My husband and I visited Porterhouse Grill for our anniversary. We experienced outstanding customer service, and the cocktails and steak were amazing. Our waitress was attentive, and she made the best cocktails. The mashed potatoes, the crème brûlée, and the cheesecake were good. My husband loved the garlic bread, but I thought it was too salty. I did not love the steamed veggies. I felt they were overcooked and over-seasoned. I would have had a better experience if my reservation note had been considered for where we were sited. It was a special occasion for my husband and me, and we were sat at the first table from the entrance, in front of the bar, when the restaurant only had seven guests. It was cold outside, and every time the door opened, I felt the wind come in. We were sited immediately next to another couple, and it was a table set for four people when it was a date for two. I understand the need to make a reservation, but why would the restaurant ask what the occasion is if the staff will not consider a special setup for the occasion? Porter House Grill gets a 5 out of 5 because it is a steakhouse, and their steaks are absolutely delicious. Additionally, their cocktails are amazing, and Customer Service was terrific, Porter House does not have a private parking lot; consider bringing quarters for street parking, or you may use a parking garage nearby. Cons: Porter House does not consider your reservation notes to make a guest's special occasion memorable. read more

See all

Went for dinner last night, and it was not busy at the time we arrived. The bread tasted very off, and multiple people agreed it was. My wife ordered chicken masala ( which to my understanding tends to be grilled chicken) but came out fried and doesn't say that on the menu. The potato didn't have flavor and after having asks for a lot we didn't ask for salt and pepper that was not on the table already. The green beans were good! Other family members ordered spaghetti, surf and turf, and another dish I can't remember. That dish came out cold and was obviously warmed up in the microwave when it came back and was still not that hot. They offered 10% off the bill which never was on the bill at the end and double charged kids spaghetti despite's the 2 kids sharing 1 order. It's been a while since I had eaten here but definitely will not be back. Unacceptable experience for the quality and price of food when much better options exist around the corner. read more

Our last 2 trips to PG have not been very great. Long wait times for service was one issue. Biggest problem is that I ended up at Piedmont with food poisoning. We will not be coming back. read more

Service was fine, but the food was unacceptable. A table of 4 people spent almost $500 and only three had cocktail. the steaks were sub par, overcooked, pla of food cold and filet was gristl; never should happen with filet Mignon. a family of 4 spent almost $500 for a very disappointing meal. do not recommend this restaurant at all!! read more

Been here twice now for lunch and it's a pet good deal especially with the portions. Lunch ranges from $15-$40ish and they aren't usually busy during the day. It's a causal fine dining restaurant so don't worry about having to dress up. Just worry about where to park since it's in downtown Athens. My friend and I were sat immediately, and ordered the loaded fries and chicken carbonara tortellini. Food took a decent amount of time, and was very flavorful and filling. We both were full till the point we needed a box. Our server was also very attentive and nice. I'd highly recommend coming here if you're ever in Athens!! Just another thing to be cautious about is the prices are different than the ones on their website. Overall, 10/10!! read more

Porterhouse Grill - Chicken Tortellini Carbonara Lunch - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

Going to shoot straight off the hip here: Ambiance is dated, food is average, prices are insane.

I called on Wednesday, February 11to make a reservation for Thursday evening at 5:45. The young lady told me they were never busy that early and would have plenty of tables. We arrived at 5:35 and were told there was nothing available! Wait, what?! The hostess on duty was quick to tell me she wasn't working that night and couldn't help me. To keep from making too big a scene, we left, never to return. Terrible way to treat customers. Won't go back read more

Good downtown location with an easy walk from a parking lot if not able to get street parking. The food was good for those in our party with salmon, filet meatballs, shrimp scampi, steak, and chicken. The drink menu offers good options with a mule I had never seen that was more fruity than the traditional Moscow. The bad was unfortunately they were out of several food items. This may have been due to both graduations and a cheer competition in the area. Our server handled the large parties well. read more

