Crust was really good, but nothing extraordinary pizza wise. Standard pizza shop, friendly service, clean indoor seating

Great pizza. Ordered two 12" pizzas. They are a few inches bigger than that which is a nice surprise. Ordered a half pepperoni half cheese and a specialty white pizza. The white pizza was fantastic. Their crust is amazing. I could eat it plain. If you order it in as in eating there the space is a little cramped. But what isn't around these parts. Atmosphere is ok as it doesn't feel like a pizza place with half of it being a coffee bar. They do play classical music at least when I was here that gave it somewhat of an Italian feel? None the less great food. Would definitely go back. read more

Carmine's - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Quality pie! Had this on our first night in Chatham and the whole family enjoyed it! We called in our order and it was ready right when they said it would be! read more

I will also preface this review with saying I'm a New Yorker with access to excellent pizza & I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Carmine's. We approved of the plain slice and thoroughly enjoyed the chicken, bacon, ranch special slice. Crispy crust & tasty toppings. The ability to get pizza by the slice is great. Has fountain sodas, takes credit cards, nice amount of seating. I'll be back! read more

Carmine's - One plain, one chicken bacon ranch - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

I've been coming to this place for years and it's been the most consistently good pizza. They have white sauce or red sauce combinations and they are all good. Staff is friendly even though they are usually busy and understaffed. Coffee drinks are great too plus it's the only spot in Chatham that does coffee after 3. Def recommend read more

Pizza, not so hard. Dough, decent red sauce, something on top. But for some reason, Chatham and pizza places compete with Dominos, Pizza Hut and other blah chains and think they have mastered the obvious fast and cheap pizza. Burnt bottom, so so dough, and toss on something. Yikes. When will someone in this town ever spend a few dollars and deliver a decent pizza? No delivery required. Just make a pizza with love. read more

Rude! After they clearly made a mistake with our order (they mixed it up with someone else's phone order), they proceeded to take 45 minutes to correct it. And they berated us and served other customers. Find pizza somewhere else. read more

Pizza is awesome! Don't stray from there and you'll be fine. ...but we also ordered a salad. It was fresh enough, but was the least impressive and most expensive garden salad I've ever seen from a pizza joint. Lesson learned. Stick to the pizza. read more

Very good Pizza and cooked to perfection! What a nice staff they have at Carmine's the owner should be proud of them they all work hard! I highly recommend this place in your in Chatham one of the best places around and the large pies are enormous! read more

Best pizza on the lower cape by far! (I would say Palio Pizzeria in Hyannis takes #1 on the Cape though) My family and I bring all of our guests to Carmine's and now they always request to come back every year so I probably go here once a week in the summer. The atmosphere isn't great just because there isn't that much space and it's always really hot inside at the height of the summer. We always order it go and then bring it to Oyster Cove down the street (which has picnic tables) or to Lighthouse Beach. The crust is very light and thin crust and the sauce is very flavorful. Although I don't normally prefer plain cheese, at Carmine's that is my favorite because too many toppings takes away from the great flavor of the sauce in my experience. Also, a great dinner takeout option in Chatham, which is hard to find close to the center. read more

Hot as hell in here on a summers night but the slice of pizza and teeny tiny I think they gave me a thimble of root beer did hit the proverbial spot. There were probably 422552 kids in here but my pizza was good. Saucy, the way I like it. Sweet saucy and not too cheesy with just enough grease. Excellent crust. I would go back here next time I'm walking down Main Street. read more

The pizza was horrible. It was overcooked and greasy. The person working the register spoke with a thick Bulgarian accent, like she just came to America. It was hard to understand, tainting my overall experience. Pizza was so soggy that after I lifted up a slice, it fell in my lap. My new corderoys and galoshes were tainted, like my experience. Menus are really unorganized and they are literally everywhere which really pissed me off. My overall experience was tainted. Please keep job hirings local. Thanks but no thanks, Marcus Gormley P.S. Check out my music on YouTube read more

i went in with a folding bike and they didn't let me, I'm like serious?? It's smaller than a baby carriage. Meanwhile the pizza was good, the crust was crispy and the cheese was delicious, pizza not salty at all, small slices and it was pretty expensive for me. read more

I have very rarely ever given a one-star review of any restaurant (not worth the trouble), however, our recent experience at Carmine's deserves it. Ultimately, the pizza is good -- if a bit overpriced ($18 for a large cheese, $25 for large with toppings). It was a hot and humid night, and was crowded, so the "35 minutes" we were told it would take for 2 pizzas was not a big deal at all. What was a big deal was the short, blonde Manager being incredibly rude to us when we had the gall to check in at about 25 minutes as to see whether or not our pizza # had been called. On a casual Friday evening in a jam-packed establishment with pizzas coming out every 30 seconds, we wanted to make sure we didn't miss anything -- and we had forgot to set our IPhone timers at the precise moment that we had ordered our pizzas. When I asked if #94 had been calld, the courteous college student working the oven casually glanced at the tickets, only to be interrupted by the short, blonde Manager lady with "you ordered at 7:22pm and were told 35 minutes. There is a clock right behind you. Look at it, find 7:22pm, and then count forward 35 minutes and it will be ready." That is a direct quote, verbatim. You can imagine my displeasure (let's be honest, I was hoping it played out this way) when at 8:00pm on the nose I returned to find that one of my pizzas was not done -- and I returned the rudeness and asked where the hell my pizza was. Her apology of "I'm sorry for being short with you earlier, it is really hot back here" was a pretty weak excuse. She is running a restaurant -- with customers -- and shouldn't be at the front of the house. We won't be back. read more

What an unpleasant experience. If you want cold pizza with dubious ingredients by all means this is your place. The food quality is only outdone by the attitude of the staff. 40 minutes before the place is to close they go radio silent and wont pick up the phone. A quick run to the place to order a pie was greeted with "only slices" left retort. Really? You're open for more then 30 minutes! They had 8 slices left so we took them, Okay now we have a pie but in pieces. They insisted on charging us individual slice prices!!! Hey, I feel their pain and they are trying to salvage a "lost" season but don't completely screw the customers you do have. Your pizza is not so great. Don't go unless your desperate and don't mind being treated unfairly. Rating: zero stars read more

I do truly like Carmine's but there is something always a little strange about mostly Eastern Europeans serving Italian trendy pizza (for example with Buffalo chicken) in very New England Chatham. It is convenient when in town and perhaps the best pizza in Chatham. We still like the regular cheese best of all. Call ahead when you want a whole pie! read more

It's definitely not cheap but the value is high. Veggie pie was piled with toppings and hot chocolate is the real deal. Recommend going with eggplant instead of olives on the regular veggie (although the olives are kalamata) read more

Carmine's - Veggie pie with eggplant - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Honestly, this place was really disappointing. It was recommended by a friend and we stopped by on our way back from Provincetown. The pizza just had no flavor. The crust was meh at best and the sauce left more to be desired. The staff also wasn't super friendly so it's hard to find a reason why you would actually go here. read more

Pepperoni pizza was excellent and greek salad was made with all fresh ingredients. It did not disappoint.

Great pizza. (A large is massive!) The meatball sandwich was also delicious. Great takeout on a rainy day!

The best pizza place in Chatham, Massachusetts. It's takes only 10 minutes for my Buffalo pizza with a great quality of the product. 18 inches side pizza will be a good option for all family at this place. The customer service was helpful and good with all customer details. read more

Carmine's - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

I'm going to knock a star off my rating for their complete inability to estimate food prep time. Estimated 45 minute wait time, pizza didn't even go until 55 minutes. Check out Sweet Tomatoes or New England House of Pizza for other options with better service. read more

Needed a quick pizza before game time. The ladies working we're friendly, quick and pleasant despite it being the end of the night. They made sure to take care of us with drinks, plates, napkins, cheese and more! Pizza was great on a cool Autumn night. read more

Some of the most fresh and flavorful pizza you can find on Cape for sure. The crust is nice and crispy out of the oven but gets a little less so if it steams in a box for too long (i.e. as takeout). Eat by the slice while walking through town, enjoy a pie in the clean and vibrant dining area, or one of the parks in town. It's consistently and reliably great. read more

Had the best veggie pizza here last week. My husband had a calzone and raved about it. We were visiting Chatham for a conference and just stumbled onto this place. Ramona was so nice. She explained the various kinds of pizza. I wanted to go back the next day to try another pizza but we had no time. I would highly recommend this place. You won't be disappointed! read more

Awful. Owner argued it was OK to wait 45 min for Pizza. Folks after us were served before us. Felt unwelcome. Never felt more discriminated in a restaurant. Stay away!!! read more

We've been coming here from Buffalo, NY for 10+ years. Coming from Buffalo-we know good pizza. Carmine's is often top of our list when we come to Chatham. Best when right out of the oven! It's always a great and quick option! read more

A bit on the pricey side but outstanding pizza (green pepper and red onion); fresh ingredients; beautifully baked pie. Greek salad on the side; try the ranch dressing made in-house. read more

It was pizza, I remember it being much better in past years, it wasn't memorable this year. On par with a frozen pizza , but this had a bit to much oregano. So if you don't feel like searching for a frozen, go here it will be cooked for you. read more

Carmine's was great tasting and perfect for a large quick family meal, would eat there again.

