We stop here every year while at the cape. This place is located on Main Street in Hyannis. The pizza is excellent, just like the pizza in Italy. We usually get the lunch special which is a personal pizza and a salad. If you love Italian pizza this is the place to go. Excellent wood fire oven pizza with fresh ingredients. They also have their own garden on the roof in the summertime and the cook creates unique dishes. read more

See all

Pizza was amazing. Very close to Italy and NYC. Outstanding gluten free. Meatballs we delicious! Salad had very fresh ingredients. Well prepared for COVID! read more

Real wood fired pizza (yes - a bitter New Yorker tired of false advertising). Service was friendly and excellent. Pizza was outstanding - chewy slightly charred crust. Salads were also very good. A lunch mate said the cauliflower was delicious. read more

Under renovation right now. When they were open for business they had interesting and innovative pizzas. Keep an eye out for the reopening it will be worth the wait! read more

The pizza was excellent, service was good and very nice atmosphere I would highly recommend!!

The best pizza in Cape Cod! The gluten free pizza was phenomenal and definitely the best gluten free pizza I have ever had. Wish I lived here so I could eat it every day. 10/10 !! read more

Pizza Barbone - Gluten Free Burrata Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Just like Italy! We both had the lunch special...mixed green salad, 12" pizza and soda ( skipped in favor of wine). The salad was perfect, fresh, crisp, dressed perfectly. The pizzas were a wonderful mix of charred crust with the right chew. Highly recommend the sweet sausage!! The server was friendly, attentive but did not over do it. If we were locals, this would be our go-to. read more

I would be careful ordering dessert at Pizza Barbone. My 84 yr old mother ordered the Orange Cannoli and it smelled and tasted just dreadful. We asked one of the staff members to taste the Cannoli and he brought it back to the kitchen. They actually came back and said to us, and I quote, "Sorry, that Cannoli got into a bin with Vinegar and Soap" "Would you like another dessert?" Oh sure bring it on! We will not be going back to PB- good luck- if you order dessert ask what bin it was in :) read more

Good spot, pizza was pretty good. We got mushroom arranchini and they out honey on it, which to me ruined it it was to sweet.

Cool pizza place with great salads, pizza, and desserts. I've only eaten the pizza, but all the other stuff sounds great. There is even a cashew cheese option for an extra $2 for dairy-free folks. They also have a marinara pizza that comes with no cheese. I tried the cashew cheese and liked it more than Daiya cheese (which I'm not a fan of). They apparently have dairy free gelato, too! The interior of the place is really swank with a cool modern style and the alternative rock play list is equally awesome. Friendly staff as well. read more

Pizza Barbone - Margarita pizza with vegan in house made cashew cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

No one waiting no at the front. A few tables open. Handful of people at the bar. Told 45-60min. Huh? I guess this is a restaurant that tells you at the door if you are allowed to eat or not. They apparently don't take a woman with a baby belly and three kids with her husband that's mix. What's with the crazy bias here? It's the off-season. There was no one waiting at the front not a single human. During the summer do they just separate people at the door like a nightclub? You can come in you can't. No reason. Sucks. I guess the vegan cheese is that sought after. **In response to staff response. 2/18/2018 @ 1030pm. This is what your website says. This is why we did not make a reservation (we figured limited meant only for large parties or special events not for the whole evening anyone can book that would be unlimited). "Reservations are not accepted between May 1st and September 30th. We do accept a limited amount of daily reservations in our off-season between October 1st and April 30th." If the entire restaurant was reserved this statement would not be correct as it says limited. I would've loved to eat here but I am just not believing what I am hearing unfortunately and it's frustrating. read more

I've been to Pizza Barbone a couple of times now. My husband thought the Sopressata pizza was excellent and also liked the meatballs. I recently modified the Bianco Verde pizza to be just roasted garlic and cheese without the arugala and balsamic because I like cheesy bread and it was awesome. The Pistachio pesto was also good, but I was thinking it would be with pesto made out of pistachios instead o basil pesto with pistachios on top. The pizzas have a nice chewy crust but aren't the most flavorful. read more

Got curbside pickup here: mozz-pepperoni pizza, kungpao brussel sprouts, and cavatelli bolognese. Pizza was ok, quite small - nothing special. The pasta was quite good, but the brussel sprouts were a disappointment - hard, bordering on raw. I made much better brussel sprouts at home! 4 stars for the pasta, 3 for the pizza, 2 for the sprouts - av of 3. read more

Pizza and service are great. I wouldn't recommend kids that can be picky with food. Their not expecting a gourmet like pizza. Took my brother for his birthday and they give a nice desert with a candle ! read more

Pizza Barbone - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Pro-tip go for a late lunch unless you want to wait forever.... That's how amazing this pizza is. Be sure to peep the specials too. I have been blown away with items on that line-up. read more

Great place. Nice interior and clean. Well staffed and friendly. Pizzas were excellent - very tasty.

