Cancel

Open app

Search

Pizza Grace

4.4 (171 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Updated 2 months ago

Pizza Grace Photos

PIZZA GRACE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Hipster
Casual
Trendy
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pizza Grace

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Megan R.

Such an amazing "fancy pizza" experience! Service was great, drinks were great, pizza is delicious beyond belief, marinara was so good I could have drank it!!! I only hate I was too full for dessert! They have super cool icee/cocktail, which is unlike anything I'd ever had before! If you want comfort food, but an upscale experience, this is it! Plus, they use a 20 year old sourdough starter um what

Chorizo pizza
Alison L.

I usually love this place but the food fell flat this time. Additionally service was much slower than usual and we weren't checked on often. The chorizo pizza barely had cheese or toppings. As you can see in the picture all the cheese and toppings are co contracted in the middle. The chorizo was not chorizo but rather it was just a thick cut bacon without any chorizo flavoring and there was barely any of it. Additionally, the Caesar salad which had been hyped up by so many in bham was just a regular Caesar salad. Nothing special especially for the price. Disappointed because it was much better last time.

Caesar salad
Ellie M.

Really enjoyed Pizza Grace! Love the cute pizzeria vibe of the restaurant. The staff was super nice and helpful. We started off with the Caesar salad - it was unique since it had capers in it, which I think was a fun spin. The pizza was very good! You could really taste the crust and how fresh it was. We got two 14" between 3 people and it was too much! I would love to return to try more items on the menu.

Cara D.

Absolutely worth a visit. We had the meatballs, Caesar salad, and the burrata pizza. Everything was phenomenal and the sourdough crust really makes a difference!

Sara W.

I wanted to love this place and I just didn't. The service was very good but the pizzas are all one size so it's a lot of food. Most of the pizzas should be eaten hot and fresh so highly recommend splitting a pie. Otherwise you will have much less satisfying leftovers at home. The cocktails were delish. I would go back and split a regular cheese pizza with someone and I think that would redeem my first experience. It smells delicious inside with the wood fire ovens though.

Camille F.

Wonderful service for Sunday lunch! This highlight here is totally the dough -- you can tell it's super fresh and has that great sour flavor. The 14" pizza is the perfect amount to split between two people. I love this location, and the gelato spot next door is the cherry on top. Parking on Morris Ave can be difficult some evenings, but well worth it. I love that you can see into the kitchen. The art on the walls is fabulous, I wish they would put the artists' names by them so I could look it up!

Pepperoni Pizza and peach and prosciutto pizza
Faye Y.

Food first, thoughts after... This was my second time at pizza grace. The first time was before Michelin guide. Went with some friends and no surprise had to wait. They do not take reservations and are pretty popular. From the host to the server everyone was so friendly and down to earth. The apps were delicious. Pizza was overall okay. A little burnt but still good. The seasonal peach and prosciutto was so good! Got to try their hot honey and homemade ranch as well.

Garlic Bread
Angela M.

I love Pizza Grace! This is my second time here and I had to get the garlic bread again. I'll probably get it every time and could just eat this as my meal. Highlyyyy recommend. We split the pepperoni and the Calabrian, which is on their summer menu and has chicken on it and is so flavorful. Their sourdough crust is really good and just a solid pizza overall. They do not do reservations so it's always good to get there early and put your name down. Luckily they have seating outside where you can drink a glass of wine or a really good gelato shop right next door to wait. Will be coming back!!

Bottom left - Gnudi. Top right - Roasted Gulf Shrimp. Both EXCELLENT!
Allana W.

Wow! We ordered the Roasted Gulf Shrimp (TO DIE FOR) and the Gnudi (PHENOMENAL). Our pizza was half white, half mushroom. The staff was beyond helpful (told me to keep my shrimp butter to dip the pizza crust in - super grateful for the tip!) The ambiance is cozy with an exposed kitchen and intimate seating. Highly recommend!

Nardello pie
Danielle B.

We are here on a Sunday at 11 am. The restaurant is not too big but they do have outdoor seating. We had the Caesar salad and it was plenty for two to share. The fried capers and sourdough crisps were a nice touch. We ate the pepperoni pizza and got a pizza that was half the mushroom/olive and Nardello. The crust was sourdough perfection. The toppings were delicious and the pizzas were definitely covered in topping. We loved every bite. The service was speedy and the staff was friendly. A great place to grab a specialty pizza!

