What a great and highly underrated spot! The employees there are very friendly, contrary to some of the reviews on Google and Yelp. Today, I got the cheese calzone, fried dough, and cannolis. They were all delicious. Their calzones are only around $10 for a plain cheese. And, the portion is quite big too. It's not too doughy and their dough is flavorful and delicious. It looks like they top their calzones with a good bit of butter. It may look a bit soggy on the bottom, but the flavor is still excellent. Their sauce is lightly sweet and goes perfectly with the cheese. It's packed well and is the perfect amount of cheese for a calzone. Would have liked a bit more ricotta specifically and maybe a side dipping sauce, but still amazing! The desserts are pretty good too. Some of them are (as expected) not made in house, but others like the cinnamon rolls and fried dough are. When I ordered, I initially switched one of my desserts for the other. But, they just gave me the other dessert for free! Very considerate. The cannolis, although partially premade, were still quite tasty. Good amount of filling, great texture, adequate amount of chocolate chips inside, crispy outside, and nice chocolate cover. Their fried dough is also tasty and similar to a funnel cake. Would have maybe liked a sweet sauce (like caramel or chocolate) with the fried dough, but I had some leftover caramel to use so no issues there. All in all, a very good stop for pizza in Monroeville. It seems extremely underrated, and I was the only person to be in the store at the time (and my order was the only one for pick up at that time, which was Labor Day weekend). This place needs some more pizza and calzone loving visitors! read more

See all

so after waiting 2 hours for my delivery I knew my food was going to be cold. I did call after 1.5 hours to see where it was and he assured me it was out for delivery. 35 minutes later he brought it himself and apologized and offered me only free dessert next time!!! My pizza was cold and old. it was a white pizza that was supposed to have tomatoes on it but there were none. the wings were only warm and there were tomatoes on the hoagie that I asked for no tomatoes. I did ask for EXTRA CHEESE and there was no cheese at all!!!! this is unacceptable! I think I should be entitled to a full refund. Never again:( read more

Holy S%!t this place is fantastic! Food was delicious, special instructions were followed perfectly, and it was delivered 15 minutes before they said! read more

Gateway Volleyball ordered a total of 46 pizzas for an event. Everything was perfect, from ordering, timing and quality of the pizza. Friendly and helpful staff. Highly recommend. read more

They are open late which is good if your looking for pizza late at night. I ordered a simple pepperoni. I asked for extra crispy. Nothing fancy or unique about their pizza. Just okay if nothing else is open. read more

The food is amazing I absolutely cannot stop buying the hot wing dings and they even offer all flats for a small fee but 100% worth it if you're anything like me ... the ranch is really good taste like it's homemade and the management and other staff are very respectful nice and friendly. 10/10 would recommend and the place always seems clean which is always a plus when dealing with food! read more

Simply the best pizza joint in town! Great location for an easy dinner when I don't feel like cooking. My family has ordered from here several times while living in Monroeville and are always beyond happy with the outcome. read more

Pizza Marsala - Barbecue Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

They just delivered me frozen boneless wings. Not cold but actually so frozen. Really how the heck did this happen. Well never order from them again read more

I absolutely love this place!! the pizza is excellent!! All the food is so fresh and tasty and there are so many options. The manager Ender is so professional and always treats his customers with respect He also treats his employees the same! Pizza Marsala is by far the best food in The Pittsburgh Pennsylvania area! read more

Pizza Marsala - A special did you have to request - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

BE AFRAID, BE VERY AFRAID! The worst, I repeat the worst Pizza establishment I've ever ordered from! I don't know how or why they decided to get into the Italian food business, when clearly they know nothing about great Italian food or business for that matter! The staff lies, is Ruth and the delivery drivers are only concerned about their tips, instead of the timeliness and warmth of the food they are delivering! They get the orders wrong, the food arrives cold, and when you complain, it somehow becomes your fault! I would have done better to go to domino's, Pizza Hut or Papa John's, or even McDonald's for that matter. Unless you are a masochist, do yourself a huge favor and find another, better pizza delivery joint! And... Isn't it interesting that all of their good reviews seem to come from those who are friends and employees of the restaurant... read more

