I like to highlight many local restaurants in Milwaukee... especially those that are family-owned "Ma &Pa" type. But this also includes those locally owned and created restaurants that "appear" to be a part of a "chain". Well, Pizza Shuttle was born in Milwaukee in 1985 and owned by their local founders. They have created a restaurant that can meet every taste bud in the world. Give them a look and continue your support of locally owned and developed restaurants. https://www.pizzashuttle.com/. read more

I haven't been to PS in a long time. I get their emails all of the time but just don't go there for whatever reason. I received a survey email the other day which said I'd get a free medium 2-topping pizza if I did it. Sweet! Free pizza can't be a bad thing. I ordered online and showed up about 30 minutes later. The pizza wasn't ready yet but I only waited about 5 minutes (Kinda busy for a Sunday night). Anyhow, the pizza was fine but I'm disappointed because none of the free add ons I requested were there which you can see from my pics. Lack of attention to detail I guess but no basil, parm cheese, oregano or garlic butter crust is a lot of things to miss. Even if it is a free pizza at 7pm on a Sunday. read more

See all

So I am not a fan of tomato or onion on pizza but this has changed my way of thinking. As long as they're fresh and on the right pizza is perfect. The crust is light airy and has the perfect crunch. I will be back to this staple again soon. read more

Pizza Shuttle - BBQ chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

we've been waiting for our pizza for half an hour. We ordered two 12" sausage and pep pizzas, one with no sauce. multiple people who ordered after us got their pizza before us. Their whole setup is very messy, toppings strune about, the whole place is a mess. Pizza is ok. read more

We ordered this pizza to go after a late basketball game tonight and it was pretty good. We ordered the thin crust. They had multiple crust options. The taste reminded me of old school pizza. The menu had many other options as well. read more

See all

I called and ordered a medium pepperoni and a large BBQ chicken pizza. I never asked for the speciality whatever they have as I've never even been to this place. I simply said I just want a BBQ chicken pizza. Apparently I should not have been so vague. Pizza showed up in the 45 mins they stated. Ran to my hotel room where my friends where waiting and opened the pizza and I was like whoa what is that. Note I do not do well with spicy food. So to my surprise the entire pizza was covered in jalapeños! Also note it was 3am. I immediately called the place and was told they could make another pizza but I seriously wasn't going to make it to 4am waiting. I asked if they could do a partial refund for the confusion and they said no. He so kindly (not really) let me know that obviously my normal BBQ chicken is different then their normal here in MKE and that it was also their most popular (like I'm an idiot). Well I have traveled to almost every state and I've never had a BBQ chicken pizza that looks like this. So just note that if you order a BBQ chicken pizza it will be covered in jalapeño and cheddar cheese and you can try to pick the jalapeño off but the entire pizza is still spicy and it ruined the pizza and made the whole thing taste funky. Oops almost forgot about the pepperoni pizza... it was a pepperoni pizza haha nothing added thank goodness and was good. read more

Pizza Shuttle - BBQ chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

First time pizza shuttle customers. Menu looked great and ordering online was simple and quick. Estimated time was 45-50 minutes. At 65 minutes we called to check on the status as we were still waiting. Employee was pleasant and told us they were just waiting on the driver. We waited an additional 45 minutes before our pizza was finally delivered. Food was very cold by now and had to be heated back up. The food itself was good once heated. read more

Great food for pizza night with family or food for game day. The service and ambiance at the restaurant is A1 and the delivery Service is great as well. read more

Order you pizza and half hour later your pizza is called after you eat your fries/ wings are cold / No since on everything at once.... Well you can drink as many soda as you can wait ....... read more

WORST. EXPERIENCE. EVER. Went there for the BIER SPECIAL and got the slice, breadsticks, and beer. Got the pizza and beer right away. After waiting 30 minutes went up to counter really upset. They said it would be another 5 minutes. Dumped what was left of beer and left. So mad. Worst was that you would have thought the cashier would have known I was upset and tried to say something to calm me down. Felt like they just could care less. Been going there since the late '80's when they were on the other side of the street. I'm done with them. read more

Pizza Shuttle employees are amazing. I used the wrong date for an event and had to order pizza and beverages for 80+ people and Pizza Shuttle came through for me! Pizza was great, delivery was awesome - special shout out to Angie and Brian for turning what could have been a really bad day to a success. read more

Pizza shuttle has recently changed their wings they are not as good as the previous ones. The individual pizza slices were over cooked. I'm a bit disappointed in the quality lately. read more

Thank you Mark from Pizza Shuttle for taking care of my problem professionally and promptly.

