I usually love this place. Our experience tonight was in one word, unwelcoming. My daughter has two food allergies, I always tell the server and it's usually no big deal. Tonight was a different story, I order the kids a cheese pizza it arrives they dig in immediately. The manger walks over and tells me I shouldn't eat out with a child that has food allergie, among other comments she was saying under breath our entire meal, it was beyond unpleasant. Her abrasive comments and rude demeanor made me extremely uncomfortable. Just a warning if you're eating out with a food allergy probably best to stay away. You'll be judged and then have to endure huffs and puffs like your business is unwelcome. I'm only giving three starts because our server was gracious, kind and everything the manager wasn't. read more

Great pizza, beautiful outdoor seating, delicious drinks. Slow but kind service. Wine was served in a water glass which was very disappointing and negatively affected our experience here. They should consider serving wine in a wine glass, especially if they are charging 17 dollars for one glass of wine. read more

See all

The pizza is great. Light, crisp and great toppings. The white clam is great. The pizza overall is on the lighter side but overall surprisingly excellent pizza to be found on an island. Would recommend just getting take out and buying wine at the stop and shop to eat at home instead of buying bottles at the restaurant as they are marked up substantially. read more

Probably some of the worst pizza I've ever had. Toppings were anemic and the crust was coated in raw flour. I guess when there are limited options, you can phone it in. read more

Pi Pizzaria - Cheese pie with broccoli and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Been eating here for at least 15 years, one of probably 2 or 3 restaurants we frequent on Nantucket. Food is predictably excellent, arrives hot, with pleasant service. Been hearing for years about how great their steak is, but have never been able to resist the pizza. Tonight my son and I finally ordered the steak and can confirm the reviews: it was outstanding. Medium rare, tender, hot, with great pan jus, gnocchi on the side. Just fantastic. read more

The food was yummy and service was nice. No free refills here which bugged me. Overall nice dinner. We didn't get the steak and gnocchi this time but it's wonderful also. read more

Pi Pizzaria - Menu's - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

2.5 Stars - A good attempt at bad New York style pizza. Paying 4$ more for dollar slice quality. If you're going for other food you might have a better time. read more

We love the crust -- which is a true NYC-style crust, glutinous, thin and yes, foldable! -- but the toppings leave something to be desired. A Margherita ($21) came with no tomatoes, a thick slather of sauce (actually of good quality, but just in too high of a ratio), and almost no mozzarella. The little mozzarella on the pie was "fresh" as in it came in brick form rather than in shredded form -- but it wasn't tender as it ought to've been. And there may have been three 1/2 mm slivers of basil present. Pepperoni pizza ($23) included the most minute amounts of pepperoni, cut into thin strips and nearly invisible on the pie. Man. The crust does a lot for us -- but it can't go all the way! read more

Pi Pizzaria - Marinara Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Small and quaint. Bar service while you wait for your table. Delicious pizza and kind service.

Food is amazing. Anything you get is delicious! Service is amazing. Beer is cold. If you can sit at the bar!

The restaurant small. We were seated by 5:15. We ordered a clam pizza to start then an eggplant parmigiana and lasagna for our main course. First the pizza came out lukewarm at best with dried up clams on top of the crust. There was no flavor and tasted like day old bad pizza. Which it could have been given we were the first clients of the evening. Both main courses were lukewarm except the side of pasta which was overcooked but hot. The eggplant was mushy as was the lasagna. Neither had any flavor. Our waitress was lovely and attentive. It was a huge disappointment read more

This was excellent stone fired pizza on Nantucket. In addition to having some very high quality food, they were absolutely accommodating of our extremely large Boy Scout group (we had 11 scouts, and 7 adults). Sizes of the large pizza are decent. I would comment pricing is high but given the price of everything on Nantucket they are completely reasonable compared to cost of everything else. Super friendly staff and the only complaint from anyone was they still wanted more food after everything was done. Inside was packed and everyone seemed very happy with their meals from what we could sense. Not a bad choice if you are wanting a nicer quality pizza. read more

What the heck?!? Pi Pizzaria, could you care less? This was the one of the worst pizzas I have ever tasted. It's not even fair to call it pizza. Come on guys, I know you probably don't care but could you care a little? $25 for what's called a large, you'd be kicked out of every city nationwide for trying to call this pizza. It's an abomination. floppy, no taste, gross, inedible. You should be ashamed. What a bummer. read more

