Great spot! We were in town for a softball tournament and my daughter and i decided to stop in and try this spot out. We ordered fried calamari for appetizer and it was seriously on point and tasted amazing. We also ordered a meat lovers pizza, it came fresh out the oven and was delicious. They even had quite a few selections of wine. If i am ever in the Willis area again this will definitely be my go to spot. Oh and last but not least, service was exceptional! read more

Pizza Shack- Willis - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willis, Texas

I love Pizza Shack pizza and always have really great service. There is so much to be said about what a great place this is. However, I tried the Chicken Parmigiana for the first time, and it was so overly salty that my lips started to burn. I don't know what's in the recipe, but I really think the salt should be reduced. read more

Yum! Not that I expected anything bad, but this place was much better than I expected! My wife and I were instantly loyal customers after our first visit and now look for excuses to come back as often as we can :) read more

Amazing place to eat 10/10 everything all the way down to the service the place was packed when I ate there and still had really fast refills definitely recommend going here read more

Everyone has their particular preferences and this place nailed my manicotti desires ( also the ravioli). We have returned twice and now we are regulars when we head out to Lake Livingston. I don't understand why It does not show up when I search Yelp restaurants in Willis! read more

This is our favorite place to eat in Willis. Even if you don't live close, it is worth the drive. Great pizza!

This is a great place to eat. We order off the regular menu. We are always so very pleased with service and excellent food quality. My favorite is spinach and garlic with no sauce. read more

I think with Covid they are doing great. In fact it was really good. I ordered a wedge salad and it came out so nice it looked like it came from a 5 star upscale restaurant. In addition to the salad I also got a pepperoni and chicken pizza and it was really good as well. This location is still great hopefully one day their other location will more closely mirror the quality and service the have here. read more

Would give it a 1.8 first time back in over ten years and it has gone to shit. Had the gumbo and it was clearly not fresh. Had the spaghetti with meat sauce and it had no kick to it all. Have order numerous pizzas with lots of topping and it is always wet. I won't be coming back and I wouldn't recommend this to anyone. Do yourself a favor an just get a fast food pizza if you live in Willis. If you want Italian food go to the Oliver Garden in Conroe. Only thing that was half-way decent was the dinner salad. read more

Since a two-star rating is "Could've been better," I selected this one. It is very difficult for me to give our beloved Pizza Shack anything less than a five-star rating. We have been regular customers for the last seven years. I offer this review as constructive criticism in hopes that Michael S. will adjust and improve. My only complaint in the last seven years is the current size of the "Large" Greek Salad. Used to be that you may see the size of the salad fluctuate a little depending upon who made the salad on any particular day, but they were always what I would consider a generous portion size and something one could make a meal out of, especially if you added the chicken. However, the last four or five times I've ordered the Large Greek Salad, the lettuce has not even passed the halfway mark on the salad bowl. I believe the current price is $9 dollars and with the current portion size, this is not a good value. I have decided to pass on the Greek Salad for the time being but wanted to leave this review in hopes of a correction in the kitchen. Everything thing else at Pizza Shack is great and all the staff are wonderful. I've never ordered the Small Greek Salad but can only imagine how disappointing that must be. This isn't something that will stop me from eating at Pizza Shack, I just won't order the Greek Salad. read more

I love this restaurant, and I think the name is misleading. It is a nice full service restaurant, with freshly made genuine Italian food. Nothing fancy, except for the cupcakes, but that's another story! The service has always been gracious. I think you can tell if a restaurant is a good place to work by the attitudes of the waitstaff, and I suspect Pizza Shack is a happy place to work. The cupcakes!! Don't bother saving room for dessert; just order some of the most interesting and delicious cupcakes, ever, to go. You won't regret the calories! read more

Impeccably the best pizza I have ever tasted EVER, between the shack special pizza and the meat lovers pizza...we were grinning from ear to ear when those beauties came out to our table!!! Never ceases to amaze me when we order a new delicious item such as today with the "Special Garlic Bread" which was light and crisp with the perfect amount of cheesy goodness with an added perfect side sauce on the side for dipping!!!! Scrumptious!!! Thank you for the incredible awesome food Pizza Shack! Now, we could not leave dessert out...of course not...but we were taking it home the absolute best cupcakes to share with friends and family- for a party we are having at our home later this afternoon! Aren't they lovely!! Last but certainly not least we were blessed to get "Tate" as our server. His customer service is over the top. From the moment we sat down to when we left he took care of everything needed including clearing our table as we completed appetizers and picking up the empty sugar packets, refilling tea to boxing up left overs and bringing us tea to go. Thank you so much for great service Tate! We will be back!!! read more

