Prattsville Diner

215

640

1157

11 months ago

Old school great. Staff is great and awesome old atmosphere. Don't be in a rush and be polite and this place will be amazing. Great staff and great food. We stoped in and had a feed. It's cash only. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kayo N.

197

546

402

1 year ago

I'm a little embarrassed that as part-time resident of town for a few years, I've never made it to the diner. I think the earlier reviews dissuaded me, but I learned recently that the management changed. On a recent visit my partner and I shared an open faced turkey sandwich smothered with gravy, w/ sides of broccoli and fries, and a breakfast bowl with ham, potatoes, eggs and swiss cheese melted across the top of the mug. We enjoyed hearty portions, and a good meal. We got a blueberry turnover to go. Service was friendly and quick. Definitely worth stopping into. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Zippy Z.

0

20

1

1 year ago

I do not recommend this diner at all. We had been waiting for 45 minutes after ordering with no food on our table. The service quality was terrible and we had to cancel our order as it was taking too long, it was still not ready after 45 minutes of waiting.This is the worst restaurant I've been to. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karin C.

20

11

4

2 years ago

The food, service and atmosphere is true hometown perfect - every time. A must visit when passing through to Grand Gorge

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jough K.

0

21

522

2 years ago

The Prattsville Diner is a wonderful place to dine - breakfast - lunch and dinner - and meet new people - love to all from Hollywood Joe - - see you soon - - read more

Prattsville Diner - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Powell M.

Elite 25

25

382

168

6 years ago

Classic diner fare, polite service, our eggs are perfect, the hash is crispy. And truth be told, I have to order their cornbread every time I go, even if I know I am going to be too full to finish it all. (I take it home for a snack) Cash only, but they have an arm machine. One day I want to go there for dinner and try the meatloaf. Also, get the corn nuggets for the table. read more

Prattsville Diner - the menu of the restaurant - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Menu for lunch - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Don K.

9

83

10

2 years ago

What a great little spot. A place where the waitress knew everyone's name. A menu that covers all the breakfast and lunch staple with some real down home feel. My wife and I stopped in for breakfast and I had the meat lover's bowl. Hash browns, scrambled eggs, ham and bacon all smothered in a creamy sausage gravy. Exactly what I would cook for myself at home. My wife enjoyed the blueberry and walnut pancake special. Did I mention that I also had the griddle house made biscuit? Awesome. We finished up breakfast with the bread custard. An original recipe dating back over 50 years. Bravo Prattsville diner. We will be back very soon and I already have my order picked out!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Frederick R.

70

73

77

5 years ago

Went for lunch today and ordered a turkey club; two halves with chips, two pickle chips and macaroni salad, which had been made with way too much mayo. Turkey was initially salty, good but not great. Tried to the Cole slaw; much too much dressing. I make mine that has more mayo yet still tastes like a good Cole slaw. Disappointing. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Christal M.

0

6

4

3 years ago

Delicious food and quick service. The waiter was a little rude but it's the food that mattered. When i went there wasn't many people there but the diner is small so i can imagine it gets pretty tight. read more

Prattsville Diner - meat lovers bowl - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

D W.

0

1

0

3 years ago

I had the best breakfast with the best muffins I have ever had. I food was great. The service was fast and friendly. Great small diner. Will be eating there again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Megan D.

Elite 16

290

170

157

8 years ago

Service is fast, menu is simple and the food is delicious. Love the benches to fit more people in a small space. Will definitely continue to come back for their laid back, country atmosphere. read more

Prattsville Diner - Eggs and hash (on the menu on the wall!) delicious! Would recommend getting the potatoes well done if you like them crunchy :) - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

James T.

0

25

5

4 years ago

We thought we would try the diner again after it changed management but nothing seems to have changed. The coffee is absolutely horrible. I don't know how that place is busy all the time and everyone is drinking the coffee, the food was mediocre at best. I had The Garbage breakfast, and it was garbage. The price was ridiculously high for the amount of food we received. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Tyiki W.

