Had such an amazing meal. Ordered a bunch of apps and had drinks which were all great! Our waitress, Champaine, was also amazing. So sweet and on top of everything!! When I booked the reservation online I put that the occasion was anniversary and they surprised us with a piece of cake and the plate said happy anniversary with a sparkler. Would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

I cant believe I am finding out about this hotspot today. Music is phenomenal! I ate the pork chop....beyond delicious. Trevor the chef is absolutely amazing! Came to talk to the patron's. Come here! I danced....are...and drank all night. read more

I went to this establishment for Sunday brunch with 4 of my friends. The place is small, and stylish. They have a dress code that they strictly enforce. If you don't follow it they are not shy to turn you away. While there, they turned away a guy who had on a nice designer sweatsuit. The place seems to want to be classy, but has room for improvement. We made reservations, and as we walked in we were told by the hostess, and then by our waiter when we sat down that there is a two hour limit for the table. They had a prefixed $59 menu for brunch, and an automatically gratuity at the end. Brunch came with your own bottle and an entrée per person. You have to finish the entire bottle before leaving, or you had the option to take it home unopened. If you decided to drink your bottle there, they present it with a long bendy straw to drink out of... Not something I would have imagined. The entrees were nothing special. They had about three options that were included with the price of the fixed menu, and about 4-5 options at an additional cost ranging from $5-$11. Although good, the music was extremely loud, we could hardly hear each other speak. Not only did we ask if the volume can be turned down a little, another table asked as well and they didn't budge at all. Food was okay, the wings were tiny and the "truffle fries" were regular fries... boring and not worth it. The shrimp and grits were very tasty and big portioned sized, but prepare to eat it all because they don't have the proper to go boxes to put it in after asking the waiter if they had anything other than the paper cardboard that was presented. I would've expected at least tinfoil to go plates as most other places have them. The peach French toast was tasty, and well presented, and my other friend seemed to enjoy her burger. Having about 20 minutes left of the table, the waiter again told us that our time is almost up and that the next reservation was here... We didn't see anyone waiting, but okay. Brunch wasn't horrible but I would go elsewhere. I will probably go back to try dinner as I hear that's a better experience. read more

Went here for Mother's Day . They had a beautiful diverse menu , perfect ambience with jazz music playing in the background . The food was delicious ! I had the Lobster and crab with garlic mashed potato while my mother had the fried branzino over a sweet potato mash. The wait staff was attentive , however, just a tad slow. They brought out our appetizers well before our drinks due to delay at the bar. Other than this , I do plan to return to try out other items on the menu. read more

DONT COME HERE!!! I wish I could give them a zero but yelp makes you select some type of stars. I visited prime 39 yesterday afternoon for some early dinner with my two friends. For context I have been to this establishment prior also with issues but yesterday takes the cake. Let's start with the service because the host looked like she didn't want to be there. She sat us and said nothing about our waitress coming soon or anything when mind you happy hour was ending in 15 minutes and their menu is not that big so we pretty much knew what we wanted. As our waitress is walking by us to go talk to the host for whatever reason I ask the host where is our waitress/waiter, will they be coming? Then our waitress goes " im the waitress" okay so why haven't we been addressed then? Next the waitress takes our drink order doesn't say much which I found weird and walks off. She brings us water and after that the manager comes over and KICKS us out of the restaurant. Her reasoning is "due to an employees safety we will have to leave, they cannot serve us anymore and she's confirmed with the head manager that this is acceptable and we must leave, we don't want this to escalate and call the police" we didn't even do anything literally sitting there. thank goodness we aren't problematic people we were just confused because to our knowledge we did not know anyone that personally works nor could we see anyone really because we were sitting at the first booth/table by the door. Our waitress must've said something. So as the manager is making us leave we are outside trying to figure out where to eat next since we're hungry as hell and out of the doors come another waitress or bartender whatever, trying to attack my friend. Low and behold this girl is like a psycho stalker from my friends old school and she is outside the restaurant, her place of work, being held back by her manager and another bus boy screaming looking an absolute mess trying to kick punch whatever and me and my friend are just standing there watching her act a fool. So I said get her back inside or well call the cops because now we're damn near being attacked and y'all kicked us out cause we're the problem? Then as we are leaving she's still trying to run after us. Afterwards we went to the restaurant across the street and they called the police to come look for us so then we had to deal with three officers walking up on us in a totally different restaurant for no reason. I'm pretty sure this girl hasn't been fired. All in all very unprofessional establishment, the food is overhyped and over priced and the management has terrible customer service. The waiters/waitresses had bad service each time I went. Don't spend money here. 0/10 experience. read more

Went to celebrate a birthday and the service was mediocre at best. Don't go for a special occasion keep it light. Dinner was okay but they made it clear they do nothing for any occasion. While I understand this we are in the middle of a pandemic and there isn't much to do other than dinner. Very disappointed. read more

