A great pizza option in downtown Nantucket that has limited seating, a fun vibe and solid neopolitan style pizza. Not large, but enough for 2 people (especially if you have a side salad). I ordered about 7 pizzas online and they did add a mandatory 20% tip and they don't pick up the phone, so you couldn't even order via phone. And then when picking up said pizzas, which was quite a lot to carry, there was no offer to help carry them, paper plates, napkins, etc.. And, some of the pizzas were not cut through (and when they do cut the pies, they only cut them in 4 large slices). Again, just some customer service opportunities, especially if you're going to force a 20% gratuity on orders, but not really offer any great service. So, there it is. Nantucket prices, for solid pizza. Ordering online wasn't the best UX, but you get what you get, sometimes. read more

Pizza was very mediocre. And the clerk was a little entitled. Total came to $6.42 and I gave $7, and he didn't give me the change. I was planning on putting the change in the tip can anyway, since I hate carrying change, but to automatically assume that and not give the change is a little messed up. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

High quality and perfect for the price point - a salvation on an island of pretentious nonsense. Thank god for a solid pizza and a great atmosphere. An absolute gem! read more

The pizza was amazing. Crust was fantastic, highly recommend the pepperoni. Grab a pie and head to the beach! read more

See all

Friendly personable service and amazing Pizza! We stopped in for a late snack and our experience was fantastic.

I've heard people call this a hole in the wall... that would be a kind term for what's hardly a functioning establishment. All who work there have a serious attitude issue - no one was helpful, or smiled, and the few things we asked them for they made look like was a massive inconvenience for them. See the horrifying unsanitary photo of the bathroom to get a clear picture for how the place is kept up. As for the pizza - we got carbonara and shrimp scampi, each a ~$23 pizza. Both were primarily dough, which had great taste, chew and char -- but the toppings were almost non existent. No idea what we were even paying for. Carbonara had 5 little specs of guanciale total, the pizza just looked like plain cheese with a bad messy egg with the yolk broken when we got it. Shrimp scampi is just confusing - it's an oily pesto base with nothing else but 5 shrimp pieces. Bizarre there was no cheese or anything else but pesto and dough. We were also charged $7 for a bottle of water. Tomato sauce we asked for to dip the crust in was watery and tasteless, and the kid tried to give me a cold container of sauce out of the fridge instead of heating it up and bringing to our table. This place needs A LOT of work. There is a shred of hope seeing the cute branding and knowing this is under the Ventuno umbrella because Ventuno is fantastic. Hopefully they can turn it around! read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Hole in the wall, with a handful of seats, banging out fresh pizzas from a wood burning oven that were delicious, shockingly had a table white wine bottle that cost less than a pizza obviously pricing is Nantucket pricing (so outrageously expensive), very casual with nice staff, and was a perfect end for our day in Nantucket before heading back to the ferry read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

I am baffled that this place only had 4/5 on Yelp. Honestly, incredible pizza. And that's coming from an NYC pizza snob. Love it. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Very good and fresh pizza! The wait was long but it was a busy night so understandable :)

Great pizza. Not pretentious and good food. Exactly what I needed. Unassuming from the outside but you'll see locals stroll out with these pink pizza boxes constantly read more

We kept seeing everyone carrying around Gemelle pizza boxes so we decided to check it out. Upon arriving we asked which pizza is the fan favorite and were told the Margherita so this is what we went with. It came out within 5-8 minutes and was piping hot. The pizza was more of a thin crust but plenty of cheese/toppings. Overall I would give this pizza a 6/10, the crust was a bit burnt and I didn't think it had an overwhelming amount of flavor. It did have true Italy inspiration but I thought the crust was just a tad too thin. I've had some amazing Margherita pizzas and unfortunately this was not one. I didn't think it was bad, but definitely nothing special. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Great thin crust pizza. I got the sausage with green olive. It was a little spicier than i anticipated but i still wolfed it down. I want to try their other pizzas, especially the shrimp one. read more

Great pizza and calzones. Small like place but worth the trip. Service is great also feels like a little home pizza shop.

