Cancel

Open app

Search

Pistol Pete's Seafood

2.9 (10 reviews)
ModerateSeafood Markets

Pistol Pete's Seafood Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Pistol Pete's Seafood

Recommended Reviews - Pistol Pete's Seafood

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

5 years ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

the best fresh and prepared seafood around! i love this place. fried, broiled or fresh...it's the best!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of DJ M.
493
793
3719

16 years ago

Helpful 19
Thanks 0
Love this 18
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Pistol Pete's Seafood

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood Markets 2,061 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Penn Jersey Seafood - Grilled shrimp and scallops with broccoli and rice

Penn Jersey Seafood

3.9(11 reviews)
5.0 mi

The owner JT is so funny, he's very nice. He's very very welcoming. The food is great. I mean the…read moreCrabs, shrimp, fried fish seafood salad. Everything is always so nice and fresh. The service is wonderful. If you come a couple times,He remembers you by name or the conversation y'all had last.

First of all the guy at the counter was very rude. We asked him if the platter could be split…read morebetween two people and he said no I will post the picture below of how large the platter was. It could definitely have been split so he lied.second of all it was a little gritty and not as clean as I would like, the bathrooms were disgusting. The corn on my platter was old and inedible. The clams were rubbery and tough. You do go to the counter to get your food yourself, but I figured they would clear the table for us, especially since I tipped them $10 but as I was walking out the door, the counter guy yelled at me." hey you need to throw away your trash!" it was very embarrassing, and I had neatly piled my plates and trash so that it was an easy cleanup and I figured they would have to wipe the table anyway, but now knowing how nasty it is in there, they probably don't wipe the tables. I do not recommend nor will I ever go here again. To top it all off I spent more time in the bathroom afterwards than I would like.

Photos
Penn Jersey Seafood - This is the platter that the counter guy said couldn't be shared!!! It was clearly enough food for 2 women!

This is the platter that the counter guy said couldn't be shared!!! It was clearly enough food for 2 women!

Penn Jersey Seafood - Onion rings and crab legs

Onion rings and crab legs

Penn Jersey Seafood - Deluxe seafood combo

See all

Deluxe seafood combo

Avenue U Fish Market - Fresh Organic King Ora New Zealand Salmon

Avenue U Fish Market

4.8(40 reviews)
57.9 mi•Sheepshead Bay, Midwood
•$$

I want to commend Angelo on a truly great seafood market. It is great walking in and smelling FRESH…read moreseafood-"not fish". I have been around seafood my entire life and as a food professional it is gratifying to find a family run shop that cares about freshness. Really fresh seafood should smell clean, mild, and reminiscent of the open ocean, completely lacking the pungent, heavy smell that people typically associate with "fishiness". Avenue U Fish Market is clean and creamy smelling, just like right out of the water fresh. I bought soft-shell crabs last weekend that were the best I have ever had in my 60 years. They were lively, plump and most importantly delicious. Angelo personally picked 4 of them for me and my wife. I wanted to let Brooklyn and Rockaway know that it is worth the trip to Avenue U Fish Market. Keep up the great work and shop local. Support a small family run business. Get the Soft Shells while they are available. Thank you Angelo, Adam Smith

Another local gem in the neighborhood. The staff are extraordinarily knowledgeable about all the…read morefish, not just the origins, but will also give you helpful advice on how to cook and prepare everything. I know for a fact that their salmon is high-quality and delicious. One of the things I keep coming back for are the crab cakes. They get them from a local small business on Long Island I believe. They come frozen and you just have to heat them up in the oven for about 20 to 25 minutes or pan fry them for 3 to 5 minutes on each side. Hard to find really good crabcakes and these are definitely worth it at $4.25 a piece.

Photos
Avenue U Fish Market
Avenue U Fish Market
Avenue U Fish Market - Fresh & Wild Caught Porgies

See all

Fresh & Wild Caught Porgies

La Mexicana - OAXACA CHEESE, CHORIZO, CARNE ENCHILADA, CARNE CECINA

La Mexicana

4.3(61 reviews)
1.0 mi
•$

This is the second La Mexicana store, the other being on Rt. 13 in Bristol, PA. It is smaller than…read moreit sister, and without a dining area to enjoy an authentic Mexican meal. Aside from that shortcoming, it has two aisles full of Real Mexico - foods, kitchen supplies and even a few pieces of clothing, all manufactured South of the Border for the local population. This part of Bensalem and southern Bucks has the largest representation of Chicano culture, and if you explore a bit you can find tiendas mas grandes, y excellent restaurants very nearby to fill your cupboard and belly. I stopped in hoping their was a kitchen and dining area here, but finding none I was happy to buy some chorizo for our breakfasts at home. Friendly people who easily suggested the best place to grab a good meal in the area. I'll keep that secret to myself.

I have been coming to eat here for 3 years. In my previous review you will see I rated this place 5…read morestars. I absolutely fell in love with this place. Now, every time I go, they mess up my order, and I have to go back to fix it. They don't offer delivery for their mistakes, and I live less than a mile away! They girls that work there are very friendly, but they don't know what they are doing and need more training. They need someone double checking orders before someone wastes their time to pick it up. I always pick up food for me and my coworkers, and I can tell you every single time I go they mess up my order. One time they even put pork in my taco instead of beef. Disrespectful. I am sick of being disappointed by you guys. They offered me a credit for the "next time I go", but I will never spend another dime in this place. I will be showing up again for a refund on the food I did not receive. Llevo 3 años viniendo a comer aqui. En mi reseña anterior verán que califiqué este lugar con 5 estrellas; realmente me encantaba. Ahora, cada vez que voy, se equivocan con mi pedido y tengo que volver para arreglarlo. No ofrecen servicio de entrega a domicilio para corregir sus errores, ¡y eso que vivo a menos de una milla de distancia! Las chicas que trabajan allí son muy amables, pero no saben lo que hacen y necesitan más capacitación. Hace falta alguien que verifique los pedidos antes de que uno pierda el tiempo yendo a recogerlos. Siempre recojo comida para mí y para mis compañeros de trabajo, y les aseguro que, sin falta, cada vez que voy se equivocan con el pedido. Una vez incluso pusieron cerdo en mi taco en lugar de carne de res. Es una falta de respeto. Estoy harto de las decepciones que me llevo con ustedes. Me ofrecieron un crédito para la "próxima vez que vaya", pero no volveré a gastar ni un centavo en este lugar. Volveré para pedir el reembolso de la comida que no recibí.

Photos
La Mexicana
La Mexicana - COOKING DRY PEPPERS

COOKING DRY PEPPERS

La Mexicana - TRES LECHES

See all

TRES LECHES

Pistol Pete's Seafood - seafoodmarkets - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...