We were looking for something "different" than just a typical Pizza or Chinese place. The first issue I found really annoying was the website. The menu page is half covered by their banner. It makes it REALLY hard to see what you're scrolling through. I took a deep breath and continued anyway. The sandwiches sounded good so we ordered two. Being a little homesick I ordered the "Chicago Italian Beef." Actually, we both did. How do I begin? It was WHIMPY. Barely any beef and although the description says: "We buy from an Italian guy in Chicago" No restaurant serving Chicago style Italian beef would EVER be so SKIMPY in their portions. Plus...um, if you're going to claim it's a Chicago Italian Beef, then here are some lessons: 1) Chicago ALWAYS overloads the beef. 2) It's ALWAYS served on one of two rolls - either Turano Italian French Rolls or Rosen's French rolls. No exceptions! 3) If you're going to offer this sandwich and call it a "Chicago" Italian beef, know that there are ALWAYS three levels of wetness. Dry, wet and dipped! And we DO NOT call it "Au Jus" EVER! Not some dinky cup of dirty water! AND they were cold!? WTH? These were just sad, left us hungry AND broke! $11 for one - I can't even call it a "sandwich" unless you're talking school lunch sandwich. And add on the delivery fees, tip and taxes. Two "Sandwiches" cost us over $30 Really disappointing. Never gonna bother again. read more

The pizza is good but the dine in service is bad. When I arrived to pick up a pizza, there was no organization/professionalism with the staff. I got skipped maybe 3 times by what appeared to be cracked out individuals loitering in the lobby. And it took for ever for them to bring out an already done and getting cold pizza. If you're looking for good pizza and nightmare experience picking it up. Pizza shuttle is your place! read more

Most horrific dining experience I have had in ages - Staff very nice and friendly but food is absolutely wretchid my friends burger is pictured read more

See all

Great food, could use a little more garlic and parm. bring back the mini corn dogs. This was the only place in town that I know serves them /: read more

Poor service and the last few times my teenage son ordered for delivery when i wasn't home he was harassed by the delivery drivers for a tip with one of them wedging themselves in the door so he couldn't close it we will never order from them again delivery drivers do not wear masks read more

This place is delicious! It is very family friendly... there were a few families like ours here on a recent Friday which was nice to see! We have been making quite the tour of pizza places recently and we LOVED this pizza. Their pizza is large, filling, and well-priced especially if you go M-W which is when the pizzas are a total steal. Anyway, the pizza was a hit with my husband, my kids, and myself. Here, you order at the counter and wait for them to call your number. It is super casual with paper plates and plastic forks/knives that you grab yourself. They don't give out cups for water, but they sell bottles of water for less than 50 cents! No too bad! They have a nice beer list. If you are looking for good pizza in MKE and want an unassuming, casual spot, come here! They also have a good variety of ice cream for sale, much of it is very low-priced too. Enjoy! read more

Pizza Shuttle - Casual, family-friendly spot. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Overprice, too expensive, too many doughy items aka too bready . 10-12 dollars for personal size/small pizza too expensive , large pizza for 25 dollars , never again don't deliver to area where i live no thanks read more

Awesome food! We ordered from door dash and it was amazing. We are from out of town so this was our first timing eating at pizza shuttle. The chicken Caesar salad was amazing. Their sausage and pepperoni pizza and breadsticks were mouthwatering. Next time we come to MKE we will definitely order pizza from here. read more

Crazy good pizza! This place was packed on a Friday night, but I ordered ahead for take out. The Detroit style was super yummy! We also tried the Mac and Cheese Pizza. I was skeptical that it would be tasty after having the famous Mac and Cheese Pizza in Madison but we ordered anyway, because our 6 yr old is obsessed with Mac and cheese. While not something I would order every week, this one was actually delicious and not greasy and gross. Definitely worth trying. read more

Definitely very good pizza. I usually get the deluxe and it's never failed me. The other menu items are pretty good to.

