I didn't like the new chicken sandwich my preference is the wreck. The restaurant was clean and business like.

Came here on a Thursday early evening. We ordered soup, sandwiches & a shake. Friendly service. The menu is difficult to read on the wall. I had my elderly father who needed an actual menu to look at. My Mediterranean sandwich without chicken was kind of soggy & not toasted very much. Still tasted good though. The hot peppers were so hot this time. They aren't consistent. My dad liked his turkey sandwich. Nice selection of chips to choose from. The vanilla milkshake was delicious. My fountain Dr Pepper was refreshing. The restaurant is clean & comfortable. read more

The entire staff is fantastic. Our office started up again after a week of no power and Potbellies came through with a last minute order for our crew. Thank you so very much for your kindness read more

I came to this potbelly location an hr before closing and got refused service there was one person inside and another in the back of the building there was no sign saying closing early won't be coming back to this location never got refused service when the Business is open read more

Made an order on the mobile app. Wanted a roast beef sandwich, noticed it wasn't on the menu anymore so I ordered a wreck as it's the only sandwich with roast beef on it. I have picky eaters and they only wanted roast beef. I paid for extra meat, made my customizations, and noted to please be generous with roast beef as it's the only meat on the sandwich. One of their employees and or managers called me to tell me that they can not help me with the extra meat as it affects their inventory. Proceed to accuse me of calling about this yesterday or "the other day" that they would not do this and their GM spoke to me....I haven't ordered potbelly's in weeks maybe a month ...they accused me of being someone else and not fulfilling my order to my customizations after I'm spending over $90 dollars at their store. Honestly so rude and I should have just canceled the whole order. I called back to talk to whoever called me and explained that they had me confused with someone else and she then again proceeded to accuse me of it saying the phone numbers look the same.....I assure you wasn't me.... I paid for extra meat and all I wanted was beef and cheese and this is what they gave me for a $14 dollar sandwich. Unacceptable!!!!! Either way either carry roast beef or don't potbelly's...do better read more

See all

I blame management for what has to be the worst Potbelly location I've ever experienced. I've been here twice now, both visits after 5 PM, and both times were absolutely terrible. On both occasions, I stood in the store for over 10 minutes before ANY employee even acknowledged my presence. When they finally did take my order, they made the wrong sandwich despite my clear instructions. The staff doesn't smile, seems completely disengaged, and I'm pretty sure they overcharged me. To top it off, the soda machine was broken during my second visit - which I might excuse if everything else wasn't already falling apart. I've been to many Potbelly locations and they're usually great, but this one is a complete disaster. The lack of basic customer service, attention to detail, and management oversight is appalling. Save yourself the frustration and go literally anywhere else. Management: your evening staff needs serious training or replacement. This location is damaging the Potbelly brand. read more

This particular day, I just wanted something a little different than what I usually get to eat for lunch. I had never been to Potbelly, and so I said why not try this place. When going in, the restaurant was clean and it looked like a nice place to have lunch. When I got into the restaurant, there was one customer who looked like they were paying, and there were three workers behind the counter. I walked in looking a bit confused because I was try to find the menu. I realized that the other two workers were just looking at me and not acknowledging me. That was a big turn off for me. Next, I figured out what I wanted to order, and I'm standing at the counter, and the gentleman standing right next to the bread says absolutely nothing to me. I then proceeded to say, can I order here, and then he takes my order. That is not ok with me because that just shows the lack of customer service and professionalism in this establishment. I ordered the Original Chicken Club, and it was made really well. My sandwich was hot, the flavors were great, and it was toasted to perfection! I also got a bag of bbq chips and a chocolate cookie. And I was not mad at the price at all! I would definitely come back for the food, but I really believe that the customer service outweighs the food. If I have excellent customer service, my food experience will be great as well. I only wanted to give two stars, but since the food was good, I gave three. read more

Potbelly - Chicken Club - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

See all

The steak sandwich was terrible. 95% of the steak was scrap stuff that people throw away, that can't be chewed (see some in the pic). That was at 9:00 pm on Wednesday the 17th. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

