It was likely our mistake to order salads from a place named Pizza Shark. Pizza Shark was so highly recommended that we were looking forward to our lunch. We ordered the Buffalo Chicken Salad. We both agree that it was the worst salad we have had in a long time. The ingredients were fresh. Upon opening the container, there were three large wedges of lettuce and a small container of blue cheese dressing. In order to find the additional ingredients, we had to dig under the lettuce wedges to find the two cherry tomatoes sliced in half. Several cucumber slices were hidden under the lettuce wedges. The wedges were so large that cutting them to a size that would be edible with a plastic fork and knife was impossible,. Tucked under the wedges was a buffalo chicken tender. We ended up pulling the wedges apart after the forks and knives broke and eating it with our fingers. The salad was inedible after a few minutes of frustration. I understand that presentation suffers with takeout, but this was ridiculous . read more

A small place which provides excellent pizza at reasonable prices The service is attentive and prompt. read more

Perfect pizza, highly recommend! As we were staying at an air B n b there wasn't a good oven for reheating. Even at room temp it was great!

Tried this place a couple years back with a mediocre result. Thought we'd give it another go but really not improved from before. We ordered a large pizza (only small and large sizes available) with half double pepperoni and half hamburger. Wait time was not long and they give you a buzzer if you want to wait in your car (no seating available in the shop). This is a take out place only. Got home with the pizza and opened the box and was disappointed by the amount of pepperoni that was on it so I'm not sure they understood the double part of the order. Taste was good but my mouth felt like it was duking it out with the crust. The crust was very tough and had to be torn apart more than biting a piece. They do have an excellent selection of chips, candy, and drinks. Person behind the counter was very pleasant and handled the order process quickly. Unfortunately this experience and the one previous means that we won't be returning. read more

Pizza Shark - Half double pepperoni and half hamburger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

After a long trail walk we were ready for pizza! I had found this spot online before we came and with it being our last day on the Cape I had to make sure we gave it a try! After perusing all the tasty sounding offerings we decided to the Tiger and only ordered a small. The small was plenty for two people and it was so nice to be able to sit in the shade on the picnic tables nearby. There were only three though, and this spot is on the rail trail (bike trail) so I imagine it could be busy in peak season. The pizza was so delicious though so even if you have to take it to go, make sure you give it a try! Lots of chicken and saucy and the crust is great too! I was hoping they would have a kombucha in the shop but no such luck. I did snag a bag of tasty chips to drag to the beach later and there are plenty of soft drinks and other snacks on offer as well. Oh and this place is quite the bargain too, as food goes on the Cape. Good to know, right?! read more

See all

Pizza shark has many fun pizza options and makes their own delicious sodas! The service was quick and you can get beer there as well! Just be aware that the vibe seems pretty aimed at takeout only. read more

Great pizza, interesting shop with lots of additional items if needed including ice cream. Shark style definitely has a kick, I loved it but if you don't like spice I would pass. read more

Really good pizza! We had the Megladon and the Say Cheese pizzas with Caesar salad. Everyone was satisfied and we'd definitely recommend. Service was as pretty good if you overlook the sour pusses on the teen employees who didn't want to be working on a summer Saturday night. Our order was correct and ready when we arrived for pickup. read more

Had a pizza late afternoon. I called it in. It was not good it was like a left over . It was chewy. I get my pizza there all the time This is the first time it's happened . read more

We were so tired after an 8 hr drive and arrived to Harwich in the pouring rain. Stopped off here in desperation for some milk or juice, bread and wine to bring back to the house. The girl inside was delightful! So welcoming, so happy- I saw the pizzas flying out the door for pickup- ordered a pepperoni one and waited with a beeper. It really only took 10 min on a busy night. Delicious! Great looking- great tasting! Great yummy crust! Can't wait to try the ice cream! Fabulous place for a quieter area! read more

Visiting during the office season, we saw how highly rated this location was and stopped in for some take-out pizzas. The meat lovers pizza was so loaded, 1 slice was a meal in itself. I personally loved the "Great White" pizza, which was so cheesy and flavorful, we added mushrooms on ours and they don't skimp on the toppings here. We ordered online and was ready at the time estimated. Staff was very friendly and prices reasonable for the area and the amount of toppings. The location itself was a little hard to find as we were looking for a sign that says Pizza Shark, but actually it says pleasant lake general store. Excellent pizza, highly recommended! read more

