Cancel

Open app

Search

Pie Shop

4.3 (104 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Pie Shop Photos

Business Info

PIE SHOP ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Live music
Moderate noise
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Pie Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Leslie S.

I was looking for a strawberry rhubarb pie for my boyfriend's birthday, his favorite pie. The pie was scrumptious, fresh, and was made with fresh strawberries and rhubarb. My boyfriend almost ate half the pie the first night I surprised him with it. 10/10!!

Andre A.

I heard this was a H St staple, so I had to check it out. Really like the small, personal chill vibes. The cashier/server was cool and very helpful. Great variety on the menu with a mix of savory and sweet pies. We went with the Smog and Spinach and Goat cheese Quiche with an apple pie for dessert. Presentation-wise, everything was cooked well. I wasn't a huge fan of the Smog crust, but I will never judge a place solely on one thing. Looking forward to trying something different next time, but I would recommend it.

Brittany W.

What a little gem! When we first entered, we were a little apprehensive because it was a complete ghost town and it did not have a cozy bakery feel like we were imagining. We ordered a selection of pies to share: checkerboard, key lime, berry, and Berger cookie. Key lime was hands down my favorite, but the Berger was interesting since it's a local cookie (but on top of more of a custard filling). The slices of pie were bigger than we expected (we wouldn't have ordered as many but the employee tried to show us the size with her hands and the slice didn't seem very large based on her measurement), but we indulged! Would definitely come back here in the future (or order a whole pie to go for a special occasion).

Blueberry Pancake Pie
Kaya A.

I'm disappointed with the pancake to blueberry ratio. I think the fruit of a fruit pie in the most important aspect. The blueberries were all towards the crust so I found myself eating it in an odd way. More blueberries is my tip! Ice cream was yummy!

Brian L.

When I came in I was torn a out which pie to get because they have so many options. What looked the most appealing were the Peanut Butter Nutter and Key Lime pies. The nice worker behind the counter told me that their pies are made fresh every night before the store opens. It's actually a 24 hour operation here. Obviously I couldn't try them all and in the end I went for the Banana Toffee pie and we can't wait to try it out later. This pie doesn't seem to be loaded with so much sugar and calories that could keep my kids up all night. The gentleman suggested that I check out their website to see all of their options, since they change their pie pin-up on a daily basis. What a cool pie shop!

Berger Coookie Pie
Arthur C.

I ordered the Berger cookie pie, which was like a mix of custard and chocolate in a crumble pie. A first for me, the pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream provided a solid dessert while I strolled through H Street.

Coconut sweet potato pie

Cool little pie shop. Simara (sp?, counter person) was helpful and pretty cool. Savory pies were good, pulled pork was the preferred choice. It was like eating bbq pork rib smokey goodness. The spinach gruyere quiche was fluffy and light. IMO, the Gruyère cheese didn't come through very strongly. We also had the SMOG (steak, mushrooms, onions and gruyere). The smog was good, but compared to pulled pork it was subdued. Again, the Gruyere didn't come through as much as I'd like. We ordered 2 sweet pie slices, key lime and coconut sweet potato pie. KL was nicely sweet (maybe a little too sweet IMO) and tart. The graham crust was nicely done and not soggy as many KL pies I've had over the years. The texture of the KL filling was firm and not overly dense. I'd order it again and eat it with a hot strong black coffee I was struggling to choose between the Chocolate Pecan and Coconut Sweet Potato pie, looking for something less sweet than the KL for our second slice. Simara suggested CSP pie beside it was less sweet and not always something they make.. It wasn't too sweet and the coconut came through very subtly. Both in the taste and texture. I ordered an iced coffee to go along with the pies, and let's face it, it was a pretty warm afternoon and my pie search was a little out of our way. So I was feeling warm. I drink my coffee black, though they offered cream and agave syrup. The iced coffee was strong and quite good. Often iced coffees are overly diluted. So that was big plus and I received a free refill. So the Pie Shop is off the beaten track for most tourists. The neighborhood is very local. Don't expect a clean scrubbed National Mall or financial district feel to it. The neighborhood is urban and somewhat gritty. The PS also features live music, when we arrived (Sunday late afternoon) it was quiet, but the music started up as we were leaving. Look at the list of performances, they may or may not be to your taste. At the PS, you order at the counter, and in our case S brought our slices to our table (you seat yourself). The inside of the shop has a worn local feel, expect a very casual space with worn dark wood and inexpensive chairs and furnishings. It's small and can't seat many people. As of this writing the savory pie slices run around $12, while the sweet pie slices are around $9. Would I go back again? Yes, I liked the pies and wanted to try more. I'd recommend going earlier in the day to get the best selection of pies. We also came on graduation weekend, meaning there were a lot of pies ordered and picked up, so they sold out of many of their pies. The PS does a brisk takeout/togo business too.