Typically this place is solid except for maybe the long lines but today was an exception. There was no line but when we went to order sandwiches I noticed mold on the bread in front of me. I ordered my sandwich and tried to point it out to the girl at the counter. Instead of saying thanks for pointing it out I was scolded for touching a bag. I tried to explain my side but she wanted none of that and just left the moldy bread for all to see. I am no expert but mold on bread in a plastic sealed bag is not a good sign. Beware. read more

they messed up my order when i tried ordering the new jerk chicken, i did say i want the new spicy chicken sandwich. i had forgotten the name and it wasn't on their menus yet. the women prepping the sandwich talked to me like i was stupid. she had asked if i wanted barbecue sauce on it. i was confused because it's supposed to be a jerk sauce. so when i go to check out i told the cashier. he had them fix the order. but i don't appreciate being spoken to like im stupid when it was just a misunderstanding. read more

This is my favorite Potbelly restaurant. Bri, Micheal and the whole weekday morning/afternoon crew rock. The bread and veggies are is always fresh. I always get the same sandwich Veggie melt toasted twice and they know how I like it. That crew is always smiling and brings the best to their customers. I visited the Navy Pier location over the weekend, I would give it 1star for food only customers service was horrible. This is my Potbelly home in Munster read more

Food made me sick. In the bathroom all night. I ordered a wreck and it just didn't make me feel good afterwards.

I ordered an original pizza melt and given a skinny. I informed the manager Ramon that this sandwich is the wrong size , he said the all come out different. He showed me the bread for the original bread and my sandwich was half the size. Then he said what do want me to do. This is the second time I had a bad experience at this location. read more

I purchased a chicken club sandwich yesterday morning and when I went to eat my sandwich, I was going to put the hot peppers on the sandwich and found a screw! It is absolutely ridiculous that this was not caught not only at the prep station but at the topping station. This is just insane. On top of it all, the manager only refunded one sandwich that was purchased and not my whole order. WILL NOT be ever returning to any Potbelly location. Check your sandwich before you eat it if you are going to go to Potbelly. Something needs to be done about their cleanliness and food preparation. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

See all

Ordered a sandwich for pick up since I was in a rush and I was super excited to eat it to just notice that they put nothing but bacon and lettuce when I ordered an Italian sandwich. I am extremely dissatisfied .. read more

Potbelly - Bacon lettuce no dressing no peppers no meat - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

I used to come here all the time and I thought the chicken was more fresh now it looks like deli meat and just has a weird texture to it. I won't be coming back again but service was good for what they have. read more

comically slow service. moving slow motion and giggling over getting the man in front of me the wrong Sandwhich. When they finally get around to speaking to you, their eyes are so lifeless it's like I'm not even there. read more

Always a go-to quick lunch option. Staff is always friendly and professional, lots of seating (even with COVID), clean, and the food is great too. HAVE to try the chicken pot pie soup! Air Force approved!! read more

Potbelly - TSgt Eric Wienke, local Air and Space Force recruiter for Lake County Indiana - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

I have gone to this potbelly multiple times and by far this has been the worst experience. The Bread was soggy like it had been out for a long time. I found a red hair in my sandwich. The whole sandwich was a mess and falling apart. I called to complain and they said they were going to refund me the money for the mistake and it was never done. Always check your food before eating it. read more

Potbelly - Big ham - Sandwiches Near Me - Munster, Indiana

See all

They locked customers out at 6pm they're making everyone order online. Terrible service

I am so sick and tired of the manager "Sally" that works at the Potbelly's in Munster. She talks to people like there incompetent, I have been there multiple times, and she always is either rude to her customers or rude to her staff, and at this point I am fed up about it. There has been multiple times I have been in there where she either is showing poor customer service skills, Super disrespectful to her employees or when she just acts like she hates her job. The first problem that happened was when my mom ordered a sandwich and it was literally thrown together, to the point it wasn't edible, I called up there to ask if I could bring the sandwich back to have it remade, and she told me NO, but if I wanted to try and get a percentage off my next sandwich I should go feel out something online and it would be sent to us via "mail". I didn't ever ask for our money back, I just wanted my mom's sandwich remade. The second incident was when I went in and asked for Half a sandwich half a salad. I almost ask for the same salad and the same sandwich every time I am there. I always ask for a half Wreck sandwich with a half a wreck salad. Yes I am aware NOW that you all don't do a wreck salad as One of the options. Which I understand maybe it was a miscommunication somewhere along the lines, but I have been doing that for over a year. She then asked me was I confused in locations, which to me is questioning my intelligence, considering the fact this is the only potbelly I go to. It wasn't just what she said but really how she said it. Then I asked one of her staff members (literally the same person that made my order the day before) and before she could talk back, Sally spoke up for her saying " No, No, No, No we have never done that". Then I go in there today, and order a full wreck sandwich and a full wreck salad, and she still goes out her way to tell her staff members to make sure that is a full sandwich and a full salad when I didn't even order a half and half since the previous situation of her telling me very rudely that they don't do that. And I'm really just sick and tired of her rudeness. read more

