Can you say Ermagerd! I thought that Subway what I was stuck with for sub sandwiches... NOT anymore. Jersey Mikes opened up on December 5th 2012 and I am damn glad. Here's the skinny: Cool staff They slice the meat there The Big Kahuna Philly Cheese Steak Door to the back parking lot Here's the fat: The staff is pretty cool here, talkative, easy to get along with and generally pretty awesome. There's a lot of choices for subs and the employees know 'em all. All the cold cut's are sliced right there, they've even got a meat slicers right on the front counter. The slicer is clean too, props especially because of the amount of meat that they must go through. If you're lookin' for something that really pops and gets your mouth watering, get The Big Kahuna Philly Cheese Steak. It's loaded! Extra Cheesy and is seriously on point when it comes to how everything is put together. Not one ingredient overpowers the other, they all just meld together perfectly. When the owners took over the new building they added a door in the back of the store to the secondary parking lot. This helps a lot because there is hardly any parking out front and can be kind of a pain. This place is really worth a look see if you haven't heard of Jersey Mikes. I was told it's a chain with 30 something stores in Illinois. SYOY read more

See all

I thought I'd give Jersey Mike's Subs a try. I entered a store with six (6) visible employees trying to look busy. I was the only customer in the store. There were more workers than customers which was the first thing that hit me. Second, the menu wasn't that easy to decipher. All I wanted was a simple tuna sub. I decided to get just the 6" sandwich since adding the drink and a bag of chips was no bargain. I paid nearly $10 for just the sandwich. I know inflation has caused prices to surge recently but I did not feel my meager sandwich was worth 10 bucks after I consumed it at home. I live very close by. If I would have purchased the simple combo, I would have paid about $20 and that was much more than I was willing to pay for such a lowly presentation and not very appetizing endeavor. It just wasn't worth the asking price. Gee, imagine what a family of four (4) would pay to be fed here? Sadly, fast food chain restaurants are quiet the costly alternative to filling your stomach these days. You'll never get rich being a frequent diner at Jersey Mike's, nor can you count on getting a nourishing meal. Better options remain for the discovery, I'll let you seek and find them out. read more

The food was so sloppy completely drenched in mayo.. Mustard and oil. This was our first time ordering from this location and I dont think ill be back read more

Went to Jersey Mike's for the first time this evening. Arrived at 8:35 pm. We noticed their TV was off so we asked if we were too late to order. No, we were told. So, I ordered a Ham & Provolone and asked for it hot. I was told they couldn't heat it up. I'm confused.... I say, why can't I get it heated up? I realize it's under your "cold sandwiches " but come on... No, I was told. Our grill is off. I said really? No hot sandwiches after 8:30?? I told them they should put that on their website or front door! Went to Potbelly. read more

I am new to the area and type in a good customer and a happy customer of Jersey Mike's in the past. But I've tried this place about five times now and the people just don't seem to care that are providing service. There are one or two people that are that are fine and professional but the others just kind of hardly treat you like a customer. This last time I came they made my sandwich and when they were done and I paid for it. They like pushed it to me instead of like saying. Thank you and handing it to me. It's just. I'm not trying to be a complainer but man customer service sucks read more

I ordered through door dash and my sandwich was made wrong. It was mainly my fault as I added ingredients but the app made it plain with the added ingredients when I wanted it mikes way with added ingredients. I called and the manger was so nice and understanding. He made a new sandwich for me and did not charge me for it. The space was cleans and the rest of the staff was friendly as well. read more

This is my 6th time here. I love the Philly sub with chicken, cheese, peppers and onions. This sandwich is served hot. You can choose from an assortment of breads. I prefer the rosemary cheese bread. It's a perfect blend of flavors in an awesome sandwich. The only comment I have is that the sandwich I order isn't always consistent. Sometimes it contains too much meat and veggies, while other times there's not enough meat or veggies to cover the bread. I end up pulling excess bread off the sandwich before eating it. When I visit the Jersey Mike's location in Flossmoor, IL, the sandwich is always consistent. In fact it's my favorite location. So, overall this Jersey Mike's in Indiana is just okay. Since my husband likes it so much (his sandwich is always flawless), I'll probably be back. read more

They need a little help here. Placed an order online and when I went in to pick up my sandwich...it wasn't ready. The "not ready" part isn't why I'm giving this one star. What I really didn't like was the employee having a full-on meltdown right behind the counter. I didn't stick around to find out exactly what the issue was but it sounded like they were over worked and under paid. The employees here are usually really nice and do a good job. It was really disheartening to see someone so overworked and under appreciated by the owner that they were on the verge of a breakdown. I left without getting my sandwich...didn't want to add to their frustration. read more

Extremely good sandwiches however very pricey how ever it also has great service. I recommend.

Consistently good sandwiches made fresh and Mikes Way tastes so good. People are friendly. Good brownies too!