Pizza sauce. Cheese and toppings very scant and price very high. Service was ok but it was not worth the money. Ambiance is ok but my order was to go. read more

I am a bit of a snob when it comes to thin crust pizza and this blew me away! I'm not used to a thin crust that still has a little softness to it but it worked!! My Buffalo margarita was cooked perfectly, had lots of basil and lots of super fresh sauce with a nice bright flavor. This is on my list as a must do anytime I'm on the cape!! read more

Pizza Barbone - Buffalo Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Food: Standard Neopolitan pizza. Ambience: NA (did takeout). Quick view of the restaurant looks pretty nice, with outdoor and indoor seating. Price: Very "reasonable" for Neopolitan pizzas. These are usually more expensive, so 15-17 bucks for a 12'' pie is actually very reasonable compared to some of the restaurants in Boston. Meatball was a bit too salty. Service: NA (did takeout) read more

The best pesto and pistachio pizza I have ever had in my life! I would come here again hands down!

Pizza Barbone is just simply a great eat. If you are hungry and happen to be walking around Hyannis then you are definitely in for a treat. We came to Barbone for lunch and ordered Barbone meatballs as an appetizer (which we got right away) and margarita pizza and a sweet sausage pizza. If you are thirsty and want a refreshing drink with your pizza or meatballs I went for the lemonade which simply made my day. In conclusion, Pizza Barbone was a great pizza place and if I happen to come to Hyannis again this place would definitely be a big win-win. read more

Pizza Barbone - As you can see in this picture, I would definitely do anything for just a slice of this pizza. Thank you Pizza Barbone. - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Exceptional!!! As good as any pizza that I have had in New York, Staten Island or Brooklyn. Amazing coal fired crust ..... must try!!!!! read more

We have only done take out the past pandemic years, but the quality of the food is great. We have tried a few of the pizzas, and the pistachio pesto remains our favorite. read more

Just don't go there. Ordered a pepperoni pizza, and chicken tenders for pick up, and I couldn't be more grossed out, and disappointed. Look at the state of these! They were also a bit pink inside as well. Not an ounce of seasoning, it was like chewing on a dog toy. Awful!!! And not only that, the pepperoni pizza was $20 and was only a personal sized one! So bad. The chicken was around $14. Never agajn!!!! read more

Pizza Barbone - Chicken tenders - Pizza Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Service, service, service. Horrible wait for take out. Over 45 minutes. No offer of a discount of any sort. The restaurant was pretty slammed although people that sat down after us received their food before us. Food overall was fine. One last thing, the romaine salad that we received for takeout did not have the appearance of what was typically served. Our salad was all chopped up None of the hearts were left intact. What a disappointment after a beautiful day spent at Martha's Vineyard. read more

Overpriced pizza with a soggy crust. Won't be going there again. Not sure where the hype comes from for this place

Simply delicious! We had the forest mushroom pizza and meatballs, then shared the tiramisu ice cream sandwich. Great service too!

Super great place. Awesome atmosphere and decor. Fairly priced for obviously fresh ingredients. The choices are unique and are refreshing combinations. I can even go with my vegan friends! Super yummy. read more

Excellent pizza. I ordered takeout and it was ready very quickly (15 minutes). The ingredients were very fresh and the red sauce was some of the best that I've ever tasted. Also, the crust was just right. I would highly recommend...best pizza in the Hyannis area. read more

Okay pizza for the cape, but not in the category of great pizza. I've been to some of the great pizza places in the US - Di Fara, Pepes, Pizzeria Bianco - and Pizza Barbone isn't in that class. Barbone has some interesting toppings, but the crust was disappointing for what was supposed to be Neapolitan style pizza in a wood oven. Most notably the crust was bready. The dough should have been pocketed with big blisters where the dough would have risen in a 700-900 degree oven. We ordered three pizzas margherita, mushroom, and pork belly with hot honey. The flavor of the tomato sauce came through on the margherita and that was the best for my tastes. The fancy pork belly pizza with hot honey was interesting but the sweetness of the honey made me feel like I was eating a dessert. If you're in Hyannis, Pizza Barbone is worth checking out, but it's not a destination that I would go out of my way for the pizza. read more