Friendly staff, great attention to service, and awesome food. Try the roasted brussels sprouts and the BBQ salmon! If you like garlic, do yourself a favor and try the truffle fries. Be sure to make a reservation and be on time, as Prime 39 is in high demand and takes COVID regulations seriously. read more

So Good! This spot is sexy, will absolutely be going back. I had filet which was great, but the surprise was the fried chicken...possibly the best I've ever had and the mac and cheese is top 3. I didn't love the crab cakes, but everything else was fantastic, from the greeting to the dessert. Nice addition to the neighborhood! read more

Prime 39 It's a great place to eat. Food was delicious. Drinks was on point. The problem we 4 guest had was the waitress took our drink order then came back took our food order after we got our drinks. Come to find out a bottle of wine come with one of the food orders good to know before we ordered drinks. We got our appetizers, then our food but my friend she never received her food. We wave down a waiter and he said he will check 10 minutes later we wave down the waitress because she never came back to see if everything was okay. Food and bottle of wine came out and truffles was supposed to be on the side, not even on the plate chicken said crispy but it had sauce on it. She wasn't please at all and sent food and bottle back. When waitress finally notice we were done eating. We waited 10/15 minutes for our dessert. Still didn't ask if we wanted a drink. Then Manager/Owner I'm guessing brought the dessert out. He was very nice. Waitress came over asked if we want more drinks. Why at this point. Dinner is over. We were force to tip because its included. Waitress needs to be more attentive. read more

OMG, everything about the experience was AWESOME! At a time when just being able to get out and dine with family and friends is such a treat It was the icing on the cake (so to speak) to have been in such a welcoming space. From the decor to the ambiance, the excellent wait service oh and the exquisitely creative and delicious cocktails.....and lets not talk about those LAMB CHOPS. I could go on and on. I would highly recommend this experience and I will gladly travel (all the way from the Boogie Down) to do it all over again. read more

Wanted to try this place, the menu looked great! I walked in to a crowd and many people were not wearing a mask waiting for their table. Decided to come back another time. Will update my review then! read more

Great place to eat in Long Island. Food is tasty and the drinks are not watered down. With a beautiful ambiance. Strongly recommend.

I am so glad I do not have to travel all the way to NYC for a grown and sexy dining experience. Prime 39 has it! The staff is courteous and knowledgeable about the entire menu. The food is delicious. The drinks are great - not watered down at all! The broiled oysters are mouth watering good! read more

I went to Prime 39 to celebrate my birthday and my experience was HORRIBLE!! These reviews are very misleading because I was very excited to come to this restaurant and finally booked for my birthday. They pick and choose who has to follow the dress code. My fiance had a hat and not only was he told to take the hat off (which he did right away), security told told him to take the hat back to the car. Its my birthday so he did what he was told to do. However, when we were seated about 5 guys had hats but security seemed to overlook that. We had water sitting on our table for about 20 minutes with no greeting from a waiter. Time was just passing by because we were conversing. The manager came over to our table to greet us and ended up putting in our drink and appetizer order. Still no waiter! After about another 20 minutes our waiter arrives but still no drinks or appetizers. She then was in a rush to put our entree order in. Finally, the drinks and appetizers arrive. It was only a party of 2 for our reservation. Our entree arrives an hour plus later and we were served at the same time as a party of six that was seated approximately 45 minutes after we were seated. My sides were cold and part of my order was missing. I provided an additional star because the strip steak that I ordered was cooked to perfection. The stuffed shrimp that my fiance ordered was very good also. I was looking forward to my birthday dessert but that never happened because as soon as we finished eating the check was delivered to our table. After the waiter was informed that it was my birthday when the entree order was put in. We paid the check and left! Worst birthday dinner experience EVER! Food was good but the service from beginning to end was by far my worst steakhouse experience that I ever had. Not worth a second chance even though the food was great! read more

The food was amazing. The wait staff was attentive. The vibe was sexy and the drinks were everything. I love this place!

OMG...I came to this spot with a few girlfriends. We loved everything about this place. Great vibe, AMAZING food and a variety of fun cocktails to choose from. Everyone seemed very friendly....as if they legitimately cared about the service that we were provided. The place has a sexy/chic vibe that made us feel like we were in the city. Loved it! We all agreed that we will definitely be coming back. read more

Hmmm. This is a store front location, and patrons treat it as such. They come in dressed with street attire. The set up is okay, dark like a steak house, but it is partitioned off due to COVID and the airconditioning must have failed the day we were there, because it was steamy. For the prices on the menu, they should have a no sneaker, no short policy, but I guess the owner is not thinking that far. I came in dressed up and I should have come in my street shorts. I took a friend for her birthday, and the food was decent. I do not like 20 plates on the table. Serve the dinner with the sides on one plate, I am good with that. The bartender ( all of them)( the woman lead bartender ( super nice) and on point. Drinks( on point) Chaz the waiter (nice guy, on point). The food was a tad bit on the salty side, but we made it through. They can expand menu with one or two more choices. Would I return, yes, but not dressed up and not for the food. Just to have a glass of wine. I would be super laid back because they are. I guess I have to go into city, to dress for a night out. read more