I called them on the road to order a pizza on my way home. It took a bit of time to explain what I wanted on my supreme thin crust pizza. So the person I talked to on the phone was not good at taking instructions. I wanted to substitute Italian sausage for the pepperoni. I had to repeat it several times because she couldn't understand what I wanted. When she repeated my order, she kept getting it wrong on the read-back. Then I realized she got the order right, but just read it back incorrectly repeatedly. So, when I got there, it turned out they got it right. It was so good; highly recommend. read more

As many years as we've been customers of Pizza Shack, I've never written a review. But after seeing a couple of negative comments I feel compelled to say that we order here regularly (maybe too often!)! Not one bad meal in 25-plus years. When we have out-of-town guests this is where they want to eat. And Pizza Shack was a place we felt totally safe this past year because we know the owners' dedication to the community. Their specialties and pizza are great quality and always delicious. The desserts are TOO good. A wide variety of offerings for kids, as well. And the waiters have been good-natured when we've had lots of kids in there too. As a Willis native I particularly appreciate Pizza Shack's contributions to our schools, churches, community. If you haven't tried Pizza Shack, please plan on it soon. Jan Parker Dial read more

Every time we pass through the area we always call ahead a grab a pizza or two. Great crust makes awesome pizza & nice people make a great experience. They've been doing curbside since COVID and they've been executing very well. See you next time read more

We ordered 3 different pasta dishes and pizza. Everything was delicious. Great tiramisu.

Not a good value. Very expensive. Service was ok as was the salad bar, but for the price I expected much nicer atmosphere and better food.

Wow! This was our first time here! The zucchini is amazing- hand cut strips lightly battered just amazing! We also tried the calamari- why i give them 5 stars is it just didn't taste right- they took it back and the manager came over to chat - they were so nice- I rarely say anything- and told them we are fine- the food is amazing and we are defintely fans! We had the seafood bake- shrimp crab meat and crawfish in it- sauce was perfect with tasty baked cheeses too! The servings are pretty big and filling so we split the dish- and we defintely did not leave hungry! We even saw a family of little kids come in- you can watch them hand toss pizza dough and one of the staff brought all the kiddos a plate of pizza dough to play with and make their own little pizzas ;) Highly recommend this place a the food- the friendliness and the atmosphere are all fabulous!! read more

They used to be pretty good but last Monday 7-27-2021 was terrible. It was extremely loud with screaming kids (not the restaurants fault) and pizzas that were well below Caesar"s quality so salty I didn't bother to take it home. Hardly any toppings on the Hawaiian and the Pizza Shack pizzas and the dough was mushy. Only thing that was good was the fried mushrooms. It is well worth the extra drive to the Montgomery pizza shack. read more

Terrible service! They seat you but no server appears. When you flag one down they try to ignore you. Flies landing on tables. Management prefers to talk to friends about racing rather than about his customers. I don't believe he even apologized. Won't be back! Very disappointed been coming here since 2012. read more

We have picked up pizza a couple of times since my first review-still awesome! Last night we were able to dine in. It was excellent! I hope to be able to try other items besides pizza but it's going to be difficult because we love their pizza. read more

Usually a home run for dinner, but this time only about a "single" base hit. Wedge salads have bacon bits, mine did not. Drink went empty for over 7+ min (forever in restaurant time), and they were in the back end of the dinner rush 8 pm; main entree served without side of bread (had to ask like 5 min after getting entree). Owner is attractive. She walked into the dining room as I was leaving and greeted read more

Pizza Shack- Willis - Pizza Near Me - Willis, Texas

See all

Do not, I repeat DO NOT order a veggie pizza!!!! Twice I had soggy pizza where toppings slides right off the dough including pizza sauce and toppings. As far as what i have eaten here the seafood bake is quite amazing. So they earn an extra star. read more

Pizza Shack- Willis - Pizza Near Me - Willis, Texas

See all

I have been coming here for ad long as I can remember. The best pizza ever , and the people are so nice . I've never had a bad experience. It's better than Pizza Hut or another or branch in Willis . I highly recommend going here . read more

Wife and I stopped in for lunch, we both had the buffet. The pizza was good but the selection was always poor due to only 4 slots on the buffet, twice we found two of the same pizza out. I was very surprised there was no pasta on the buffet. We both ordered a dessert and shared with each other. The Italian cream cake was very dry and just not good. The cannoli should have been served with a small hammer to break it....it was soooo dense.and the filling was too. We enjoyed the fried pizza bread covered with cinnamon and powdered sugar on the buffet more than our $8 desserts. All the good reviews make me was to try other things here but I do not recommend the buffet or the desserts. read more

DELICIOUS!!!! we were staying at Lake Conroe and really didn't want to go "out" and eat. Unfortunately they didn't deliver to the lake. My husband decided to go pick it up. I ordered online and my husband left to pick it up. Upon arrival, he was greeted instantly and our food was out before the scheduled time. We had a wedge salad, Caesar salad, pasta sampler, cheese bread, and bread pudding. First of all, the portions are huge!!! The wedge salad was so yummy with homemade bleu cheese dressing. My husband scarfed his Caesar salad and said the dressing tasted homemade as well. My wedge salad was so big that I ended up eating a few bites of pasta. The manicotti was to die for and the homemade marinara is amazing. The lasagna was delish. And the Alfredo was super good. You know how many times you get that "tomato sauce heartburn"? Not with this. It's so fresh, we didn't have an issue with heartburn at all (and it was late when we ate). So now for the bread pudding!!! I love Louisiana style bread pudding. This one is similar, and oh so yummy! I certainly recommend this place. Staff is super friendly and the food is unbelievable. Go for it!! read more

Soggy pizza crust, other menu items ok, typical fast order cook sauce from a can type restaurant. Montgomery location is much cleaner and better. read more

This is our favorite Willis area restaurant going on 4 1/2 years. They are always consistent, the food rarely disappoints. We have eaten there dozens and dozens of times always the same. We are doing curbside these days and the food is still just as good. It's rare that a local place has their act together to this degree. Thanks for all the great meals, y'all. read more

This place is a gem. My wife and her friends used to drive from Huntsville on the weekends during college just to eat here. Sandwich's and pizza are all great and cool atmosphere too. Best place in town (Willis). Extra parking across the side street. Nice wait staff. Their muffuletta is my shit. read more

Great pizza and friendly staff. Place is always clean and they have a cool window for the kids to watch the pizza being made.

I love their garlic & spinach pizze and their bread pudding. All of their. pizzas are great but other items taste like pre-prepared, frozen items. When they tore down the old old building (yes two olds) and built the new one (quite a few years ago) I think they tried to upgrade their menu from pizzas and burger to "fancy" items. Sorry but my spaghetti and lasagna are about 100 times better. You really can't go wrong with their pizzas and I love that they have personal size pizzas read more

Pizza Shack in Willis is my family's favorite pizza place. They never disappoint! All around great place, prices and service! In addition to the be pizza be great, they have awesome cupcakes too! read more

OVERHYPED, OVERPRICED and OVERCROWDED. I have had much much much better pizza and pasta. This place is getting three stars because Pizza chains (Dominos, Pizza Hut and Papa Johns) all deserve two stars. Pizza was watery, pasta was undercooked and prices were way too high especially when breadsticks aren't free. read more

I have eaten here several times but this time ot was a aweful experience we were greeted by a waitress named Hailey from what i was told. She took our order then brought our food out and that was the last time she came to our table but the table beside us she waited on hand and foot she was refilling their drinks over and over again but not once asking us if we needed anything finally after waiting 15 min to see if she would ever come back i flagged another waiteress and asked her for our waitresses name she told me Haiely. And asked 8f she could refill them for us and i told her no i wanted to speak to the manager so she went and got the manager the manager was very polite and tried to acomadate us the best she could but by this time i was very aggrevated and just wanted to pay and leave as a manager myself i feel this was very unperfessional Hailey and it also was the first time i was very disapppinted i the food it was uneatable literly i left 3/4 of my food on the plate . Someone needs to re- train this young lady read more

We absolutely love this place. Best Pizza around Lake Conroe and surrounding areas. My wife and I usually "add" a few ingredients and may subtract a few others to make the pizza "our own". The waitstaff have always been accommodating and helpful. Thanks Pizza Shack. read more

I used to like this place. I was very disappointed tonight. I ordered Rigazzi which I get often. But they brought me Manicotti tonight. I was very hungry so I ate a little thinking the cook has just messed up. I looked up the menu on the Internet and figured it out. Watch you orders! Rigazzi Fettuccini alfredo with ham, mushrooms & peas topped with provolone then baked to perfection $7.49 Manicotti Baked pasta tubes stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan $10.99 read more

The owner was very unprofessional, rude, and tuned down a table of 15 and 10 before their official closing time. He could have made good tips for his waiters but they will miss out. There's a baseball tournament in town, as an owner you should be more flexible and take in customers if you're not officially closed. read more

DELICIOUS!!! DELICIOUS!!! DELICIOUS!! The pizza is great. But can we talk about the cupcakes... so yummy. The menu has a huge variety of stuff and the service is also great. For sure going back read more

Love this place! Great service and good food. The Wednesday buffet is very good and very popular! We can see why!

Finally got a pizza with enough tomato sauce on it that you could taste it. Awesome! Wife and I ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, basil, and onions. A little stingy with the basil but otherwise a great pizza. We also had the Shrimp Poppers for an appetizer. Wow. Perfectly cooked and the ingredients compliment each other well. Resist dipping them in the Ranch Dressing if you can. It's not needed in my opinion and hides the crunch. Great job Pizza Shack. Highly recommended. read more

See all