125

137

476

8 years ago

I really enjoyed this dinner. I was in the area staying at a beautiful villa for the weekend while on a snowboarding trip. I ended up going here to get some food the day I arrive. I really like dinners because the normally have lots of different choices and this dinner sure did have options. They had so may specials that it was so hard to decide what to get. I enjoyed the food so much that I cane back again with a bunch of friends. I had the Chen wings the first time I went and the fried shrimp the second. They made a home made cocktail sauce and it was pretty good. I have never had it like that before. I will be try that again next time. read more

Prattsville Diner - More breakfast - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Chicken wings - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Breakfast - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Fried shrimp was great. - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stephen B.

0

5

8

4 years ago

My wife and I had a great lunch today . This restaurant is under new ownership . The owner Mike is in the kitchen and certainly knows what he is sending out to the very good front end staff . The food came out hot with great portions. While we were eating ten people walked in and had their orders at their tables within a very short time. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ryan F.

Elite 25

518

2052

8063

7 years ago

Had breakfast at Prattsville Diner on Saturday morning. A simple diner that serves up cheap and delicious breakfast food. Quality: Before heading out on a hike, decided to load up on a big breakfast. And Prattsville Diner's Original Breakfast Special was just that. Two eggs, toast, bacon, sausage, home fries, and a pancake, with a coffee as well. Everything was high quality and I especially enjoyed the addition of a pancake to the meal, giving an excuse to douse the plate in syrup. Quantity: The Original Breakfast Special will not leave you hungry. Value: $11.50 for the Original Breakfast Special. Ambiance: Prattsville Diner is a local diner in the Upstate New York town of Prattsville. Near the Catskills, this is a simple breakfast spot that caters to the folks that live in the area. They have booths and tables around the edges of the space and a seating bar along the back wall. A few arcade games sit in the corner to entertain any children guests. They also had random knick-knacks on the walls, ranging from a deer head to autumn-themed towels. Crowd: A steady supply for locals who stop by every weekend, or even more frequently, for breakfast and coffee. Service: Small town diner, where the staff is super friendly and genuine with everyone. Parking: A few spots out front and free street parking in the area. read more

Prattsville Diner - The Original Breakfast Special - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Arnica M.

130

71

31

9 years ago

Love this place ! People are all nice and it's the perfect country Diner so if you are passing through Prattsville stop in for some breakfast ! Thanks see you soon read more

Prattsville Diner - open sign in window - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt M.

75

241

496

7 years ago

Walked in it was busy, but not packed. No acknowledgement of our presence. Got the distinct feeling that if you are not local you are not welcome. Waited 10 minutes; walked out; made my own burger on the grill. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Stuart S.

0

6

0

4 years ago

Truly mediocre at best. Lame diner food and the coffee and water were undrinkable as it seemed they didn't get the detergent off them completely. I saw two other customers send back their food in the 20 minutes I was there. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jimmy B.

120

117

37

8 years ago

Wooow! What an absolute treat. Back to back breakfasts at The Diner. Breakfast special, all day everyday. Can't wait to be back in Prattsville. Def getting a vanilla milkshake next time. A Ruthian Homerun. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

JoHell - Joelle M.

0

1

0

4 years ago

We heard it was under new management, so we thought we would give it another try. The coffee is still disgusting. There's not enough sugar or cream in the world to make it taste good. I gave her back to coffee and asked for a cup of tea, it was Lipton tea so it was good. The breakfast was, ok. Good serving size. I had the garbage bowl, and the potatoes were not seasoned at all. It was kind of bland. My husband had two eggs with Corn beef hash, bacon, and sausage. Not sure what pig they got their bacon from but it definitely was not a local pig. The service was very good, the waitress was very friendly and nice. Very comfortable homey atmosphere, but the coffee was terrible. I must say, their muffins look delicious. I don't feel That breakfast was worth $40 read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dewan A.

