Wow. What an amazing place. Went here twice in the last week because the pizza was so good. Ordered several different pies and wings and all were absolutely fantastic. The Candyman is a perfect wood fired pepperoni with that sweet heat of the hot honey added. For you ricotta, meat and hot banana pepper fans (one of my fav combos) the vodka 2.0 absolutely delivers. The loaded margherita was so unique and had the perfect ingredients of each topping on it. Mine and the tables favorite was the Quattro formaggi. So creamy and funky with the addition of blue cheese. Wings were cooked perfect. Went with the cattleman's and flaming garlic parm. Garlic parm are some of my go to wings but sometimes they lack flavor. I tend to drag them in a side of hot sauce when I order. These accomplished that with the sauce on them. Perfect amount of heat. Cattleman's were delicious if you like that flavor. Decor and atmosphere are very nice, and the tap list and mixed drink list has something for everyone. Owner Vinny and waitstaff were a 10/10. Our waiter was hustling all night and extremely attentive. If you haven't been here yet and have been eyeing it up, get here, you are not going to be disappointed. read more

See all

Woodfire pizza 4/5. For $10 you get a pretty decent pizza. My Margherita pizza could have used more basil. For $10 not bad. I've paid a whole lot more at fancier Italian restaurants and the pie was not much different. I do have issue with paying $12 for a margarita cocktail. Especially for a very average restaurant like Candyman pizza. My one drink cost more than the $10 pizza!!! I highly doubt they're using top shelf tequila. That's a big no-no. Should not have cost more than $8. Service 4/5. Service is a little slow. They were very busy. I only saw one server running around the whole place. She was working hard and she was polite. Ambiance 3/5 small dark restaurant area if you're dining in. Nothing special or anything appealing. Simple. read more

See all

Enjoyed pizza and wings outstanding. I'm not a fan of thin pizza but this was delicious. Cooked to perfection the service was very good. Server was on the ball. Helped us out with the menu and was right there with water and soft drink Sat up front was very quiet and we could have a conversation without being overloaded by the music. Very good dining experience read more

Attention Yelpers ! $10 wood fired pizzas on Wednesdays ... this is what brought me here last week ! I chose the Candyman Pizza - think pepperoni and cheese with hot honey . Enough for 2 meals . Tasty . I also sampled a piece of my friend's Quattro formaggi pizza - delicious as well . Also , wings and the chicken slider (much larger than a slider ) got rave reviews . Service was friendly and they did separate checks for our 6 top . They collaborate with Caputi's Pub next door - look out for their special deals as well . I'll be back to order some wings ! read more

Candyman Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

We ordered over the phone for pickup and seemed like it was organized but when we went to pick it up 30 min later, the order was never transferred from the bar to the connected pizza store. They slapsticked it together and just felt rushed and undercooked. Not impressed after such good reviews. read more

Candyman Pizza - Quattro formaggi - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

The pizza is soooo good! Love the candy man pizza with hot chili and honey!! You can also order wings from caputis next door. The only negative thing about this place is it's not open during the day for lunch and it often sells out early at night :/ read more

Disappointed. Not sure how you can undercook a wood fired pizza, but it was and hardly had any basil, which I requested to have added. Good luck read more

Came here for a special whiskey pairing dinner and had a great experience! The food was great. The pizza is brick oven style, and I really enjoyed both pizzas I tried (their cheese and pepperoni, and another with bacon, blue cheese(?), and walnuts). I also really enjoyed their salad and some fried appetizers they served. Drink selection was creative too. I ordered a loganberry cocktail which was delicious. They also have a bunch of beers to choose from as well. Service was fantastic too. Everyone was very friendly, drinks were made quickly, and food came out hot and often too. Cool atmosphere. Great place to hangout with a few friends, or enjoy a sit down pizza dinner. read more

Candyman Pizza - Whiskey tasting event - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Excellent service, good and atmosphere. I recommend getting there when they open at 5pm because it can fill up fast! I really enjoy the Mystery IPA with a pepperoni pizza. All the pizzas are personal size so don't be afraid to order two or more to share with friends. I'd also recommend the four cheese za! read more

The pizza is fresh and delicious! It's a perfect size and not over done with the ingredients.