Chocolate Pecan Pie
Pinky J.

After finding this spot on UberEats and being tired of paying the delivering fees, I finally decided to go and pick up my order (which you can place online from Toast app). Parking is a hit or miss (well makes sense since it's located on H street). The establishment had a unique vibe and was very clean. The staff were nice and helpful, not too much interaction. CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE (WARMED) OMGGGGGG if you're a chocolate lover, this a dessert heavenly slice on another level. Super delicious, rich, decadent and tasty. Love at every bite I promise and worth the drive. To make matters worse, I was paying almost double on UberEats which I won't be doing anymore. I'm definitely coming back for my sweet tooth fix.

BBQ Pulled Pork Pork - Slice
Hiral D.

Love this place, minus the very loud rock music from upstairs. Sweet and savory pies are all delicious. I got the tofu curry pie and we got the berger cookie pie to share. We also brought friends here and got french toast, pecan, and strawberry rhubarb pie. Slices are huge in my opinion and the pies hit the spot!

See all

Photo of John P.
0
37
16

3 years ago

Come here. You won't regret it. The pie is wonderful. Especially the blueberry pancake pie

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

I love Pie Shop and recommend it to all my friends! With live music and fresh pie made in-house, I am definitely coming back for more!

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Incredible pies, awesome music, fantastic customer service. I personally prefer their sweet pies to their savory pies but both are great!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Zach S.
4
123
4

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Bunmi E.
171
32
1

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Awesome pies, fantastic people, and amazing music venue. what more could you ask for?

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Adam S.
381
13
2

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

The sweet pie wasn't that great. Tofu curry was ok. Location is clean and accessible. The workers and nice and friendly.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Pie Shop

Are there any seats for the live shows?

I believe so! There would have to be!!

Can you order food before a show?

yes if there is a show the shop is open!

View All 4 Questions

Review Highlights - Pie Shop

“I ordered the Berger cookie pie, which was like a mix of custard and chocolate in a crumble pie.”

Mentioned in 6 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cafes 6,462 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

9:30 Club - Baylen

9:30 Club

3.9(798 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$

Wow I can't even count the number of shows I've seen here in my lifetime. As I'm originally from…read morePittsburgh, it was nothing to make the drive to catch some of our favorite bands performing. This old school punk venue has been around since the early 80s and I started seeing shows here in my late teens. The history behind this place is just mind-blowing and incredible. To me it's one of the best places to see a live band. The sound is spot on. I've seen Fugazi (sadly never got to see Minor Threat), Bad Brains, and several other bands here. Iconic and legendary venue... for music lovers it's a must at least once to see a performance here.

Solid concert venue in a convenient location in DC. Parking is available on surrounding streets if…read moreyou arrive early enough. You can also pay for a parking pass through their website but the lot only opens up an hour beforehand so be sure to plan your evening with that in mind. We ended up parking on the street for only $3 since we arrived early to grab dinner nearby. The entry line was super long and literally went around the block but it moved surprisingly fast. Staff was friendly and helpful at the door. The inside was dark when we arrived and it would've been nice to have some house lights so people could find their way around the venue a little easier. The AC was cranking and the temp was comfortable. Upstairs has standing room and some bleachers which provides a good view with less of a crowd. Their VIP area looks nice and I'd be interested in splurging next time for a seat and a better view. There's bars downstairs and upstairs and even some food concessions. Getting out of the venue from the balcony was a bit stressful with only one way out. It makes you imagine what would happen if you needed to get out in a rush... other than that, it's a good space.