Gonna give it 4 stars because the owners were so nice the pizzas wwre a little to undercooked but the flavor was definately there the owner was so pleasant and kind read more

This is my favorite spot for lunch in Hyannis. Although Pizza is their keynote item, I go there for the salads which are sensational. And the service is fantastic! Maggie Davis Nutritionist read more

Went to Pizza Barbone late afternoon and got a classic cheese pizza and a Mesculin salad. We sat outside at the picnic bench and the vibe was very European....which was great...what was even greater was the awesome salad with dressing fro heaven and a perfect pizza. I have eaten there many times over the years....and will continue to do so....! read more

Stopped here on a rainy night for dinner after a day in Provincetown, craving pizza. This appeared to be the perfect Yelp recommendation, which proved itself to be slightly disappointing. We first shared the asparagus and buffala for appetizers, definitely worth trying if you ever are hungry enough to start your meal with an appetizer. These alone are worth 5 stars. The staff is super nice, from the hostess to the servers, always smiling, checking on us a few times during the meal. The decoration is well done, and the tables/seats are simple yet extremely comfortable. Then we moved on to individual pizzas, and with 6 of us at the table, opinions were divided. The mushroom pizza was super tasty, and so was the margherita; these 2 being the home runs. On the other end we were not impressed by the Mashed potatoes and the pesto ones which were really too dry and not as tasty. For all of them, one sure thing is that the dough is fantastic, as someone who always leaves the crust behind, i couldn't resist this time! Few things to note: - wouldn't recommend drinking wine from this place, as we tried a few which really weren't impressive, and served in soda glasses (definitely doesn't help making wine any more enjoyable). - expect to be there for a long time/dont go starving, because it is very slow. We did have a large party but the wait time between our appetizers and the pizzas was too long. Would I recommend this place? yes for appetizers and some of the pizza, especially if you are looking for a great service. Do i think it is currently overrated ? maybe a little... we had high expectations with the previous reviews and were not so nicely impressed overall. read more

Pretty good place, good location, nice aesthetic and beautiful pizza oven. Really wish they put it to better use though. It's good pizza, I wish it was great pizza. It's not a place you go and then think about after and sort of have delicious flavorful flashbacks about. They have a lot going for them but also have not maximized there full potential, not even close. I would love to see what another chef could do with this set up. I don't wanna be too negative, it's a really nice place, really nice people, good pizza. I just want it to be the best pizza place in the whole world and it's just not. But I believe it has the potential. read more

This isn't the downtown rush pizza place. Everything is amazing. Such a comfortable space to dine in and every bite was melt in your mouth amazing. read more

See all

Can't wait to go back! I am newly dairy free and also gluten free (neither by choice). When my husband received a gift card for Pizza Barbone I was hesitant to go considering I can't order a cheesy delicious pizza. To my surprise it was a hidden gem for gluten free and dairy free pizza. The crust was the best I've ever had and they also make their own cashew mozzarella. My husband who typically does not like gf or vegan options thought the pizza tasted great! For dessert I ordered the vegan lemon gelato :) The dairy free and gf pizza 12" thin crust cost $21 but felt it was totally worth it. Staff was so kind and welcoming. read more

After doing some sight seeing we stopped in here for a early dinner. As we were walking up we wondered if they even had sit down tables. They do, it was small on the inside but well decorated and clean. Quite a few servers working who were easily able to handle the customers sitting down and the people picking up orders. To start with we ordered zucchini fries and arancini balls. Both were very good, light breading on the zucchini and served with a tasty ranch aioli. For dinner we ordered four pizzas. Pistachio pesto, forest mushroom, bianchi, and potato. They were all good. I enjoyed the wood fire crust. Not overly crisp or soggy a perfect mix. I would say the table's favorite pizza was the pistachio. The least favorite was the mushroom. I think it was the rosemary on the pizza which was a bit overpowering. Price wise for four people, two glasses of wine, two beers, starters and four pizzas it was reasonable. We enjoyed this restaurant and would go again if we are ever in the area again. read more

Excellent meal served with a smile! We ate there on Saturday 11/21/2020; the food, the wine, the service were all outstanding. We had the Prix fix meal, large salad, really good fried mozzarella with marinara, spaghetti and meatballs, and Tiramisu gelato for dessert. YUMMY! Always exceptional, never disappointed in Pizza Barbone! read more

Awesome pizza and service! Unbelievable oven leads to nice napolitano style pizza! You can tell they use great ingredients. We had a seamless online ordering experience. Really appreciate their efforts during the covid crisis. read more