See all

We went for a friend's birthday. When we went to order, we were told multiple things were unavailable, including the 20 oz. Ribeye. They said the delivery truck didn't come that day. Logistics problems happen and we still found something on the menu. My friend and myself ordered the Steak Frites, that comes with a 14 oz. Ribeye. Several minutes later our waiter let us know they also were out of the 14 oz. Ribeye. They said we could replace the Ribeye with the Strip. I asked for Pittsburgh Rare and my friend asked for Medium Rare. When our steaks arrived, mine was over Well Done and my friend's was Medium Well. Our waiter took our steaks back to be recooked. When they came back, my friend's steak was correct however my Pittsburgh Rare Strip had came back Blue Rare. I like Blue Rare as well and was ready to eat so I let it slide. However, when the check arrived, I learned they charged us an up-charge to cook a steak at a steak house Pittsburgh Rare, and then didn't even cook it that way. Our waiter was nice and was dealt a pretty sorry hand by his management and kitchen. He did a good job for the situation he was put in. This visit was beyond disappointing. read more

Had dinner last night, party of 8. The service was terrible. The server was not properly trained. It was a joke at top dollar prices. The prime rib was an embarrasement. The wedge salad wasnt a wedge. Dont get it. They were out of 2 apetizers, and 2 of their 3 cabernets. Wont go back. read more

Amazing amazing amazing! I don't know why I don't go here more often! My sandwich was so phenomenal; I will say the cheese inside was incredibly dense and rich and was somewhat overwhelming but it was delicious and a new experience for my pallet! The fries were amazing! And the tortellini is always good here. read more

See all

Porterhouse grill We had multiple issues. We went with a party of six for my son's 24th birthday celebration. We made reservations, but we didn't need to because there were not many people at the restaurant when we arrived. We were seated and placed our drink order. The server was fantastic throughout the whole night. And our issues were not his fault at all. So we ordered some appetizers and my father-in-law asked for bread. Server said they are out of bread because they had a party going on in the back room and they ate all the bread. And we were surprised and asked if they could please try to find some, but that never happened. Now my father-in-law is a bread man, and if he had known there would be no bread at this restaurant, we would not have gone there. Anyway, the appetizers were fantastic. We had the meatballs and the shrimp cocktail. My husband ordered a $12 wedge salad with ranch instead of blue cheese and he also wanted shredded Parmesan on it. When it came, the lettuce was brown and the only thing on it was blue cheese dressing. So he was upset about that and sent it back and they brought him another one that looked a lot better. The menu said the salad had tomatoes on it, but his was naked. So he had to ask for some tomatoes and shredded cheese. When we ordered our food, my in-laws wanted to split the meal and they charge six dollars to do that. But when their food came, they got sides on different plates, but the steak was only on one plate and it was not split in half. They said they do that to let the steak rest. I think they should've let it rest in the back room for a few minutes and then cut it and put it on their plate. But that was fine. My husband ordered his $70 ribeye rare and it came out medium. Huge disappointment. He just ate it anyway because he didn't want to wait for another steak. I ordered the steak salad with no onions and dressing on the side. when it arrived, I had extra onions and no dressing at all. So I picked them out one by one and then waited for my dressing to arrive. All the steaks came with green beans and something was off on them and no one ate them. We finished our meal and offered my son a choice of crème brûlée or chocolate lava cake for his birthday dessert. He loves crème brûlée and ordered that. Then the server had to come back and tell us that they were out of crème brûlée because the big party ate it all. My son is not a chocolate lover, but he took the lava cake anyway. The server brought two of them to the table and we ate them and it was delicious. Then the bill came. Right away I noticed that the price of my son's steak was incorrect. Then I started looking at the bill and noticed that they had overcharged us on six different items. Anywhere from $1-$5 dollar up charge. it added up to $20. I went and got a menu so I could compare the prices and show the server what was going on and he said he would have a manager come talk to us. I'll say it again, the server was fantastic and he had a smile the whole time and he was not the problem. So it took about 10 minutes to have them change the bill, but we never saw a manager and that was disappointing. I would've loved to tell him about some of the issues we had. But anyway, we paid our $500 bill and got out of there and I don't think we will go back. There are only a few really good steakhouses in Athens, and if this place wants to charge the high prices, then they need the service to back it up. read more