763

2171

2476

10 years ago

Nice spot. 1) I really like the sloppy joe and pizza burger they have. 2) The service was amazing. The hostess was fantatic. 3) Overall, very affordable menu. read more

Prattsville Diner - a view of the dining room - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Barry W.

0

9

0

4 years ago

Loved the place and am do laundry while food on order.All the locals eat there and so do summer vacationers,

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katie S.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Came over from Middleburgh to have a bite to eat quick. Great food, fast, polite, and will definitely be coming again!!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joshua D.

0

16

8

7 years ago

When you drive by, it does not look like much. However, when you taste the food here, it is certain that you will love what you eat. I recently got breakfast here today and the egg, sausage and cheese was very much a treat. Cash only, but ATM is inside. I am sure to come back! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian G.

0

1

0

3 years ago

really impressed with this place. was passing through and stopped for a quick bite. everything I had was tasty and I wanted to eat everything I saw the waitress walk by with. give it a shot!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

maria r.

Elite 21

17

295

479

10 years ago

Nice surprise, very low key little place. It food was tasty and fresh. Nothing fancy, but then your in the middle of nowhere. So if your hungry I recommend you try it. I had the turkey club and it was very yummy. Turkey was fresh and moist. Will definitely stop by next time I'm in the area. read more

Prattsville Diner - a man sitting at the bar - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Grilled cheese with bacon - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Prattsville Diner - Turkey club - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nathan R.

1

2

0

6 years ago

Got takeout for lunch and the service was quick. The Turkey Club Sandwich was great! I will definitely be back for breakfast sometime.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brie B.

0

2

6

6 years ago

Absolutely amazing diner!! Came in with my group of 14 friends for brunch and they were so sweet and accommodating -- purely A1 service!! We're all very satisfied and couldn't be happier with the swiftness of service and the amazing food. We all want to thank you for having us and especially Tracy! Couldn't be more grateful to have her as our waitress, absolutely wonderful. Sweetest woman I have ever met; even though she had to have a mask on you could tell she was always serving with a smile. Came here for a weekend trip and hopefully if we come back, all of us agreed this is the spot we're coming back too!! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Daniel B.

235

24

5

8 years ago

A gem of a diner in a small mountain town. Service was fast and friendly. Order was out in minutes and fresh fresh. Some of ther best bacon I've had. If you're passing through I highly recommend stopping by for a meal.. Heads up, it's cash only! But prices are so cheap for the quality of food and service. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tirtho D.

45

4

0

6 years ago

Mad racist. And the food was exceptionally bad. The eggs and hash browns both were sour when I ordered.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nicole L.

50

3

1

8 years ago

I love the atmosphere of this diner. The staff is friendly and the food is delicious. The food is home cooked and delicious.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

M. H.

0

1

0

8 years ago

July 20, 2018 Prattsville Diner: Two of us went for lunch at the diner. There were very few customers there, perhaps five people. We waited OVER 35 minutes for two sandwiches to be made. As we had waited so long, we asked to speak to the owner. The owner came to the table with two RUDE comments: "This is NOT McDonald's restaurant! This restaurant has been here ___# of years." We said to him, "You don't apologize for our long wait for two sandwiches?" "Sorry", he relunctantly offered. We will NOT return to the Prattsville Diner. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer T.

0

4

0

11 years ago

Such a great place! I was just passing through and stopped in for breakfast because of a lack of options in the area. I'm glad I did! I was pleasantly surprised at how nice the place was. I was honestly expecting it to be a dingy place with greasy, low quality food, but I was wrong! It was a cute, All-American Diner with a nice country log cabin feel. Great prices, heaping serving sizes, good service. Can't go wrong. I live close to the city, but my father lives in the area and we both will most certainly be returning customers! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Chrissy F.