When I lived/worked on Milwaukee's East Side this is the "go to" place for pizza and wings or whatever else you want to eat. This is definitely an awesome hangout spot. During my travels, I've NEVER found a place like this. I really miss the Pizza Shuttle. It will always be A hometown favorite of mine whenever I come to visit. The food is always good. I've NEVER had a bad experience here. read more

See all

What a awesome little pizza shop!! They had ice cream too for which I reluctantly did not indulge in. You order when you come in. You can see you pizza and order by the slice. They also have wings , like big wings that were tasty!! This was great for my kids they only needed their one big slice of cheese pizza!! Now the pizza is thick crust so for thin crust lovers this was not the spot for you. I personally love pizza thick and thin so I give it two thumbs up!! Oh they also had wild cherry Pepsi as a choice at the drink fountain!! Forget water I had to have some!! This is a great place to drag the family for an easy, quick, and affordable meal. Pricing was very reasonable!! read more

zero stars for this place!!! food was horrible, cold and tasteless!! And they messed my order up by not delivering everything. Coming from out of town I expected my experience here to be on point.. this ruined it cause we all were starving!! read more

They told us the wait time would be long, so we we're prepared for the wait. It was also 1:30am which made us extremely happy that someone was still open. The pizza arrived hot and delicious, it tasted absolutely divine . The cinnamon bread sticks were outstanding and definitely my favorite part of that meal, 10 out of 10 recommend. We pizza shuttle!! read more

I ordered a gourmet pizza- sausage amore a few weeks ago- added mushrooms and a 2 litter soda before 6:30pm. My bill totaled over $40.00 for these two items for delivery. I was told it would be 45 minutes to an hour to receive my order. I called an hour later and my order was walking out the door. I did not receive it until thirty minutes after it left the restaurant. It took an hour and a half to get my order. My pizza was cold. I called to let them know. The guy taking the order gave me two choices- to get a new pizza or a credit. I paid $27 PLUS extra to add mushrooms. It would have been around 10:00pm to get a new pizza. I chose the credit. I called today to use my credit- he didn't tell me the credit was only $15. What a rip-off. Ordering from Ian's pizza from now on. read more

Orders are almost always accurate, love their deluxe pizza on thin crust. Family favorite!

I love this spot! The food is yummy and they always have a special! If you dig wings... this is the spot! BBQ is my sauce of choice!! The pizza is good too! This a gem that all the locals No about! read more

Pizza here is one of the bestest! Crust is great, cheese is real, oily pizza which is the best! All food selections are great and decent prize! read more

Had better frozen pizza unfortunately, cheese fry's had no flavor as well as fry's tasted old and shockingly the cheese was cold smh. Mozzarella sticks bland. Safe to say will probably never return. read more

You know when people say "I don't want to think about how much money I've spent at Pizza Shuttle over the years?" Well, when I say that, I reeeeeeally mean "let's not think how much money I've spent at pizza shuttle over the years." I probably could've bought a new SUV. But Pizza Shuttle is deeply engrained in the lore of the east side here...it somehow worms its way into a zillion stories I have from my two decades in Milwaukee. A phone call from around 1994: "Oh wow, when I come up there does pizza hut deliver to the dorms?" "We don't have pizza hut, its pizza shuttle up here." "Is it any good?" "No it's kind of gross but they deliver late." Many 20-something romantic dramas were solved with a girlfriend over an order of their breadsticks during a too long visit to their weird little dining room. Longtime friendships were made at 2:45 am by ordering wings and mozzarella sticks from "the shuttle". The place serves a little bit of everything (menu is the size of a small newspaper) from pizzas with cashews as toppings, to a lebanese chicken sandwich to funnel cakes. Luckily I've whittled my orders down over the years and have sampled way too much of the menu so you don't have to (unless you want to -- and i can't judge you based on what I've ingested from here over the years) The Good: Sicilian pizza (any pizza really, esp. if you like it doughy) Cheeseburgers Wings (really surprisingly good and many flavors) Chicken strips with mashed potatoes and gravy Ice cream Their brownie sundae Mozzarella sticks The Gross/"I can't believe I waited for delivery of that": Sub sandwiches (dry and gross) Fish fry Garlic bread Bosco sticks (dry and gross -- possibly a theme here) Veggie burger (dry) Any pasta dish (too salty) You're hungry, forget to order and its past 4 am on a Friday night? Nap for a few hours... they'll start delivery again by 10 am on a Saturday. These days I usually only eat their slices because a.) They're very filling, cheap (.99 to $2), and quick, and b.) because the universe is playing some sort of crazy jedi mind trick on me and planting my 24 hour gym a few steps away from it. Get a slice...but if you end up ordering some crazy delivery of way more than you can eat at 3 am? It's a'right...I can't judge. read more

