Delicious food, friendly service, large portions, and a great price point for the island. Highly recommend and will be back very soon!!! These reviews should be reset since it is under new ownership and is better than ever! read more

A great local restaurant ruined by new ownership. The service, the food and loud patrons' makes this place is the worst on the island. I'm so sad to have to write this review. Even the pizza and lasagna was inedible, frozen would have been better. They ran out of the cod the only fish they serve. The prices increased by 40% and the quality of the ingredients took a nosedive. We will never go back. read more

Under new ownership and has a slightly new menu. Tonight we were a party of 3, all used to dining out. I went rogue and ordered the bavette steak with potatoes, and mizuna salad...arugula. Never had a bavette steak and it was excellent, cooked medium rare. The potato wedges were absolutely out of this world and had a garlic aoili dipping sauce. I would highly recommend. My wife had gluten free pizza and it was the best she's ever had and I concur...she let me have a small piece. Guest had a pizza and that crust was out of this world. I would highly recommend trying Fusaro's, not the same as previous owner, but excellent all the same. Oh, the server was outstanding and the entire staff was very friendly. I see the July 30 review was only 1 star, maybe a bad night. read more

Service : excellent Cod was excellent. Particularly excellent Vodka pizza was excellent Very happy with fusaro's. I was worried when it was sold and am looking forward to many repeat visit. read more

Terrible! Ridiculously overpriced, small portions and total tack of ambience. Skip this place for sure.

We were walk ins for dinner and we were greeted quickly and seated in the covered patio. Food was very good. Service was very good and pricing very reasonable for Nantucket! We will be returning next time we visit the Island. read more

Went to Fusaro's for dinner last night and the food was so, so delicious, I'm shocked there aren't more 5-star reviews. I've never been compelled to write a Yelp review before so this is a first for me, but here goes: Service was fantastic; our waiter was attentive, knowledgable, and fast. Hostesses were very friendly, we were seated on the patio immediately, which was lovely and comfortable. But that fooood though! It's almost embarrassing how quickly we devoured our meals. We started with the meatballs and crispy brussel sprouts for apps - and holy sh*t were they delicious. My kids are super picky eaters and they were literally fighting over the last half of the last meatball. I had to ask my husband to move the brussel sprouts away from me because I wasn't even scooping them onto my plate, just shoveling them straight into my mouth. For dinner, I got the Fusilli Alla Vodka and I wish I could adequately describe how mouth watering the sauce was. Without question it's one of the best pasta dishes I've ever had the pleasure of eating. Easily top five. My husband raved about the Fettucine Giardiniera and my daughter ended up stealing his plate after she finished her spaghetti. We are going back for pizza because the tables around us were all enjoying theirs and they looked too good to pass up. The drinks were delicious but the food was the star of our show for sure. I hope this review helps folks visiting the island and locals alike in choosing Fusaro's for their next meal out! read more

We went for an early sitting to the restaurant and sat out on the porch. The staff was very welcoming and attentive throughout the meal. We all had a starter, I had the scallops wrapped in bacon and they were absolutely delicious. Then I had the Parmigiana crusted Haddock and was one of the tastiest meals I've ever had. We all had delicious food and excellent company and the staff were wonderful and attentive. I can highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a delicious meal on Nantucket. read more

The fried mozzarella is one of the top 3 in my life. It's a flakey type of batter that is very light. I could eat 2 servings by myself. The Alfredo sauce was runny. The pizza was decent. I would go back and just eat the fried mozzarella. read more

The calamari had a nice spice but was soggy (possibly because I ordered it for take out but still like 7/10). I got the Anastasia pizza and was underwhelmed. The crust and bread was boring but the mushrooms and tomatos really popped with the truffle oil. Good vibes inside I will definitely be back to dine in and try some pasta read more

Returned a year later and sat at the bar and had a really good meal, great beer and nice crowd. read more

Fusaro's - Small Fungi Pizza with a Peroni beer, delicious! - Italian Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

I had dinner here 2 nights ago and got food poisoning. I had the mushroom pasta dish, it was $30, ok tasting (the first time around haha). Started puking within 6 hours of finishing dinner, sick for 24 hours. I would not recommend this establishment based on my experience. read more