1

55

15

12 years ago

Had the grilled cheese with bacon and fries. It was amazingly delicious. Mozzarella cheese and the fries were curly and cooked to perfection. Service was great. Definitely a great place to stop and get full. read more

Prattsville Diner - Mozzarella and bacon grilled cheese was delicious. - Diners Near Me - Prattsville, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Southard P.

1

12

1

10 years ago

Went for breakfast this morning. The food was great and the service was fantastic. Everyone was very friendly. Stop by if you are looking for a great breakfast at a reasonable price. Cash only is the only downside. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Richard K.

0

205

0

10 years ago

An honest diner. Great breakfasts. The special has delicious eggs, sausage, bacon, potatoes, AND a pancake. Feels local.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

MrRoadseven1 M.

0

7

0

7 years ago

My favorite diner for many many years. Food is always great and prices more than fair. I've been eating there a few times a year for most of my life. (Many years!) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

David M.

0

9

0

10 years ago

The best diner in all of New York. Go out of your way to eat here. This place has been a staple of the community for years and has the best pancakes this side of the Hudson. Amazing. Delicious. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katie H.

136

10

0

9 years ago

The pancakes are thin with crispy edges, very unconventional but oh soooo good! and the French toast doesn't fall far behind! Super friendly staff! Definitely will be coming back. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George H.

36

20

0

9 years ago

My wife and I have eaten here many times and love it. It's not exactly around the corner from us, but we feel it's worth the trip. The people, service, and food are excellent. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Prattsville Diner

14510 Main St
Prattsville, NY 12468
Directions
(518) 291-2076
Call Now

Hours

What time does Prattsville Diner open?

Prattsville Diner opens at 6:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Prattsville Diner close?

Prattsville Diner closes at 2:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 6:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Prattsville Diner take credit cards?

No, Prattsville Diner does not take credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Prattsville Diner serve alcohol?

Yes, Prattsville Diner serves alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Prattsville Diner have TVs?

Yes, Prattsville Diner has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Prattsville Diner have bike parking?

Yes, Prattsville Diner has bike parking.

Does Prattsville Diner have outdoor seating?

Yes, Prattsville Diner has outdoor seating options.

Does Prattsville Diner have parking?

Yes, Prattsville Diner has parking options. Private Lot Parking, Street Parking

Other Amenities

Does Prattsville Diner have free WiFi?

No, Prattsville Diner does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Diners 362 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Wise Guys Sammys

4.4(90 reviews)

33.6 mi

Really good sandwiches and homemade chips, along with friendly customer service. I'm glad I found…read morethis spot downtown. Note that the higher-priced sandwiches are larger portions that can easily be shared, and they also come with fries. The staff at Wise Guys is warm and welcoming, making you feel like family from the moment you walk in. One minor note is that the draft beer selection is a bit limited. 10/10, would recommend

The person working the counter was nice. But my chicken sandwich came out super raw. They also…read moreforgot my friend's sandwich completely.

The view of the bar from our table.

Buffalo Wings

See all

Hamburg Berry Berry Sneaky (sour) - so tasty!

Perrone's Farm

4.9(32 reviews)

25.4 mi

Consistently great service and massive sandwiches, homemade roast beef and hero rolls!read more

The best of the best Italian meals to go and subs. Served with a smile and maybe a little kidding…read morearound. Every time I'm in Cobbleskill, I stop by to pick up something to bring home for me and my son. It's also a seasonal flower shop! I also bought Lasagne with sausage to go and meatballs. The sauce with the meals is to die for. As you can see in a sub, there is plenty of meat

See all

Toko Provisions

4.8(6 reviews)

29.6 mi

Wow! What a little gem of a place. The baked goods, breads and pastry are delicious. She has a…read morebig assortment of wonderful gluten free cakes and cookies. We tried the yuzu and also the matcha flavored shortbread/cookies. They were wonderful Then we had sandwiches - egg salad and also a ham and cheese. The sandwiches were super fresh and filled to the brim. She heated the ham and cheese one. Yummy! The bread is so delicious.$11 each sandwich - which actually felt like a bargain for the quality and quantity. Next time we will try the asparagus . Lots of cool Japanese pantry items in stock including hard to find specialty sesame oil and black sesame paste ..etc. I rarely give 5 stars - but between the service, the great food, and the chill atmosphere - this is a winner. We will be back! Arigato!

