Cancel

Open app

Search

Pizza Primo

3.9 (48 reviews)
InexpensivePizza
Closed 10:30 am - 10:30 pm

Order Pizza Primo Takeout or Delivery

Pizza Primo Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pizza Primo

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

a pizza box with a tomato on it
Kyle P.

Did enjoy the large one topping pizza pepperoni for $12.50 on Monday and Tuesday nights Pizza Primo Worthington. I never had Pizza Primo Worthington until tonight. It was delicious and will get it again. It was not greasy and that was a great thing. Was very happy with my order and will go back to Pizza Primo Worthington soon.

The box!
Tina G.

For starters, the guys who run this store located at the corner of a small strip mall near 161 and North High Street are so friendly and welcoming. We ordered a large supreme and it was very tasty. Pizza Primo has mastered the signature cracker crust we Columbus natives grew up with and love so well. The sweet, slightly spicy sauce, small cut vegetable toppings (could have added more green peppers and onions :-)) with edge-to-edge placement make eating their square cut pieces especially enjoyable for children. They also offer a thick crust pizza as well, which looks great.

Pizza ok Salads awful Had 2 times Same results $$$$ Do not recommend This one in Worthington

Mark M.

Picked up their large Pepperoni and I just wasn't feeling it. Lots of pepperoni but it didn't have much taste. The sauce was also blah and the crust was just too thin and crunchy--it was like eating cardboard, no thanks. Staff were friendly, that's about the only good thing I can say.

Jen B.

Paid extra for blue cheese and as you can see in photo its slightly sprinkled. Not enough regular cheese and it's just not great. Delivery from yelp on a Sunday at 9 and it took exactly an hour. All food was cold but even if hot it's just not good. Will not order here again.

Big Menu!
Emily R.

This place rocks! Stopped by on Tuesday and got their $9.50 Large pizza special. Pizza was awesome, thin crust, great sauce! Staff was super friendly, can't wait to try the Italian Sub. A definite must try local pizza shop.

Pepperoni, mushroom and jalapeño.  Always good.
Geoff H.

Love Pizza Primo. Tried something different. Pep, mushroom and jalapeño. Have to keep trying new things.

$26 for this.

See all

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Xen N.
48
1
0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Uugghh!!!! We ordered it and DRY!!! Italian sub. No veggies!!!!! The bread was crisp but DRY!!!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Pizza Primo

I am a New Yorker and I have not found one good pizza place in Ohio. I have heard it's the water here that makes the taste so different. Does anyone know of a real good pizza place?

That water thing is kind of a myth. Google it for fun reading. Try Brooklyn pizza in Powell. Pretty authentic. I'm from NYC so I can vouch. Then again I have to say I prefer midwestern style now. Better toppings, more flavor, crispy.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Review Highlights - Pizza Primo

We loved the thin crust and melted flavors on the supreme pizza.

$14.95 Supreme Pizza

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 16,380 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH

3.9(339 reviews)
1.1 mi
$$

I schedule places for a group of us women over 50 to meet for lunch on a monthly basis. A variety…read moreof restaurant options in different areas of CBus was provided to me. I picked Pies & Pints from that list this month. I'll share the good things first. I loved that they took a reservation for me as there were 11 of us coming. Granted, once I got there, I realized it probably wasn't necessary as they had a long row of tables against a wall that easily accommodated groups. Regardless, it's nice to tell the group that we have a spot waiting for us. We were seated right away and service was good. They were fine with us having separate checks. I think that's become easier with the POS technology now, but it's still nice to not get the side eye when you ask for separate checks. The menu is limited - which we all should have been aware of prior to arrival. I sent the link out to the restaurant menu with my monthly invitation so women know what they are signing up for. My case - I only go for the fellowship and just get a diet soda. I intermittent fast and don't eat until after 2 PM daily. Regardless, some of the women must not have paid attention to the menu - even when ordering. At least one was shocked when she got a pizza. It had spinach and other vegetable fixings so when she ordered she was clueless. The food looked excellent. Not traditional pizzas but many white flatbread style pizzas. Even so, most women picked at their food. Maybe a few got boxes to take home the food. No one complained. No one said a word about the food. If they are like me, they are there for the company - not so much the food. I gave three stars based on a bunch of old ladies non preferring pizza. Objectively, the food looked good but do not go here if you're not a pizza person or you're looking for a traditional red sauced pizza.

Pies & Pints - Worthington…read more Mushroom Garlic Feta: Roasted & fresh garlic, roasted mushrooms, caramelized onions, fresh herbs & olive oil. Black Bean Cheddar: Jalapeños, seasoned black beans, salsa, cilantro & crème fraîche. Rosemary & Roasted Garlic Flatbread: With warm goat cheese & balsamic reduction.

Photos
Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH - Grape Pie - red grapes, gorgonzola, and fresh rosemary

Grape Pie - red grapes, gorgonzola, and fresh rosemary

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH - Spinach Garlic Pie - Spinach, red onions, gorgonzola, fresh garlic & roma tomatoes

Spinach Garlic Pie - Spinach, red onions, gorgonzola, fresh garlic & roma tomatoes

Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH - Chicken Gouda Pie - Marinated grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, red onions with chipotle crema & scallions

See all

Chicken Gouda Pie - Marinated grilled chicken, bacon, smoked gouda, red onions with chipotle crema & scallions

Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville - Sweet Heat Wings  @ColumbusFoodDude

Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville

3.8(11 reviews)
1.9 miClintonville

I had never been to a Brenz Pizza before. The food was premium ingredients. My friend and I shared…read morethe Spicy Citrus salad with Mandarin oranges, new Brenz Bites, along with the Pizzas was the medium Midwest Duo with cupped sliced sausage with Ricotta cheese and banana peppers, and personal Classic Pizza. The pizzas were delicious and very tasty. They do not have fountain drinks because they do more with carryout and delivery. I had a Diet Pepsi and she had a Starry. Also, we share a yummy cookie with red velvet, and different chocolate chips. Vinny and another guy took great care of us. I will be going back to Brenz Pizza soon for the great service and excellent pizzas with fixings.

We went into this joint expecting something more like Mod or Blaze, but it's not that. (Not a…read morecomplaint! We love some counter service! But it's very take out coded.) We ordered a 12 inch pepperoni and a 14 inch heritage honey. I didn't clock that the heritage honey had sausage on it, or I would have left it off. It was fine enough, just didn't add to an already pretty good pizza. The super picky pizza lovin kid enjoyed her pepperoni for sure and we were happy with ours. It's a not thin, not too thick pizza that's cut tavern/square style. I'm a traditional wedge pizza girlie so next time I'm going to ask for that. But still very good pizza with an immaculate number of epic cheese pulls. Very generous and yummy toppings. The service was pretty exceptional for quick service. Someone came around and asked if we wanted our salads first, and we did, so they brought those to us. I really loved the Greek salad--my fave Greek salad at a not-Greek spot--and husband was ok with his Caesar, tho he could live without the bacon. He just prefers a traditional Caesar. Our salad delivery also came with a napkin dispenser and thank goodness because the heritage honey pizza is messy is the best kind of way. The salads came in to go containers with lids, in a convenient style that would make walking around with a salad or taking a salad to a pedicure easy breezy. Our pizzas came to the table in the box (excellent!) and we were provided paper plates, cheese and peppers on request. The music was pop with lots and lots of Taylor Swift and by the time we left it was packed with people looking for takeout. I'm excited to try some other things.

Photos
Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville - Grand Opening at 5063 N. High St.

Grand Opening at 5063 N. High St.

Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville - Chef Salad  @ColumbusFoodDude

Chef Salad @ColumbusFoodDude

Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville

See all

Gallos Pizza - Man, what the hell is this?! Totally weird margherita

Gallos Pizza

4.2(20 reviews)
4.9 mi

Stopped here to get bubble tea felt like I really needed to eat something so I decided to veer away…read morefrom getting bubble tea and chose pizza Maybe not the smartest thing to do at 3 o'clock because pizza was probably out there since 12. I chose the bridge park special, which was a pizza with an olive oil base mozzarella cheese with a basil pesto over it. Grilled chicken and grilled onions. The chicken taste like rubber. I did not eat it after the first piece didn't trust it. It's very hard and chewy. The rest of the pizza had a good flavor. It was served a little too hot, but considering it was 3 o'clock, I was glad it was heated thoroughly. There was a lot of olive oil on it. It was a very greasy piece of pizza you needed an extra napkin. Service was excellent. The man that took my order was pleasant and he even brought my pizza to where I was sitting that was appreciated and a surprise. As far as ambience, there's like patio twinkle lights on the top. It's a big food hall so the seating is shared among all the vendors again I was there at 3 o'clock. There was maybe two other patrons it's not a very popular time. Would it come back? Sure I would just come back closer to 12 when the pizza was guaranteed fresh I feel this might've been sitting for a while. This would've been a four or 4 1/2 star piece of pizza had the chicken, thin tender Instead, I had to go with a three cause it was neither wonderful nor was it awful. It was just good. Again, I would come back... And will. And when I do, I hope I can give it a higher score.

UPDATE: After since I ate (only some) of this, my stomach has been upset for 2 days. I regret…read moreeating any of this weird food. Not food poisoning, just stomach upset. I want to start by saying, normally this is a pretty good spot. Lately, man idk what is going on. I got the strangest margherita pizza I have ever had, and a cheese and pepperoni that was also kind of weird. There is almost no cheese whatsoever on the margherita, and it was dehydrated too, which was also unusual. The cheese and pepperoni one was fine I guess, but there was a solid layer of pepperoni beneath the cheese, which made the texture benefit super wet. Again, all just kind of off. Service is good; not a freestanding location and it's inside the Bridgepark north market. I can't say if I would come back or not? Perhaps if I saw a tastier looking item walk by that was ordered from here. Posting a photo of one of the slices.

Photos
Gallos Pizza
Gallos Pizza - Garlic bread

Garlic bread

Gallos Pizza - Interior

See all

Interior

Pizza Primo - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...