The food is great . Service is 110 percent , ambiance is so relaxing like you chilling out at home. Try the cheese garlic bread

We dined at Fusaro's on a Wednesday during off season in January. However, neither service nor quality of food were anything but stellar. The experience was similar to what I am used to from Europe. The waiters were professionals knowing their craft versus part-time employees doing a job. The meal was great. Aperitif: Habanero and jalapeño infused margarita on the rocks with spicy salt rim Appetizers: We had the carpaccio and Nantucket calamari. Both delicious. Main course: Capellini with scallops, spinach and prosciutto in a white wine sauce and Scallops over roasted fingerling potatoes with aioli (the menu said French fries but I asked to change it to the potatoes and it was no problem) Again both dishes were very good and the scallops in both dishes were cooked to perfection. The pasta was slightly under seasoned, but tasted perfect after adding a pinch of salt. The fennel salad with the scallops was a bit overpowered by the mayonnaise-based dressing. A more pronounced fennel flavor would have made this dish stand out even more. As drink pairings we had a Pinot Grigio with the pasta and an Athletic Light (nonalcoholic) beer with the scallops. I was happy to see a nonalcoholic option on the drinks menu. A light beer is a good and acceptable pairing with the seafood. I suggest adding a Peroni 0.0 as a secondary and Italian beer option. Dessert Grappa, coffee and tiramisu. Again, great attention to detail as the whipped cream was made with coffee. Ambience and service The small and cozy restaurant is an ideal spot for a date night or a family dinner. It is quiet and elegant enough to have a conversation but not so formal that children have to stay home. The bar area feels separate from the main L-shaped dining room which again offers multiple experiences: cocktails with friends, small bites after work or a full dinner. The staff knows what they are doing. The different courses were spaced out nicely and we never felt rushed to either order or finish quickly. The waiters struck a great balance between being attentive and allowing us space to enjoy our meal and conversation. Thank you for a wonderful evening at your restaurant. We will definitely be back the next time we visit Nantucket. read more

I've had dinner inside Fusaro's and have ordered pizza for take-out plenty of times and was never disappointed. This evening I ordered the entree - "Gnocchi alla Sorrentina" which is described as: "baked house-made potato gnocchi, Pomodoro, buffala mozzarella, basil." List price was $22. The total was $23.54 (with tax). When I opened the brown paper bag I was presented with what you see in the picture below. No salad, no bread, no napkin, no fork, no knife. The picture you see was the portion that was served untouched. The food is always delicious, but I feel I was short-changed on the portion this evening on the take-out order. read more

Fusaro's - Fusaro's - Gnocchi alla Sorrentina (take-out) - Italian Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Everyone enjoyed it. We would go back. They seated us promptly and the food was flavorful and timely.

Just ate at this restaurant. We were stable of 6 and they don't take reservations. We need we would have a wait due to the size of our group. However, as we were waiting we notice the that large parties were being seated before us. Once we were seating we watched others come in after us and served BEFORE us!!! Besides an hour gap between apps and entree once we got our food the portions were pathetically small and one was wrong The waiter told the the manager that we were not happy, he told 15% of the bill. That was nice but because of so many things that went wrong the manager should have come to our table personally. It's definitely a locals place and they don't seem to care about the tourists. We have been coming to Nantucket for summer vacation for many years. We will NOT be visiting this restaurant again!!!!!! read more

SLOW. After 75 minutes, no food and the waitress had been to the table once. Other tables that sat after us got food. We approached the manager and they were unapologetic, unhelpful and arrogant. Even when the food eventually came, the waitress didn't acknowledge the wait or lack of service. 4 entrees (including a small pizza and kids plain pasta) should not take this long (especially seating at 5:45pm). SMALL. Portion sizes were tiny for the price. SO-SO. Taste was bland. This was our first time at this restaurant after coming to Nantucket for over 5 years and will be our last. There are so many better choices. read more

Excellent meal and excellent service. The restaurant has a "at home" feeling.Everyone at our table ordered different things, and we were all happy! read more

Decent food, small portions for the price. Atmosphere was cute and the staff was excellent.