I ordered a chicken Mediterranean Sandwich and I got hummus and chicken on it. It was a pick up order so I did not watch the employee make it. Where were the roasted red peppers and artichokes? I like this sandwich but from this experience, I think I would only order it if I was there to ensure they made it correctly. read more

I enjoy Potbelly sandwiches but this location is always understaffed, making the wait for one simple sandwich get to be 15 minutes plus. Even when there's not that many people in the restaurant, it takes forever between getting the sandwich and paying. One time I read more

My sandwich was wrong and when i went back to get it remade it was hard as a rock and made poorly.

Food was ready at the time of estimating pickup. Order was correct. Staff was nice. Website here was easier to order off than the actual potbelly website read more

My Dad is in the hospital and the food is the worst--expensive and not at all tasty....kindve like the Cuban at this location. I asked for extra cheese. Nope. The sandwich was supposed to come with pickles. They ran out. Actually they did not. They gave me a quarter wedge of one of their big pickles. They couldn't slice it. A cup of soup, a sandwich, avocado, a drink, and a dream bar--$18. Yeah, thanks but no thanks...never again. read more

I love that they finally brought back the PB&J but every time I go the place is a little dirty. Not enough to be too disgusting to eat but just think they need to do a better job. read more

Can count on a great sandwich here. Good for kids too. Turkey sandwich is solid. Warm or cold options. Great toasted sandwiches.

Shit smacked and my wallet took a smack oml I'm just typing so I can post this review wtf

Been going to Potbellys for years now. Saw this new one in Munster and thought we'd give it a try. Did not disappoint. Tasty sandwiches and tasty soup. Very clean & well lit environment. Friendly staff. Not much more to say. We will be back :0) read more

Terrible customer service and delivery process. I placed an order for delivery. I was given a 12:50pm est delivery time. I called at 1:50pm inquiring about the status of my delivery I was informed my order was out for delivery and they would give the grubHub driver a call. I called back at 2:26pm to check the status of my deliver. I was told the order wasn't placed, a manager had to look up the receipt and call a grubHub driver out. Called back at 3:26pm to cancel my order to be told my order was picked up from 10 minutes prior and was on its way. It's 3:46pm we will see if the order ever arrives. read more

Every time we go to this location, the food is ok but the teen employees who work there in the afternoon are more interested in talking to their friends than in listening to customers or even communicating with each other to get an order correct. You're at work. Please act like it. read more

So.... going to the Munster In. location, I had ordered a kids meal, and when going to pay for this I mistakenly noticed that I had brought the wrong amount of money! I told the girls that I was sorry but to please keep this order on the side and that I work just right down the street from their location and will be right back to get more money because I left my entire purse at the office! The girls at the register basically said "go ahead and take it" "its no problem" "just.. if I could leave us a good review" which I am doing. Thank you girls, you saved me an inconvenience of going and coming back with a 30min lunch break. You ROCK!!!! read more

Great customer service and Great Sandwiches as well as soup! Prices are sort of on the high side but over all its a great lunch spot. I love their chocolate malts and the sandwich called "the wreck"! read more

The 3 women at the front that took care of my order where smiling, happy, & very nice. I asked if the marinara had meat in it because i dont eat meat. She answered me and said "let me switch gloves for you since you dont eat meat". I didnt even ask her to. The 2nd lady was super sweet and made her job fun and made me laugh. The cashier offered me a bag and was very nice. I loved my experience there!! read more

The walnuts on my wife's Uptown salad were stale and smelled and tasted rancid. Told staff. My sandwich was good.