Wow!! This may be the best lobster roll we had on our entire trip to Boston, the Cape and…read more Nantucket! Simply delicious and worth every penny!! They have a beautiful garden area with picnic tables to sit and eat your lobster rolls. We also did the homemade Guacamole and wow that was delicious too! I can't say enough good things to say about the lobster roll and guac from 167. They do have a market on property too for fresh fish, beer/wine and some other small goods. We actually got dropped off at Cisco brewing and walked over here just for that lobster roll. YUM!

Came here after a day at Cisco Beach and WOW was I blown away by their lobster roll!…read more Located on Hummock Pond rd. We came on bikes. Very close to Cisco Brewery and on the way to or from the beach. This is a must-stop. We got two lobster rolls (which come with chips and a pickle) and to drink a sun tea! I was BLOWN away by these lobster rolls. I'm a bit of a lobster roll enthusiast. This was the best cold lobster I've had outside of Maine. They have a slight twist in the classic. Hardy amount of lobster, perfectly cooked, and lightly dressed and topped with chive. I think they drizzle them in a lemon butter too. The bun was outstanding, buttered and then salted, the extra salt is a nice touch. Drooling writing this review and remembering how good they were. They were that good! We also got "Hannah's homemade sun tea", sweet and refreshing. They also have ceviche, guac, and other things on the menu that looked great and I can't wait to try. Staff was friendly and welcoming. They have outside seating with umbrellas for shade. The parking lot gets packed though so come on a bike if you can. A+ 167 Raw, can't wait to come back.

Such polished service! Had a 9pm reservation but showed up at around 8:30 to see if the could…read moreaccommodate us earlier. Although there was not a table available at the moment she said she would call when one becomes available. We stayed local and were delighted to get a call 15 minutes later to let us know that our table was ready. It really left an impression that she was willing to make a phone call just to get us in 15 minutes earlier. We had heard excellent things about the service, the food and the cocktails and we were not disappointed. The crab fried rice with an extra egg was delicious and we also enjoyed the tuna poke and the scallion pancake. The service was polished without being rushed.

I wanted to like this place more!! It was difficult to get a reservation so I expects a lot. The…read moreseating is limited. They serve very quickly. Tapas are the call! The options seemed to fuse too many different things together, for meI liked the blue crab fried rice best! The ribs were a pass. Scallion pancakes were fine. Miso cod skewer was reminiscent of Nobu. I felt rushed. It's good, just not necessarily, for me.

There are times when I regret recommending the Lemon Press to so many people because it's become so…read moredarned crowded. Darn me and my big mouth. And darn other people and their big mouths! I'm shaking my fist at all of us! The good news for those of us who are bad at planning ahead is that it's walk-in only for breakfast and lunch. (Compare and contrast to certain Nantucket restaurants that must be reserved weeks or even months in advance.) At Lemon Press, you can reserve for dinner in the dining room downstairs, and I suspect it's a good idea to do so nowadays. During the day, wait times, especially for two-tops, at the upstairs cafe are not usually unbearable. I'll admit that at first I only recommended the restaurant to those with bland palates (like my otherwise wonderful MIL). But since Chef Lyall Frosler began heading up the kitchen in early 2025, the food has been excellent and anything but bland. At a recent meal, the Nantucket Bay Scallop Wraps ($29; bibb lettuce, pickled onions, bacon, scallops, Aleppo aioli, shirazi salad) included extremely fresh, sweet, tiny bay scallops, cooked to a perfect temperature; crisp (not rubbery) lardons; beautifully fresh lettuce; flavorful seasoned tomatoes (I guess a functional sub for shirazi salad). The aioli was pleasantly spicy, not over exuberantly glopped on. A Chicken Gyro ($19; tzatziki, hummus, shirazi, greens, pickled onion, Persian pickle, feta, tahini) was made with very moist, tender chicken, not the most flavorful by itself, but well paired with a wealth of flavorful garnishes. The chicken was sliced in pieces that were a bit too large and unwieldy to consume easily as a wrap; this would be better as knife and fork food. I think shirazi was once again just tomato with possibly a bit of onion, but nicely seasoned. The bits of Persian pickles on the plate were wonderful. A Breakfast Burrito with sausage ($19; eggs, potatoes or duck hash (+$4), cheddar, peppers, onions, Aleppo aioli, hot sauce) was quite a fun, spicy wake-up call for your mouth. Nothing bland about it. And of course we've very much enjoyed all the snacks and goodies we've had from Lemon Press at various events they've catered: crisp, flavorful falafel; lobster rolls; crostinis; grape leaves; tiny pastries with whipped feta. The cafe is absolutely charming inside, with beautiful wallpaper, vines growing from glass planters suspended from the ceiling, and jars of sumac salt on each table. (The Progeny couldn't stop eating this stuff by the spoonful.) The upstairs bathrooms are very narrow and, while not filthy on a recent visit, could definitely have been better maintained. Wait staff have been completely incredible on our visits, especially the lovely young woman who could be of Persian descent (I'm guessing in part b/c she pronounced "sumac" with an emphasis on the second syllable as Persian and Arabic speakers do instead of on the first syllable as native English speakers do). She and her colleagues work their tails off, though the restaurant is so busy, there can still be long wait times for food. Bottom line? DON'T GO! Stop taking my table, alright?