The food was bland the service was slow but everyone wore masks. We asked the couple next to us what they thought of their meal and they weren't happy either. They didn't eat their Mac n cheese, so we were suspicious but decided to stay and just try something else. Big mistake. Everything was bland. The sweet potato mash had marshmallows that were mounds of melted white mush, not like the slightly charred marshmallow toppings I've had before and it didn't taste good. The creamed spinach tasted like it came out of a can and the garlic mash tasted like they left out the garlic. They overcooked and over seasoned the shrimp, the lamb chops were over cooked, and the fried chicken wasn't good either. Our waitress didn't introduce herself , then stopped coming over to our table until we asked for a manager. The manager was nice, apologetic. She sent champagne and cheesecake. Even the cheesecake tasted bland. How do you mess up cheesecake? The food and service were bad and she was only "able" to take off some of the bill instead of removing from the bill everything we DIDNT eat. We left hungry and annoyed. I won't be going back or recommending it. read more

Went here for the first time and I knew before hand the food was on the pricey side. The service was very slow which I found funny because the hostess who seated us made sure to point out the 2hr seating limit. The drink I ordered came out in a tiny glass and it was only half full. The mussels and garlic were good but the fried calamari was very salty. For entrees I ordered the strip steak and mashed potatoes and my steak was cooked well but it was also over salted. I also had the fried chicken with the wilted collard greens (more of a salad style) which was good but over salted as well. I have nothing against flavorful food but when I say some dishes were over salted I mean they were SALTY. We planned on doing dessert but the service was slow and we didn't want to wait. It was loud inside but I didn't mind. I would maybe go back earlier or on a less busier night and avoid the stuff I found too salty, but honestly it seemed like the chef had an off night so I doubt those dishes would be as salty the next time around. 2 stars for slow/barely there service. read more

i will never eat here again. hostesses are rude!!!! last 3 times I went in and same experience. food is not great and defitnely overpriced. read more

I have lived in lynbrook since 2006. I have seen restaurants come and go on atlantic.. but this restaurant is amazing and needs a local review. I come from of family of restaurants and good food and this place has exactly that.. i was there on sunday and ordered the oysters and the chop dish which was a pan seared pork that was cooked to perfection. Everything that was part of that dish was layers of amazing blends of flavor. The chefs creations of these meals are probably the best i have had and will not disappoint.. they also a great cocktail menu with top shelf liquors..such at st.germaine which is one my favorites. There were people walking around always visiting our table to ask us how everything was ... including the owner. great place in our local hometown. in my opinion, This place is a great place for couples who want to leave their kids home and or friends.. not so much kid friendly. under 15.. recomedation... the need to enforce and adhere to covid regulations .. read more

I am currently enjoying my leftovers from Prime 39. Ugh, what an amazing restaurant experience. Since the restaurant is currently reservation only all of the staff refers to you by name. Love it! The decor and vibe of the restaurant is chic! Me and my friend sat @ the bar. We started the night off with drinks. The bartenders were super friendly and fun. We tried the specialty cocktail called the Oui. It was soooooo good! It comes in a cute bird shaped glass and is sweet and refreshing. For an appetizer we got the fried shrimp. They were so juicy and good. The seasoning and Sauce were delicious. Also, do not sleep on the cheese polenta that comes with the shrimp. It's pretty good. So juicy! The shrimp are huge and they give you about 6 (I think). Also, there are sides that the restaurant has that aren't on the menu. We ordered broccoli, rice, and lobster Mac as our sides. The broccoli is pretty amazing. I haven't tried the rice yet. But I will shortly. The lobster Mac is yummy. Not as much lobster in it as I thought there would be based on reviews. But still VERY good. I ordered the 6 oz filet mignon. It was good. I would have liked it to be a bit warmer. I ordered the Oscar toppings (crab, asparagus and sauce). So this comes on the side and is rather large. I didn't like the sauce so I wouldn't recommend this. We also got lobster, I haven't tried it yet but I'm looking forward to it. Overall, it was a great night filled with great food. The staff is lovely and the food is well seasoned and delicious. read more

I was very excited to have what was called a Manhattan style steakhouse in Lynbrook. It did not come close to that description. Sauce was piled onto all of the food. The expensive steak was cooked perfectly but was buried in sauce. I would expect that at Outback but not when I order a $50 steak. The wings were very good and the fried chicken was excellent. They were out of four different items that we asked for and were told that the menu description was not accurate for three different items. This is expected for a new place and understandable. The two things that are not acceptable is that the place was packed and they were not totally following Covid protocols. They also did not even attempt to close at 10pm and the party was still going strong when we left at 10:15. They did put on the lights but that was it. The final reason that I would not go back there or recommend it was that the owner was extremely friendly and went over to say hello to every single table but ours. We definitely stood out as different in this restaurant but I did not feel uncomfortable at all and the other patrons were very friendly to us but the fact that the owner ignored us was insulting. He literally went from table to table all night and skipped over our table multiple times. read more