Really really really good pizza! Nice cozy and quiet spot. Their other food is really good also and…read morethey service is stellar. Def can't wait to go back.

I've been coming here for years I do love their Sicilian slices. It's always the right mix of good…read morequality cheese, sauce and dough. I have never gotten a bad pizza from them ever. You can order at the counter or if you want you can sit down restaurant style and they do have a restaurant style expanded menu of pasta and etc. The service is very good be it at the counter or the waitress. It's a nice casual place to bring a date or a group They usually have soccer on TV if your fan of that sport. It's definitely worth a visit

I have passed by this place for yrs on the way to my parents house and never really gave it a try…read moreonly because we usually get pizza from Joey D's, Angelinas, or Rodolpho's...But this past Saturday when I was thinking about what I wanted to have for dinner Ottos popped into my head and I thought "why not give that place Otto's a try"...I really love the fact that their website has pictures of all of the menu items and lists all of the toppings/ingredients for their pizzas/specialty pizzas. This way you know visually what to expect. I placed a phone order for pick up. We got a white pie with onions and the honey mustard chicken wrap. The pizzeria is in a small strip mall where Piscataway could be South Plainfield but also could be, or is approaching Plainfield... IYKYK, if you're local to the area and know this road intersection haha...if you drive too fast you may miss it...When I went inside was greeted by a gentleman at the register and a young lady with glasses that was putting together and organizing orders. Both individuals were friendly and smiling...The gentleman was having a passionate discussion with a customer about the Knicks etc while we were waiting for our food...I like when you go places like pizzerias and take out spots that the people working there engage with customers, so it was cool, I am a Knick fan, so I hopped in the conversation myself...As I was standing there I looked into the display case and the buffalo chicken pizza caught my attention, so I asked if a slice could be added to my order...In total a personal white pie with onions, the chicken wrap, and the buff chix slice came to about $34. We really enjoyed the white pie and the buffalo chicken slice we ended up splitting (I was only supposed to be getting the wrap since I am watching my calories). I had a few bites of a slice of the white pie and it was super flavorful, creamy/rich from the cheeses, and really hit the spot. We really find ourselves ordering less and less traditional tomato sauce pies...so when you find a place that does a white pie well...Its noteworthy... The buffalo chicken slice was one of the best I have had (Two Tony's in Linden and Italian Village in Plainfield are what I always compare buffalo slices to, because they are top tier pizzerias for buffalo chix). Otto's uses the right amount of buffalo sauce and ranch. Looks like they toss the chicken pieces in the hot sauce whereas some other places just do a diagonal drizzle of buffalo and a diagonal drizzle of ranch. The honey mustard chicken wrap was great. The breaded chicken...I am not for certain, but tasted like storemade/homemade breaded cutlet, as opposed to frozen breaded chicken tenders...I mean if it is frozen chicken that is just tossed in the fryer, then its the best frozen chicken I have had in a long time, and I am still not mad at it haha I am not sure what brand of honey mustard they use but its very good def will be getting the wrap again...I really wished I had went to Ottos sooner than I did...Its a "hidden gem"...We have been missing out all this time...I see the 4-star rating here on Yelp, and I am confused why it isnt higher. The pizza is right on par with the other spots that I frequent that I mentioned at the beginning of my review, and is head and shoulders above alot of the other places in Edison-Piscataway-South Plainfield that I wont even bother mentioning. Def go to Ottos to get a pie next time you are in the mood for pizza! Sorry no photos were taken for this particular review but again...If you go to their website...what you see is what you end up with.

Called ahead to order two slices to go. They are one of the only places open at 10am, so I was…read moreinterested in trying for future "early lunches." When I arrived, the food was already bagged and ready to go. It was pretty good! A tad too much cheese, but the sauce was on the sweet side, which I like. I would definitely go back again, now that I know they exist and are open early!

This is a mainstay of Piscataway and we need to support this place! It's been years since I've been…read morehere, but my new coworkers and I started ordering here every other week. The prices are unbelievable and the food is abundant. The free bread that comes with the pasta is bigger than the pasta itself, and it's very good on its own! The staff are so friendly and greet you like an old friend. The ambiance is super outdated, but that's part of the charm. The food, the service, and the place is the definition of "comfort food." Please continue to support Stelton Pizza so that it can stick around for years to come!