Walked in hungry. Walked out with two outstanding pizzas. Highly recommended. Was told it was the best pizza in the island. We enjoyed it.

The most delicious Pizza Margherita I've ever had. The dough was perfectly cooked, nice and chewy. The sauce was fresh and bright. Excellent cheese pull! read more

Pizza was great. Amazing bite and chew, despite the thinness of the pie it held up with the toppings. Simple, and that's all you really need for a good pie! We got the Calabrian chili, marinara, and potato pie. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Potato pie - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Awful service. Called to pick up a pizza and walked in and was not greeted or asked my order. Then sat and went back up in about 5 minutes and somehow never got my order. read more

it's hard to find pizza on the island of Nantucket and one night last week I called pi pizzeria, and the wait was three hours even just to pick up. so we ordered from this little place and the wait was reasonable. I have two main complaints about my experience. First of all the phone number that is listed everywhere as being the phone number of this restaurant did not work. When I walked to the restaurant and showed up in person, they simply said "we're too busy to be able to pick up the phone. ". so it would've been nice if there was something on the website saying do not call, please come in person. The second thing is that I ordered a couple of pepperoni pizzas and honestly each pizza had like five or six pepperonis on it. and honestly, it's Nantucket and everything's expensive and I know that, but for an expensive pizza you could give me more than five pepperonis please. The pizza itself was very good so I guess I read it highly for the food but poorly for the phone service or lack of and poorly for skimping on the pepperoni for an expensive pizza read more

I was not expecting to be eating pizza on Nantucket, but nor was I expecting a huge storm to dump so much water on the island during our 2 day visit. Pizza is what hit the spot and this was such a good pie. We started with one and ended up ordering a second one and devoured it too. read more

Amazing. Came here for a quick pizza and beer before our ferry and could not have been more perfect. Reminded me and my husband of pizzas we've had in Italy. Excellent (and fast) margarita pizza with a cute aesthetic and friendly staff. read more

Phenomenal pizza. Great service super friendly staff. Great toppings. I highly recommend !!!

Excellent new addition to the island food scene. I esp enjoy the shrimp pizza (although beware -- it's spicy!!) We ordered in advance and everything was ready when we got there. read more

Came here on a rainy night and it was worth the soggy wait. Quick and friendly staff. I wish I could give this place more stars since the girl working the door ran outside after two different parties because they forgot something--one person even left their pizza. Bravo girl! We ordered the salsiccia (sausage) and the margherita. The dough was cooked perfectly, nice bubbling and not soggy. The salsiccia may be my favorite pizza ever. The sauce is olive oil or garlic base and the Italian sausage was outstanding. It had equal flavors of fennel and spice and was chunked up on there in a free form. It was delicious! read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Wonderful Pizza, the crust with chefs fermentation become a much better platform for the other ingredients.

Yes on the pricey side but dammm good pizza. Has a twist of Italy and definitely isn't like your usual American pizza. Great flavor although wish it was bigger but the ingredients are fresh and was a rather short wait to from order to finish. read more

Very pricey so let's get that out of the way! The pizza is artesian so on the smaller side, however the descriptions of the pizza does not do it justice! So good! And the ingredients are fresh and thick. We absolutely loved this pizza. The staff were friendly and the pizza came out quickly. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

It's not your typical American pizza. You know, the type where you order 10 pizzas because your little league team just won the annual championship. That's NOT this type of pizza. Instead, it's more of an upscale artisan type of pizza. Some may even say this is exactly what you get when you order pizza in Italy. I liked it, and I'm a pizza snob. I was pleasantly surprised. However I didn't like the size. Like others have said, it's more of a personal sized pizza. So if you have several people in your party, you'd probably want to order one pizza per person. Sure it's pricey, but this is Nantucket. It's still better than that Oath Pizza garbage down by the docks, where they make it in front of you, à la Subway franchise style. I loved the seasoning, the crust, and the toppings. I ordered the "Salsiccia" sausage pizza from their menu. It didn't contain any tomato sauce because it's considered a "white" pizza; containing olive oil and cheese. The sausage was very good. Being a pizza snob and usually ordering a sausage pie as my de facto "taste test", it sort of has made me a sausage snob over the years. They claim their sausage is house-made and that's entirely believable. It was very good mouth watering type sausage, the type that's common around the New Haven region of Connecticut. Yup, just like the other Yelper said, it was charred (not burnt). That's actually a good thing. The more charred it is, the better it is... in my opinion. Take-out only... Pizzeria Gemelle is located on a tiny small street in the center of town. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - This called a pizzeria box. It is a box for your pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

