaster oven, on 350 degrees, and I was reliving my youth. It was everything I hoped it would be. Thanks Prime and I'll see you on Friday for a whole pie. Or two. read more

Prime Pizza - Pep/Plain slice. - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

We ordered two pizzas here for the Super Bowl yesterday, and I honestly can't emphasize enough how disappointing the entire experience was. We got an 18" supreme and a vegan gluten-free pizza. What immediately stood out was that both were equally expensive--about $30 each--even though the vegan pizza is much smaller. Not great, but the game had already started and we needed food, so we went with it. The website already showed delays for our selected delivery time, so we had to push it later and ended up waiting over an hour. We also called to make sure Parmesan and pepper flakes would be included since we forgot to request them online, and they said yes. When the delivery finally arrived, the "supreme" had no meat at all--just a plain pie with a few mushrooms and onions and barely any cheese. We were shocked. Also there were no Parmesan or pepper flakes. We called, and to their credit, they agreed to remake and redeliver within 45 minutes. I appreciated that they believed us, but it still meant waiting nearly another hour while the game was already halfway over--so we ended up eating the wrong, flavorless pizza just to have something. When the replacement supreme finally showed up, it was at least made correctly--but still disappointing. The toppings were extremely sparse for a $30 pizza, and they didn't even reach the edges, leaving what felt like more than half the pie was plain dough. The thin crust wasn't crispy, and the slices drooped so much they were hard to eat. I actually had to put it in the air fryer just to make it somewhat decent. Honestly, Pizza Hut or Roundtable would've been better. Overall, this was an expensive, frustrating experience with very underwhelming food - definitely not what you want on Super Bowl night. read more

Best pizza I've ever had in my life. Easily 5 stars and the staff was super friendly & nice and the vibes were immaculate read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza and wings - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

I agree with the reviews that say that this location doesn't taste the same as LA locations, but we still love having access to a Prima Pizza location from OC. Try heating up the pizza by the slice using low-heat and no oil on frying on- it tastes better than some Joe's pizza locations in NY ‍ read more

Karina & Christy went above and beyond for our first time having Prime Pizza in Brea. First of all their pizzas are all made fresh to order and you taste the freshness especially the crust. Absolutely delicious!! My Son wanted pepperoni for his bday! His Aunt recommended Prime Pizza from past experience in El Segundo, so this was her first choice being in the Fullerton area. Though the location is more of counter service style, the Brea team was very attentive when it came to us dining outside. The Brea team was attentive and anticipated all our needs. What stood out the most, was that we were celebrating my Sons 14th bday. Karina was able to rustle up a candle and brought out their signature cinnamon knots with a candle! ;) Definitely above and beyond! Prime pizza seems to flourishing and with bringing in these type of team members it is not a surprise why! Thank you Karina & Christy! The Negrete Family read more

I came to this pizzeria with high hopes, but it turned out to be a huge disappointment. I placed an order online, and the girl on the phone didn't even understand what I wanted to order (it took 20 minutes--maybe it was her first day). When I arrived at the pizzeria, the pickup time was fine, but unfortunately, they got the pizzas wrong. Needless to say, I won't be coming back. read more

Prime Pizza - undercooked pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

Ordered 2 pies 1 NY style 1 Sicilian Round has no flavor Sicilian raw on the bottom and no flavors at all. No big expectations but was not worth at all. read more

Came here on Sunday around 6:15pm. I'll tell you this is peak hour of busy. You've got people lined up to order, and people waiting on delivery. The order line moved, so it's not like you're stuck waiting to order. They ran out of pepperoni sliced pizza as one person purchased all the slices (smart move?). We ordered four pizza single sliced and the wings to dine in, and wanted to take the pie home. There was a miscommunication on the order with the wings to be sent home, however one of the girls was quick to address it, and bring it out to us. Despite it being slightly overwhelmingly busy, I thought the crew handled it very well. I will return, probably not close to peak hour and order beforehand and just pick up. read more

See all

The service was great. However I ordered a variety of items and everything was very very salty (the half and half pizza, two square slices, chicken wings and meatballs). I was very disappointed and my family and I could feel our blood pressure rising from the saltiness. read more

Walked in to the tiny order area there were 2 people ahead of me waiting to order As I was looking at the menu I noticed 4or 5 guys in clear view making pizza... After watching them I left immediately. 2 guys (with gloves on) 1 without twirling pizza dough watching in come to a rest over their arms peeling it off to toss again.. one had a watch on... These guys are in a fishbowl in clear view of customers and need to remember this.. read more

Had very high hopes as I was looking for a NY style pizza with crispy crust locally (everywhere I go is a bit soggy). Tried ordering one time and the wait was going to be over an hour and a half, wasn't about to wait that long for pizza. Tried another time, and I got a supreme and hawaiian and the crust was crispy-ish, but not near as good as the expectation I had. Also, the supreme was really salty and just really not that great. The pizzas were also really pricy and the quality, taste, and experience did not make up for it at all. read more

I don't like giving businesses unfavorable reviews but I want to save you money and disappointment. I like to try new businesses but this pizza reminded me of what we got in the cafeteria in sixth grade: burnt crust on the bottom, flatter than a pancake, mostly tomato sauce, and very little cheese. And it was supposed to be a cheese pizza! We literally threw it out after we both had one piece. Don't bother or waste your money. Going back to Frattelino's. read more

Prime Pizza - Barely any cheese on this cheese pizza. Pieces were stiff, not soft, and not chewy. - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Food was good. Service was great. Was told it was a 10 minute wait for pizza. They came out in 2. Definitely would return.