"Peach & Prosciutto" 14 inch pizza ($32)
Grace H.

One of my absolute favorite restaurants in Birmingham!! I would eat here once a week if I could. It's a cute, unassuming spot off the charming cobblestone Morris Avenue. The pizzas and apps are always perfect. They also have the cutest rotating wine menu in collaboration with Golden Age Wine in MTB. The servers are also always so kind and not in a rush. If I could change anything, it would be to take some reservations. I have had to sadly pass up on doing several meals here due to not wanting to bring a group to a restaurant without reservations. Additionally, would love to see a slightly more enhanced outdoor seating area.

Menu
Thomas C.

The staff were excellent!! A very welcoming and comfortable environment was also a nice feature. There is a full view of the kitchen which is an open concept. The pizza was good if you like a lot of dough. The toppings were good but sparse. It's not what I would consider a conventional pizza. It's also made with a sourdough crust which was good! It would be a good choice for a date or a family.

01/30/26
Gabe P.

We came to Pizza Grace on a Friday, for an early dinner. Upon arrival, it wasn't busy(AT ALL) but we blinked and this places was full of pizza wanting patrons! This isn't the biggest restaurant. It's comfortable and you don't feel like you are sitting on top of anyone. The ambiance is relaxed and decorated nicely. My fav part is the exposed bricks. Table seating, a few bar seats and some high table top seats are available. We ordered the pepperoni pizza with mushrooms on 1/2. I also requested a side of hot honey. The pizza was quite tasty and I loved the sourdough crust. The ingredients were fresh & of great quality. Our server was really polite and kept our water glasses full. I also had a Good people IPA. They have a respectable wine list but had limited beer options. If you come here, parking on Morris Ave could be a challenge. Thankfully , it wasn't for us. This was my first time at Pizza Grace. The yummy food and good service were worth the visit!

Pepperoni pizza

See all

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ed W.
0
33
0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Loading...

Pizza Grace Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Pizza Grace

Does Grace Pizza serve alcohol?

Yes!

Are dogs welcome?

In the courtyard outside I'm sure.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Wooden City - Fresh Burrata

Wooden City

4.7(153 reviews)
0.1 mi

We made it to Wooden City for dinner on Thursday night. We made reservations for our party through…read morethe link on the restaurant's website (Resy), and the process was straightforward and easy to modify when our party size and time changed at the last minute. Wooden City is located off Morris Avenue in a shared row of older buildings. There's a private parking lot behind the building, and you can have your parking ticket validated at the restaurant. The location and vibe on Morris Avenue are really neat and uniquely Birmingham. It's a great addition to the city's dining scene. Our party of four started with drinks and shared three appetizers: the Bread and Butter, Heirloom Tomatoes, and Steak Tartare. My favorite was the Bread and Butter. It's house-made focaccia served with a sun-dried tomato spread and an oil dipping sauce. The bread was amazing. For my entrée, I ordered the Peel-and-Eat Shrimp from the appetizer menu. It was fabulous--a generous portion of large shrimp that were perfectly seasoned and grilled. For dessert, we shared the Chocolate Mousse and Blueberry/Blackberry Crisp. The crisp was my favorite. It was served hot with a scoop of vanilla ice cream--an excellent way to finish the meal. While Wooden City doesn't have a large menu, everything we tried was very well done. I definitely recommend giving it a try, but don't be in a hurry. The service was a little slow during our visit.

This place was recommended by a local Birminghammian and it was a good recommendation. Three of us…read morewere working somewhere nearby and we took an Uber here and it was kinda packed. We snagged some seats at the bar and had some drinks and shortly after that, our table was ready. And they were able to keep everything on one check, which was nice. No need to settle the tab and start a new one at the table. And the old fashioned I had was delicious. For food, we started with the Hungarian Hot Stuffed Peppers. These were pretty good and the heat gradually snuck up on you as you ate them. I don't know if it was because the heat was more intense as you worked your way towards the stem or just a gradual burn. Either way, these were good and worth the heartburn later. The thick focaccia helped with the burn a little. Speaking of heartburn, the pepperoni pizza may have contributed a bit to that too, but again, totally worth it. The cup-and-char pepperoni was charred nicely as were the edges and bottom! I love a nice bottom! These were easy to share between two of us. Service was amazing from the bartender to the waiter to the uber driver (who didn't really count, but nice job, man). We felt welcomed and I can see why the place was crowded on a Tuesday evening.