Pizza Shark - Large Great White with added Mushroom,Yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

See all

Reasonable prices and the pizza was so delicious.. especially when your camping and don't want to go out and you want to eat pizza by the camp fire read more

Very delicious pizza totally recommend. Their crust is also very crunchy and amazing best crust ever! The place is very clean and staff are friendly! read more

Decent pizza - we did take out. Cheese, sausage, Hawaiian and a salad. Liked the ratio of cheese and toppings to crust. Crust was a little tough. read more

Pizza Shark - Half cheese half sausage - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

See all

Walked into this place and the Beatles were blasting, and the Pizza chef was singing while my guitar gently weeps. This is my kind of joint. Pizza was excellent. read more

I really love that they have used the old store at Pleasant Lake to restore it into a nice pizza place. We tried the Great White shark pizza and it was really good. I also added the Calabrian Chili Oil and it added a nice kick, which is unusual for a pizza, but it hit the right spot for me and those that like spice. They have a really nice selection of pizzas that are much more different than the traditional choices that you see everywhere, so I applaud them for their creativity. My only feedback is that we waited for the pizza and took it home to find it too cold, even though we are five minutes away. Not sure if it was not cooked hot enough or if the box did not support it keeping it hotter, but we did put it in our toaster and it was just right. Great concept and great place to eat. read more

In the food desert that is Cape Cod, pizza is a luxury. As Pizza Shark expanded into Chatham I was hopeful. New England Pizza is under cooked and disgusting....Carmines, are they ever open? Unfortunately Pizza Shark has chosen to lead as the "economy" vendor in town. Whoever designed this menu did so off a spreadsheet: Evidently toppings are so expensive that they need to be regulated into scarcity. So fair warning, if you want a pizza with more than just cheese on it, Pizza Shark isn't for you. The owner is too busy counting the peppers and onions. read more

Yum! This place is right on the rail trail. We each got a slice (plain, pepperoni, and 'breakfast'- red and yellow pepper with scrambled eggs, which sounds weird but was delicious). This little market also has drinks and chips and other snacks, as well as ice cream, making a perfect little spot on the rail trail. There are a couple steps in, so it is not wheelchair friendly . read more

Awesome takeout-only pizza shop right along the Cape Cod Rail Trail! Couldn't decide what to eat for a late dinner and spotted Pizza Shark was still open! We ordered their signature pizza "The Great White" which is a white pie topped with olive oil, garlic, ricotta, buffalo mozzarella & basil. As recommended, we got it "shark style" which means it comes drizzled with Calabrian chili oil....WOW! Amazing. May have been one of the best pizzas we've ever had (and we're from CT where New Haven style Apizza comes from...just saying). Definitely don't sleep on this new pizza joint!! read more

Pizza Shark - The Great White "shark style" - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

One of my go to spots! My favorite is the cranberry walnut salad with chicken but the pizza is great too. Food is always fresh, delicious and reasonable prices read more

I am gluten free and finding really gf pizza is incredibly hard. Most taste like cardboard with tomato sauce on top. Pizza Shark literally has the best gf pizza I have ever eaten. I lived most of my life in NYC and I still say this. The crust is chewy and delicious, the toppings are generous, the staff incredibly friendly, and the prices are competitive. read more

I used to love this place but lately they just have been disappointing me. Usually the pizza was my favorite! But the last few times I felt as though O might've well ordered dominos. The people are always so pleasant! And I love how legitimate they are with their times when you order because the parking lot is super small. The area you go into pick up is small but so quaint! Tiger Shark! My favorite but not lately, sadly. read more

Great pizza, great giffords ice cream. Perfect place along the rail trail to stop. Swimming is right across the street and the little shop is everything you could need. Also adorable merchandise. read more

Great Pizza! Pepperoni, Aloha and Goblin all got equally good reviews. I ordered on line and it was ready upon arrival. Got some ice cream too!.....can't get that at the other pizza spots! Try the BLUEBERRY!!! Glad to see someone saved this great old building. I went there for candy & soda on my Schwinn in the 70s read more