I ordered a pizza for my 4 year old sons birthday who recently came out as transgender (female to male). I was chatting up the owner, trynna get some sweet deals & discounts ch'feel. Well he wouldn't offer any money off but he did throw in their signature blue milk pizza. The blue milk pizza comes standard for all transgender children below the age of 5, it tastes like a mix of kerosene and acetaminophen. Needless to say all the kids loved the blue milk pizza, except for my sons friend Dougan (who threw up blood as he's lactose intolerant. Dougan is always ruining things, so I can't say this upset me as it's what the little demon deserved. Sweet Justice) I will be returning to Pizza Marsala for my 1 year old's coming out party for lots and lots of pizza milk and hopefully a discount next time! read more

Pizza Marsala - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Ordered a pizza and a hoagie to be delivered. two hours later a stone cold pizza and hoagie showed up. We called for a refund and they said they will be back in 45 minutes to pick the food up. Not sure what they plan to do with it but they are welcome to it. read more

Ordered: Steak Hoagie and plain cheese Both were very juicy and packed with flavor definitely stop by or order spot! read more

Pizza Marsala - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

I work across the street and have given them numerous chances, from pizza to burgers/subs to tenders, salads, e.t.c e.t.c... They're ridiculously overpriced, first of all. They charged me almost $9 for cheese fries. $4 for fries, $4 for cheese. You have to pay extra for any dressings, which is ridiculous(for example, the buffalo chicken wrap doesn't come with ranch, you have to pay for it LOL). The food is frozen GFS garbage. The pizza is awful. It tastes horrible and there's a stupid amount of cheese. All you taste is rubbery cheese and a mild hint of canned tomato sauce. I'll starve before eating here again. read more

Really good Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Ranchero version). Surprisingly different, although more of a ranch for taste would be admired. The chicken was great - fried & breaded, not grilled. There were also potato fry slices on the pizza. Giving it a different flavor. 1 slice of a Medium 8-Cut pizza will make you full, while 2 slices will make you stuffed! Will order again. read more

Pizza Marsala - Ranchero Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Medium 8-Slice) - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

The food is very good here. I just hate that every time I order a hoagie the decline to put Mayo on my sandwich. If I say extra Mayo on my sandwich that's what I want. I don't want 2 Mayo packets for a whole Italian hoagie. read more

Pizza and Wings. Get them here, you won't be disappointed. The small vegetable pizza is LOADED with veggies. The veggies are fresh and perfectly roasted. Pair this with some jumbo wing pieces and you won't be able to roll off your sofa. Whatever you order, you'll get the symbol of delicious food: a greasy brown bag. If food could make bedroom eyes, the grease spreading across a simple brown paper bag would be it. Onto non-food stuff: The plaza is tight, but there is free parking AND a beer distributer next door to fuel your post-pizza bad decisions. The service is why a star missing- I ordered online and as soon as I walked in, saw my order waiting for me. The man behind the counter ignored me, another man messing with the oven looked at me then looked at his coworker ignored me, then he also ignored me. I smiled pleasantly and stared at at my food, debit card in hand. Finally, a woman came from the back, noticed the men ignoring me up front and came over to get my card. No frills, no haste from the workers, but it matters not! My order was ready, my order was correct, and my food was tasty. read more

Pizza Marsala - Small Vegetable Pizza - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

It is very hard to miss. It sits in a tiny strip mall. Pizza was excellent. They have a very extensive menu. They also sell it by the slice. I look forward to trying more menu items. read more

Pizza Marsala - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Amazing pizza and great prices. It's great to have a pizza place so close. I recommend meatball parm sandwhich, pizza, Buffalo chicken and fries sandwich. read more

My husband and I were in town for the living dead weekend at Monroeville Mall and needed a nighttime pizza to round out the experience. We picked these guys because they were one of the only menus the hotel had available and didn't feel like searching for another place. We are VERY glad we called them because that pepperoni and sausage pizza was the BEST pizza we've ever had!! And we've put down some pizzas!! We practically had to arm wrestle over the last piece, but finally settled for splitting it. The sauce was phenomenal!! I wish there was a Pizza Marsala in Columbus!! read more

Ordered thin-crust pizzas. Arrived on-time with lots of cheese, they have a good sauce. Recommended.

