I really enjoyed my first time trip to Miracle Pizza. After brewery hopping, I stopped here to grab a snack. When I arrived, it wasn't busy for a Saturday afternoon. The staff was ready to assist me and provided really pleasant / helpful service. I regret that my phone battery died while I was here. I didn't get many pictures of my food or inside the restaurant. I was able to get a picture of my leftovers later once I got home. The New York slice was pretty tasty! It had the right about of pepperoni/ sauce / cheese ratio. It was great!!! The crust was not too crispy or doughy, so it was just right for me! This is a nice spot to hang out with anyone. It's really laid back and casual dining. Next time I have a hankering for some pizza , I'll add this spot to my list. I recommend checking out Miracle Pizza! read more

See all

Worst pizza I've ever had. I ordered a cheese a Pepperoni pizza and you can tale they just have it on display put it in the oven and gave it to us..... read more

The New York slices of pizza were good. It was hot, fresh, and flavorful. Lot's of topping options. We went with traditional pepperoni and cheese slices. It's nice to have a back door from Avondale Brewery directly into the Miracle Pizza. The ambience is cool and laidback. Some arcade games, a huge bar that is stocked with liquor, beer, and wine, TVs all around playing sports, and good music. The service is friendly and very helpful. read more

Miracle Pizza - New York Slice of cheese pizza with red pepper flakes on it - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Delicious and fresh! Thinner crust makes for foldable bites. I got the Eat Your Veggies pie (food for days!) and it was fabulous, loaded with fresh toppings, and piping hot delivered to my table. You can sit at the bar or get table service. There's also a path to the Avondale Brewery outside area (when they don't have a paid event ongoing). Management was very kind and open to feedback. They're working to improve the Avondale concert pizza experience where they sell slices during the concerts. I mentioned the last concert I attended, the slice was lukewarm and not fresh. Looking forward to giving them another chance at the next show. It's so important to eat while I boogie to keep my energy up! Support local! read more

See all

Regrettably for Miracle Pizza, the Magic City has some amazing pizza spots. While their location and their space is a miracle, nothing about their food is. We started with the garlic bites with marinara. Bits of pizza dough were baked and tossed with garlic butter and served with a savory marinara. The little bits of dough were flavorful but tough. The marinara was lackluster. We asked for a side of ranch to dip them in, and honestly that was the best thing we had. Rich with plenty of dill, everything there should come with the ranch. We ordered the double pepperoni pie and then wondered where the "double pepperoni" was when it arrived. The crust was bland and doughy. There wasn't a huge abundance of cupping pepperoni on top. And it needed the ranch. Finally, we ordered a cannoli (the only dessert available). While the orange zest in the ricotta filling should have been delicious, whoever zested the oranges got too much pith and made the filling bitter. Our visit was a disappointment, which made us sad since the servers were so nice. I'd love to give them a better review, but it's easy to pass on Miracle Pizza and hit one of Birmingham's better spots. read more

See all

Do I think Miracle Pizza will work a miracle in Avondale? Pizza is in general easy to do, but very hard to do right. I was here on a Friday night and could not believe how empty it was. Miracle deserves more love! Family friendly, nice staff, order up front and sit down. The 14" za was demolished by two hungry ladies. We ordered the Spicy Salami and Honey. It was good, but I feel it could have been even spicier/saltier/pepperier. The location is right on the main strip in Avondale, would be a great spot to eat before or after checking out Avondale Brewing, Saturn, 41st St Pub, or one of the other bars around. Arcade games in the back! read more

See all

This was my first time to visit Miracle Pizza. We were always a big fan of Post Office Pies, so our fingers were crossed that it would be just as good. My favorite was the veggie minus tomatoes and olives, and it was absolutely amazing. We also ordered the all meat which I heard was also really good. I liked that there was an option to order single slices even at dinner time. The service was really good and the staff was really nice. Also there was plenty of room for the seven of us. read more