See all

Pizza Shark tv commercials are funny. I was golfing in Harwich, so ordered a Shark hamburg & onion pizza after. Terrific. Large was a good sized pie. Right amount of toppings. Correctly cooked. If you're in the area, Pizza Shark is the real real. read more

Ordered a large meatball pizza with extra cheese and sauce and ricotta cheese on it and it was stupidly good. Hot out of the oven and in my hands 30 min from imagining it. Friendly staff, delicious food (cranberry walnut salad excellent as well) Highly recommend for your year round pizza enjoyment on the Cape read more

The people in my party like their pizza, but the server behind the bar was rude. We waited a long time. She forgot to put in part of our order & got something wrong that was allergy related. read more

Loved this pizza. My favorite in the Harwich, Dennisport, Chatham area. What was very impressive was the way they followed my instructions on the online ordering site. I asked for "very light sauce" and they executed perfectly!! Wait time was appropriate for Summer on the Cape and the staff was very friendly when I picked it up. My new "go to"! read more

Pizza Shark - Small cheese - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

See all

Artistic pizza. Fun combinations and funny metaphors for pizza using different types of sharks. No dining area. Just take out. read more

Pizza Shark - Deep blue pizza $16 (hamburger meat, blue cheese, caramelized onions) - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

See all

While sandwiches are OK I was in very disappointed by lack of vegetarian options. Live nearby and would love to come in regularly but limited menu is a turn off. (The nice young counter girl is vegan and there was nothing for her!) Is management aware of current trends in nutrition? Jake read more

Pizza Shark is so good that I am willing to advertise for them for free (i.e. I purchased their branded sweatshirt in a very nicely faded navy blue color). Larry and I actually tried a slice from the Chatham outpost first (see my other review!), and it was so good that we ended up ordering an entire pizza pie from this Pleasant Lake location since we were staying in Harwich. This pizza is so, so good, I think about it at least once a week. Pizza Shark, if you're reading this, please put me out of my misery already and open a location in Melrose, MA. read more

Small corner store type vibe, but my God does this pizza slap. Walking in my expectations were very low because it was like a mini liquor store, but the shark-named pizza was amazing. The meatlovers and chicken/ranch pizzas were nothing short of top notch. Strongly recommend. read more

Pizza Shark - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza crust was hard to chew and lacked toppings, including sauce. It was...just ok. The location was great.

Pizza shark is a huge YES from me. We get the great white and my goodness does it hit different. I'm saying it now best pizza on the cape. Ingredients are quality and the crust and delicious. You cannot go wrong here. read more

Pizza Shark - Great white with added red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Harwich, Massachusetts

The place was cute and quaint.. pizza was amazing. The young lady helping us was very nice .. we didn't get to try the ice cream because we arrived just in time for only pizza.. it was my first time in Massachusetts, we were staying in Cape Cod.. but are from Los Angeles.. definitely will remember this place for there delicious pizza and friendliness read more

We were visiting friends in Harwich Port and decided to try Pizza Shark for a group dinner. We got the megalodon for the meat eaters of the group, the nurse shark, a cheese pizza for the kids and decided to try to The Great White Shark Style). No one professed to be a "white pizza person", but The Great White was the crowd favorite!! All were excellent! I would highly recommend, and we will put this on our cape rotation. A definite must try! read more

I can't believe this place remains in business. This is the WORST pizza I have had in a decade or more. Are all of these positive reviews written by their friends, or does the general public just have terrible taste or not know what good pizza actually is? We ordered 7 or 8 pizzas for a house. No one with taste liked it. Avoid. read more

Yes they accepted a large group of kids very appreciated we got pizza soda very good business

For the first time in a long time, we ordered from a place that got our order 100% correct AND it was all SO good! Would definitely come back when we are in the area again. Food was really, really good! read more

Best gluten free pizza I have ever eaten. As close to regular pizza I have come across anywhere. Most times the crust tastes like cardboard, but their's is chewy and has that taste one associates with good pizza dough. Highly, highly recommended. read more