A great pizza option in downtown Nantucket that has limited seating, a fun vibe and solid…read moreneopolitan style pizza. Not large, but enough for 2 people (especially if you have a side salad). I ordered about 7 pizzas online and they did add a mandatory 20% tip and they don't pick up the phone, so you couldn't even order via phone. And then when picking up said pizzas, which was quite a lot to carry, there was no offer to help carry them, paper plates, napkins, etc.. And, some of the pizzas were not cut through (and when they do cut the pies, they only cut them in 4 large slices). Again, just some customer service opportunities, especially if you're going to force a 20% gratuity on orders, but not really offer any great service. So, there it is. Nantucket prices, for solid pizza. Ordering online wasn't the best UX, but you get what you get, sometimes.

Pizza was very mediocre. And the clerk was a little entitled. Total came to $6.42 and I gave $7,…read moreand he didn't give me the change. I was planning on putting the change in the tip can anyway, since I hate carrying change, but to automatically assume that and not give the change is a little messed up.

Decent pizza option in Nantucket if you aren't wanting to venture out for the evening. We ordered…read morein and had no issues with delivery. It was a little cold and lacking in flavor overall but not bad. Probably wouldn't order again but it might be better in person and the delivery guy was really nice.

Ordered a $37 custom pizza with pepperoni, bacon and extra sauce, got a nasty plain cold pizza for…read more"Claire" (not my name). This is the second time this place has been the absolute worst delivery option on the island. These is even after i called MULTIPLE TIMES this evening to make sure they knew my order and where to deliver it after last time. I called the restaurant six times after our poor delivery driver was told by Sophie's to bring this pizza to us and got no answer. Guess we'll have to get our money back via disputing the charge? This place shouldn't be allowed to operate a delivery service.

Great pizza, beautiful outdoor seating, delicious drinks. Slow but kind service…read more Wine was served in a water glass which was very disappointing and negatively affected our experience here. They should consider serving wine in a wine glass, especially if they are charging 17 dollars for one glass of wine.

The pizza is great. Light, crisp and great toppings. The white clam is great. The pizza overall is…read moreon the lighter side but overall surprisingly excellent pizza to be found on an island. Would recommend just getting take out and buying wine at the stop and shop to eat at home instead of buying bottles at the restaurant as they are marked up substantially.

We stopped here last night and got a few slices for dinner. It's great that you can just order by…read morethe slice. I loved it! Staff were friendly! We were able to walk to the water with our slices to enjoy them and had a perfect first evening in Nantucket!

The service was weird. We asked for a whole pizza ($28), which was just made and sitting on…read moredisplay, and she said we had to wait another 15 minutes for a new pizza or pay the per-slice price, which would make it much more expensive at $6.50 per slice (around $39). So we waited. The pizza tasted all right. It's meant to sooth any late-night post-drinks muchies but given the lack of ambiance and frills, it's just an okay spot to get food. If I did a little more research, I would consider Pi Pizza or Oath Pizza, so read those reviews and make your decision! Make sure you get a receipt like the other reviewers said! Cashier was a bit shady about that. There's no seating inside, no AC, and it's hot as you know what! They do have shakers with cheese and red pepper flakes and garlic.

Delicious food, friendly service, large portions, and a great price point for the island. Highly…read morerecommend and will be back very soon!!! These reviews should be reset since it is under new ownership and is better than ever!

Very cool spot on the Island. Owned by locals and worked by locals. Service is fast and friendly…read moreand atmosphere is very cool. Although their menu is not large everything on it is great! Specifically the pizza!

So good! Delicious. Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo good.read more

I don't wanna be this person, but I have to be- close to $50 for 2 small, personal sized pizzas in…read moresconset the other evening. While we may have asked for lighter crust, it was pretty raw with almost a cardboard texture for base. I feel like their pizza is slightly inconsistent, because I've eaten it before, and have loved it.