Pi Pizzaria - It's supposed to be pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

I give this a solid 3. I ordered the Great Italian pizza, Large (16") and a side of garlic bread. The service was great. Pizza is just OK, but not great. Flavor is there, but check out the photos. There's barely any toppings. I think a GREAT Italian pizza would have at least double the toppings as what I received. Even if they just increased the onions and peppers they'd make it so much better without costing them a lot. Also, the center was quite soggy, with lots of sauce, so it was super saggy. The garlic bread was meh. It definitely seemed like store-bought bread, serving was really small for $7 and the flavor wasn't great. I give it a 3 because it's not good enough to automatically want to go back for more. I'm definitely going to try other pizzas on the island. read more

See all

If you are visiting Nantucket Pi Pizza is a MUST! The food is incredible, they don't just sell amazing pizza, they also have one of the best steaks I've ever had. The staff is friendly and the vibe is perfectly cozy. read more

Pi Pizzaria - Pi pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

This place is great! They have a nice outdoor patio. (Dog friendly too) Service was great. Pizza and the minestrone soup were excellent. Perfect on a chilly evening in Nantucket! read more

Pi Pizzaria - Minestrone Soup - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Ordered a clam pizza. Got rubber bands on a piece of stale bread. Stay away. Check your bowels after eating here

Pizza - 3 stars. Service - 1 star. Worst service on the island. Rude, inattentive server (Friday lunch) who couldn't be bothered to do her job. read more

We ordered three of their speciality pizzas. The clam pizza was my least favorite as it was a tad dry. I would have preferred more of a garlic oil on top. The great Italian pizza was everyone's favorite. Also, you can't go wrong with the margherita pizza. The tomato sauce is fantastic! read more

Pi Pizzaria - the front door of a home at night - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Peeza was good why was the water 20$? I had no idea that they were going to charge me 20 dollars for water.

We called a pizza in for pick up and waited close to 2 hours but it was a Sunday night so I can't blame them too much there.. definitely a popular spot. The pizza was solid no complaints there. I'd recommend going inside for a meal rather than ordering for pick up. The fried mozzarella was great! read more

all 3 of our pizzas were burnt and very dry. One, strangely had a burnt edge crust, yet the bottom crust was really undercooked. Won't be getting pizzas from them anymore. So sad, as they have always been a treat in the past. read more

NO stars whatsoever!!! BAD, BAD news! I CANNOT get over the disrespectfulness that I just experienced this evening. I called this place, and told the boy who answered that I would like to have dinner at an outside table, and that I would probably like to order pizza, and I would have liked a Caesar salad as well. He told me that there would be a long wait, and that there were 50 pizzas ahead of mine and that I should order ahead, and to go ahead and order it. I told him that I would have walked forty five minutes to get there, was almost there, and that I would sit at the table as soon as I arrived. When I arrived, he repeated and repeated in a loud voice that it would take an hour and a half, and that there were a lot of orders ahead of mine. I arrived at 6PM. He never said that I should order from a waiter, or be seated by a hostess. So, I waited and waited at the table, a party of ten and a party of four came and sat down and I watched them get their food. I asked the waiter for a drink, and said that I would like to order a Caesar salad from him, because the first guy where I placed the pizza order didn't ask me whether I wanted one. He also didn't ask whether I wanted an appetizer or a salad, which I did. The waiter bought the drink, but not the salad, and disappeared! I sat longer and longer and longer, and then. a Hostess came up to me and very meanly announced to me that they would need the table for people who are eating in! She was so very nasty, demanding to know how I ordered my food, and who gave me the drink! The party of ten right next to me we're eating their pizzas! I had to insist that I be allowed to be served and eat my dinner as I had planned. Why in the world would I walk forty five minutes to carry a pizza back??? Do NOT EVER go to this place, as I certainly will NOT!!! The hostess said to me, next time you come, you need to do things the way WE like to do them. Funny, the person who answers the phone doesn't even know how that is... At quarter to 9, I asked the hostess about when I would get the food, , and said that I was really upset about this experience, very hungry, and should I just leave? She said that she was sorry, and didn't know about the situation going on... She said the pizza would be ready in 15 minutes, so I waited some more, but it was closer to thirty. By then it was dark and cold, and there was no one else sitting outside. I thought for certain they would apologize, and finally just give me the pizza, so I called a cab to drive me back. The cab arrived, in 20 minutes, but the pizza had still not been brought to the table, so I went inside, and asked if it was ready yet, and told the rude guy that I had a cab waiting. I said surely after this fiasco you wouldn't expect me to pay for it. He said, of course we would, you just took up our table for 3 1/2 hours! Then, he wouldn't let me pay for the pizza, or let me take it! He said we don't want your business, I don't care if you write a review, and don't come back here, or I'll call the police! The hostess then came back and said, we served a lot of food to people tonight, but not to you! This is certainly an alternate universe at Pi pizza, one you don't want to be a part of, and to think, I had been giving them business since they first opened, roughly 20 years ago. The inexperienced rude kids that they have there now, are VERY bad for business. read more