Stumbled on this really cute grocery/deli with a Japanese twist. I had custardlike egg omelette…read moresandwich. Really reasonable price. I also bought some gourmet Japanese grocery items that I haven't seen anywhere else. Dry Ramen noodles and furikake. Definitely worth a stop.

Inside of store

Egg salad - fresh with loads of greens.

See all

Outside storefront

Rossi Rosticceria Deli

4.6(815 reviews)

49.2 mi

Great Muffaletta sandwich. Nearly as good as Central Grocery in New Orleans. The other folks with…read moreme enjoyed their sandwiches as well.

thank you to the great staff. I was making prosciutto bread for the first time. I needed the…read moremeats cut a certain way according to the recipe. the two gentleman who were assisting me during lunchtime, no less, were so helpful. the bread came out great. thank you!!

Number Four panini

See all

Brave The Flames

4.6(36 reviews)

17.1 mi

A GEM! On vacation with the family we decided to walk to…read moretown to explore and hoped to find some sort of food for lunch. The atmosphere was welcoming and there Is a beautiful energy about the place and those who are part of the team. The food was excellent. Each item was not simply a burger or taco, etc, but a mouth watering creation. We couldn't help but insist all 9 of us try one another's food. The additional three kiddos also couldn't get enough! I honestly would be tempted to find an excuse to make the two hour drive from home to enjoy the experience again!

What an incredible hidden gem! My husband and I are visiting the Catskills and were searching for…read moredinner places. We discovered this place thanks to a lovely bookseller at Briars & Brambles. This was the perfect comfort meal for my birthday. Clean self seated tables and order at the counter. The service was fantastic. The owner/chef came by to check in with us. Everything came out super fast. Reasonably priced, especially compared to the area. Very casual relaxed vibe. The star was the sugar shack mac and cheese (recommended to us). It was maple syrup, brown sugar crumble and bacon with mac and cheese. Definitely unique and well balanced. It's quite sweet and savory but super unique. The chicken tenders were some of the most flavorful fresh ones I've ever had. Like you think chicken tenders are basic but this was incredible. Also thanks to the staff for letting us do a side of hush puppies (it was only part of the Friday fish special). The shrimp basket and fries was a large portion and delicious. Love that you can get unlimited sauces for the food at $.31 cents a sauce. Alcohol is served and reasonably priced. Loved the non alcoholic fresh drinks. Husband had an Arnold Palmer (N/A) that was made fresh. We'll be talking about this meal for a long time.

Interior

BTF Famous Onion Smash Burger ($14.35) and French Fries Basket ($8.20)

See all

Exterior

Higher Grounds Coffee

3.3(92 reviews)

10.3 mi

This cafe is located close to Wyndham Mountain and there is lots to do in the area! They offer…read morebreakfast and lunch options as well as some pastries and specialty chocolates. The drink menu includes milkshakes and smoothies as well. There is a dining room off the main area with lots of seating options. There are some local souvenir and art for sale that you can browse while you wait for your food. All in all a great place to stop for a quick bite to eat or to refuel on caffiene! As a bonus, the bike shop next door has a friendly dog that greets you in the parking lot.

Lackluster experience. Had to wait for a while to order while the barista completely ignored us. I…read moreget that he was busy making drinks but a greeting would have been nice. Someone saw us waiting from the back and came up to take our order. The raspberry iced tea was good and reasonably priced at $3 but nothing remarkable. The tourist merchandise was very overpriced. The self serve hot tea was Lipton and Celestial Seasonings from the grocery store.

