It's an ok pizza, in an area where the pizza is fairly mediocre. Little pricey, but not a surprise on the Cape. Greasy, so use some napkins to soak up some of the grease before you drip on your shirt :) read more

New England Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

This is the eggplant Parmesan that I just received. I also got a Greek salad that was half the portion that they normally serve. You decide. read more

New England Pizza - This is the eggplant parm that I pay 27.00 for. The Greek salad was half a portion $12. You decide. - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Best salad dressing in the world. Hands down. Dave Portnoy missed this spot on his pizza tour of the Cape!

Upping my review and I will explain. Is this the best pizza? No. Is it ok? Yes. But on Valentine's night when we were back in Chatham, and when many, many other restaurants were closed, New England was open and doing their safe curbside pick up. It was a perfect Valentine dinner for us back at our cottage. Leftovers for lunch the next day. We watched a good movie and enjoyed with a nice red wine. It was a cold wintry weekend. New England pizza meant cheer and warmth. I hope all our favorite restaurants and pubs can open back up and we are grateful New England still has its ovens on. read more

See all

We enjoyed the pizza here. My wife is a pizza maker and is keenly critical of crust, sauce, cheese, etc. While this was not the world's finest pizza, it was a surprisingly good product. A local friend recommended it to us, and we approved. We did take-out, so I can't say anything about service or decor. read more

Stopped last minute - the pizza was SO fresh, the crust was perfect. The waitress was an added bonus, she was wonderful, attentive and friendly. Worth another stop when back in the area. read more

Pizza was delicious, the crust is crunchy yet fluffy! The sauce is delicious, barbecue chicken was phenomenal. The people working were very nice and generous. The atmosphere of the place is awesome. Very welcoming! read more

I'll eat here again if I'm extremely hungry and nowhere else is open. Italian roll had soggy, old tomatoes and the bread was really hard. Steak and cheese was very dry, had no cheese. Final rating is 2.7/10 Willing to try them again in the future if reviews dictate things have changed. read more

They tried to pass this microwave dog food as a steak and cheese sub. The old grandma who use to run this place must be spinning in her grave. Absolutely pathetic. read more

New England Pizza - New England tried to charge me $14 for this microwave dog food! - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Nothing like the old New England Pizza... very confusing concept to the restaurant. You walk In and there is a pizza counter where you can order food and sit and wait for it OR sit in the same dining room and get a waitress and order food from the Knots Landing. So you can eat from the restaurant with waitstaff or walk up and order your own food and eat in the same dining room (or another dining room)....if this sounds confusing, it is if you there! No one knows what to do when they walk in. We chose to walk up to the counter and order a Pizza, eggplant parm, and kids pasta. Took 40 mins+ !! We went up and the women at the counter to ask about our order and she sounded surprised we didn't get our food. Pizza was cold and nothing like the it used to be. 2 solid thumbs down. We also asked for parmigiana cheese and was given a shaker of it. When my daughter went to use she asked what the black stuff was in the shaker. It was mold!! We brought it to the counter and the male manager (?) was basically just like Oh well and gave us new cheese. We will not be back to this very confusing restaurant for poor quality food. read more

We have been going to New England pizza for at least 40 years. Has been an annual tradition. We walked in tonight and the manager was terse and rude. We actually were so put off by the manager we opted not to stay. Very disappointing. read more

Not out of this world, not terrible. Just A-ok. We ordered a large pizza, it was very big. Just cheese. It was decent tasting, maybe a little bland. We also got a greek salad. The salad was decent size. Fresh. I would return in a pinch but I would also consider other options in the area. read more

I called in a steak and cheese sub order with a couple of special requests for pick-up and nothing was correct! The sub was terrible. Eat in might be different but be careful ordering for pick-up. read more

I will tell you, we are staying right in the center of Chatham. Another Pizza place....directly at the bottom of our street! A stone's throw away! I don't want to bash them. However, I called at 9:15pm......(they close at 10pm). I wanted to order 2 Pizzas. Before I could even get it out.....he said "we are closed". Enough said. Likely a young kid answering the take out phone....and didn't want to stay late. I called New England Pizza. Which has recently moved across the street. Wow! first of all, you can choose to eat dinner on the left side....bar....awesome. The Pizza side is on the right of the building. The staff, friendly, welcoming, and happy to see customers! Wow! I got there a little early 9:45p for my pick up......Sophia the owner came out....Hi David.......just a little bit longer. Couldn't have been nicer! New England Pizza is MY strong recommendation! Thank you Sophie, David read more

I had the BEST Tuna Sub w/tomatoe on delicious homemade bread toasted w/provolone & baclavav for dessert! Nico & other dedicated staff stayed open after the Tornado to feed many hungry people w/o power. God bless him & the kind crew that worked the gas ovens that day w/o any aircond. to help hungry, scared people who couldn't pass on the roads due to downed trees & powerlines! Despite the stress he was cool, calm and kind! Thanks Nico! Sincerely, Sharon Hughes Assistant Principal Harwich Elementary, Monomoy Schools read more

New England Pizza - Nico of New England Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Arrived around 5:30 pm and were surprised not to find a line on this hot and muggy line....mamma was working the register and taking orders and she was quick to get us our pitcher of beer, lemonades and waters, and salad.....waited 15 - 20 minutes for our pies to arrive and the kids blew through $5 on the pinball machine..... I really enjoy it because it is a family operation, its reasonably clean, lots of tables and a few flat screen tvs.... Pizza's were SO GOOD....I always eat too much here....everyone was happy..... 1 large cheese and 1/2 sausage 1 small veggie 1 ziti (noodles) 1 Pitcher of beer 2 lemonades 2 waters Total $65.72 read more

Really enjoy the pizza here. Sauce is semi sweet and not too much. Coming from New York my family is hard to please when it comes to pizza. Will be back. read more

New England Pizza - 18' square - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Ignore the haters. This is a CLASSIC. My family and my parents families have been coming in the summer for years. This is a family-owned place and without fail, they recognize us every summer even if it's been a few years in between. The pizza is delicious. Period. That said, don't order delivery - that's not their forte and it doesn't matter because why wouldn't you want to take the family out to a spot after a long beach day? The décor is no frills but you will enjoy a cold glass of beer and pizza with your family. Seriously, leave your Michelin expectations for pizza at the screen door and enjoy a simply delicious pie and a family tradition in the making. read more

We decided to go to this place because a lot of places were a long wait. Interesting place...staff was nice, the place has that 80s feel and something out of a movie. The kids ordered chicken fingers- was good. Fries were undercooked. Mac and cheese was on the cold side. My son ordered a chicken grinder and it was not very good, no flavor. I did order a meatball sub, and it was delicious! We also ordered a cheese pizza to go and it was good. read more

See all

This is another Chatham establishment that is frozen in time. It's fun to come back here each summer and visit. Nothing much has changed in this pizza joint over the last few decades. This isn't NY pizza, it's more of a Greek style. Pizza is just ok in my opinion, but I grew up eating here, so I am used to it. Prices are a bit high, but not horribly overpriced. Service was acceptable. This is a good family friendly place to take kids to. read more

I am a resident of Chatham trying to support our local businesses as much as possible. This business is not worth supporting and I find the staff to be lacking in customer service in every way. They seem to have a knack for messing up orders and unable to take responsibility. The young boy who delivers the orders to your car is extremely rude, unable to admit fault. The food is ok but certainly not worth dealing with the people. read more

WORST SERVICE EVER -- complete disrespect. 2.5 hr for pizza and basically said tough S when called multiple times wondering where it was.

I am giving this restaurant a 2 because the woman/greeter, (taller blonde with short hair) had the most horrible customer service mannerism, (if you can even call it that). When we entered the restaurant on a Thursday night she didn't even make eye contact with us the entire exchange. After she took our to-go order, she demanded where we sit at the bar. Talking with her while she was taking our order made me feel like I was at Wal-Mart, only their staff have a better way with people. It made us feel horrible and not really wanting to give this business our money but at that point, we just wanted a pizza. The bar tender (female) was nice. The unfortunate thing is that the woman with the awful customer service is actually training a bunch of malleable younger staff who work there. Ladies, please don't emulate her salty attitude--she was the absolute worst!! Also, the pizza was not very good either. Had I known all of this in advance, I would have driven up to the next drive to Carmines. Trust me--save yourself from this bad encounter and don't eat here. My two cents!! read more

Solid. No complaints. Very dependable. Baby K and Pearl split one half of the large square cheese pizza, while Frau K and I split the other half, adding mushroom and onions. Lots of vegetables on this pizza. Crispy crust. Sauce was pretty sweet, said Frau K. We also tried the recommended Greek Salad. Also good. Fresh. Service was good. Place was clean and bright. Lots of screens showing an NBA game. No frills. Just a good place. read more

New England Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

A Chatham institution. Always good, for years. And don't forget the Greek salad with your pizza.

Not bad. My parents have been bringing me to summers in Cape Cod all my life. 35 years. We used to go to New England Pizza and we always enjoyed it. I think part of that was the fact that we NEVER went out to dinner around home, so the simple act of being on vacation and going out to dinner as a kid (both nice things) made for nice memories and meals. Over the last 10-15 years we've been trying different places in Harwich and Chatham. I still haven't really found a favorite. It is not like pizza in the tri state area (NY) where the good stuff is everywhere. So, we tried New England Pizza again yesterday. The pizza is a bit different than what we are used to - Greek style. The tomato sauce is unique but I kind of liked it, although some of my family did not. We also got an italian combo sandwich to split and it was nothing special, but the bread was pretty good. We took the food home. But I picked it up and while I kind of like the interior of this place - again, probably good memories - I consider it a detraction. Poorly ventilated. Decor very basic. Nice beer selection and a small bar which I think is relatively new (in the last 20 years!). The woman behind the counter I recognized. The arcade games and TVs have clearly had an upgrade. But in general it is the same old New England Pizza. Like I said, not bad. It's pizza! And among its competition in Chatham/Harwich it is definitely comparable and I think I'll go back a few more times. read more

Came in at 3.00 in the afternoon and only had counter service. Took our orders and stold to sit down. For 40 minutes I could not find anyone. If I did pay cash would have walked out When I found someone and they checked on our order heard yelling in kitchen that it was a to stay order food was cold. We ate it as we were famished. Maybe being New Yorkers we ar use to good pizza. Pizza was average at best. We were in town looking to relocate nearby. When I move to Chatam, I will no frequently this establishment. read more

Food is OK-good at best. Workers never seem to know what they are doing and constantly mess up orders. Also, we ordered a few weeks ago, and the next morning I threw up 3 times and felt sick all day. I don't know if it's from the food here, or just a coincidence, but I know that I won't be back. Only reason I gave 3 stars is because of the cheesy garlic knots, that's probably their best item. I will say, whatever woman is answering the phone is doing an amazing job- sounds like she's doing it all by herself and answering more than one phone at once. If she's not the manager already then she should be, because she's the only one who knows what she's doing. read more

Classic Greek family-owned pizza joint right down to old arcade games like pinball and a clucking chicken that spits out toy-filled eggs. The lovely little owner Antigone went above and beyond to help us feel comfortable and make sure our needs were met. Beer selection is very impressive, complete with a frosty mug. Though the place was empty when we rolled in on a Tuesday night in mid-December, the fact that it quickly filled up speaks volumes about the quality of food and service. read more

Stopped in for dinner with my wife and daughter on a Thursday evening. We were all tired of fried foods and French fries and wanted a change. This restaurant doesn't offer table service and you order at the counter and they'll call you up when it's ready. It's a nice size restaurant that has big screen tv's and alcohol. We ordered a 10 inch pizza with eggplant and two orders of the spaghetti and meatballs. It took approximately 25-30 minutes to get our food. There was nobody else there other than people doing takeout. The pizza was disappointing. It was bland with no taste. There wasn't much sauce on it which probably was the reason. I'm not a pizza snob and I've eaten bar pizzas, cafe pizzas, and frozen pizzas. This just didn't make the cut. The spaghetti and meatballs was a healthy portion with a good amount of meatballs. However, it was very basic. I must admit the sauce on the spaghetti was tasty and made the dish worth eating. The 4 garlic rolls were good and not to garlicky. The dining area was dirty. The tables were dirty as were the floors. Even the table we sat down at had crumbs all over the table. Somebody wasn't doing their job. Worst yet, the restrooms were outside around back near the dumpsters. My daughter told me they were absolutely disgusting. Dead flies and bugs included. Once again, someone not doing their job. read more

Is this a fancy place? No. But it's a homey place with good pizza, and the beer is served in frosty mugs. The old lady behind the counter will engage you in friendly chitchat. There's plenty of room for a group of friends to hang out. The place has character and I fell in love with it. read more

New England Pizza - Beer is served in frosty mugs - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Great Italian takeout option on the Cape! My wife and I got Gnocchi, garlic knots and a meatball sub - will go again next time we're staying in Chatham! read more

Easy stop for chicken fingers on way home! And good ones at that! Really is like a good old pizza place also they sell beer and wine if that's your thing. read more

Best Pizza, wings, salads in Chatham! No others even close. Sophia and her family/team are extremely pleasant and provide a delicious meal every time we have been. We have been customers of NEHouse since 2013 and it remains our "go to" pizza spot when we are enjoying Chatham. read more

I was calling for an hour to order pizza and I kept getting a busy tone ever time I called..I should not have to call that long for pizza

Ordered a calzone which was literally pizza slices folded in half (!!!) I wondered out loud whether I should be disappointed and then I just re-read that sentence again. If you enjoy cardboard Greek pizza this is your place read more

Friday night. We come in to order a To-Go pizza. Order at 5:42 p.m. 14" N.E. Supreme. Other people came in and ordered after us and got their items (including pizza) and left before us. We finally got our pizza at 6:13 p.m. Really? Never again. If you are going to spend a huge amount of money to move to the Longshore restaurant location, you better up your game. That is all I have to say. read more

Okay pizza. Expensive. Really, this is a middle of the road pizza place. You probably won't be blown away but you are not likely to be crushed with disappointment either. Eh. read more

a Chatham institution! excellent crispy pizza, the Greek salad is as good as everyone says, love this spot

I actually used to go here a lot. The owner made one heck of an italian sub, that's what hooked me in! The staff was always friendly and proffesional. Unfortunately, this past summer I had a bad experience. I had ordered an italian sub and a chicken cutlet sub - the italian had brown lettuce on it and was missing toppings. The LARGE chicken cutlet sub had one, yes just one chicken tender. When I am paying around $12 for a sub I would expect a good portion or even a fair portion for the price. When I go to buy food, especially from a restaurant, I expect to be satisfied and not feel as if I was just ripped off. read more