My 3rd time here 1st time for the review. Ordered a #7 Turkey Mike's way and a #16 Chicken Philly served hot...both on Rosemary Parmesan bread. Both sandwiches tasted Great fresh and hot overseen by me. Parking is tricky park either far right or far left due to drive thru traffic. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Order in - Fast Food Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

They charged me 18 bucks for a sub with a sliver of meat. I can't believe someone would serve a meatless sub. The bacon had no taste and was very old. I wouldn't eat here again. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Schererville, Indiana

I have been at this location a few times and never again. I got a tuna sandwich which had maybe a table spoon of tuna. The man making the sandwich was spreading the tuna like he was making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Jimmy John here I come this place sucks read more

Disgusting, found screw in my sandwich, and a snot on the bag. It's disgusting and don't even know how they haven't been inspected..Kids there cuss at each other, one of them began to argue with another employee..annnnd they look miserable and annoyed that your even there to place an order!! Grossss won't ever ever go again! read more

I have only been here once and that was enough. There was a very short line but when it was my turn to order I had to wait for 15 minutes before someone attended to me. I ordered the chicken philly. Then I waited while about 6 people who were behind me got their sandwich before me. I do want to note I was the only minority customer and hope that was not the reason why I was treated so poorly. After being there close to 40 minutes with no sandwich in sight I left. read more

I was here at 8:30 on Friday 4/9/2021 (store closes at 9) and I walked up to a locked door. When the girl behind the counter saw me she ran to the back and shut the lights off. An acknowledgement saying they were closing early would have been fine, instead I was met with childish, rude behavior. read more

Arrived 20 minutes before closing and they were already cleaning and claimed they were short staffed. If you close at 9pm, you should take customers up until 9pm. Otherwise put a sign on the door that says "we take the last order at 8:30pm! read more

Horrible service, I just wanted in and out of there, and didn't even care at that point what they served me. It was like talking to a brick wall. I miss the old staff they used to have. read more

I swear that Jersey Mike's, hires some of the most rude & incompetent people to work for them. I have heard that this location is especially bad & now I can vouch for that myself. The minute you walk, they act like your presence is an inconvenience to them, even though you are the reason they are getting paid. Pathetic read more

Walked in for lunch today and found the atmosphere to be ok. Not dirty, but didn't feel clean maybe a tad cold feeling. Behind the bar looked like a mess. The grill where they cooked my chicken was very dirty I watched as they scrapped off way too much grime . Probably not a fair description, but was not appetizing. The order process is fine, but they were fairly unorganized. We ordered, but orders came separated They had a rush once we walked in But we were first 5 people received orders before me Now i had a wrap, so i understand that's a slower order However, other wraps came ahead of mine Don't want to be too picky just something we noticed Now for quality...the turkey sandwich was fine (i was told) My wrap was 70% lettuce, which felt like a salad in a wrap Healthy i guess, but not filling Overall not bad, but definitely not memorable. Probably wouldn't go back read more

Normally we come her to receive the usual sub par service and fantastic food however this time we had to draw a line as the sandwich maker was an absolutely rude tubwad disappointment of a woman. Too bad the food is too good we have to endure the pain of coming back. read more

The sandwiches are great but the DoorDash service stinks. Order and pick up. Don't do doordash. My driver was so late, I called the store and said I'd just come pick up. The lady apologized and said she'd have me talk to the manager when I got there. I said that wasn't necessary. But then I get there and they said the driver just left. So I drove here for nothing. That's just silly and poor service. read more

This is about the service and lack of training/listening/caring...I went into the Munster location at 1:10 on 1/9/22 and there were no customers or door dash orders, etc. The 4 employees were sitting at a table. No biggie, maybe taking a break from a earlier rush. All 4 immediately went to their posts...I placed my usual order...a medium roast beefw/provolone and made mikes way w/out onions and a large super sub made mikes way. Just when I placed my order, the young man had my total at the other end. No problem...i added a tip and was asked if I was a rewards member? I said no, i have never been asked that before? Anyway, I sat down and did not hover as they made my sandwiches...I wish I had...i got home and my roast beef was a turkey sub made mikes way with onions and my super sub was made without onions. 4 employees, 1 customer 2 sammies and both they got wrong! read more

I placed a online order today which I rarely do, I ordered a roast beef and cheese. I love their chipotle mayo to I wrote it in the comments because it wasn't listed as a selection. When I got there I asked the gentleman controlling if it was put on the sandwich and he said yes. I got back to my office and there was none sadly. If your company offers an item you should have it selectable. I was very disappointed read more