Decided to give the pizza a try, it was decent, but didn't really hit the spot for me. I'd give a 3.5 if we could. The sauce was a little sweet for me, and it seemed like the flour used for the dough was maybe a mix that had some brown flour included? Just wasn't overall my taste. It was well cooked, and I like how much basil was on it as I feel some places skimp. As for the ambience, typical local WNY bar feel. People were really congregating near the entrance for some reason with their drinks, which was odd. I did take out as my normal place was closed at it was later in the evening, so can't comment too much on the service, but the pie was ready fast after I ordered and the person who was at the counter was pleasant. Overall I likely wouldn't return as as the flavor overall just wasn't my taste, but I can see why some people like it so much. read more

Candyman Pizza - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Pizza was pretty small for the price. We went on Wednesday because they advertise $10 pizza but found out that is for eat in only. We were carrying out. So $17!! Really? They are small personal sized. A bit bigger than Pizza Hut ones so we made due because we ordered wings too. The wings were delicious!!!! That's why the get 3 stars! Bbq bourbon. Pizza was ok. Really didn't get any wood from it. Crust was very tough and chewy. I expect a chewy crust but not like that. So 2 stars removed for lack of wood taste, serious price increase because we didn't want to sit in the bar and chew. Hope this helps. read more

The first time we went the food was absolutely amazing, the service was beyond amazing, and the drinks were fantastic. Today, our pepperoni pizza was ridiculously overcooked, and our drinks were weak short pours. Our server was very sweet, but new. When she asked how dinner was, I said just this. She gave me a sad face and not a single manager even talked to us. I wasn't seeking anything free, but some acknowledgment that our $110 meal was not what it should have been would have been nice. At some point we'll be back, but it's going to be a while. I'm annoyed more by management's non-response than I am by the overcooked food and 1990's-style caputi's drink I paid $10 for. Had a manager acknowledged our complaint and had a conversation, I would have walked away satisfied. Now I'm wondering whether they are victims of too quick success, and are fading from belief what goes up does not go down. Tonight's dinner was like a 1.5 star, but our first time was 5. So I averaged and rounded to 3. read more

Wonderful staff, great atmosphere and the best thing about it all is the food! Also...house made blue cheese ‍

Technically was here for a Caputi's whisky tasting and not ordering off the menu. They served some of their pizzas with the tasting and the pizzas were great. Good crust and toppings. Bar has a good selection. read more

I was looking for a pizza place in the area and found this place during a Google search. It was a weekday night around 8pm and there was only one other table there. We ordered our food, the menu isn't as inventive as I would have hoped, but we settled on two pizzas. What makes this place unique is the wall decor. Every wall has something different and are good conversation starters, but you can only talk for so long before you start to wonder " where is my food?" Perhaps, because this restaurant shares a space with a bar next door they supply the food for them, which is why our 2 small personal pan pizzas took nearly 90 minutes to arrive! Aside from the wait, the pizza was just okay. The bottom was burnt black on both of them we ate what we could. The dough was dull and the sauce was bland and really left nothing to the imagination. All and all I would come back perhaps for the trivia Night which they do have weekly or maybe if I just wanted beer and bar food. I hope the menu and the service improves! The concept is unique, but poor execution read more

Candyman Pizza - Pepperoni pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Stop for a beer at caputi's and some candy man pizza and you won't be disappointed! Love their flavors. I personally love to get the white pizza and make it Jen style and add fig and prosciutto! read more

I was looking forward to their very tasty pizza, with a crisp crust and flavorful cup and Char pepperoni, but we noticed that the table next to us got two pizzas that they said they didn't order it was given to them by a different server than ours. So it took an extremely long time to get our pizza. Our server made up for it. It wasn't her fault. Bourbon bbq wings were also done on the pit and worth the wait.Thank you to our server. read more

See all

I haven't been to Caputi's in 10 years, but they've turned a side room into a pizza pub of sorts. Wood-fired pizzas, cocktails, beers. and whiskey. We ordered the meatball app and three pizzas. The meatball app was the low point for me - fine, but unremarkable. All the pizzas were very good though. Very thin crust, great flavor. I liked the pepperoni best, and I'm sure I would've liked it "Candyman style" (with honey and chilis) but since we had our daughter with us, we figured skipping the hot pepper was for the best. The four cheese was also very good and super thin. The meatball pizza was my wife's favorite but my least favorite - different strokes and whatnot. I had a Blanton's-barrel aged imperial stout from Thin Man that they had on tap and a pour of Elmer T. Lee. There was a Phish concert on the TV and huge paintings of Jerry Garcia and some of his contemporaries eating pizza. Very fun vibe. read more

See all

We orders a pepperoni pizza to go, by the time we picked it up and got home it was cold and we had to reheat which we wonder if this affected the quality. Even with the reheat this is a really good pizza, thin crust and very flavorful. The pies are small, bigger than an individual pizza but just enough for two to split and be full enough. We need to go back and try the pizza in house to compare and this might be close to a 5/5- will update when we try it ! read more

Awesome pizza and atmosphere. No big sign out front so had a hard time finding it - attached to Caputi's Sheridan Pub. Pizza and wings were excellent, good selection of tap takeovers craft beer. Bartender was friendly and service was fast. Will be back to this place. Ryan M read more

Great pizza and bourbon. This is one of my favorite places in Buffalo NY. Try their Candyman pizza.