WARNING - MAKE SURE YOU DONT HIT THE NO CHEESE BUTTON WHEN ORDERING A REGULAR CHEESE PIZZA. I ordered a large cheese pizza online and was getting it delivered to my house. Online there is an extra cheese & no cheese option. I thought the no cheese option meant you want no extra cheese! TURNS OUT THAT MEANS NO CHEESE at all on your pizza... I luckily had a little mozzarella in the fridge and put it in the oven .. We also ordered a steak hogue which was actually delicious The delivery time from my order confirmation email to the time it got to my house was like 45 mins The taste is alright .. It's not the best I've ever had ... The crust is very plain tasting .. but that could be a factor that I had to rebake the pizza and add my own cheese read more

Pizza Marsala - WARNING - MAKE SURE YOU DONT HIT THE NO CHEESE BUTTON WHEN ORDERING A REGULAR CHEESE PIZZA. Monroeville pizza Marsala - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

The food is horrible for the price the gyro meat faker than Kim ks ass and the pizza taste like frozen box pizza like. It's was cooked in a air fryer like a old taste read more

Pizza Marsala - Gyro meat - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Horrible customer service. It took a hour and a half for me to get my food, partly because they got my address wrong. Then I asked if they would give me a discount for a mistake THEY made and they wouldn't. On top of it all, my pizza was cold and I had to microwave it. Will never order from there again. read more

One of my go-to pizza delivery joints in Monroeville. They tend to do a slightly better job than Pasquarelli's or Vocelli's, in my opinion. The pizza usually has a slightly more crispy crust, the veg toppings seem fresher. I also like their hoagies. The gyros are ok. Delivery is sometimes a little longer than Vocelli's (in Monroeville at least) but I'd rather order from here than the other delivery options. read more

This is a review on delivery pizza only, as this is our primary spot to call for pizza-needs-while-at-work. 1) Their delivered pizza is fresh-tasting and hot. And handled carefully. 2) Their specialty pizzas are a cut above. Scared to try a taco pizza? Don't be afraid! Marsala's does them perfectly. 3) Delivery is consistently quick. You will never wonder when you'll get your order. That's my two cents for my pizza delivery location of choice in Monroeville. read more

This was the worst delivery experience I have ever had . It took over an hour to get here and when it did finally arrive , the food was cold. I called twice for a status on the delivery and both times I was brushed off that the food was on the way. The pizza looks nothing like the photo, the ketchup was not Heinz and I paid over 10$ for iceberg lettuce . i will never order from here again. read more

This place SUCKS! I found hair in my food and was charged for something I didn't order! Never again read more

I love the Pizza Marsala in Greensburg, so I thought I would have the same experience with the Monroeville store in regards to delivery. Unfortunately, when I called to place the order, I specified that I needed my delivery at 11:30, due to lunch restrictions, I was ensured that this was not a problem. At 11:40 when we still hadn't received our pizza, I called back to the store and was told that it was on its way and would be just a few more minutes. At 11:50, I called again when there were still no signs of delivery and I was assured that it was on the way. I then google mapped the place from my location and discovered that it was only 0.8 miles from where we were. The pizza arrived at 11:56, and less than half of us got to enjoy the food before returning from our lunch break, which is sad because it was very tasty. read more