Breakfast burrito

See all

Moose On The Loose Sandwich Shop

4.7(15 reviews)

46.2 mi

It was so nice to be embraced by the locals of Pine Plains. Wonderful staff, great customers, lots…read moreof laughs talking about moose!

Pine Plains, NY is not a big town. Only a handful of local businesses to serve the community and…read morethe family-based crew at Moose On The Loose Sandwich Shop passes w 5 stars! When you move away from NY, you realize how much you miss a deli sandwich. We ate here almost every day of this family visit. Breakfast sandwiches are perfect! Other deli items very good. The owners are apparently all related, service is friendly and hilarious. Recommended!! (Unless you want one of those grey hot dogs from Stewarts across the street!)

See all

Frank’s Fresh Pickling

4.6(39 reviews)

42.9 mi

Best sandwiches I had in a long time. So good that we went 3x in 24 hours because we couldn't get…read moreenough. Pickles are awesome.

Owner and staff just rude and unwelcoming…read more Sandwiches good but a little light on the meat. Don't need to give business to unwelcoming owner and staff.

Counter seating

Special - the golden child 8/8/26

See all

A Smorgasbord of Frank's Pickles Sandwiches!

The Corner Counter

4.6(13 reviews)

36.0 mi

There is always a unique menu to order from here. I love the fresh options. The cashier was kind…read moreand friendly. The other workers were also kind and made a point to say hello. The sandwich was very good and there were great things to choose from to have on the side (chips, chocolate, olives and of course cheese!). The restaurant is small for seating, but it's clean and comfortable!

Service isn't the best. Normally people like to be acknowledged when in a store and at the counter…read more Just a hello! Not forcing you to order when looking at the menu for the first time. It's a cute place and I love the wallpaper. I ordered food and the lady that took my order was having trouble focusing/ listening and added things to my bill. When I corrected her; she seemed to be paying attention, I thought she removed the item but she didn't. I order a drink (coffee) also and then changed my mind. When I told her I didn't want it she said she couldn't resell the paper cup to someone else. I know.... I know.. you must be thinking (WHAT it's just coffee!) I explained I didn't see the other sign with special drinks. So even though I wanted another drink that was more money, she kept it on my bill and gave it to me. That was when I decided not to go back ever again. Poor service, then I had added that specialty drink along with the coffee I got stuck with. Only to not ever receive it. I had to bother another girl to get my drink. She did tell me to wait she had to get this family's order first. That was rude. I waitressed before, so I can say that. Meanwhile I had finished my food (which was good) and coffee that I didn't want. I was there at least 30 mins and 15mins before the other family. They weren't busy. There was no excuse for poor service.

See all

Seating area is small, but you get to admire the decor. Wallpaper has rich colors.

Watershed

4.6(29 reviews)

7.1 mi

Food is fresh. Service is friendly outdoor seating fresh baked products. Perfect location in the…read moremiddle of the charming village of Roxbury. Cute little gift shop. Walking distance to everything in this small town is within minutes.

We both love it here. Love the vibe and the employees, and even though it's small (in the winter,…read morewhen the porch is a no-go), we're always happy. There are lots of things I've enjoyed off the menu, but the egg salad presser is just plain delicious. Coffee always perfect. When our electricity or internet is out (we live on the mountain), we come down here to work, and everyone here is welcoming and gracious. Excellent place.

Chai latte and apple cider donut

See all

Outside

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cristian G.