Best pizza around. Can get backed up quite a bit if its busy so might not be best to go if you need a quick bite

The Kitchen at my house is being remodeled. I needed dinner and ordered a simple cheese and pepperoni pizza for takeout. It was delicious. I was greeted warmly by the pizza chef and the bartender. They had a nice collection of bourbon, and it looked like a cool place to bring my wife on a date, they have gluten-free crust! I will be back again. read more

This place is uh may zing! I happened to be in the area for an appointment that took longer than I had expected so I was crazy hungry and yelped the nearest pizza place. I am so glad I did!!! The pizzas were so good. The dough has a nice chewy crisp and the cheese is very rich. The best part was the weck wings. I cannot cannot tell you enough about how incredible these wings are. Please try them! Let me know what you think. read more

Candyman Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

We went last night and the prev reviews are right! The Candyman pizza is to die for!! We walked in around 7pm on a Wednesday night and found it weird that one side of the restaurant was closed. They advertise they are open on Wednesdays from 5 to 10, so I thought that was a bit disappointing. Aside from that, we thoroughly enjoyed our food and drinks. Our bartender was amazing! Even when it got busy she followed up with us. The other bartender didn't acknowledge us the entire time we were there. read more

If this place was on Elmwood, there'd be a line out the door. Excellent wood-fired pizza, great craft beers. Like I'd died and gone to heaven. read more

Candyman Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Great experience all around. We had a large group and were easily and quickly accommodated. Pizza is top notch. Wings we're great. Tater tots are the best I've had. Fantastic, friendly service. read more

Tried the candy man pizza. Oh my. Delicious! Crust is perfect, very flavorful. We were afraid to order all candyman style in case we didn't like it. Dumb. We loved it! Everything tastes very high quality and fresh. There was love in this pizza and it was fabulous! Spicy, not salty, fresh and just succulent. Highly recommend!! read more

Candyman Pizza - Pepperoni pizza 1/2 candyman style - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Great atmosphere. Food was delicious and the cook came to the table to check in on their masterpiece. We were the last pizza dough for the day so only had the option to order 1 which we supplemented with wings, equally delicious. Home made blue cheese was superb. The food was outstanding. read more

Great pizza! Was very impressed with the food- wish they had more options for drinks (another seltzer option other than highnoon) we will definitely be back though! read more

Candyman Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Not too bad! We got wings and pizza. Came out reasonably quick and the taste delivered. Great spot if you're looking for a quick bite in the area read more

The pizzas are always great. The wings are delicious. And they aren't cheap with the alcohol in the drinks.

100% Best overall bar in North towns! All the staff are wonderful, and they remember you when you come back! Excellent food!! Love this place read more

Part of what makes this place so cool, is that you can see them making your pizza, they put so much attention to detail when cooking. The crust is so flaky, thin and crunchy. The wings were good, they had so many different flavors and you could order wings by 5 a piece which I thought was pretty cool if you didn't want a ton. The artwork and lighting creates a unique atmosphere and the service was top notch we were checked on about four times and never had to seek anything ourselves. This might be my new favorite pizza place. read more

See all

One of the best pizza spots in Buffalo. Excellent service and great Ambiance even with kids. My husband, my teenage son and I stopped by Friday night. We got to play "battle ship " board game while waiting on our pizza and wings. We had a great time. Second time I ordered online and picked it up as scheduled. I'll definitely be back! read more

Secretly, I do not want anyone to know about this place...but also want people to know about this place so that it can keep being this place. So here are some words about that. Go there. Get pizza. Candyman style. Shut up and put it in your mouth. Euphoria will commence. There's beer too. Good vibes. You're welcome. read more

Best artisan pizzas in town. Great bar, helpful and friendly staff. I've never been disappointed and only regret not being able to eat here more often. Candyman style is a must, and their Margarita style is my second favorite. Grab some truffle wings too, you'll be glad you did. read more

Great pizza, friendly staff and fun, nostalgic games to play. Would come back when in town.

Perhaps my new favorite thin crust - their candyman with the hot honey is and their specials are awesome as well - Can the orders wings @ Caputi's and now it's even better - Solid beer selection as well and a cool vibe read more