Disappointing Experience at a Steakhouse That Promises More Than It Delivers Tonight, my family and I had one of the most disappointing dining experiences we've ever had. Wanting to celebrate a special occasion--my son's recovery journey after a serious motorcycle accident--we decided to try the Porterhouse Grill in Athens, GA. Given its name, we expected a premium steakhouse experience. Unfortunately, what we received fell far short of even average. We started with two appetizers. The Philly Cheesesteak Egg Rolls were inedible--greasy, with no detectable cheese, and had to be sent back. Things didn't improve with the entrees. My wife ordered the Surf & Turf medium well; it came out medium rare, and the shrimp were so overcooked they were rubbery and inedible--$66 for a plate she couldn't enjoy. My son and his girlfriend shared the Tomahawk steak, which was ordered medium rare but arrived more on the rare side. They were able to eat it, but it still wasn't cooked as requested--for $95, that's disappointing. I ordered my favorite, a New York Strip, medium rare. It arrived well done, almost burnt. I rarely send food back, but this was simply not edible. The replacement steak also came out overcooked, closer to medium well--another $66 wasted. What made this experience worse was that the restaurant was empty. These mistakes didn't happen during a dinner rush--we were the only party in the restaurant. Despite multiple issues, including two items sent back, one appetizer changed, and one entree removed from the bill, no manager ever came by to check in or offer any sort of apology or resolution. It was clear from the noise coming from the kitchen that the staff were more focused on joking around than on preparing quality food. For a restaurant named after one of the finest cuts of beef and charging premium prices, the execution and service should reflect that. Sadly, this was more in line with what you'd expect from a chain steakhouse, not a fine dining experience. I truly cannot recommend this place to anyone. What should have been a celebratory dinner turned into a frustrating and upsetting evening. read more

The service was terrible we had a reservation at 8:00 on a none game weekend and we did not ever get our order taken! We ordered drinks at the bar and never got any more service! read more

The service at the bar was very nice and helpful and the smoke Old Fashioned was wonderful, but the fried oysters I ordered were overcooked and 7 of the 12 oysters were so tough and chewy that I could not swallow them and had to use my fork to remove them from my mouth and leave them on my plate like chewing gum. Also the crab cake was mushy. read more

the service was awful, they decide to prioritize a party of 40 basketball players instead of the 50 people that were there before them. they did not let anyone know that their orders would take over two hours to get them. they shouldve just closed the restaurant but instead its everyone elses fault. read more

My wife and I went with her brother and his GF. Fortunately he picked up the bill as this is an expensive restaurant. Should be marked $$$$. Steaks start at $50. Very nice atmosphere and they don't skimp on drinks or portion size. Food was good and overall a nice experience. read more

Our family' had a reservation for Easter brunch today. We were seated promptly. Ambiance was lovely- a very talented gentleman singing and playing piano keyboard at entrance. BUT- we placed our food order from a set menu. We waited 65 minutes for our food,...during that time no drink refills or apologies from server or manager. We sat for an hour without food or drink. We decided to leave. 70% of the restaurant were sitting with no food. Our friends at another table decided to stay. They waited TWO hours form their food and their order was both incorrect and incomplete. Issues are understandable- but we were just ignored. No food. No drinks. No service. read more

Food good, Service terrible. Drinks came at end of meal. Took forever to get check. - seems like they just ignore HS prom kids

Food was hot, delicious and just like I ordered. Service without a dougt was awesome. Ambiance wonderful read more

WOW!!! Crazy fast service. Best steak I've had in years. Perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. Asparagus the way it is meant to be cooked, not overdone like in so many restaurants. I can't imagine going anywhere else in Athens. read more

The service was very good, but the food was mediocre. Went there today to try a nice lunch and ordered the fried oysters which were ok but mostly tasted like just fried stuff. I ordered the tortellini which was served luke warm after waiting 30 min for it. My husband ordered the ribeye but I'm pretty sure it wasn't ribeye. It was pretty dry and needed seasoning. The service was good and I was hungry (pregnant) and after waiting half an hour for Luke warm tortellini I didn't have much faith in them making it better so I decided to eat and leave. I wouldn't recommend coming here for anything kore than perhaps a drink. The bartender looked like he knew what he was doing. read more