Miracle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

We went the day after Thanksgiving...hoping to see chef Ben but he was out of town. We ordered @ the counter & sat down. Quiet today as it was early afternoon. Cool area with warehouse vibes. We tried the mixta salad, garlic knots, pizza slices & Italian beef. Everything was fresh & delicious. Loved the pizza crust! We tried the gelato too which also was delicious! Don't miss thrift store across the way...definitely worth a look! read more

Miracle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

We got an 18" pepperoni pizza NY style. It was a great pizza, not overly doughy and a good flop. We also added the hot honey which was a nice touch. It was a great size for three guys as well. They delivered to us at the bar next door which was cool. They also offer square style pies which are also a favorite of mine. Next time we will try it. I will go back for sure. read more

Miracle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Would do a negative if possible... Extremely disappointing experience at Miracle Pizza in Birmingham. They are clearly understaffed, and it shows in every aspect of service. The staff appeared disengaged and frustrated, and unless you're an employee sitting at the bar, don't expect to be served with any urgency -- or at all. It's frustrating because they're in such a great location with every opportunity to thrive, and the area genuinely wants them to succeed. Unfortunately, time and time again, it just ends in disappointment rather than hospitality and good pizza. read more

What a neat little gem!! Great food, fast service, and some old school pinball machines that actually work!! HUGE bar!! I can see this being a popular local hangout! 10/10 recommended!! read more

See all

Did not deliver to Avondale. Confusing. Had to wait forever. Terrible customer service. Hair in food. read more

Miracle Pizza - Garlic knots with a black hair right after opening the container. Ordered from Avondale & had to go next store to wait 15 mins. Awful - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Since when does a simple pizza dough with tomato paste and toppings cost at least $23? I like their pizza, but these prices are hard to justify--this isn't a fancy restaurant, just a pizza place that's become ridiculously expensive. The pizzas are good, and the ambiance and service are solid, but the pricing is out of control. And charging $8-$10 per slice at Avondale concerts? That's just taking advantage of people. Great food, but the cost is a deal-breaker! read more

The pizza here was very good. They had a specialty Pizza. I think it was called apple and spinach so that was pretty good also but it should have been done with a alfredo sauce or white sauce. Some type of white sauce that would have been nice but other than that the staff was friendly. It was previously another pizza shop but then this one took over and everything was good. I really like it. I'll go back to get it read more

Miracle Pizza - Lots of eating space. - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Everything right with this pizza. Excellent wood fired bubble crust. And sauce/cheese/topping ratio was perfect.

We ordered the pepperoni pizza by the slice, and it was delicious! Bham has needed a New York style pizza by the slice, and this is definitely it! Highly recommend read more

Miracle Pizza - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

Inconsistent timing. If you're coming here on a linch break dont expect to be back to work on time. At least the pizza is good though.

Pizza was delicious. Nothing too crazy, but just good pizza that satisfied our cravings. Quick service too. I liked the inside of the place. It seems like it would also be a fun spot on the weekends to grab a beer. I would definitely recommend this place if you're ever in a Bham read more

The best pizza anywhere around! Ben does an amazing job with his special pizza dough. The garlic cream sauce was superb. Definitely will be repeat customers! read more

Miracle Pizza - Bianco pizza roasted garlic cream sauce, bacon, roasted chicken, spinach, mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

My intent was to visit Post Office Pies in Avondale, but one of my friends informed me that they are no longer in business. So, I decided to give Miracle Pizza a try. I got there a little after lunch, so I did not have to wait to place my order. The lady who took my order was very pleasant and offered suggestions based on questions she asked. I ordered the Buffalo Chicken twist and the Meat and Greet Pizza to go. My loves pizza and would eat it every day if he could.  The Buffalo Chicken twist good. I have certain meat to bread ratio for sandwiches an other handhelds. They were really good. I thought they would be doughy with little protein and I was pleasantly surprised. As for the pizza, it was also good. The flavor profile is very different from its predecessor, but it was still very good. The crust was thoroughly cooked, but not burned. Overall, I would definitely recommend it to anyone that loves pizza. read more