If you are looking for good italian pizza you have found it! Great options, delicious dough and nice little nook that brings me back home. Desserts are worth it too. As an Italian who lives on the Island I'm glad this pizzeria is here! Nothing against American pizza, but sometimes I crave the real deal, you know! Nice to eat there when there's space or convenient to take home! read more

Incredible pizza and sandwiches!! All made fresh and the dough is perfect. We ate here 3 times in a week.

Delicious pizza for a nice dinner or lunch on the beach. We took out two margarita pizzas for a picnic on the beach. A bottle of red wine paired perfectly and we had ourselves a fabulous night. The boxes are so cute, the employees are so friendly, and the pizza is so good! This is a win in my book! read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

It's grim joke on pizza. The food here tastes like they hate their customers.

I was in Nantucket for 2 weeks and ate out every meal. In my opinion, Pizzeria Gemelle is the only really great restaurant on the island. There are a few other ok options and definitely many lame ones but this place is outstanding-- as good as the best pizzerie in Naples and Rome. read more

Only pizza place open after Christmas (that I could find) eclectic pizza selection. I ordered the Giovanni, it was ok and unique but it would have been nice to find regular pizza around town. Points for being open and worth a try but traditional pizza is more my thing. read more

Good, thin crust pizza. Pizzas are available in only one size (small). The restaurant is built in a small house like structure, smack-dab in the middle of downtown. It's a cute little place. I would recommend this restaurant to any "pizza snob." read more

Fabulous pizza that comes fresh out of a wood fired pizza oven. This may be the best pizza I have ever eaten. The crust is thin and perfect. The tomato sauce is to die for. It's a small space, only a few tables but it's cute and comfortable. Really great music played in the background. They may have name it Pizzeria Gemelle because it is a true Gem. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle is a true gem. We ordered two pizzas and the order was done in less than 10 minutes. It came out hot and fresh. The pizza's crust was amazing and not in one bit burned. read more

Delicious pizza! Would definitely recommend. We grabbed a few pizzas and went to eat them on the docks. Definitely more of an individual sized pizza. Also would recommend ordering in advance because we it's a small shop so we ended up waiting a while for our pizzas. read more

Pizzeria Gemelle - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Let's start with the positives- the crust is fresh & tastes amazing. We ordered from the app & delivery was very quick. But the pies are tiny! We ordered a cheese pizza for $17 because it was one of the cheapest pies, but it was so tiny we laughed when it arrived. On the mainland they would call this a "personal size" pizza. I get that it's Nantucket and overhead is sky high, but this was over the top. I gave them an extra star for foraging ahead during COVID. Best of luck to them! read more

So disappointed in Pizzeria Gemelle. We ordered our pizza at 7:30pm thinking that was plenty of time before they closed at 8:30. Maybe we should have expected poor service since it was a rainy Saturday night, but we decided to give it a shot anyways. My boyfriend went to pick up our pizzas and salads after waiting an hour and they were still 20 minutes behind. Finally he came home with our food and when we opened the boxes, my pizza was entirely burnt. The crust and truffles were black and charred with a *raw* egg on top. My boyfriend asked for his pizza well done, so I think they got the two orders mixed up ...but even well done doesn't mean burnt to a crisp. I wish we had called and asked for a refund but by the time he got home, the pizzeria was closed and it's not like they could make us new food at that point. Super disappointed that we paid $70 for this meal and it sucked. read more

Cozy dining right off Main. The margarita and the Giovanni are winners! Great place to stop in on a rainy afternoon for lunch!!