Things to do in Prattsville

208

212

20

3 years ago

This diner is like a blast from the past, and that's a good thing! It's like this place has been untouched by modernization, which is kind of refreshing. Just so you know, this area is as rural as it gets. I mean, I didn't spot a single police car, ambulance, or even a post office in Roxbury, Lexington, Prattsville, and the like during our stay. We were in the area for a weekend, and we needed some breakfast before a big hike. There weren't many options nearby, which made our decision easier and harder at the same time. The place itself is pretty simple. If you're from the city, it's like stepping into a different world. The air is crisp, the buildings look straight out of the past, neon signs abound, and there are these big wooden tables and chairs or benches to sit on. There's also a bar that stretches across the kitchen, a couple of bathrooms, and a tiny arcade that refused to take my dollars. The service was great, and our food came out quickly, and it tasted good too. I went for the southwestern wrap, while my partner had the classic breakfast. Everything was solid, and they kept our coffee cups full. We really enjoyed our time at this diner, and we'd definitely recommend giving it a try. On that gloomy day, it felt like we were transported to a time when we had zero responsibilities. And that nostalgic feeling was really something special. Prattsville Diner is like a relic from a bygone era, untouched by the exuberant updates of modern times. It's like a piece of history nestled amidst nature and towering mountains, separated by rivers and endless tree lines. This place is truly in a peaceful, remote area, far away from the hustle and bustle of city life. ---If you're looking for a good breakfast spot, I highly recommend it. Just a tip, though - we passed by around 3 o'clock later in the day, and the place was closed. So, it's best to plan your visit before then to make sure you can enjoy their food and atmosphere. read more

Jill P.

0

6

0

4 months ago

Closed for good. Not open. For sale. Not open! Closed for good closed for good. Closed for good. For sale

Stewart R.

0

14

0

6 years ago

Owned by racists who insulted my Mexican- American son in front of his mother. Will never go back.

Russ E.

0

2

0

4 years ago

New owners great food .....owners are so excited they aim to please...give it a try

Andrew S.

129

31

0

7 years ago

I eat every week end Breakfast here when staying with my GF in town.

Prattsville Diner - diners - Updated September 2026

Best of Prattsville

People found Prattsville Diner by searching for…

People who viewed Prattsville Diner also viewed

Arkville Bread & Breakfast

4.6

(75 reviews)

•$

Great place for some quick, homemade breakfast! Was in town for a couple days and wanted a quick…read moremeal before heading on the road and this place turned out to be a little gem. Service was fast, efficient, and more importantly, delicious. Staff was very friendly and the place is right next to the train tracks which I thought was so cute. Added more to the quaint, small town experience. We ordered the sampler and the kids got the banana walnut and the double stack pancakes with fruit. Thanks so much for the yummy eats and morning ambience

We wanted to stop by for a light breakfast before hitting the Bellayre slopes. Don't judge the…read moreplace by the decor as it's a no frills place. You walk in and place your order and there is a dining area down at the end. We got the veggie omelette with broccoli, zucchini, and spinach and comes with home fries and toast. The omelette is decently large as they use 3 eggs. Omelette itself was pretty tasty. My son got the French toast with banana and Nutella. That looked so good and he gulped it all up. Food while may be simple, was made just right. I would recommend.

Windham Diner

4.1

(148 reviews)

Great hospitality. Food came quickly despite a large party of 10…read more And large portions as you'd come to expect from a diner. Pancakes were large, fresh toasts were great. Eggs cooked nicely. Really no complains at all and will come again when in the area

OK, we're back at the diner. I think we'll be here two years ago maybe longer before Covid still…read morelooks like same place same food really good. I had a hungry man steak and eggs. Can't go wrong. Good steak Sue, had four deuces which is pancakes, eggs sausage, and bacon. I went with chocolate milk and sue got a Pepsi and I'm about to take some. No I'm not cause it's diet Pepsi. They actually take credit cards now used to be cash only. Come on down and dry it out.

Ambrosia Diner

3.3

(118 reviews)

The food was decent and it tastes like real food The service…read morewas nice it was like I was a king thank you guys for that The surroundings was pretty interesting I loved the lighting and space

Staff were all very friendly and attentive. Good sized portions and fast service. I'm always a…read moresucker for a good dinner.