We always try two new restaurants on our annual Nantucket fishing trip. This restaurant was a great surprise!! Amazing Italian food and a excellent outdoor dining area. Great food knowledgeable waiter and excellent food !! Great dinner that I highly recommend. read more

See all

I have been many times to Fusaro's and always get a great meal. The meatballs as an appetizer delicious. The sauce is outstanding! The meals are good portions and tasty. The service is friendly and attentive. I have recommended Fusaro's to others visiting Nantucket. read more

the food was bland and did not have much flavor at all. the fusilli all's vodka tasted like jar tomato sauce with a bit of cream mixed in and the fettuccine alfredo did not meet the mark. our waiter Allie (Alison) was not accommodating and did not make myself or present company feel welcome. she was rude and rolled her eyes at us several times. do not recommend. read more

Very good dinner spot with great service and generous wine pours. I got the haddock and would order it again! Other dinner orders pictured below: read more

See all

We pop in here annually in August and are never disappointed. The food is always great. This time I was happy to see they'd updated they're menu - and honestly it's one of the better Italian menus that I have seen. Something for everyone - seafood, pasta, veg dishes, pizza. Pasta and sausage are also made in house. They've also further renovated their patio into a large 3-4 season space. Bad reviews must be for takeout order wait times when the kitchen is overrun? I'm also guessing there may be a low tolerance for rude patrons here? To me it seems well run, with the owners in the house and the mostly adult staff doing their thing as it should be done. read more

Fusaro's - Lemon chicken with zoodles. Delicious and light. - Italian Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Food to table , took an hour to get our order , portions were small , appetizers were forgotten. As visitors from out of town we were served after the locals .. rude!!Do not recommend read more

THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND THE DELICIOUS The Bad: We ordered our food thru Delivery.com and 2 hours later we still had not received it. The Good: We called the restaurant directly and they never received the order! Even though it was 10 minutes to closing, the owner said she would make the order and her husband would deliver it. The Delicious: The pizzas were worth waiting for and because of the problems with the order, the complimentary salads were a welcomed extra touch. FIVE STAR SERVICE! We were so appreciative of the extra mile. read more

Love this for Italian night! It's a great way to add some variety in to all the delicious seafood options in Nantucket, we have been coming here for years! The portions are a good size to finish your meal and not feel too stuffed. I recommend the bolognese and the nana jean's meatballs! read more

See all

Absolute disaster of a carry-out experience. One Caesar salad, two pasta dishes, so nothing terribly complex. It took a full hour and forty-five minutes from order being placed to food being delivered. The food was forty-five minutes later than the time we were told it would be ready. I understand that restaurants get slammed and the kitchen backs up, but an hour and forty-five minutes for what we got (see photo; that's $17 worth of pasta that took almost two hours to cook) is unacceptable. There are way too many dining options on Nantucket to go back to a place that delivers a level of service this abysmal. read more

Fusaro's - Italian Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

I'd give Fusaro's 2.5 stars for service and 4.5 for taste. Nantucket is a pretty small place. Before the people working there realized that my friend was the daughter of people they knew personally, they were pretty rude to us. Though we were merely three girls shivering in the corner, waiting for the rest of our party, one of the workers INSISTED that we know if our party consisted of 5 or 6 people right there and then. Sometimes plans are hard to make! I totally get that it is an important thing to know especially when the restaurant is crowded. However, there is simply nothing we can do about it if we genuinely just have no idea if one person in the party is coming to dinner or not. Setting that aside, once they realized which family we were with, they were significantly nicer. Not a super great thing to witness but hey, it happens. The food took well over half an hour to come out. By that point, all of the appetizers and bread were gone. The food was pretty great though. Everyone enjoyed their pasta and my friend and I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza that we split. The crust was to-die for. I'll admit - I've never had a pizza with such delicious crust! It tasted almost buttery; not hard to eat by itself at all. The large pizza is the perfect size for two moderately hungry adults. Great place to go with your family and have a delicious and filling Italian dinner. Just be ready to fill in the time with quite a bit of conversation. read more