It is Easter, and we made a reservation here at 1:00. We waited over an hour and a half for our food, which is ridiculous. After our long wait, one order was burned and black, eggs were cold on another, and the last plate to come out was all wrong- the steak was well done instead of medium rare and the eggs were scrambled instead of over hard. We asked to speak to the manager on two different occasions and was blown off in the middle of the conversation. Very disappointed in this experience, especially on Easter. Will not be coming here again. Wish we could give it zero stars, but sadly that is not an option. :( read more

Horrible service. It was move in weekend but somehow they were totally unprepared. No one came over for 20 minutes. They were out of the first two entrees I tried to order. My steak took 90 minutes to come out and was overdone and inedible. They told me "6 minutes to replace" but 20 minutes later my server said "oh your food didn't come out?" Someone else in our party got crabcakes and they were mush. They comped my steak because it was inedible but I still spent $250 plus tip for four people (including me with no entree) and I couldn't even get a free beer for my inconvenience. Horrible experience and horrible service. Total rip off and they just took advantage of me because I didn't get angry with them. There wasn't even a manager in sight. Avoid this place at all costs. Sure it was a busy weekend and I tried to be understanding, but there is zero chance it is competently run on any other nights. read more

Porterhouse Grill - Ribeye. - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

When at a steakhouse get the steak! The staff graciously hosted my party of 13 without issue! Everyone in my party raved about their steaks. They were cooked perfectly! My daughter said, "I've never had a steak that didn't require steak sauce." And we've been to really nice steakhouses. So our expectations were high. I had the crab cake appetizer, a margarita, and the chicken salad. The crab cake was tasty. But the salads were mid, so skip the salads and go for the steak. We were seated in an area large enough to fit our large party which is rare in Athens and were provided with 2 waitstaff. Overall I'd give this place a 9/10 only because the of the salads but everything else was perfect! read more

Porterhouse Grill - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Its a nice place and the service is great but the food is mediocre. They need a new chef. I have been coming here for over 6 months and ask myself why. read more

We've eaten here 3 times before and had positive experiences, but not tonight. Service was good but the food was not. Oysters were less than fresh. She-crab soup was too thick and salty. Pineapple on my salmon tasted like vinegar. My husband's prime rib was smaller than advertised by at least several ounces and more medium well than medium rare. We are sad because we really liked this place. Hopefully it can recover from whatever is currently the issue. read more

DON'T! They changed owner a year ago. They have big problems. We were a party of 14 for a birthday. We seated in back with no air conditioning. Very hot. Never offered the front where air was okay in 2/3 empty dining room on a Saturday night. I arrived to meet friends at the bar. No bartender for 10 minutes. When seated the last two meals came and everyone else was finished. It was so hot that server had to bring ice for our water. It kept melting in the heat. I ordered Chicken Saltimbocca. It is supposed to have prosciutto and Fontana cheese. It had neither. The overcooked green beans still had the stems. They would not let us bring a birthday cake. And would not allow several separate checks for a large group. Prediction: they will close. read more

Great food. Justin was an excellent was very helpful! Highly recommended! Ny Strip was great! read more

Stumbled on this place as we were exploring downtown Athens. We were able to get a table out front. The restaurant was quite large, but a bit outdated inside. The food was delicious! My husband ordered the lunch special which was a filet burger with fries for $11. I had one of the best fried chicken sandwiches. It was perfectly seasoned with a great breading. Our server was very pleasant and attentive. read more

Porterhouse Grill - Filet burger with fries - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

We had a bad experience here. We were in town and I was excited to show our friends the place that I once loved to go to for special occasions. I don't know if it is because we are young (late 20s, early 30s), but the food we were served was unacceptable. For starters, the bread was burnt. I mean black. When asked if we could get fresh bread, we were told they were out. The filet meatballs were so dry and undercooked. The steaks were the only thing cooked properly but even then it was nothing to write home about. I don't know what has changed in the last 5-10 years, but I certainly won't be going back nor recommending it in the future. I was embarrassed I made the suggestion. read more

Porterhouse Grill - Insulting bread - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Not open at lunch.. call before driving and paying to park. We came to eat lunch and they were not open

The service here is absolute crap. Food has always been "okay" but nothing special. Not only that, we had a reservation to this place for over three months. Two days before our reservation kicks in, they decide to only provide a set menu, and for $100 per person. Doesn't even include drinks. I love places that move the goalposts in the 4th quarter...not. Some of these places in Athens just think that they can do whatever they want because people have limited options on busy weekends. They make it easy to remove them as an option. read more

Where could you improve, hmm? Six people for my daughter's medical school graduation. We got there early before crowd and before my daughter and husband arrived. Drinks were ordered for the four of us and them, plus appetizers. Everything slow. Our orders finally come before appetizer or salads. We tell them to cancel salads and appetizers and find our mashed potatoes and French fries cold. They come out with more cold potatoes and then after 3rd attempt they get properly heated. The ones that ordered the rib eye said it was good but that is the only compliment. I had the spaghetti with filet meatballs, blah! We spent over $450 for an extremely disappointing meal. Our server never even came to see how our meals were. We definitely didn't let it spoil the amazing time we had celebrating the graduation of my beautiful doctor daughter. I would strongly suggest if you want a nice steak dinner to go elsewhere. read more

Positives: Drinks and service was good. Negatives: Was not told about 20% gratuity being added for 3 adults and 3 kids. Then it was added after tax. Prices are much higher than the quality of the steaks. Kids meals are $15+. Prime rib was dry and tasted like it was cooked the previous day, we were there on a Saturday. Floor of the restaurant seemed greasy. I would not return, for half the price Longhorn or Texas Roadhouse have better food. read more

Had dinner here tonight with a party of 13. We arrived for an early dinner to avoid the dinner rush crowd. We had a table waiting for us and sat and ordered drinks. Our waiter, Pat, did an excellent job. One person tackling a group of 13 was a job and he handled it. Everyone liked their meal and there were no complaints. I never tried fried green tomatoes before and I had them here for the first time, now I'm hooked. We were in and out in about two hours. By the time we left, all the tables were full. They have a few tables outside if you want to sit in the fresh air. I give four stars because as a vegan, there weren't many options and I didn't have an option when deciding where we were going to eat. I had a salad, fries and Brussel sprouts.... And a few pieces of bread. read more

See all

We came here for my bf's birthday. He loves steak, so I'm sure this is one of the best steakhouses in Athens. We had the Tortellini for an appetizer and a few drinks that were okay. For dinner he ordered the special with Steak and Crawfish, I ordered the Chicken Saltimbocca. Over we enjoyed the meal and the service was great. Great for a special occasion American dinner read more

Porterhouse Grill - Chicken Saltimbocca and Steak with Crawfish (Special) - Seafood Near Me - Athens, Georgia

See all

It's been a long time since I've felt this cheated Took my family for Christmas dinner. I made the reservation through open table and there was no mention that it was a buffet for Christmas. The buffet consisted of dry, grisly prime rib, even drier chicken and some random sides. There was no bread but there was warm Banana pudding. There appeared to be one waiter and one busser + santa who was helping out. The quality reminded me very much of a Golden Corral or maybe a hospital cafeteria. I knew it was a mistake from the outset but it was Christmas afternoon at 1 so we had almost no other options. Ok all this was bad but I could have dealt with it except for the fact that the bill for 4 adults (with 2 bottles of inexpensive wine) was $422. I would have been fine with the price if the food, service, and atmosphere had not been so incredibly lacking. read more

Service: great no issues. Had a reservation for 6:15 on a busy Friday night was seated within minutes with my party of 6 Ambiance: Felt very sophisticated but casual. Great restaurant volume buzz. Aloud you to have a private conversation but not so quite you feel like you have to whisper. Food: Now unfortunately we go down hill fast. I ordered the NY strip cooked medium. Wife ordered a chicken dish, My mother got crab cakes. Kids shared fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp. Food came out in a decent time The steak was cooked well done (no pink at all) and was extremely thin cut for NY strip , asparagus was cold, potatoes were great no issues there. When I sent the steak back the asparagus came back burnt, the steak was now a better cut but cooked medium rare which I was fine with didn't want to wait again. (But you would think a steak house can cook a steak correctly?) The other dishes were ok but that's about it. Nothing really special about this food unfortunately. read more

Service was good, the ambiance itself was an older building. The food, however, was average for a steakhouse. I had steak frites with French fries. The steak was okay, the fries were good (they could have been warmer). Dessert (chocolate lava cake) was quite good. It's not the "priciest" steakhouse (cost was reasonable) but it was a moderate experience. read more