We have been pretty frequent flyers for this place and plan to continue. They've made mistakes, but they always make it right. I love this about them. Tonight, I'm not sure what they did with this pizza but it was incredible!!! Best we've had from them yet. It actually reminded me of the first time we tried this place in 2022 when we first moved here and didn't want to cook in our new house. Flavor was great, crust was tender and fluffy.... Our picky toddler ate almost all of his! Thank you for being here in our community as a healthier option for pizza. We appreciate you. read more

Yes thank you pizza god you have answered my prayers lol. I said this a bunch of times that the pizza here is great but they just needed to drop Pepsi. Well guess what guys they finally did. My pizza was great and a coke and a Diet Coke and I'm in heaven lol. read more

Great pizza and fast service. The crust has really good flavor and everything tastes fresh. Easy takeout and always consistent.

Cute local place with good pizza! Reminds me of the pizza shops I would hang out in as a kid.

Pizza is Truly homemade with fresh Veggies, homemade sauce and crust and the best cheeses. Hand tossed crust. Pepperoni is natural- no preservatives. What a difference in taste! Very knowledgeable young man who owns the Company. Strongly recommend. read more

Picked up some thin crust on a couple occasions lately. I really liked it. Kinda pricey but everything is these days. Bonus points for the drive thru window. Going to try some more things on the menu soon. Website is sort of hit or miss when ordering but can always just call it in so no big deal. read more

Email: large 2 topping pizza $9.99 Me: can't figure out how to apply deal and calls Employee: so patient and walked me through how to order deals on the website and also took my order over the phone Their customer service has won me over. The guy was so patient explaining to me how to order deals through the website as well as taking my order over the phone and setting it for a future time because I wasn't able to make it until 5pm. The pizza was delicious and I love the crust. This is the only pizza my children will eat in Jarrell now lol Even when I entered the establishment I loved the pictures about pizza all over the walls. It was clean and even had tables if you chose to stay and dine in. I will continue to purchase pizza here and support a local business. read more

Pizza Pie Co. - Lobby wall - Pizza Near Me - Jarrell, Texas

See all

We ordered a large pizza for pickup and it was ready within 10 minutes, the pizza was also really good. Way better than the other pizza place around here. read more

Hi! So I got a coupon for a bogo pizza. We got the meat lovers in regular tomato sauce and then the free in pesto. The pest made a huge difference. My partner has a sensitivity to tomato sauce so his pesto hit the spot. We tried the chicken Alfredo today too. It was amazing. So clean and fresh and good. All the pastas there are spot on. Nice hot subs too! Note that there are a lot of younger school kids that work there so they won't always interact but that's totally fine. We love that there is a drive through! The desserts and wings are just okay. The pizza with he Parmesan garlic crust is where it's at although it costs more and the pastas are a win. I know it's all so expensive nowadays but this is the best pizza stop in Jarrell. Try it! read more

Pizza Pie Co. - Delicious chicken Alfredo with penne. Totally worth it! - Pizza Near Me - Jarrell, Texas

See all

If you want a really good nice thick meaty pizza like Chicago old style, this is your place to order. Or if you want a veggie pizza, they have a wide variety as well as build your own menu. I ordered a pepperoni one time and asked for extra cheese and pepperoni, and I could not believe the amount that added. You couldn't see anything but pepperoni melted into the nice fresh cheese. I've never went inside to comment on but their delivery service has always been on time and friendly people. You gotta try their pizza, Last but not least, they do offer pasta dishes, different types of garlic and cheesy breads and a few desserts as well. read more

This was fantastic!! Excited to try their pizza and wings, but today we were craving some hot sandwiches. My wife ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch, and I got the Meatball sub. Both were just delicious, well priced and delivered quickly. read more

I was told the place was pretty good. I order me a medium Hawaiian pie for $18. I don't know what the heck I got but that was not Hawaiian and for $18 I had high hopes man was I disappointed, tasted like salty ass cheese. Definitely not going back. My order was simple I just wanted a Hawaiian pizza. read more

Pizza Pie Co. - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Jarrell, Texas

Only complaint I had was the glitch in their computer system ordering the wrong pizza. But the pizza was still delicious and fresh.

Pretty good but thin. Sauce had a great flavor but for the price I expected a bigger pizza.

I am presently 8 weeks pregnant and I have been struggling to find food that won't make me nauseous. The last 3 days I've been craving cheese pizza but due to having a really sensitive stomach I can't handle any fast food pizza (papa John's, dominoes, Pizza Hut, etc.) without getting sick. My husband knows I'm really picky about pizza due to being Italian myself, having lived in Italy, and in New York, but he swore he thought I'd like Pizza Pie Co.'s pizza. He was right! I can't express how happy I am right now to have something I can eat without feeling sick. For any other picky eaters out there I made my own pizza, added pizza cheese, did regular pan crust, added garlic butter, and regular sauce. I didn't think I'd take well to the cheese lovers one because of the feta. Thank y'all so much for making this picky pregnant woman happy read more

Not even. The minute they opened the box and showed me the pizza, I knew it was going to be bad! Yellow cheese all over the top of the pizza. It looked nasty. When I got it home, we sat down to eat the warm pizza and it was all I expected it to be: gross. I've never had yellow cheese on any pizza, at any time or location. Ever. It was not a very substantial meal either. I was not impressed at all. And we won't be back. Hopefully someone can teach them to make pizza, otherwise they are not going to make it. cibo cattivo!!!! read more

First time eating here tonight, I had to see what the hype was all about, I would say it was good, ordered a medium pizza with half pepperoni & half cheese, wanted to try the Parmesan garlic knots but they didn't have that in stock, also wanted to try the cinnamon bites but those weren't in stock yet either, I would say my expectation is a bit on the higher end since I'm from New York and we have the best pizza, but I would definitely come here and support my local pizza place. I did try the garlic wings and I wasn't a fan of them. read more

Pizza Pie Co. - Medium pizza half pepperoni and half cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Jarrell, Texas

Decent Pizza! Customer Service could be better but they are heading in the right direction! They should have a little bit more on the menu to choose from! More specials would be nice or some type of pizza reward system! read more

I ordered a Chicken Parm sub and mild buffalo wings. I received a meatball sub and garlic Parmesan wings... I double checked my receipt and it clearly what I ordered. Don't think I'll be ordering from here again anytime soon read more

Awesome New York style pies,perfect, great choices, excellent quality ... Can't wait until our next meal here... read more

Great pizza here. Nice staff. I'm not a fan of the buffalo sauce on the wings but some people enjoy it. I haven't tried the pastas or subs yet read more

The meatball sub had tiny size meatballs. I got a better meatball sub at subway. My dog wouldn't even eat the meatballs.

Came on a visit to Texas from NYC to visit family and stopped by this spot while exploring the area. I was truly blown away! The pizza was some of the best I've had outside of New York. The staff is great and the place is clean with adorable pictures of pizza adorning the walls. Turns out, the owner is from Brooklyn, New York so it's no wonder that the food was fantastic! I'll definitely be dropping by again before I leave town! read more

This place has some things to work out. My husband and I ordered from here a couple of weeks ago. Pizza taste like frozen pizza. This place does not deliver and they do not have everything listed on their website in stock. Website is also a little difficult to navigate. The people that work there are nice enough, but when my husband went to pick up, they never took payment. I had to call back to pay them for the pizza we had already picked up. When I mentioned it, they said it had happened a couple times already. Some more training might be necessary. read more

We just ate at the Pizza Pie company in Jarrell. Great pizza and wonderful customer service! They went above and beyond for us.

Really delicious pizza, very flavourful and cheesy. The staff is very friendly and everything is super clean. A great spot ! Will definitely return 8) read more

Pizza Pie Co. - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Jarrell, Texas

Every time I come to Pizza Pie Co there is always a happy atmosphere, food is delicious, and their service is excellent! My stomach is very happy when I leave read more

The pizza was ok, not bad but not good just ok. The wings however were disgusting. The wings were small and tasted gross. Do not order their wings. read more

Very fresh and delicious! The staff was very friendly and welcoming. I'll definitely come back.

It was great there friendly , quick, was delicious as well would and will recommend this to everyone!

1/26/2024 6:15 pm- Inform your employees that every person that enters your establishments don't always speaks spanish and don't mistake the customer for an immigrant just because the color of their skin. Today I didn't look like a "William" to them, so they questioned me if I paid for the pizza. The thing is that you must pay before they place your order which I did and had a receipt. So when I went to pick it up and gave my name as the other white lady did before me. I was questioned about my name and if I had paid for the pizza. I was totally disrespected, as an employee thought I was an immigrant and I didn't understand english, translating if I had paid in spanish. Not till I went to retrieve the receipt from the vehicle and ask for the manager did they apologized. No other customers were asked to verify their names nor provide a receipt, except for me. The bad thing is that my family do like their pizza and we have been going every other week since they opened to get two large pizzas. The manager is a great guy and has always treated me, as a Retired Veteran, with respect. Don't know what happened today with his employees. read more

All 3 pizzas were so greasy the grease leaked out onto my clothing. Boxes were saturated. Pizzas saturated in what appeared to be garlic sauce.Pizza's was made wrong. Couldn't eat had to be thrown away.Tried to speak to manager but not available. read more