Have ordered takeout twice in past few weeks. Food is always top notch and amazing. However, first time we placed order around 2 pm. When we arrived at 6:50 for 7 pm pickup, it wasn't ready, which was fine as we were early. But around 7:20 when it still wasn't ready, it got a bit annoying. Finally came around 5 minutes after that. Was worth it in the end but frustrating when we ordered so far in advance that it wasn't ready on time. Edit: ordered takeout a third time and it was also not ready for 20 minutes after scheduled pickup time. Food was still delicious but the service failures persist read more

A coworker mentioned going to this place so as soon as I was back on island we made a trip. Bar is right at the entrance with seating nearby. Some of the seats were a little close for comfort, but it wasn't full because we went right before closing so I didn't feel like I was having dinner with other people. Got a salted caramel martini. It. Was. Delicious. Best drink I've had in a while. Whoever mixed it that night did a superb job and I'm sad I didn't manage to get back to sample it again. My coworker and I split a pizza. It was okay, not the best I've ever had. Thin crust with fresh toppings so I can't complain too much. Classic Italian restaurant fare. I tend to be picky because I'm from an area with a large Italian American population. So the food has to be homemade to impress me. Nice place to eat, typical Nantucket prices. I'd come back for the drink alone. read more

Fusaro's - This is the Salted Caramel Martini. Best mixed drink I've had in a looong time. - Italian Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

RUN don't walk to here! We have had so many excellent meals here. Everything is divine from the service to the food. It is so reasonably priced and a lovely lovely place to dine ! Our fav!!! read more

Girl at the front said 30 minute wait took our name and number. 40 minutes later, I called them and she said I had a party of 8 in front of us. The party of 8 was actually behind me but ok. Still waiting for a call and it's almost 2 hours later and nothing. Obviously, we're at another restaurant but still. Very rude to make us wait for nothing and we only waited because it's a busy time in Nantucket and we felt locked in to eat here within a reasonable dinner hour for food that's not even authentic Italian. Let's face it probably not even a quarter Italian. From the other reviews looks like we dodged a bullet. read more

Went here 2 days in a row it was so good. It does not allow reservations. The gluten free pizza was great. The marinara sauce was excellent on the pizza and cheese was delicious. Perfectly cooked. My husband loved the calamari. The bread was excellent and oil for dipping. Had a great apperal spritz. Chicken with zucchini was excellent. Service was top notch. I will be back. read more

Wonderful home made old school Italian. Killer meat balls, delish pastas, great pizza & salads & eggplant.. Warm mid island location. Come early or later it can get crowded. Great value, not a lot of competitors on this island. read more

Enjoyed a beautiful Fall day visiting Nantucket with friends. Decided to dine at Fusaro's and enjoyed a wonderful meal to cap off our day. Staff were friendly and attentive. Weather was perfect for outdoor dining but we would have been just as happy in their very nice indoor dining room. We were a party of 4 and each person was equally delighted with their selections. If you are looking for a delicious Italian dinner in a hometown atmosphere, Fusaro's is the place to go. read more

I've been on lockdown and eating my own food for weeks, so going to Fusaro's for pick up was my first venture out during Covid times! We got an Anthony's Special and a simple cheese pizza and they were amazing! Such a treat! The pies were ordered online and were promptly delivered when we arrived to pick them up at the suggested time. We were so satisfied with our meal! We highly recommend them! read more

Worst service ever. I would not recommend this restaurant at all. We ordered takeout and were told it would be ready at 8. When we arrived at 8 we were told "whoever said 8 was wrong." We did not receive our order until 50 minutes after we were told it would be ready. This place has complete disrespect for their customers and we will never be back. The food is average at best. read more

We just had a wonderful meal at Fusaro's. This was my second time here, with my last visit being 2 years ago. The restaurant is beautiful and comfortable. The menu had so many wonderful choices it was difficult to decide on an entree. We had Anthony's pizza for an appetizer and it was incredible. Thin, crispy but chewy, delicious crust with fresh sauce, lots of cheese, sausage, and meatballs. I finally decided on the lasagna and it was spectacular as well. Huge portion. The staff were all so charming and made the visit even more memorable. I will be sure to make a trip here with every visit to Nantucket. read more