My son was starving 12 year old. (Haha) so we stopped in and got a pizza, garlic bread, and a salad. Pretty decent sized salad, plenty to share with 3-4 people as a side dish. The garlic bread was huge, 5 in our party and we still had left overs. Pizza was hot and fresh. Really good pizza pie. The lady who took our orders was really nice. We sat at a table and when the food was ready they put it on the counter and we got up and served it to ourselves. Silverware is on the side as well as what you might want for the pizza. Good food and quiet atmosphere great place to stop in for a bite and be able to hear your friends when you want to catch up. read more

Ordered 4 pizzas tonight and was told it would take 45 minutes. arrived on time and was told 15 more minutes. came back and was told another 10 minutes as they hadn't even put ours in the oven. The excuse was they were busy. Really! this is your business. Won't be back read more

The pepperoni pizza and Greek salad were delicious. Service was helpful as well. Right on Main Street.

Pizza was fine. Not bad, not great. But man, the lady in charge, or at least she thinks she is, knows how to ruin the vibe. She's more focused on talking sh*t to customers and employees than helping the 14 year olds who work for her. I'd get another slice but wouldn't let anyone I care about work there. It's a pizza place bro, chill out read more

Slices are hot with a firm undercarriage but a fluffy crust. Close to zero flop. Great proportion of chewy to crispy. read more

Carmine's - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Great owner. Was in today great gluten. Free pizza. Others had the regular and very happy.

RAMONA... the way you speak to the staff is ridiculous. Seeing a grown woman yell at 15/16 year old girls was sickening. Two young girls helping a group of 8 get their coffees in a timely manner. When RAMONA came out of the back not offering to help but yelling at the two girls (one was new). PERHAPS THINK ABOUT WHAT YOU SAY AND HOW YOU SAY IT ESPECIALLY IN FRONT OF CUSTOMERS! Disgusting to see. Coffee was good though! Hope those girls are okay... read more

One of the best slices I've had in a while! Good deal on 2 slices and a soda! Friendly staff.

The staff here are super nice and the pizza is absolutely delicious! The space itself was clean and nice to enjoy a quick slice of pizza! Definitely would come back! read more

We got take out and I do not think you can even refer to this as food! Chicken parm tasted like it was boiled. The pizza was inedible. Hard pass. read more

The pizza here was decent. The cheese pizza had a spicy marinara sauce and the veggie pizza was loaded. The crust was a bit on the tougher side but we did have to drive 30 min before we could eat the pizza so that probably made a difference. The large pizza is a decent size that can easily feed 3-4 people. read more

Carmine's - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza was really good here! Not as crispy as Palio Pizza in Hyannis (see my review on how that was like eating a tortilla chip), but it did have very flavorful sauce and melty cheese. The greek side salad was a little bit sad and pricey but the dressing was good. All in all, not a bad choice for a slice of pizza! Service was very friendly and it has tables both inside and out. read more

Good pizza by any measure. Generous ingredients, good crust, real cheese. On busy nights I would definitely order ahead. read more

Ordered takeout here on 4th of July - This town is slammed that week. They were really backed up and they did a great job catching up and getting the pizza done in a decent time. The pizza was excellent. It's a small place that has a few tables, but does mostly takeout. read more

Carmine's - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Literally the best pizza I've ever had...the pepperoni was unbelievable! Wish I could've eaten an entire pizza. Incredibly friendly and welcoming! An absolute must when visiting Cape Cod. read more

Carmine's has the best pizza and the nicest workers. We came in shortly before closing and they made us custom pizzas and allowed us to stay and eat after normal hours. The owner and the entire staff were very accommodating to our food allergies and let us know the exact ingredients in all of their food. Would highly recommend for anyone looking for a great pizza in the cape! read more

I called carmines and placed and order for a large chicken garlic pizza. All was well, was told 45 wait, I came to pick it up and was greeted by unmatched attitude that I was 10 min early. Not only was it not done on time but the pizza was purposely not put in so that it was 10 minutes late. The owner came out and talked down to me knowing I was Ukrainian and she was Russian. The experience was sickening and the food was subpar. Don't go there unless u wanna go home mad. Floppy soggy mess read more

Carmine's - Garlic chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

We used to come here every summer before Covid, and it was pretty good pizza. But after our latest experience, we probably won't be going back for a while. We called on the phone ahead of time to place our order, 1 large pepperoni pizza and 1 small barbecue chicken pizza. We got to the restaurant and told us our order would be ready in 5 minutes, and then they told us that they didn't have a barbecue chicken for us because we didn't order it...? Since they hadn't even started our other pizza, it would have been nice if they could just make it for us, but it was alright because the large was enough for 4 people. However, we didn't end up receiving our pizza until about 30 minutes after we were originally scheduled to pick up. When we got the pizza, it was nowhere near as good as it used to be. It had kind of a thick French bread style crust, and the sauce was unusually sweet. I'm giving this 2 stars because I have had good experiences with carmines in the past. I will happily update my review the next time I'm there and I have a better experience with them. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite and was surprised at how great this place is. Pizza by the slice was delicious and hot. I had both of the special slices and they were delicious. My adult daughter had plain cheese and very much enjoyed that! We had a coffee and dessert afterwards as we walked around the town. Both were delicious! Highly recommend for a quick and delicious bite while enjoying the town. read more

Good pizza, good coffee. Recommended for a quick bite. Shared a small pie with friends after a boat cruise. Good crust, sauce and cheese. Made fresh and hot. read more

Carmine's - Oven area from the back of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

I want to give more than 5 stars to this place. They could not have been friendlier and more welcoming to our large group after a soccer tournament nearby. We coordinated a drop in dinner by phone earlier in the week, during a time when all the nearby restaurants were mobbed, Carmines went out of the way to make it work for us. Really great experience. Kids gobbled up the food. read more

The Pizza is to die for! Quality, large pizza, lots of toppings, cheese and sauce!!! Best Pizza this side of New Haven, Ct.- Pete's. The crust is crunchy & yet chewy. The red sause is wonderful & they don't skimp on it!!! The cheese is high quality. It somehow reminds me of a great pizza in Italy or Europe!!! The folks there are super friendly & nice too. We talked about our gardens and food while I was waiting. Far and way the very best. read more

Carmine's came recommended as the best pizza in Chatham and did not disappoint. Great pizza and great people.

Reviewv is for coffee only! Desperately looking for an open cafe at just before 6pm we were delighted to find this place. However our celebration was short lived as we quickly found out - $4 Cappuccino, boiling hot, tasteless, soapy foam a la Starbucks, served in paper cups: no option for ceramic cups, a glazed look and a question why would we even ask for them.... Don't waste your money in hopes for coffee here. read more

I love that you can actually taste the tomatoes in the tomato sauce. Too many pizza places have tomato sauce that taste like nothing.Carmine's they know how to do it right!!! read more

We biked 20 miles to Chatham and we usually stop at Chatham Fish and Chips which the kids really enjoy. Unfortunately they were closed today so we needed to find a new place to eat so we stopped at Carmine's for some pizzas. They were totally outstanding! One meat lovers and one tomato basil with chicken. Fast service and very friendly too. Highly recommend. Unfortunately, now we have a dilemma the next time we come to Chatham. read more

Carmine's - a close up of a pizza with meat and onions - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Favorite of all time ! Best gluten-free pizza ! always fresh veggies !! My boys get the regular crust and love it !! It's a weekly must have

Bad food not worth the 15 minute wait. Pizza is not good at all.The wait was crazy for some bad pizza

Excellent pizza. The staff are friendly and efficient. The pizza was delicious. It was fresh and not greasy at all. The crust is light and airy. Great experience on a whim. read more

On my last night in Cape Cod, I went to Carmine's for pizza with the family. It was relatively dead; it was a Tuesday night and pouring rain, but it had been pretty busy earlier in the week and on the weekend. There's not a whole lot of places to sit here, so I wouldn't bank on eating in, especially if you have a large party. My family ended up ordering a large buffalo chicken pizza as well as a small cheese pizza to split between 7 people. I honestly didn't think it'd be enough pizza, but that, plus a small salad, left everyone feeling content. I really liked the buffalo chicken, although it comes with cilantro on it, which I found kind of odd for that type of pizza. I don't think it really did much to enhance the flavor, and the fried chicken pieces on top weren't incredibly crispy. Despite all that, it was very tasty, especially with the crunch of the celery, and the ranch dressing I got on the side. The highlight was definitely the crust, which was just chewy enough and very light. I'm not sure if pizza is big on Chatham, and I didn't get to experience any other pizza shops there while I was on vacation, but it was definitely some pretty good pizza. Did it blow me away? Not really, but if you're not trying to do anything fancy or trying to feed a large amount of people, then this is a safe bet. read more

Carmine's - You can get pizza by the slice here - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza is OK - reminds me of a good version of Domino's. We had to wait almost an hour for a pizza and a salad - when we arrived they had run out of salads and then only gave us a refund for the salad and not the salad and chicken. We would have complained but the poor young man trying to hold things together was being yelled out by his coworkers. So we just left down a few dollars with the mediocre pizza. Wish them well - but perhaps they should hire a non-teenager to handle the Saturday night dinner crowd? read more

My mother-in-law always says, "Everything tastes better on the Cape". In the case of Carmine's, she's right. It's a great place to stop for a quick bite when you're wandering through Chatham center. The pizza was very warm & the crust delicious. Our party ordered 2 pizzas, a calzone, and a garden salad. The garden salad was a little small, but we were pleased with everything else. read more

Went to Carmine's for the second time this month. Both times the lady yelled at me for being too early. I didn't think twice the first time but after it happened again the family decided it will be our last trip to Carmine's. Not what you would expect when you try to support a local business during COVID-19. Karmas a bitch and ironically so was the lady!! read more

Just happened to stumble upon this small pizza joint because we needed a restroom. With my wife's disapproval (because I'm gaining weight, lol) I ordered a couple slices! AMAZING. Tried he chicken bacon ranch n scallions slice and it was so lovely. The dough was nice and chewy and soft. Hidden gem! read more

Came with a group of 10, we got 3 large pies. I tried all 3 but the only one I really liked was the Californian. I can't even remember what the other 2 were. I normally like meat on my pizza but the Californian just tasted so yummy that I forgot what it was lacking in. The garlic flavor was strong but not overwhelming. read more

Carmine's - Californian - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Amazing pizza! Been eating here since I was a child and it never disappoints. Some of the best pizza in town come here every summer :)

There were no patrons when I walked into Carmine's last week. The sole visible employee was rude, vulgar, sickening and so bitter. After her crude remarks, I just turned around and walked out. Never again. read more

Ordered pizza, then went to use the bathroom. There was a blow up mattress, bedding and all types of weird stuff in there. The toilet was totally covered in feces. The sink was difficult to access with all the bedding in there and filthy. I couldn't eat the food after seeing the facilities that the employees are using and someone is obviously living in. read more

Crust was really good, but nothing extraordinary pizza wise. Standard pizza shop, friendly service, clean indoor seating

Carmine's is in the center of Chatham with plenty of parking just off the main rotary. This is not your typical Greek pizza joint with the round edge crust and solid cheese flavor. Carmine's has a fresh and inviting flavor from top to crust. I ordered their house special and it was simply great. They have many specials from the meat lovers to the veggie and in between. So stop by and check it out if you are in Chatham. read more

See all