If you want to spend $300 to have staff reaching over your head to clear things the entire time you eat come here! Seriously I've never eaten a meal and had 8 different servers crowding around me like ovulating chimpanzees at the city zoo. Not to mention the minuscule plates of sub average pasta that costs more than my round trip ferry ticket over here. read more

Called to order pizza 3 hours early, only to be hung up on as soon as they answered. Finally connected again for the lady on the phone ably to be RUDE and disrespectful. I understand that you have a busy business, but that doesn't give you the right to be rude. I was raised to respect others and not treat people poorly. Eventually your business will die down and this will be based on how to you treat people. I absolutely would not recommend this Pi Pizza to anyone! How we treat others is important! read more

We love Pi. Pizza is great. Bartenders make fantastic drinks. This year we had some pasta specials and the steak which are equally tremendous. The small space can result in extended wait times, but it is worth it. Enjoy! read more

Pi Pizzaria - Steak medium rare with gorgonzola gnocchi. You can change up the sides. - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Was excited to eat at Pi since it's been two years since I have been to the island. Waited at the door at 5:00 for it's 5:30 opening to be sure to get a table. Not sure what has happened in my two year sabbatical.. such a disappointing meal.. The antipasti presentation as I remember used to be on a beautiful wood board.. this visit, 5 items were crammed onto a round white plate, not good presentation. Olive tapenade still tasty, can't go wrong with imported meats and roasted garlic. Ordered a margherita and white clam pizza pi... How can one serve a burnt blackened crusted pizza and expect the customer to eat it? That was our margherita pi.. The white clam pi... cold clams thrown on top of a pizza crust.. and I mean cold, right out of the fridge cold.. Ordered the Tuscan Bean soup.. a bowl of salt!! The server did take it away, and replaced it with a 'freshly made' one... explains the saltiness.. must have been the bottom of the pot left over from lunch. The risotto special; Meyer lemon- not special at all. Lacked flavor. How about charging $$ for a white truffle pasta - a small bowl of buttered pasta - then truffle shaved on top.. again - not special at all. The penne ragu on the salty side, average at best, but the worst was mushy pasta - not al dente at all. I was really looking forward to coming to Pi, it is the first place we planned for dinner. Truly a disappointment to this ultimate foodie. read more

if you live on the island, this is one of the top three best pizzerias my wife's favorite dinning in its romantic, takeout is great, but I'd rather eat it hot out of the oven if you don't have any patience and you're here in the summer don't bother go home we don't need your rude Condescending attitude! Thank you to the family of pie for the excellent food you serve!! read more

Pi Pizzaria - The great Italian delicious quality ingredients! - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Going downhill. Pickup was terrible. We used to like this pizza if we could get a table but pickup. Just don't bother doing pickup it was a total disappointment ....pizza was half cooked and runny. Lasagna to go .....a gooey mess slopped in a plastic container. Ordered cake just one slice, small only a 1/2 inch slice for $14.00. $98 for everything with tip. Won't be back anymore. Ever. read more