Pizza Marsala - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

don't do it!!! the worst customer service i have ever seen! not only did they have my credit card held up for over 10 days, charging my card and not sending out the food!!! claiming my card was declind! when i offered a screenshot of the receipt from my bank, they came up with a hundred different ways and bn excuses to cover their computer error... and the only thing i received in compensation was double talk and excuses! last night i attempted to give them another opportunity, only to wait for 3 hours, never receiving the food, and when i called and spoke to the owner guess what? it was more of the same, excuses and double talk!!! lying and telling me that they delivered or attempted to deliver the food, even blaming the staff of my hotel, claiming that it was the front desks' fault!!! their integrity, work and customer service ethic should be on the back of a milk carton, clearly it's missing!!! the food is only mediocre and average at best, so you would think they could enhance the service, with a little customer sservice, but no no! this is the restaurant where the customer is never right! do yourself a favor, find another pizza delivery restaurant! don't do it!!! don't do it!!! read more

Based on online ordering and delivery. Make sure that on a Friday you give yourself an hour an a half to get the pizza. VERY SLOW DELIVERY Make sure that if you order online you call to confirm they got it. We did not get our order one night. GAVE THEM 3 CHANCES AND NOW WE ARE DONE. read more

My first "white" pizza. Awesome! Very helpful staff that didn't get annoyed when i asked lots of questions about the menu (from out of state) Delivery man was very nice as well. read more

One of the worst experiences I have had. I ordered three pizzas for delivery to feed my hungry sales team.The 5 cheese pizza had the cheese arrived with the cheese completely slid off and it looked a mess. When I called with an understanding attitude that things happen they said they would send another. The replacement pizza arrived with the same issue. When I called the "manager" said he couldn't refund me for a partial order and all that I could get was a credit there for next time I order( for one pizza).. which I am never going to do. He said the owner was on vacation and he couldn't authorize a refund to my payment method which was a debit card. He said if you want money you have to come pick it up. After not accepting that he finally agreed to have the delivery driver come back with my cash refund for the one pizza. It was really just a mess how it was handled. TERRIBLE customer service. read more

Pizza Marsala - What is this ? The 5 cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Fantastic hoagies and pizza! And a huge variety from which to choose. Very fresh ingredients, and they load up on the toppings and meat. This is my favorite go to place in Monroeville when I need my pizza or hoagie fix. read more

I loved the food great service keep up the work and I'll continue to order from you thanks

Pizza varieties,hot sandwiches I've tasted such delicious delicacies for the First time,you will gain experience.

Great local pizza place in Monroeville. We ordered the Ranchero Pizza and it was delicious. This pizza is more New York style. The large pizza is very large. The pizza slice has a thin crust in the middle with a good thick crust at the end. The sauce is great along with the cheese. If I lived in the area I would order this pizza. The only negative was the price. The pie was over $21 which seems steep for a non-Gourmet pie. I also asked for plates and they were out of plates which sucked for us since we were staying in a hotel. Give it a try over the chains. read more

Pizza Marsala - Ranchero Pizza - Italian Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Best pizza iv had in a while. Buffalo Chiclen pizza was absolutely amazing! Very friendly staff as well.

Coworkers wanted to order from this pizza place tonight. My first time trying it, & I must say it is the most blandest food I have ever encountered. I got the pepperoni rolls & pepperoni sticks. The pepperoni rolls were decent, not really hot. The pepperoni "sticks" looks like a mini pizza without sauce. The marina sauce was just basic, no seasoning or spicy. I had higher hopes from reading previous reviews & my coworkers but not satisfied at all. read more

There are far better pizza restaurants in the area. This is usually a last resort for a lack luster dinner. Their pizza has little flavor and the dough is bland. The crew that is usually working are very rude. I have had several times where personal calls are being taken while waiting to order. If you do order from here, always add 10 minutes AT LEAST to the waiting time they tell you. I am usually told 25 minutes and regardless of the day of the week it's an average 35-40 minute wait. Better try Napolis for a real pizza. read more