Our info is so outdated. Pizza Soul is no longer in Sugarbush Village, but in Waitsfield, in the Village Square Shopping Center next to Mehurons (our go to for good bread from local bakeries, local cheese, and generally well-priced, high quality animal proteins), near Tempest Book Shop (amazing, so amazing -- needs its own review soon), Canteen Creemee, and Mad Taco. The Internet tells me it's been in the "new" location since 2019. =) We left the mountain early on a day when ski conditions were pretty bad even on the way-out trails that sometimes have some powder on them even when nothing else does. We're lucky to have a lot of good ski days in our year and didn't feel obligated to ski in such awful conditions. Ordered a large pizza for pickup in 20 minutes around lunch time and were told that the place gets slammed around this time of day, at this time of year. After puttering about Sugarbush Village for a bit we realized we were in the wrong place and drove to the "new" location at almost exactly the 20 minute marker for pickup. The pizza was just as we fondly remembered: a great balance of oregano-forward sauce and not-overly-high-brow mozzarella, and a generous amount of pepperoni / toppings on a slightly more cracker-like crust than NYC-style pizzas. My family of pizza snobs likes, but does not rave about, this place. read more

Pizza Soul - Large pepperoni and peppers. Toppings in good balance, love the oregano heavy sauce - Pizza Near Me - Waitsfield, Vermont

I have physical limitations and Jason has always been very accommodating to me and makes it easy for me to enjoy his food! He has definitely "up'ed" his game! Jason is the man! Thank you and keep it up! read more

This is awesome pizza. End of story. Nice crispy crust and good cheese to sauce ratio with a hefty portion of toppings. No notes. We will certainly be back next time we're skiing in the area! read more

Located in a busy shopping area, good pizza and calzones. It gets busy fast so best to call ahead and leave time for preparation.

been trying to try the place, about 20 minutes away and has been too busy last couple times I tried. I really liked that the guy didn't scoff at my " no cheese" request and he did a great job with the pie, no burning of broccoli Big pie too! Awesome thin crisp crust! I ordered a cheese for the husband, he said it was the best cheese pizza he's had in a dogs age! Nice! This guy seems like he loves his job and well, I'm glad I kept trying! Place is a little piece of heaven, with some classic art on the walls! read more

Never open cant depend on this establishment to be open when they say theyre gonna be. Plus the dough is always to thin and bland. This is not a New York style pizzeria ! For one the pies are not big enough and two the dough is alwYs to thin and bland as a dam communian wafer. New York pizzerias would laugh this place out of existence read more

Hands down one of the best pizzas I've ever had! We got the VT vibes and we substituted the game for mushrooms and it was amazing! Who knew apples, maple syrup and mushrooms would be such a good combo on pizza only downer of this place is that I don't live close by because I would order from there all the time! It's honestly better than pizza in NY and NJ. read more

Solid pizza. New York style. The Symphony in C (a white pizza) is great. Lots of cheeses, including feta and ricotta.

This needs to be a stop on the trip, whether you're skiing, hiking, or just sampling the breweries. The owner is a certified Waitsfield culinary and cultural icon, and he slings the best pie in central Vermont. Try the Symphony in C for a life-affirming exercise in dairy. Try ANYTHING the next morning. Best part of any morning after is a slice of Pizza Soul in the air fryer for 5 minutes. Pizza aside, there's nothing else like the experience of going into this place. Sit down and have a slice and learn from the Maestro. read more

We are vacationing and has just arrived at our rental Sunday afternoon. I was not wanting to go out. Just eat in and relax for the evening. I think it is one of the very few pizza places close. They are lucky to have such a good place. The pizza is a New York style. It was cooked perfect. The tons were just enough. The sauce has a lot of flavor. A really good pizza!! Even good cold the day after. read more

Best pizza in the Valley by far! You can tell the chef takes pride in his product unlike other pizza joints in the Valley.

Loved the pizza, everything I wanted in terms of crustiness, with delicious cheese and pepperoni. Amazing customer service and hospitality really makes this a standout place! read more

I've heard about this place for quite some time and finally had the chance for an order tonight. To be honest we were really shocked at the hype this place receives. The crust is unsalted cardboard and sauce way too sweet to be on pizza. We had one red and one white based pizza. Both basically lacked character and pretty much tasted the same. Won't be back read more

Good NYC style pizza, fresh ingredients and inventive topping options make it stand out. The best part is the sauce- flavorful providing a lasting memory of good za read more

Excellent pizza!! Plain, pepperoni and buffalo chicken pizzas were a success with the family!! Hit the spot, be sure to order early as they get super busy!! Definitely coming again! read more

We were getting together with another family and wanted to do some takeout. We called a few other restaurants around 4pm and they were telling us that it would be 9pm before they could make our food. We took a chance on Pizza Soul and it worked out great. They were able to turn our order around in an acceptable amount of time and the pizza was good, which for the Sugarbush area is great. My only criticism is that the crust was a bit bland, but it's not a deal breaker. We're glad that we have them as another option for takeout. read more

This guy runs out of pizza at 7:00 pm. Don't waste your time. Called several times but he kept saying he might run out. I guess he's not capable of baking more pizza. My family would have spent $100. We ended up getting frozen pizza as nothing else was open or doing take out. read more