I tried few pizza types and they tasted horrible, bad quality of ingredients, regular oil instead…read moreof olive oil, disgusting...also they touch the slices with their hands directly.

Local pizza shop run by the same guys for decades. Solid pizza, especially the plain cheese and the…read moresausage because they shave the sausage and it's not big pieces. Good sandwiches and Italian American entrees

Just okay. One of the only pick up areas I town so it is nice to just get a slice rather than a…read morewhole pie. Wish I could review higher, but the cheese isn't fresh enough, doesn't have much of a pull when bite into a slice. Sauce in the plain is overly sweet. I think there's potential here, but changes need to be made in order to improve.

8/22/25 - I pregamed at Panatieri's Pizza in Bound Brook. It had pretty decent reviews and after…read morelast night, average pizza would've been a step up. The good: The sauce is savory and delicious. The cheese is premium. It has seasonings you can taste. The crust on the plain has good flavor. And the edge crust is crispy and chewy without being dry. The bad: the bottom crust on the plain slice does not hold up--- it's very limp. And again, the Sicilian slice lacked that Sicilian flavor. Its been a few restaurant visits since I found a square that I loved. We gave the girl at the front a simple order. One plain, one pepperoni, one pasta slice and one Sicilian slice. She seemed more interested in laughing with co-workers than my order so it was no surprise to see her only put three of the four in the oven. All the tables were appropriately stocked with napkins and condiments.... except for ours. Not a deal breaker but annoying nonetheless. Overall Rating: B- To be fair, it probably should've been a higher score because the pizza was pretty good. But I include service in my scores so their deduction was well deserved.

This place is one of my go-to's now. I like to come here for dinner and then go to Billiards Lucy…read moreacross the street afterwards, so I definitely like this location. I like how there is a huge menu here at this location. I always go with the fettuccine Alfredo and add breaded chicken. It is always a hit. They also bring bread rolls and a salad when you get an entree. The pizza is also very solid here. They have a good sit-down service here, but you can also just order and take your food to go if you don't feel like sitting down. It is also very affordable here too. My pasta entree that I got last week was only about 20 dollars, considering it is very filling and it comes with the bread and salad. Overall, you should definitely try out this Panatieri's location!

Fast and friendly service. There's several tables to sit and eat, but most people get takeout…read more Pizza was good, but it has A LOT of cheese on it, so it's very filling.

Been ordering from there for a few years. Unfortunately last night I ordered 2 cheesesteaks & it…read morehad yellow american cheese inside. YUCK! Due to the late pickup they were closed once I got home. Called today to see if anything could be done since I didn't eat it. Nope. Not even willing to remake it with another type of cheese. Will not be ordering there again. $32 wasted.

Service is bad. Placed an order online it said 20 minutes I get there 20 minutes later. The guy…read moresays 25 more minutes. I have to work I didn't have time. He was not friendly he said the pies take that long. The grandma pies. Someone needs to teach him time management and efficiency. He spends too much time running around pizzas never make it in the oven. I was in there for like 15 minutes and he never got one in.

I ordered here for pick up and it was ready within 15 mins!! Super quick. The food was absolutely…read moredelicious. The wrap is huge and the fries are cooked to perfection. It was only $13 for all of this food!!! I like how they gave Cesar dressing on the side and didn't saturate my wrap in dressing. They also gave plenty of ketchup packets for the fries. I will definitely be returning!!!! Thank you for this great lunch.

Super friendly and accommodating owners. Very large menu; lots of choices. The pizza display case…read moreis quite artistic and colorful. Most importantly the food ; pizza, salad, pasta were delicious. Almost as important is that Carlo is a big time Yankee fan.

I walked in expecting a simple meal, but the experience was humiliating. The young woman was kind,…read morebut I took a little time because I'm feeling under the weather, and the men working there kept giving me hostile looks--as if they didn't want me there. Their attitude was so rude that I only ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a soda, even though I had planned to order a whole pizza. After one bite, I threw the slice away, took my soda, and ate at the restaurant next door instead. No customer should be made to feel unwelcome or discriminated against. The community should not ignore this kind of treatment. There are award-winning pizza places in Somerville and Raritan where customers are treated with respect and appreciation. I will never return to this place.