Brave The Flames

4.6

(36 reviews)

A GEM! On vacation with the family we decided to walk to…read moretown to explore and hoped to find some sort of food for lunch. The atmosphere was welcoming and there Is a beautiful energy about the place and those who are part of the team. The food was excellent. Each item was not simply a burger or taco, etc, but a mouth watering creation. We couldn't help but insist all 9 of us try one another's food. The additional three kiddos also couldn't get enough! I honestly would be tempted to find an excuse to make the two hour drive from home to enjoy the experience again!

What an incredible hidden gem! My husband and I are visiting the Catskills and were searching for…read moredinner places. We discovered this place thanks to a lovely bookseller at Briars & Brambles. This was the perfect comfort meal for my birthday. Clean self seated tables and order at the counter. The service was fantastic. The owner/chef came by to check in with us. Everything came out super fast. Reasonably priced, especially compared to the area. Very casual relaxed vibe. The star was the sugar shack mac and cheese (recommended to us). It was maple syrup, brown sugar crumble and bacon with mac and cheese. Definitely unique and well balanced. It's quite sweet and savory but super unique. The chicken tenders were some of the most flavorful fresh ones I've ever had. Like you think chicken tenders are basic but this was incredible. Also thanks to the staff for letting us do a side of hush puppies (it was only part of the Friday fish special). The shrimp basket and fries was a large portion and delicious. Love that you can get unlimited sauces for the food at $.31 cents a sauce. Alcohol is served and reasonably priced. Loved the non alcoholic fresh drinks. Husband had an Arnold Palmer (N/A) that was made fresh. We'll be talking about this meal for a long time.

The Pantry on Main

4.4

(23 reviews)

Had a great meal here. Great parking and staff was very nice. Clean and inviting. Also the…read morebreakfast was delicious. Def worth a try in this nice little town.

The Pantry on main is the best restaurant on the mountaintop. I had their matcha which was…read moredelicious. Great customer service here, especially someone named Rupert. All the staff are very friendly and the vibe here is nice and cozy. My experience here was great, definitely recommend coming here next time you go to tannersville.

Tracy’s Cafe

4.0

(4 reviews)

Great spot for breakfast! Good waitress, good homemade and southern style food! Coffees good tooread more

I'm not sure how long this place has been reopened as Tracy's, but we wanted to give it a chance…read moresince we loved the former establishment. The hours are changed from the sign to 7-3, and closed Tuesday. They may not be the best for a group, we had 8 in our party. Tracy was the hostess/waitress and she was so friendly and constantly chatted with our son. While it took a while for our coffee to come (I'm assuming she was making a fresh pot!), our cups never got cold because she came around frequently asking if we needed warm-ups. The food took a while to come out, but it came out hot and delish! When we said crispy bacon, we got crispy bacon (and not the paper thin stuff, either!) The building and all inside it could use a little updating, but it's a good stop. Not fancy, but you'll be fed and smiling with Tracy and the regulars. Best of luck, Tracy!

Watershed

4.6

(29 reviews)

Food is fresh. Service is friendly outdoor seating fresh baked products. Perfect location in the…read moremiddle of the charming village of Roxbury. Cute little gift shop. Walking distance to everything in this small town is within minutes.

We both love it here. Love the vibe and the employees, and even though it's small (in the winter,…read morewhen the porch is a no-go), we're always happy. There are lots of things I've enjoyed off the menu, but the egg salad presser is just plain delicious. Coffee always perfect. When our electricity or internet is out (we live on the mountain), we come down here to work, and everyone here is welcoming and gracious. Excellent place.

A&G Texas Weiners

4.3

(22 reviews)

•$

We ordered breakfast to go for around 15 people. We called same day and they were able to finish…read moreour order within 30-45minutes on a weekend. Food was so delicious and portions are generous. Prices very reasonable for the amount of food you get. Highly recommend!

Good food. Good environment. Great service. If your looking for a best bang for your buck place to…read morehave breakfast or lunch this is it.

Chicken Run Family Restaurant and Steak House

4.0

(257 reviews)