Sayle's is the real deal…read more Live lobsters in any size you want, cooked to order at prices that are much more normal than you're used to seeing on Nantucket (available without the dinner platter extras). Steamers by the bag, with drawn butter and lemon. Fried whole belly clams and other seafood, done perfectly. Frying is a skill, and these guys do it right. Clean oil at the perfect temperature delivers seafood and even french fries that are crisp and not greasy at all.

I've heard massively good things about Sayle's from my friends who live in the island, year round…read more Well, thing is, it's a take out place. They do have a couple of tables outside, but it was kind of a cool and windy day and not enjoyable to be sitting out. Darn shame. Seafood was alive in tanks. Everything was very fresh. Prices very reasonable. Too bad they do not have a real eating area, not a restaurant, but a place where you can sit, use utensils, and enjoy.

The freshest seafood on the island and the only folk to carry grey sole and flounder. Charming,…read morehonest people who know their fish

Great multi-generational service and quality! Old-fashioned hospitality and very cleanread more

Killer lobster roll, best I've had on Nantucket. Nice staff too, highly recommend!…read more Also their merch is good!

Wow!! This may be the best lobster roll we had on our entire trip to Boston, the Cape and…read more Nantucket! Simply delicious and worth every penny!! They have a beautiful garden area with picnic tables to sit and eat your lobster rolls. We also did the homemade Guacamole and wow that was delicious too! I can't say enough good things to say about the lobster roll and guac from 167. They do have a market on property too for fresh fish, beer/wine and some other small goods. We actually got dropped off at Cisco brewing and walked over here just for that lobster roll. YUM!

Holy yum. Breakfast bagels were amazing. The bagel itself was dense in a good way. Perfectly crisp…read moreand chewy. Not too hard. I got Asiago cheese bagel (sausage egg and cheese). The white cheese they used (idk which) was so yummy and added perfect flavor to the bagel sandwich. Most days I'd probably only be able to eat half but I was so hungry today so the full sandwich was good. They serve Starbucks and that was perfectly made as well (I got hot white mocha). There was an awkward situation where one staff member tried to hand us our bagel order then the other staff said it's not ready and they proceeded to go back and forth, confusing us as to whether or not we were okay to take the bag. Turns out it was the correct order, but only half of it. One staff member just wanted to put the second half of the order in the same bag and the other didn't understand that - causing confusion for us as well. But good service for us regardless just a little awkward. Cute store and good breakfast options. Would go back!

A must visit food establishment when you are in Nantucket…read more Whether or not you are cooking your own meals, or need prepped foods, NANTUCKET MEAT & FISH MARKET is a must visit. The raw meats & seafood section has a well-curated selection of meats, seafood and cuts. The shelves are stocked with items that will go well with the meat and seafood selections cooked in the manner you'll likely choose. Party items like wine, champagne, charcuterie board elements are available too. Their DELI is a great place to get your LOSTER ROLLS or even CRAB SANDWICHES. They make and serve coffee as well. They have a sizable parking lot which is overflowing with impatient vacationers in certain times of the day. All workers are efficient.

Good shop on Nantucket for fresh seafood. We called around and this shop had the best…read morenon-supermarket price for lobsters. They held 10 aside for us. They were ready during the timeframe promised when we arrived. They even gave me some ice for the coolers I was transporting them home in. We cooked our own, but the shop does offer pre-cooked option.

Our go to source for protein from the sea! We stop by when we need ingredients to assemble our poke…read morebowls. Add this place to your shopping list!

We encountered Yoho and its lovely folks at Cisco Brewers on a Friday, when we went for drinks and…read morelive music. A dozen oysters were $33 and well shucked with just a few shell fragments and LOTS of liquor left in the shell. Oysters (described as "Nantucket Blondes") were meaty, very briny as east coast oysters often are, substantial. They reminded me a lot of Wellfleets. Lemon wedges and horseradish + vinegar sauce were on offer as garnishes. Yoho has SO much good stuff on the menu, including a gorgeous ceviche, that I must come back to try. Reasonable prices for Nantucket. We're going to seek this place out.

amazing food amazing people i literally almost cried when they opened again for the season !!!…read moreperfection always

The Net Result came highly recommended for a tasty lobster roll. It was a little busy when we…read morearrived but service was fast. Inside there is a fresh seafood market, freshly made sushi and a counter to order hot food - including burgers, fish and chips, etc. There is a cooler with drinks, ToGo food, fresh sushi desserts and other goodies. You can get a sautéed lobster roll (hot) or a chilled regular lobster roll (mayo based). I went with the sautéed version along with a cup of clam chowder. Others in my party ordered fried oysters, and fried shrimp. My lobster roll was good but the bread was a bit dry. Not sure if it was coated with butter (if so, it was a little dry but not a deal breaker.) The roll was packed with meat and was filling. The clam chowder was filled with lots of actual clams. Overall my food was good and it's worth a visit. I would recommend a visit.

The best seafood market in the area…read more Worth every penny. Never disappoints. I've lived in Manhattan for years, but grew up on the water on Long Island (with a boat) and love fishing. I've visited the Cape since childhood, and return several times a year. This is the place where, if you want the freshest fish (if you know fish and can cook it at home) is the place to go. It's also the place that if you don't know fish, don't worry; you can't go wrong here, Hatch's Fish Market only carries the freshest seafood. Don't be intimidated. If Hatch's doesn't have it, the fish aren't running - "local" is the operative word here. Lobster, steamers, bluefish pâťe, scallops you can count on, the freshest fish filets... It's where REAL locals, chefs and those who know, go. Need I say more? Did you see the movie "Tony"? (I did, last night). Were you inspired to cook seafood at home tonight? There are many places I could have chosen as my first review on Yelp - but why not start with the BEST...

Terrible service. Kept me waiting for ten minutes while the guy chatted with a friend. So rude. I…read morewas just about to walk out. Won't be going back.

Coffee is great, but the chocolate chip cookies are to die for! Great little shop with many options…read moreand outdoor seating. Can be a little slow when busy but great for a quick bite.

My family and I enjoyed getting a quick breakfast bite here. We liked the creativity and…read moreavailability of seasonal coffee drinks. There were some premade bites for purchase. We liked sitting outside at some of the tables. In fact, they probably could use more tables outside on these summer days.