We visited this place for our last meal before heading off Nantucket. We avoided it previously…read morebecause it was labeled as "touristy " but the reviews looked good so we went for it. It's busy but we got a table for 5 immediately at 10am. The options looked great. We got gluten-free avocado toast with an egg (bland and meh, I've had better), Turkish eggs (very good), LP. Breakfast (filling and tasty), açaí bowl with berries and honey (yum), midnight cold pressed juice, lemon ginger shot, iced matcha latte (too sweet), iced saffron cardamom (too sweet), iced latte (perfect). We were happy to end our trip here. The inside is summery with low and high tables near the bar. I had to ask for my drink twice because it appears they forgot it. The staff were friendly and apologetic. Loved it overall!

We visited Bar Yoshi four times in the past three weeks. The food is inventive and delicious, and…read morethe service exceptional! Our favorite server is Brian. We love sitting outside.

Bar Yoshi is the perfect spot of sushi and other Asian bites right at the harbor. They are a small…read moreplace, so they have some tables inside and lots of tables mostly outside. They will get full so a reservation is needed! We walked in and were able to snag a seat at the bar at 8pm, but they wouldn't let us sit at a table as they were full! The vibe inside was upbeat, loud and dim. It was very lively! I had the spicy tuna roll and the noodles. The noodles were exceptionally delicious. Drinks were also made well. My partner had a soda, it was $8 which was shocking even for Nantucket! Overall Bar Yoshi was super fun and a great spot for sushi, even late night bites since they are open late. I loved the atmosphere. If you are looking for a lovely place for food and drinks right in the harbor, check out Bar Yoshi!

This place is super cool, it's an old whaling pub and they have kept the theming throughout! You…read moreMUST make a reservation, as they are like impossible to get into! The service was very nice and friendly, the food was so good!! We had the Philly cheesesteak roles app which were delicious. For dinner did the lobster fettuccine, absolutely worth it. So good, I forgot to take a picture before I ate it. I highly recommend it! Giving everything 4 stars, because unfortunately the drinks were not good. I had the peach bourbon smash and the mint was old and not good. We also had a Hugo spritz and it was so sweet it was undrinkable, so we asked to take it off and they did which was nice.

Walked "in" to the outdoor dining. Cool spot. Like all things Nantucket it was a great use of space…read morebetween things. Promptly seated right at opening to beat the crowds. Friendly service beginning to end. We tried the lobster roll two ways, fish and chips and kids chicken tenders. Warm buttered lobster roll was good, not great. Enjoyed the slaw and salad that accompany it. Not crazy expensive at $39 but not a ton of lobster on the roll. Wifey basically had the same only lobster was dry. In both cases a bit on the chewy side. Fish and chips was not really eaten/enjoyed, and we fed the chicken tenders to two dogs at a neighboring table. Lots of good options on the menu. Would try a great many other things before going back.