I went with a couple of fiends for pizza. The young gentleman at the counter was nice but the woman who, was seemingly in charge, was neither hospitable nor helpful. I can get good service and great pizza from awesome people, elsewhere. read more

Down in Chatham, there's not too many quick food choices to go with kids. This place sits inside a small gathering of shops and looks like just a regular pizza place. The nice thing about the place: the staff is very friendly and fast and the food is pretty good! They also have some grinders but the pizza is great! Nice golden crust and huge slices! We ordered a large for 3 of us and we couldn't finish. The prices are reasonable and there is plenty of room to sit. Nice place to stop in when strolling the friendly streets od downtown Chatham! read more

Had one slice of the daily special, tomato bacon and feta... delicious crust and tasty cheese. And they had lattes! Would return.

Kind of expensive but at least it's made right. Great pizza dough (the crust is good too), its perfectly thin, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Mmmm! read more

Grabbed a quick slice and a Greek salad - best pizza I've had in a long time. Wish we could get it in Baltimore! Salad was fresh and yummy. Only negative was no brewed iced tea - just Fuze from the machine. read more

With pizza, I'm picky. I've been spoiled by Long Island, NYC and now New Haven (CT) pizza my whole life. We stopped in for a couple slices before a show. It's a typical pizza place. The staff was friendly. The pizza was OK, but nothing to write home about. Pretty good crust. Not much flavor in the sauce. Satisfactory cheese. We didn't get any toppings. Would we go back? Probably. But I'd try some other local pizzerias first. read more

One of the things I hate about being from NYC is that I feel obligated to be harsh when I review pizza. "Oh, I suppose this is good enough, but you really have to go to [insert restaurant] on [insert street/cross street] in [insert neighborhood]. It's a little hole in the wall; you'd probably miss it if you don't know where to look." But here's my little secret: I don't really care THAT much about NYC pizza. I don't go out of my way to find the best in Manhattan. I have never turned up my nose at a slice, even if I was at freaking Chuck E. Cheese's! So if anyone was expecting me to be like, "Oh Carmines, pretty ok for *snort* MA pizza." You do not know me and pizza! This stuff is great!!! If you're a veg, you are in for a freaking treat. Kalamata olives [Dear Carmine's guys reading this review: It's KALAMATA not KALAMATTA! You're welcome.], spinach, artichokes, plus all the standard pizza-topping fare. Cheese and sauce are not in any way overwhelming, but actually compliment the rest of the pie super nicely. Seasoning is great: fresh basil and lots of generous fresh garlic! Crust is buttery and soft on the inside/crispy on the outside. You order at the counter, and they give you a number. There are some nice tables inside, and I do wish there was a table or two outside as well! But as long as it's not a crowded hour, the place doesn't get too uncomfortable. And the girl at the counter tells you when your pie will be ready, so you can walk Main Street while you wait. One small pie has 6 good-sized slices. Easily enough for two people. There's also a little coffee bar in the pizza place. Tasty drinks: hot, cold, or frozen. I wasn't blown away by my frappe, but the iced latte was delish! If you're super picky about pizza, maybe you'd find fault with Carmine's. But honestly, you're probably annoying at most pizza places. In my honest opinion, as a would-be NYC pizza snob: Carmine's is the best I've had on the Cape and immensely recommended! read more

Great experience, walked off the street, ordered pizza with sausage and it was delightful. The sausage tasted of fennel and garlic. The large was 18" and each of the 8 slices was LARGE. Would go back there for pizza and comfortable setting for the family. read more

This is a 0 star place. Terrible service with untrained staff. Owner is a price gouger. Shameless. Power to the town was knocked out fir a few days in Chatham and this guy decides that pizzas should cost $40 each. Most communities come together and help each other out. Not here, the owner doubled his already high prices. Carmine's is a loser read more

Good pizza! During our MA trip, we had pizza at three different spots - including Regina's in Boston, and I can safely say that Carmine's was the best. Nice, thin crust - not quite Napolitan, but close -and reminiscent of NY-style pizza. If you're on the Cape and looking for a slice, this is your best bet. read more