Pizza good. Salad terrible- lettuce old and had gone bad- Lettuce brown and slimey Give it a try- but don't expect a fresh salad. read more

The best pizza in the state. Friendly staff. Order at the counter. There are pinball machines in the back. read more

Miracle Pizza - Mushroom pizza is beyond good - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Been here a few times while going to concerts and once for lunch. Love the pizza by the slice and my girlfriend and I shared their Eat Your Veggies special. The Veggie was so good we ate all but 2 slices and I didn't miss having any meats on it. Service has been consistent, super friendly and professional. Spare yourself the wait at Black Market and make a Miracle happen. read more

Delicious! After eating pizza in Italy, my son thought he'd never eat pizza the same in USA . Well after eating there last weekend he called me to report this was a SOLID- meaning delicious !! Can't wait ti have a slice soon. read more

The garlic and mozz roll was fine, but the pizza and wings were very below average. Pizza seemed like it had been cooked earlier and was just thrown back in for a min to reheat. Wings were soggy and flavors were lacking. They also didn't have multiple items on the menu, not only had some run out, but many they just weren't serving. Staff was nice. The wing happy hour didn't start till 7, which we didn't know, but they were willing to do it for us anyway. Food runner had no idea what we had ordered, brought us the wrong things multiple times, but had a good attitude. read more

We were very sad that post office pies left, but this place is an upgrade! Very happy with the quality of pizza. Don't be scared to ask for the pizza well done. This dough is great with some char on it. We will definitely be back. read more

Miracle Pizza - Slice of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Birmingham, Alabama

See all

Great pizza, and awesome staff. Always loved Post Office Pies at this location and the interior is unchanged. Will definitely return!

New favorite!!! Superb fresh ingredients, unique options, classics as well. Got the meat and greet and it was phenomenal! Great staff and atmosphere!!! read more

The pizza was just ok. They were out of one of the items we specifically came for. Not one employee seemed as if they even cared we were there- they were... cordial? It was odd. 1/2 of the employees were snacking as they walked around the restaurant which I found off putting. The bathrooms were clean which is the only reason I chose 2 stars. There's much better pizza and much better service in Birmingham. read more

Excellent Pizza! Excellent Service! Wonderful Wine! Cool Vibe with Cool People! Just steps from Avondale Brewery where our concert was! Thanks Yelp for a 5 Star Fun Find! read more

Excellent pizza . Friendly staff . Looking forward to Lunch's here when they start opening for it May21st . read more

We dove into Miracle Pizza Company prior to attending a concert next door at Avondale Brewery. We ordered the double pepperoni pizza. The pizza has a thin crust, lots of cheese, and lots of small pepperonis. The pizza was good--a tad greasy for my taste. We debated trying the veggie pizza--wish we had. Unfortunately, they botched our order somehow--you could smell burnt pizza in the air. Some others got their food 15-20 before us. They were nice about it and gave us two complimentary drinks. They have an attentive wait staff who are friendly. read more

Food was good, but customer service was dry . I wouldn't eat here again because I didn't feel welcomed but as stated before the food was tasty. read more

The absolute BEST thing I have ever tasted is the Magic City Mushroom pizza! Layers of flavor, very high quality ingredients, especially the mushrooms...just to die for! And the veggie pizza was so fresh, the vegetables looked like they were picked that very day! Not too well done, no sogginess to be found. Would recommend to anyone! read more

Great pizza! Awesome staff! Definitely my fav by the slice place. Great addition to Avondale!

Came to try this place out based off of reviews. Place was empty. Typically that says it all but we gave it a go. Sadly we left quite disappointed. Pizza was ok. I've had much better but also had worse. Biggest problem was the massive roach that scampered across my feet as I sat and ate. Left me wondering how many more of these are running around in the kitchen. Roaches equal 1 star for me. Health violations are a no go. Tons of pizza options in Birmingham. I won't be giving this one another try. read more

Hot honey pizza is one of the best in the city. They also make cannolis in house!! Wife and I got it to go, took about 15 mins.