Photos
Wooden City
Wooden City - Tavern Burger - american cheese, iceberg, grilled onion, dill pickle, bacon

Tavern Burger - american cheese, iceberg, grilled onion, dill pickle, bacon

Wooden City - Gimlet

See all

Gimlet

Pies & Pints

Pies & Pints

4.1(395 reviews)
0.3 mi
•$$

I visited Pies & Pints this afternoon for lunch, and I have to say I am CRAZY for never stopping by…read morethis place before! Multiple people have raved about how good it is, and I've been meaning to try it for years. It's been around the corner from my job as long as I've been working there, but I'd always put it off or find some reason or other not to go. The entire experience was a ten out of ten. I was greeted as soon as I stepped foot into the restaurant. The bar is right in the front just past the host stand, and one of the bartenders welcomed me and handed me a menu to review for my order. She even offered me something to drink while I decided what I wanted. I looked up from the menu when I was ready to order and there she was, ready to take my order. I waited about 15 minutes for my food, and that was all. It was such a lovely experience. The whole vibe of the place was laid back and comforting. I felt relaxed as soon as I walked in and just having someone welcome me when I enter means the world to me. I was in a big hurry today, so I really appreciated the in and out service. Love love love this place! I ordered the small sriracha shrimp pie. It was absolutely delicious. The ingredients were fresh, and the shrimp was cooked perfectly. They weren't gummy and overcooked like I was afraid they'd be. A lot of places have trouble with shrimp because they cook so fast, but I was very satisfied with my order. Overall, I'm happy that I finally tried Pies & Pints.

Didn't even realize this was a chain. It's a regular stop for me in Lexington KY…read more Had it delivered to my hotel. Pizza and salad were both great as always! Just don't forget silverware.......

Photos
Pies & Pints - Pizza skins... traditional skins but on pizza dough.. very large and filling app!

Pizza skins... traditional skins but on pizza dough.. very large and filling app!

Pies & Pints - Menu.. with happy hour specials.

Menu.. with happy hour specials.

Pies & Pints - Menu

See all

Menu

Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Smoked wings

Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview

4.0(426 reviews)
0.9 mi
•$$

This is the best choice if you want a great pizza. The location was super easy to find. We started…read morewith the fire baked wings which were delicious. I definitely want to circle back for those. We decided to get half Bbq brisket pizza and half This Little Piggy pizza. Since we stopped in on a Sunday the Mimosas were $6 (major score). The service was excellent and super kind. They made sure everything was perfect. I had a great visit and can't wait to go back.

I'm not the biggest pizza fan in the world so I would take my review with a grain of salt. I came…read morefor lunch on a Wednesday and it was extremely dead. We decided to sit outside which was nice because they were making good use of the ac inside. I was thinking about getting 2 slices, but by the time I did that it seemed like it would be a better deal to get a whole pizza. But I knew that would be way too much pizza for me. Our waitress informed us of the lunch special for a pizza and salad it's $13 or 2 slices for $18. She was great and super informative. The slice and salad intrigued me because you could get any salad on the menu. The slice options for the day were the white shadow, pepperoni, cheese, and maybe the wing & the prayer? I went with the white shadow & the spinach salad. I loved the salad with ranch, but it felt like it was missing a crunch maybe ? The balsamic vinaigrette really didn't add anything to the salad for me. The white shadow was pretty good but super greasy and maybe I'd add a protein next time. It was definitely cheese and grease overload but that's what I signed up for so I can't complain. I really wasn't wow'd by the pizza over any other place honestly. But the service and ambiance was great! If I had a taste for pizza and was in the area I would possibly stop by for the slice and salad deal again.

Photos
Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Bar area

Bar area

Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Spinach Salad

Spinach Salad

Slice Pizza & Brewhouse - Lakeview - Loud door mentioned

See all

Loud door mentioned

Pizza Grace - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...