Really enjoyed my experience of prime pizza. I have tried almost all the good pizza around OC, and I'd put these guy toward the upper tier. I ordered the Pepperoni pizza, gave it a solid 7.9 pizza score. I actually think the star of the show was the lemon pepper wings. Probably the best lemon pepper I've had around here. Also tried a square pizza slice, the spicy pepperoni. I definitely prefer the round pies. But it was decent. The ease of ordering online and it being ready for pick up so fast was kind of remarkable for a Saturday. They are working fast over there!! read more

See all

Got a Sicilian slice with some garlic knotts ! Arnold Palmer couldn't decide what was my favorite ! Everything was amazing . Speedy service ! Definitely will be back ! read more

I was exited to hear a New York Style pizza was opening in Brea. Finally got to try it and it was pretty good. Nice thin crust, light sauce with a just the right amount of cheese. I got the Lunch Special of 2 cheese slices and a drink - $10 + tax. It's cheaper than Szbarro's Pizza for 2 slices and a drink ($14.95 + tax). Slices are a bit smaller but it still hit the spot! I've only had the cheese pizza here so my review is only on the cheese pizza. I'd say it's good. Has good flavor with a good crust. I wasn't blown away but overall it's a pretty good tasting pizza. I definitely feel reheating the pizza after sitting for a while affects both the taste and texture. You don't get that ooey-gooey cheese melt or pull and the crust ends up pretty chewy. If I ever get to try a cheese pizza fresh out of the oven, I'll gladly update my review. Service is walk-up counter ordering then wait for your order. I've been a few times now and each time I chose take out so I just sit on one of two benches and wait. If you're dining there, staff will bring your food out to you. Store front is a bit smaller but functional for ordering. There is a glass casing filled with a variety of pizza's on display. Overall, if you're in the mood for New York Style thin crust pizza and you're in or around Downtown Brea, Prime Pizza is a good spot. read more

See all

Saw a post on IG about this new pizza place that opened up in Brea and wanted to come try it. My family and I came here right when they opened at 11am on a Saturday morning and decided to try their Meat Lovers Square Pizza Pie. It was about $32 and had 8 slices. It was pretty good. Pretty filling as well! Flavor was good. We also got a side of their Meatballs that came with 4 pcs and 2 garlic knots, and the Churro Knots (6 pcs). We enjoyed everything we ordered. I only wish they had seating inside. They have a good amount of outdoor seating, but the day we went was super windy so we couldn't really enjoy our food there. Not sure if they even have any restrooms on site so be mindful of that when you come. Our order came out pretty fast...waited about 20-25 minutes. Overall, we enjoyed everything we got and would love to come back here again and try other flavors out. read more

We've been a few times now with some admittedly high expectations as a house of pizza snobs. The first visit we tried a bunch of things. Cheese slice was decent. Pepperoni, also fine. The Sicilian was the best we tried by far. Then they didn't include the white slice we ordered. Bummer. The last visit we ordered a white pie with sausage which was disappointing. The ricotta was almost flavorless, but the sausage was quality. The Sicilian was just OK this time, basically just a slice of focaccia. Given the price points here, there is a lot left to be desired in terms of flavor and ingredients. We haven't been to other Prime locations and this was highly recommended by friends. But, it's just not worth it. We won't be back. read more

We stopped by on a Wednesday night, wanted to try a new local pizza place. We were impressed, and we are pretty going when it comes to food. We for a slice of cheese, one white slice and BBQ slice. The cheese was really nothing great about it, hardly any cheese tbh. The white slice wasn't awful, but it didn't taste fresh. The BBQ slice was strange ,BBQ sauce and Marinara? ‍ strange combo but ok. Last was the ranch, all we could taste was the black pepper. I don't normally do reviews but was really bummed about this place. read more

I ordered a pizza and waited 20 minutes for the sides but the pizza was ready???? All they could say was sorry!!! Worst service crew. JT read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Food is Great! Service is Swell! Ambiance is Fantastic and Terrific! Thank You Prime Pizza, Everything it was all Delicious! read more

Prime Pizza - Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

I came here for the first time the pizza slices was $5.75 I got two slices one spicy square pepperoni and one bbq chicken slice the pizza tasted very old stale and hard there was no tomato sauce in the pizza it tasted like hard bread. I'm not sure when they made the pizza but it literally tasted like they made it over 8 hours ago and they just warmed it up it was gross disgusting and old. There was no indoor seating we had to sit outside it was windy everything was flying away napkins paper and straw I will never come back. read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy pepperoni square slice - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

I'm not sure how ai heard about Prime pizza in Brea, but I am so glad I did. Another reviewer mentions the crisp crust and tangy sauce and ai have to agree! The slices are big, and perfectly foldable for the quintessential NY fold. I ordered two slices (the pepperoni and a white sauce slice) and an Arnold Palmer since I was dining by myself. The pizza is so good! It's definitely NY style. An unexpected delight was the Arnold Palmer - Fresh and made "in house" I think. At least it tasted that way to me. It absolutely hit the spot. Ordering was pretty easy. The staff was so nice. It was kind of the staff to bring my pizza all the way over to the seating area outside so I didn't have to walk back. I did expect there to be some inside seating, but it's all good. Not every pizza place has that. I was glad there was some seating outside. I think next time I will order ahead to take home. It was busy but not crazy. There was no line. Looking forward to going back! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza by the slice and exterior seating - Pizza Near Me - Brea, California

See all

Pizza needed cheese $30.17 for my pepperoni pie left me disappointed Walmarts $7 pizza I was very satisfied and it had everything on it.. read more