Wonderful place for a date night. Love it there! Can't wait to return. Great service, even better…read moremeals.

Okay to be honest this Nantucket trip was last summer so I forgot a lot about what we ordered but…read morethe one thing that stands out from this place even till now was the lobster fettuccine. If I I had to narrow down to some favorite dishes from the week there this would be near the top of the list! The lobster was so fresh and the sauce and pasta were homemade so it was just such an amazing dish!!! But seriously everything we ordered was so good and the service was wonderful as well!! Definitely worth visiting! Nice ambiance as well and this was our last dinner before we left which fit perfectly!!

Quite a change from the old Starlight…read more Creative, well executed small plates and main dishes. Beef tartare was excellent, and the Tuna Sashimi Bowl hit the spot as well. Service was solid and prompt; the overall "price/value" relationship is arguably the only fly in the ointment...fine dining pricing in a "bar style" atmosphere, even by Nantucket standards. Will come again, though.

The bartender was very rude cursing at people trying to pay a $20 cover for a bar to go into. He…read moresaid the F word after we asked how much the cover was very rude. If you ask me would not spend my money here on this whole entire island. "$20 fucking dollars" why would I pay that if that's how it was presented ?

Lola 41 is one of our top five favorite restaurants on the island. My family has been coming here…read morefor almost 30 years every summer so we've eaten many times at almost all of the "multiyear establishments". Lola 41 has always treated us like royalty and served us spectacular drinks and top quality food; especially the fresh and crisp sushi rolls (our favorite). If sushi is not your thing, there is plenty of other choices to delight your senses. You will not be disappointed! Jessica (who runs the place) is usually seen greeting customers, making sure their dining experience is exceptional. She has been a big part of transforming and maintains this wonderful eatery as one of the best dining experiences on the island. I couldn't recommend it any higher...try it, you'll like it. 5 stars for sure!

Ate here the other night as dining options are limited in winter. Wow this place was great…read more The service was amazing, the food was amazing, the desert was amazing. I got the Korean Beef Bulgogi and it's was the best Bulgogi ive had in years. 10/10 will be back again in summer.

Love their bar area off to the side. Cozy and sexy u shaped bar. Had the amazing lobster rangoons…read moreand a tropical mocktail. Bartender was warm and friendly and the vibe was good overall

Had cocktails at the bar - AMAZING, cool place. Great mix menu of cocktails - a nice "pop in"…read morebefore heading to dinner. Bar seats only 8-9 people

Our no longer so secret party spot. Even in the off season, it's ridiculously congested. If you…read morescore parking on premises, it's like winning an organ transplant. A few years ago, someone offered to buy my parking space for $500. (I declined.) There's often live music. (Check local publications or their website for up-to-date schedules.) There are often a number of food trucks present. On our recent visit, we had oysters from Hang Ten (enormous, meaty and sweet, but shucked with a ton of shell shards); tacos, guac and nachos from Millie's; and pizza from Eat Fire Pizza. And of course we had a number of decent beers on tap from Cisco Brewers. They seem to tend towards lightness, minimal hoppiness: good summer brews for warm weather. It's family friendly -- including canine members. Our pup is a seasoned New Yorker and accustomed to crowds, but even she seemed a little frazzled by the press of people at times.

Went to Cisco last weekend at Nantucket. First of all paid $25.00 each for a tour which was the…read moreonly thing worth the trip. But, then got charged $10 each for "cover charge". So I go up to the bar and buy two drafts. When paying I was my credit card and put "no tip" on the screen. Then I place a couple of ones on his tip pile. I walk away, then my daughter's boyfriend said he noticed the bartender, entered "20% tip". On the screen. And sure enough... credit card bill comes in and there is the tip on my statement. Very poor and classless act. I always bought Cisco beers in the package stores on the Cape. Never again, and will make sure everybody I know hears this story. Just poor and pathetic way of doing business.