Ah, Pizza Shuttle. You were my bestest friend in college - we'd hang out after long, drunken nights at the Avalanche and watch the room spin together. You delivered to the MU campus and your proliferation of coupons meant that even a broke-ass college student could afford to order regularly. Like many good friendships, sometimes you grow apart. You know, one of you gets a job, gets married and pretty much stops partying non-stop and the other person just keeps on keepin' on? Inevitably, there comes a day when the grown-up misses that old friend and goes back to the well. That day came for me this past Sunday Funday after watching volleyball. A small group of us headed in to Pizza Shuttle to assuage the pain of losing (and to soak up some of the beer). Slices for less than $2? Sounds good. Beer on tap? Okay! Cheese sticks? Don't mind if I do! Nothing was really great...but it certainly wasn't bad either. I think it might have been better if we had ordered a fresh pizza vs. getting some of the premade slices but whatever - it was super bread-y and did the job it was supposed to do. Pizza Shuttle...I keep getting older and it stays the same age. Basically, it's alright, alright, alright. read more

I feel the same as Rachel F. - how have I not reviewed Pizza Shuttle yet? Dang, I have been here a lot, although less often in more recent years because I'm partial to Classic Slice and Transfer for my pizza needs. Pizza Shuttle gets the job done, though. We go way back - ordering delivery when I lived on my lonesome and even having a first date here long before the renovations. I remember they used to have those plastic, red and white checkered table cloths and the high schoolers kept playing Sublime songs on the jukebox over and over. Is that eccentric guy still there playing doorman and giving a friendly word or compliment to everyone who came in? Pizza Shuttle has a lot more than pizza and everything is decent. The staff are always super friendly. It seems like they always find some sort of deal to offer, too. And it's not just them trying to upsell, like a lot of places might. They are legitimately offering to save me dollars. read more

GREASE. These pizzas are so greasy which is a shame because I enjoyed everything else about the pizza: toppings, crust, and sauce. I guess you can buy the pizza by the slice pretty cheap so I shouldn't be so "picky." I would definitely try this place again but it might have to be after a night out. read more

This is a 4 star place if you've smoked enough marijuana but otherwise there are better choices for pizza in Milwaukee, like right across the street. Dining in on the weekend would be okay if you like being surrounded by loud drunken idiocy, and ordering delivery isn't bad if you're not going to insist on getting exactly what you ordered around half an hour after the promised time. The pizza itself? I'd be very surprised if you could find someone who isn't currently a college student or was a college student last time they experienced Pizza Shuttle endorsing the quality of the Pizza Shuttle pizza. read more

I was not impressed with the pizza, but I loved and highly recommend the broasted chicken! It was so juicy, even after I zapped it in the microwave the next day for leftovers. Their mashed and gravy sides were really delicious - which is why I had leftover chicken! It was a great price and I appreciate their late hours since I work late. As a new Milwaukeean, I love that you love fried chicken as much as I do! read more

Unreliable. Cancels orders. Not in any way a reliable place to order a late night pizza. Don't waste your time. They couldn't manGe a 10:30 pm order. read more

I can't believe the 3 star average this place gets! I had Pizza Shuttle twice in two days while in Milwaukee, and I do eat a LOT of pizza. So when I say that Pizza Shuttle is pretty damn good, it must be true. This review is only for dine-in and carry-out. The menu is very deep, they have specials that you can look up online for every day of the week. Had the thin crust Works, wife had thin crust spinach artichoke and tomato, both were personal sized. I couldn't believe the amount of topping a pizza this thin could hold...perfectly cooked to a crisp, good cheese, it was so good we had to have it twice l over the weekend. For now, I'll consider Pizza Shuttle my king of pizza in MKE, until another pizza prince seizes the throne. Bonus, they deliver until 4am on the weekends. Milwaukee is pretty serious about eating late. read more

Pizza Shuttle - The Best Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin