Had a special with two 2 litters of pop on FB and their website but when I went to pick the order up and already paid for it they refused to give me the two bottles of pop that was part of the deal. I showed them their facebook page and they said they had the right to change at anytime!!! So they changed the deal after I paid!!!!! Would never go back plus the pizza tasted like a frozen Toney's pizza... nasty read more

Pizza pantry is the OG of the community for a great reason. Food is always consistent. We have never had a bad meal there. We really enjoy the sub sandwiches , and their wing orders are a dozen, rather than the 10 standard at most places now. Service is always good and ready at the time promised. Strictly a takeout place, great for bringing home food to enjoy read more

We ordered the family pack of pizza and wings and a 2 liter of soda. Everything was delicious and the order was very prompt. Would highly recommend. read more

Usually fresh and delicious food, with friendly staff. Their hours seem to be a bit limited these days. Their "small" pizza is enough for probably 3 hungry people (6 large slices). We always love their onion petals or the hog fries. Their salads are also very good and fresh. Pizza crust is delicious and thick, all around usually a good meal. read more

See all

We just found out about this place today and man o man we have been missing out for all this time. The pizza is simply outstanding. You cant say much more than that. Other than they have very reasonable pricing, friendly staff and a extensive menu my family and I cant wait to try more of. Espessialy the fish fry we could smell cooking when we picked up our pizza. That smelled amazing. read more

Great pizza we had the taco one. We loved it. We get it when we can. Service was quick and the man that waited on me was very polite.

For Gods sake do something with the rest of the building! Decent pizza for Genesee Co. Need better hours. This place was once the go to pub, restaurant, bowling alley back in the day. Now it's using a third of its potential. If it was put to better use it could be the destination place in CorFU. read more

Our extended family has always thought of this place is the "default" of what good pizza should look, taste and smell like. Awesome pizza, awesome wings, quick and hot, locally owned. read more

This is one of the areas tried and true pizza shops. Been eating here since the 80s! Pizza crust is so good, wings fantastic, and the subs are delicious. Service is usually good, call in ordering is the best idea here. Wish there was more seating, best as a take out service read more

Husband and I came to Corfu, NY to see the Smashing Pumpkins at the Darien Lake amphitheater and stopped at this amazing pizza place for a pizza! We had a small BBQ chicken pizza for the two of us (six delicious cheesy slices with perfectly cut chicken pieces and great BBQ sauce with red onions). Our cashier and waiter was friendly and strike conversation with us and made us feel welcome! I recommend it! read more

Pizza Pantry - Delicious cheesiness! - Pizza Near Me - Corfu, New York

Pizza pantry isn't a bad place. Given the area it's probably the best around. Dough was ok but was cooked too crispy for my style. Sauce was meh. Toppings where decent but the peps (weren't the char cups) with everything mentioned The pizza was ok. It wasn't anything that would give me a WOW factor since I try pizzas from all over the NY area. But I'd come back in if I was in the vicinity. The place inside is really nice to eat at. Great staff on hand. read more

See all

It's good! It's fresh and being away from Buffalo. No complaints. There is not a lot of options around here. It's a good place to have in town. I grew up Buffalo with LaNovas. When my husband wanted to move back to the village where he grew up, I was like oh no!!! No more good pizza and wiiiiings. I was wrong! They have a Char B Que Wing that almost rivals LaNovas. They just needed a lil more bbq sauce IMO. I am glad to say fear not! Corfu has a great Pizza joint in town! read more

Amazing food and staff. Cant go wrong with the Aussie BBQ Grilled chicken wings. my favorite. BEST pizza place around hands down.

Just wanted to say thank you to Bev, Patrick and the staff for going above and beyond for the rehearsal dinner we hosted at Pizza Pantry last month. The menu, decorations, music, It could not have gone better. Two down sons down two to go so we plan to be back. read more

Food is good, not great. The service is garbage. It's only take out now as they closed the restaurant portion which is not cool because that was the best part. The managers are terrible with customer service read more

Have only eaten here once but I'll be back fo sho. Had the white pizza and it was really good. Very garlicky and parmesany. Only thing that would have made it better is some tzatziki on the side to dip the crust in. read more

Pizza Pantry - Mmmmm...... - Pizza Near Me - Corfu, New York

Just spent THIRTY TWO DOLLARS on wings. Ordered 12 BBQ saucy and 24 garlic parm, crispy and saucy. They repeated as we went and repeated at the end. Drive back to Skyline and we get 12 garlic parm and 24 BBQ. We call to inform them and they say oh gee, we wrote it backwards, sorry. Really?!? We spent $32 and that's it? I've been in the restaurant business 30 years, you can do better than that! It was your mistake. My bf called, you say sorry sir, what's your name and next time you call, we'll give you a $10 credit. Your mistake has now become our misfortune. Not only will we NEVER come back- we'll pass this along to everyone at Skyline. Terrible customer service! Learn to better correct YOUR mistakes. The customer shouldn't have to deal with, oh sorry! read more

My first time at this place, and I love it, customer service was excellent, cole was very nice.

Hand down delicious. I am In town and was told they deliver Didn't feel like leaving the hotel room. I ordered the Chicken Parmesan. It was huge spaghetti topped with 2 huge peices of chicken. The cause is so good but different. Has a nice bite to it. You can definitely tell it's homemade. Comes with a nice side salad and hot fresh half a loaf of garlic bread. I will definitely have left overs for lunch.. Amazing meal . Two thumbs up Pizza Pantry. I will let my coworkers know you deliver and to give you a call. read more

After a long day at Darien Lake, we wanted something easy to take back to the camp site. I was skeptical about ordering pizza from a "pantry" but there weren't many choices. I ordered a sheet pizza with pepperoni and cheese. The pizza was SO GOOD!!! The crust was thick and actually tasted homemade, not like it came from a freezer, the toppings were plentiful and good quality. We needed enough food for me, my sister, and her four boys, ages 23-12 and after everyone at their fill, we had leftovers. I was surprised by the quality and the value. I would definitely order again. read more

Wow! We used the Pizza Pantry for a conference for our leaders and they were incredible. The staff, notably Patrick, went above and beyond to make sure everything was taken care of for us and the food was absolutely amazing! You have to use the Pizza Pantry for you next meeting, conference or party!!! read more

I've had the opportunity to go to this establishment several times in two summers while visiting Darien Lake Theme Park. The food is good - especially the white pizza, and the wait staff friendly and courteous. Their hours nicely accommodate families who want to make the most out of a trip to the DL park and still get a bite to eat at lunch or on the way home. I'd recommend this as an alternative to pricey amusement park food. read more

Excellent shrimp dinner - large shrimp that were nice and crispy. And I appreciate it being brought to truck during this virus situation - especially since I saw several people going inside. read more

Pizza is the best I have ever had! The chicken wings are also excellent. They also have loaded fries that will blow your mouth away! The just got a soft pretzel braid that you gotta try it comes with nacho cheese and omg it's f-in good! read more

This is pretty much the only choice for food around Darien Lake Theme Park unless you go to a gas station. I'm surprised there aren't more food places in this area considering the prices and quality of food in the park. Anyway, we ordered a pizza, chicken fingers and fish fry dinner. Pizza wasn't my favorite... Kinda bready but my kids devoured it. The chicken fingers were good. I liked the barbecue sauce. It was slightly sweet and spicy. Fish fry was good, big portions. I'm sure we'll be ordering from here again! read more

We ALL loved the food! ! Had chicken wings, specialty pizza-tomato and garlic, pizza with pepperoni. Homemade pizza crust, yummy

Patrick did a wonderful job hosting our leaders retreat over the weekend. Great meeting space and good breakfast and dinner. Top notch service. Thank you! read more

Their food is awesome. I have been going here since I was 7 years old, and I'm 37 now. Best tasting pizza around. Would have gotten 5 stars, but the prices have gotten a bit stiff for my taste. My favorite is the mushrooms, but I'm not paying 6.99 for them all the time. Good deal on Tuesday's for the large pizza for $10 read more

My friends and I took a 3 hour trip out to Darien lake for the day. We asked a worker who lives in the area for a good sit down place to eat on the way home, he recommended the Pizza Pantry. Although service was a tad slow, the food was excellent and our waitress checked on us frequently. Definitely worth the wait, we will be visiting again! read more

After a long day at Darien Lake, the family starving and zero patients we were looking for something quick and easy. Pizza Pantry from the outside had little to be desired, but once inside I was pleasantly surprised. Our waitress told us about the family special large pizza, 24 wings, and a pitcher of pop with free refills. We also ordered the hog fries. BBQ pulled pork on waffle fries (amazing). The homemade crust was excellent and the toppings were piled one (mushroom, onion, and pepperoni...yummy). The wings were good sized and cooks perfectly (just crispy). The waitress had no problem splitting the wings into BBQ and medium, perfect for a family that can't decide on the same things. To be honest I normally base our waitresses performance on how well she keeps our drinks filled. This was not a problem she even brought a new pitcher of pop before the last one was finished, not only that but two other staff members while she was away also asked us if we needed more refills. In the end service was excellent the food was great and we will definitely be back the next time we are at Darien Lake. Looking forward to the Wednesday special, family-style all you can eat spaghetti dinner. read more

Pizza Pantry - Pizza Near Me - Corfu, New York

Overnight stop from traveling the NY turnpike, I-90. Wanted some pizza and found this place on yelp. Super food, great price, nice people. Really liked the pizza. We sat in the bar area. 8pm a Sunday night. read more