If you want the pizza- go, sit down, order, and eat it there- Don't take it out. Pi is also a bit of a strange restaurant all in all- The owner Evan is cool- but there is an unusual vibe to it which is hard to describe but it definitely exists- a bit creepy I must say and I am not the first to say this. The Mussels and or Clams en Brodo I love- they don't make the bread for dipping but it's kinda perfect for the simple dish- San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, basil. They have some little piddly antipasto choices which are just kinds general and not great- sort of an after thought IMO . Parmagiana. Chicken & Veal are good but very American style with pasta Marinara. Risotto- haven't ordered it but I am very particular about this- it can be great, good, average or horrible- There is a great little market where you pick up your takeaways with European items- Italian cookes and beverages, You can grab wine, Beer crackers and I think some cheeses, Olive oil for sure- Really Good stuff. The take away. It is all in all mostly- very good- One thing- Cocktails are good but a bit overpriced for the space. The bar is a local haunt for sure. I have been there many, many times and will likely to go continue for sure. read more

The pizza at Pi Pizzeria is outstanding. It is classic Italian artisan pizza made in a wood gas oven. The pasta and entrees are delicious and the nightly specials are not to be missed. They also have the best steak on Nantucket. I am shocked at the negative reviews. These people complaining about a wait for pizza in July and August. What do you expect? They have one oven. The wait is not that long most of the year. Everything is great, I love this restaurant and eating at the Bar. read more

See all

Let me list the issues.... It should be less than 1. We called at 5:30, when they open, and they stated it would be an hour for pick up. What we ordered wasn't ready (the Pizza), it would be another 30 minutes, for the Pizza. Finally, after 1.5 hours the pizza was ready. When we got home, EVERYTHING was cold. The pasta had VERY little sauce, and had no flavor. The portions were small (especially a spaghetti for $26.00). A pizza place that can not do spaghetti and pizza even decent? I would NOT recommend this place... read more

This place is the best pizza and service on the island. Make sure to get there early as there will be a wait but it is definitely worth it.

Food was fine, a bit bland and pedestrian, but service was poor. Nice enough but completely inattentive. Took a half an hour to get get drinks, another half hour to get appetizers (upon request). Others served and gone while we sat and waited. No checking in on the table. Comped desert to climb back into favor which was an appreciated gesture. Maybe it was just an off night, but not a great dining experience. read more

Don't bother to call ahead and place a takeout order. First, they tell you it will be about an hour, twenty before it will be ready. When you finally show up 1:20 later and give them your name, they expect to be paid, right then and there. Then expect to wait around another 25 minutes while they actually put your pizza in the oven. Another words I doubt they take orders over the phone at all. Do yourself a favor, walk over to the Stop&Shop and buy a yourself a frozen pizza. read more

Literally just got done eating the pizza here!!If you are looking for authentic thin crust wood fired pizza!! This is your place!! Ordered a cheese and a pepperoni. Both pizzas came out a little well done perfect!!The sauce was delicious as well as the cheese and pepperoni on both pizzas!! My wife and I are both Italian and the pickiest people in the world. This place surpassed our expectations!! read more

I love pi!! The pizzas are so delicately made. The sauce is amazing, and the crust is crispy. They do not put too much cheese, but I also love the "marinara" red pie. The salads are fine but not the best. The staff is helpful and friendly. I also love the Italian atmosphere. We have ordered pizza, pasta, and dessert here year after year and it is always delicious!! read more

Being spoiled from Neapolitan style pizzas in NY, I have to say I was not impressed with Pi. You would think having an hour wait for pizza would mean they're amazing. Not so much. It's good but not great. The dough-topping balance could be better. Their hot subs were also a bit lacking in flavor. read more

Pi Pizzaria - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Fantastic pizza and great Italian home cooking. Also has a nice small store selling Italian wine, beer, olive oil and other Italian comestibles. Be warned - in summer you need to plan ahead and place your take out order at 4pm. If you want great pizza done in 20-30 min come back November-May. read more

Pi Pizzeria had been on my Nantucket Eats list for several years. But, weekends always went by so fast, summers abruptly ended, and then I missed hitting Pi once again. So when planning a trip for WineFest this year, a friend asked what my dining requirement would be (clearly my friends get me!) and I immediately said Pi Pizzeria. My review here is very simple: BEST Chicken Parmesan EVER. The ragu sauce addition is a must. I only wish they delivered off island. read more

Pi Pizzaria - Chicken Parmesan with ragu - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts