Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    PJ's Classic Creamery

    5.0 (7 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 4:00 PM

    PJ's Classic Creamery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like PJ's Classic Creamery

    Recommended Reviews - PJ's Classic Creamery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    20 days ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of zane b.
    101
    50
    0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Darcy H.
    37
    316
    10

    1 year ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mary G.
    0
    64
    37

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Amazing bon bons full of flavors, creamy and dairy free gluten free options. I highly recommend

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - PJ's Classic Creamery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 18,536 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cakes of Paradise - Rainbow cake by the slice

    Cakes of Paradise

    4.7(575 reviews)
    4.5 miGeorgetown
    $$

    When I tell you... BEST CAKES IN SEATTLE/all of WA! I've been to other states and they don't make…read morethem like Cakes of Paradise, well besides Hawaii itself. Our family favorites are Chantilly, Guava and Pineapple Delight. We come for everyone's birthdays and pretty much every holiday or special occasions. We come so much, I still don't know why they don't offer a little discount/rewards for their utmost and loyal customers. So they see our family once-three times a month with a lovely cake order. I remember when they had a location down in Renton too or sold a variety of their cake slices down at the Renton Uwajimaya! Their Seattle location is very convenient for anyone coming from north or south. They offer a variety of different desserts as well, along with coffee/other drinks too. Very laid back place to purchase from and workers are fast with what you need to get picked up or to purchase. I've always recommended Cakes of Paradise to everyone who asks for a recommendation or to new family/friends visiting Seattle. You will always satisfy your sweet tooth with them!

    First time here, and I was honestly so excited because I'm obsessed with guava cake!…read more For a Hawaiian spot, I was expecting a really chill, welcoming Hawaiian vibe, but unfortunately, that wasn't my experience. The worker seemed like he really didn't want to be there and came across as short and rude. The customer in front of me even picked up on the vibe and said to him, "You seem like you're having a rough day." I wasn't going to let that ruin my excitement, though! I left with the guava cake, coconut/pineapple cake, and rainbow cake. I also tried the guava donuts and maple bars. The desserts themselves were what I came for, and it's unfortunate that my first experience was affected by catching a worker on what seemed to be an "off" day. Hopefully, next time the experience matches the laid-back, welcoming Hawaiian atmosphere I was expecting.

    Photos
    Cakes of Paradise - Hau'oli La Aloha! Heart-shaped Guava cake available in 6" and 9" sizes for the month of February only! Pre-book today!

    Hau'oli La Aloha! Heart-shaped Guava cake available in 6" and 9" sizes for the month of February only! Pre-book today!

    Cakes of Paradise - 6" round Rainbow cake (Guava/Lime/Passion fruit)

    6" round Rainbow cake (Guava/Lime/Passion fruit)

    Cakes of Paradise - A heart shaped guava cake for vday :)

    See all

    A heart shaped guava cake for vday :)

    The Sweet Side

    The Sweet Side

    4.1(157 reviews)
    5.7 miMapleleaf
    $$

    Lemon cake serves 16, I think the medium size. Great flavor and good icing to cake ratio. Dense and…read moremoist. Order 48 hours ahead of time. Super helpful on the phone to answer any questions. Can customize messaging. You need to leave these cakes out at room temp for 6ish hours before eating so make sure you pick it up in the morning. They also serve cakes by the slice at their shop and fresh baked cookies. The chocolate peanut butter is rich.

    Tasted okay, but quite overpriced for what you get…read more We ordered one of the pre-designed cakes for my son's first birthday. First things first: the design was adorable. We loved how it turned out. I am a bit bothered that you can't collaborate on the cake design at all given how much I paid, but oh well. Secondly, the actual cake was very nice and tender. We all enjoyed that. However, the frosting tasted terrible. Honestly it tasted more like vegetable shortening than butter. It left a really greasy taste on the tongue, and didn't have much flavor at all. It was far too heavy. I understand that may be partly required for the design of the cake... but I have had cakes like this that tasted way better. And on the design front, where I am from, you can collaborate with the bakery in your local grocery store for a fully unique cake -- and get a cake for $40 that both looks and tastes amazing. I had so much fun doing that last time and the bakery came with great ideas. That simply does not exist in Seattle... bit of a bummer.

    Photos
    The Sweet Side
    The Sweet Side
    The Sweet Side

    See all

    Seatown Sweets - Stunning birthday cake

    Seatown Sweets

    4.5(111 reviews)
    10.7 mi

    What a delightful shop! They have all kinds of fun sweets - cupcakes, brownies, bars, cookies, cake…read morepops! They even make fancy cakes for special events; ie: weddings. I settled on a chocolate peanut butter covered sandwich cookie, a S'more cupcake, and a key lime cheesecake. The gal who helped me was kind and helpful. Everything we had was delicious. I will definitely pop in again for more treats soon. I like that they are open until 5pm on weekdays. Bakeries tend to close on the earlier side and it's nice to have them as an option. It was an unexpected surprise to find this lovely shop in Kenmore - I'm so glad I did!

    I tried the cookie cream cupcake, Oreo cupcake, and the double chocolate cake. Overall, I think the…read moreprices are very reasonable, especially if you're looking for a small cake or an individual dessert. The cakes were fresh and offered good value for the price. However, they were much sweeter than I prefer. Out of everything I tried, the double chocolate cake was my favorite because it had the richest flavor. My only complaint is the sweetness. I wish there were an option to make the frosting or cream less sweet, as that would have made the desserts much more enjoyable for my taste. Overall, it's a good spot if you have a sweet tooth and are looking for reasonably priced cakes.

    Photos
    Seatown Sweets - Beautiful birthday cake with HBD topper

    Beautiful birthday cake with HBD topper

    Seatown Sweets - Assorted Cake Pops (12)

    Assorted Cake Pops (12)

    Seatown Sweets - Smores, salted caramel & apple pie cake pops for party favors!

    See all

    Smores, salted caramel & apple pie cake pops for party favors!

    From V With Love

    From V With Love

    4.9(92 reviews)
    13.3 mi

    From the get go, my fiancée and I planned our wedding to be unusual and whimsical, that meant…read morebreaking a lot of traditions, including what to do for dessert. We wanted something unusual for a wedding that would leave an impression. Valeria delivered on that goal and then some. Most of my guests had never even heard of a mousse cake before, and now I think for many it's their new favorite dessert. The little cakes I asked for were colorful and beautifully decorated in exactly the colors and shapes I requested, they added a wonderful touch to the presentation and vibe of the wedding. They were of course also delicious, both the regular ones and the gluten free ones. Speaking of gluten free. We had multiple gluten free guests including the maid of honor, Valeriya took care to make sure that the gluten free cakes were kept properly separated to avoid cross contamination, she also managed to make them a different shape and color than the others to make them easy to spot, while somehow managing to keep them beautifully on theme. Our gluten free guests were floored by how tasty they were. Valeriya manages to make a wonderful gluten free dessert that avoids the common shortcomings of a lot of gluten free baked goods, and that really brought an extra spark of joy to our guests. I could go on but long story short, I recommend From V with Love Cakes 100 times over. We went with the strawberry vanilla bean and for gluten free the raspberry pistachio flavors and loved both, but she has many others to choose from to match your tastes and occasion. I will hopefully never get married again, but I'm sure to have other big events in my future, and I'll plan to reach out to V for all of them.

    Very disappointing experience for a birthday cake order for my little one. She completely messed up…read morethe custom cake toppers I ordered. Even though I shared the exact placement she cut up the name and stuck them to the cake board by removing the backing which she wasn't even supposed to remove. She even missed one letter from the name during pickup and didn't even notice until my husband pointed out. I would have appreciated if they reached out to me if the toppers were confusing. The cake was also disappointing since the jelly part didn't thaw even though it was picked up at 12 PM and was in the fridge(not freezer) until 5:15 PM and then it was completely outside until 7 PM. The jelly part was very hard to cut and such a waste of money, since I paid for a premium mousse cake. I have two stars because she agreed for the partial refund for the messed up topper. The refund was only after I reached out to her about the cake after our party. I have added the inspiration and the output(name changed for privacy).

    Photos
    From V With Love
    From V With Love
    From V With Love - Mini set

    See all

    Mini set

    PJ's Classic Creamery - desserts - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...