After stopping by for subs or pizza over the last five years, I finally felt the need to explain…read more"The Muse" to people. The formula is actually pretty simple: the food is excellent... the service is memorably bad. In fact, it's become a running family joke every summer. We always wonder, "How bad will the customer service be this time?" It's almost part of the experience. It starts before you even walk in. If you call to place an order, they answer the phone like they're genuinely annoyed that it rang. Then they tell you your order will be ready in, say, 20 minutes. My advice? Add another 15 minutes to whatever they tell you. It's almost automatic. When I say the service is bad, I don't mean the employees are overwhelmed or having an off day. They often talk to customers as if you're inconveniencing them simply by ordering. It's consistently curt and surprisingly rude. Then comes the twist... You slide your credit card into the machine. It asks if you'd like to leave a tip. You make your selection. Then--like someone flipped a switch--they smile, hand you your food, genuinely thank you, and wish you a nice day. And somehow... it works. Five minutes ago you were annoyed. Now you have your food, you're relieved the ordeal is over, and you're walking out smelling the pizza! It's like a customer-service Jedi mind trick. They don't convince you the service was good--they just make you so happy to finally have your food that you momentarily forget how you were treated. I've watched this happen to me--and to plenty of other customers--for years. And yet... I keep going back. Because the food really is that good.

I never leave reviews but felt compelled as this was the WORST service ever. The people at the…read moretakeout counter were extremely rude. Zero customer service skills.

I eat a lot of Indian food all over the world. While the restaurant is not a high end place (I…read moredon't think that's the intention) the Indian food is excellent. We had the chicken curry, kids had burgers and fries. Excellent and tender chicken. I like the fact that it's a chill relaxed atmosphere and not a stuffy up tight place. Staff are very nice people They also do American and Japanese food so it caters to a lot of people

Shangri-La Kitchen in Nantucket is such a solid spot for a casual meal. The mix of sushi, curries,…read moreand pizza sounds wild, but they pull it off - everything is tasty, fresh, and super satisfying. The portions are generous, prices are reasonable for the island, and it's perfect for takeout or a relaxed dine-in night. Friendly staff, lots of options, and definitely a go-to when you want something easy and delicious on Nantucket.

Great time at Cisco brewing! This place will get PACKED during the peak season so be prepared for…read moreit to be busy. It's such a nice place to hangout outside during a beautiful summer day. If you are visiting the island they have a shuttle which will pick you up from in town, it runs in a continuous loop about every 20 min. Once at Cisco, they were charging a cover of $10 a person to get in. Inside they have a large courtyard, lots of tables, and a big stage with live music. They have a wine station, full liquor bar, and the beer station so you can try all of the things they make. They were doing a signature cocktail with fresh cucumber which was delicious and refreshing! They also distill their own spirits and single malt whiskey. They had one of the best wine Frosè I have ever had, called the Nantucket Frosè. It has FRESH fruit and berries, SO good!

Our no longer so secret party spot. Even in the off season, it's ridiculously congested. If you…read morescore parking on premises, it's like winning an organ transplant. A few years ago, someone offered to buy my parking space for $500. (I declined.) There's often live music. (Check local publications or their website for up-to-date schedules.) There are often a number of food trucks present. On our recent visit, we had oysters from Hang Ten (enormous, meaty and sweet, but shucked with a ton of shell shards); tacos, guac and nachos from Millie's; and pizza from Eat Fire Pizza. And of course we had a number of decent beers on tap from Cisco Brewers. They seem to tend towards lightness, minimal hoppiness: good summer brews for warm weather. It's family friendly -- including canine members. Our pup is a seasoned New Yorker and accustomed to crowds, but even she seemed a little frazzled by the press of people at times.

Wonderful service and great staff…read more The restaurants offered outdoor seating in addition to indoor one. Definitely a plus on a beautiful summer day. They also are family friendly as they offer coloring paper and crayons for usage. Night time the restaurant turn into a disco bar.

When Nantucket calls off I go. Especially when it's the daffodil festival . This is an extremely…read morebusy time to find a restaurant but we were lucky enough to get a table at the Charlie. . As soon as I walked in the door I spied the Lonster quesadillas and they looked amazing. When I asked the waiter he said hands down they were the best thing on the menu and indeed they were. Jam Packed with plenty of lobster chunks it made this New Englander very happy!