Wow was I impressed with my first stop at Jersey Mike's! I have been wanting to try them for the longest because I get their coupons in the mail all the time. I definitely regret waiting. They make a fantastic sub sandwich. I tried the tuna, the Italian, and the Big Khahuna cheese steak, all were fantastic! Your choices of toppings include mayo, lettuce, tomato, jalapeno peppers, banana peppers, oil and vinegar, pepper and some kind of salsa. I'm sure that I'm probably forgetting something. They don't have the topping selection of Subway, but what they have is adequate. Now, let me tell you where they lose a star with me; THEY ARE FREAKING EXPENSIVE! A footlong is like $14.00 bucks with tax! I had a coupon to buy 2 footlongs and get the 3rd for $1.99 and my total was still $31.00! That's pricy for sub sandwiches. Another thing I didn't like; I bought one of their pickles and the guy reaches in the jar and pulls the pickle out with his hands! Granted he was wearing gloves, but it's like get a pair of tongs or something! Other than that, Jersey Mike's is a worthwhile stop. The next time that I'm in the mood for a sub, but I don't have the taste for Subway, Potbelly's, or Jimmy John's, I know where I'm going! read more

See all

I love jersey mikes. This local is our go to spot for it. I get the big kahuna chicken cheesesteak. It has been good all 3 times I've gotten it and super filling.. the staff is friendly and service is fast. Just wish they served fries. But still a delicious place to nosh at read more

Overall my sandwich was really good! I love all sandwiches I've ordered from jersey mikes. From the hot subs to the cold subs all have been fantastic and the bread always taste fresh. I haven't had jersey mikes in months so I was excited to get a sandwich, but today the staff was a mess. Upon arriving the guy taking orders just stared at you and didn't ask if I was ready to order or if he was even ready to take an order just a dead stare at me. I'm laid back so it was more comical then anything. The girl putting the toppings on sandwiches completely had 0 care. I ordered 3 sandwiches only 1 was mike's way and she just started putting toppings on all of them and I kindly told her no that only the one was mikes way. I'm not sure if she had ear buds in and completely did not care what she was doing after the 3rd time of her not listening and starting to put vinegar on every single sandwich I had to tell her once again, the best part was when I was getting oregano on my sandwich the lid fell off and oregano mountain on top of all the sandwiches (not her fault it could've been other workers) the thing that got me was she didn't say sorry or that she would remake the sandwich, so I asked her to just take the toppings off because there was a line of probably 4 behind me and I wasn't gonna make her remake it, but an offer would've been nice instead of her rolling her eyes like it was my fault she dumped the whole oregano shaker on my sandwich. Overall, I'm not mad It was funny how chaotic it was I just hope jersey mikes can train their employees to be a little more personable or listen to what to put on a sandwich lol. read more

Want to stand in the restaurant and watch the employees make 10 remote orders before even entertaining the idea of taking your order? Come here! read more

Get up to The counter to order and the employees were arguing about who gave out an wrong sandwich to an customer instead of and apologizing to the other customer that was wait to get the correct sandwich. Lady in front of us ended up walking out in discuss. We stood around for a bit longer waiting for them to be done arguing back-and-forth and also ended up walking out as well. read more

The food was ok...after all, it is a chain sub shop, but I'm giving them 4 stars because the staff was really nice and friendly (and fast).

I've been frequenting this place since it has opened and I can honestly say I haven't been disappointed. I've tried multiple types of sub sandwiches, some that I wouldn't normally try, and they all have been great. My most recent sub "The Grilled Pastrami Rueben" was terrific. The staff is friendly and always make you feel welcome. The owner, Raul, is a great guy and always makes you feel at home. read more

The slowest service there ever!!!! Always! You can tell it is constantly short staffed, and that the staff that works there hate their jobs. Go to a different one JM! read more

We will go out of our way for a great fresh sub, Mikes will not let you down. .I always do a 13 Mikes way..But the Meatball and Philly s are good too! read more

See all

went there 20 mi s to close got an Italian sub was really good. I drove from Lansing.

I'm sorry Jersey Mike's has to bear the brunt of this review, but their landlord hired a company that is booting cars then charging crazy fines to remove. If you park anywhere from Starbucks to oberweiss, then go to shop at any stores not in that area, you will get booted. These are words directly from the representative. I wanted Jersey Mike's mike's today, but will not go there for this reason. So if you park there and they don't like how you're parked or where you go, be prepared to pay!! read more

I went into the store the other day and I was in a really big hurry to get to work. My break had just ended and I still had not eaten yet. I walked in and it seemed like it was sort of busy which isn't usual. This young man I think his name was jahseer or jahzire took my order and made my sandwich in less than 5 minutes. Really smooth transition and I got to work with time to spare! Not to say also an amazing sun like always. read more

I usually get the beef and provolone cold and as far as I'm concern, it's the best around

A huge thank you to Jersey Mike's for the great sandwiches that they sent to the workers at Community Hospital today. The were delicious and very much appreciated. read more

I waited with my wife while at least 10 people got their sandwiches as we stood waiting for ours. I ask the cashier ( who literally everyone made repeat himself because he was speaking so softly) where are sandwiches are and he tells me on the grill even though they had been on the table behind him for at least 10 min. And then my cheesesteak ranch bacon sandwich was horrible on top of that. read more

The manager (tall, black guy) acted like I was doing him a favor. The food is good but it'd be nice to not have a guy ask "What do you want?" when you come in. Then no thank you, just walk off like I was bothering him. read more