It a local pizza stop at the Sugarbush Village. As far as I can tell, it is being run and prepared by the single owner. I know that he has some help some times but hang in there- the pizza is worth the wait. Often when you call to place an order it will be at least 30 mins before the pizza you have ordered is ready. Why is that? Because it is all being made fresh, right then and there, and that's honestly the only way to eat pizza. They have some awesome and unique flavor combinations so make sure to check out the menu. I am personally a fan of the VT vibes. read more

Disagree with comments below about the owner being rude and not understanding customer pizza. He was very accommodating. That said, the pizza was not very good. Crust was not bad but the sauce tasted like it was straight from the can. Win some, you lose some. read more

OUR FAMILY LOVES THE PIZZA!!!! Our getaway isn't the same without Pizza Soul! Seriously recommend it!!! read more

Pizza Soul - Pizza soul is fortunately right at Sugarbush mountain. Best pizza - every time. Thanks Jason! - Pizza Near Me - Waitsfield, Vermont

Best pizza around, owner has some quirks but once you get to know him he's a good dude, has odd hours but I'll deal with it cause his pizza is on point dough made fresh daily read more

By far the best pizza in the Mad River Valley. True New York style pizza. We've had several of Jason's signature pies and they do not disappoint! His new location in the Mehurons Plaza is super convenient. Our favorite is the One Drop with Chicken. read more

Incredible pizza ..not sure if it's the sauce or the love Jason puts in it. Fed the whole family for $20. If ur visiting don't miss this culinary genius at work!!! read more

I am a big time pizza snob and this place is simply fantastic. On busy nights I can imagine this dude gets overwhelmed and it's hard to give accurate estimates on pick up time - he only has one oven, so give him a break! Amazing pizza, chill guy. read more

This is the BEST pizza in the Valley! Try the VT Vibes and the One Drop, you won't be disappointed. Make sure that you order in advance during ski season. They are busy! read more

Pizza Soul makes a damn good pizza and the guy was very friendly. We ordered 4 pizzas to be ready 15 minutes before kickoff on Super Bowl Sunday. Our pizzas were ready right on time, and were awesome. Wyatt N is a hater and probably needs a hug himself. Thank you Pizza Soul, you made our Super Bowl party a success. read more

The best pizza in Vermont. Jason is great and remembers you. He has moved from the mountain down into town. He has help now and they are just as friendly. I cannot recommend them enough. Well worth any wait time you might have. read more

First of all the guy that works there is just amazing. He makes pizzas buy him self hand crafted to perfection. Second of all depending on when you order your pizza it is pretty fast. Lastly it's the best pizza I have had ever the crust is amazing!! read more

This place is great!!! Pizza is so yum, great service too!!! Don't forget to check out the variety of maple syrups... Amazing experience!

Delicious Pizza! Love the sauce and cheese. Try the pizza with apples, maple ham, cheddar and maple syrup... sounds weird but it's super good.. kind of like a monte cristo almost :D read more

Great thin crust pizza! Good mushrooms. Mostly for takeout, but they have two tables.

The pizza took a little longer than normal, but it is well worth the wait. One of the best pies I've ever had. Also had a great conversation with the guy running the place. Highly recommended. read more

Really didn't think I'd find such a great pizza place on the side of a mountain in Vermont, but the owner here puts his heart and "soul" into the pies. The output it a huge 18" thin crust that has great proportions of crust to cheese to sauce (which is quite good). Now in his third year, it's a perennial favorite of mine. The only thing this place needs is more hired help so the poor guy has a moment to breathe. read more

Is this place ever open? Seriously? We've lived in Warren for over a year and the 6 or so times we've attempted to call no one picks up. Yelp says they're open. No answering machine with hours (easy enough and would be helpful). Why does every business around here have such wackadoo times they're actually open!? I miss Bongiorno's. Guess I'll spend a million dollars on Blue Stone pizza that's cold by the time I get home. Sweet. read more

This is probably the best pizza around here. The guy who makes the pizza is nice.

I've tried 3 times. Owner is a real jerk. Sure, the pizza is great, but service is horrific. The owner is rude and has no concept of customer service. Shocked he would get more than one star. read more

Wanted some pizza and found this little place and thought I'd try it out with my dad. We ordered the 'mo-stax' meat lovers pizza ($21). For $7 more than the cheese pizza we expected there to be loads of meat on it, however there was scarcely three things of any meat per slice. The pizza itself wasn't the best pizza I have ever had but when you are hungry it can get the job done. I wouldn't recommend this place unless you really want pizza and don't feel like picking up a frozen one to cook yourself. Overall I probably will not order from here again, the pizza we got was not even close to be worth the cost. read more

We got two pies, the Symphony in C (amazing flavor) and a half cheese/half pepperoni. The crust was really perfect - just the right thickness and crispiness. The toppings and sauce were also excellent. I would highly recommend and think we've found a new pizza place when we visit. FYI - they have a few tables in the front where you can watch the owner make each pie. Entertaining for kids! read more

Good pizza but owner could do a better job of estimating how long it takes to make a pizza. Like for instance tonight when we placed an order and were told it would be 90 minutes. When we finally walked over to pick it up, we were told it would take an additional 20-25 minutes because he hadn't even started our pizza yet. No thanks! read more