Photos
9:30 Club - Evil 04.09.2025

Evil 04.09.2025

9:30 Club
9:30 Club - D4vd

See all

D4vd

THROW Social - Try out a tropical drink! we have a full menu of specialty cocktails at our full bar- don't forget about happy hour!

THROW Social

3.7(375 reviews)
1.0 mi•Ivy City
•$$

I came here with friends for the Latin Coffee event. I had a great time - shoutout to the dj and la…read moregrecacoffeex. The space was huge and there was outdoor space with a bar, seating and games. The servers were gorgeous and super friendly even with how busy they were. The dance space was spacious and perfect for all the dancing. My only note is there was no AC! It was sooooooooo hot in there and there was only one fan. I'm sure it was a last minute issue but they need fans in there as a back up. Especially with events with that many people.

Now I'm only giving them this low score is because of the situation me and my partner ran into on…read morethis past Sunday (July 10th). Online the place looks great and interesting so we decided to hit it up around 9pm because it doesn't close until 2am. So when we walked in the place was pitch black and the vibe was really off. We had to pay $20 a person to enter which at first I was confused because I thought this place was games, bars, music, and vibes...not at all. So we were walking around and the crowd I'll just say wasn't the type I wanted to be around. Only one bar was open and the music was weird. So we decided to leave and when I asked the person who was taking the money what was going on tonight they said an event. Now, this event was not posted anywhere on their website or social media. So I would caution going at night or call beforehand because I don't think I would want to come back because it was nothing like it is portrayed online.

Photos
THROW Social - Tres chic!

Tres chic!

THROW Social - The Liquid Lullaby

The Liquid Lullaby

THROW Social - The Pain Killer does just that!

See all

The Pain Killer does just that!

St Vincent Wine - TIME MACHINE, OREGON WHITE WINE PRODUCED & BOTTLED BY BOW & ARROW - DUNDEE, OR

St Vincent Wine

3.9(209 reviews)
2.9 mi•Park View
•$$

Black owned business…read more I've been wanting to try this place for a long time and I'm glad that I finally did. First, don't expect table side service, you have to use a QR code to order your meal and put in an "order" to speak with someone. While this wasn't the best, it worked for what we needed which was to ask questions about the menu. Next, you cannot get a glass of wine during the weekend brunch/lunch but you can purchase a bottle and take the rest home. Lastly, there was nobody at the front door so we simply walked into the restaurant and sat ourselves. Beautiful restaurant however, more on the speakeasy/rustic side. Now that I've gotten that out of the way, let's get into why I gave this place a good rating. Well, the wine selection and pasta were enough to make me beyond happy. But the cost was a bit questionable. Pasta- shrimp and caviar (can't remember the sauce) but know this dish was hearty, bursting with flavor, and freshly prepared. It was absolutely delicious with every bite. Wine selection- I ordered a remarkable bottle of 2022 white wine and the citrus and stone fruits made it perfect for the shrimp and caviar. The prices for both the bottle and pasta were really expensive but honestly, I didn't feel bad because I enjoyed both. Now, I do plan on visiting during hours when I can order a glass of wine because with the cost of the food and the cost of the bottles, it wasn't cost-effective for a single diner at all. Hope to be back soon!

I was really looking forward to my visit here. I heard some great things about the vibe and…read moreambiance. I was really excited to sit outside in the courtyard, but unfortunately it was a little chilly out, so I decided to sit in doors. The host was accommodating. So kudos to them. The food was excellent. From the deviled eggs and the crispy potatoes as small appetizers; both were superb. The lobster bucatini was as advertised. The homemade pasta, texture of the noodles and softness of the lobster, everything was superb. Even the wine. I wish I can give this place a 5 start rating, but I can't. It was because of the service. I would think if you're going to automatically charge the 20% gratuity, I would expect that I'll have a server. You order your own food from the QR code and pay from the QR code. You are given water, and are expected to pour your own water. And worst of all, a bottle of wine was delivered, uncorked, and placed on my table to pour it myself. And then when I saw that the table next to me, had a server who poured their wine for them, I knew then that it wasn't a restaurant thing, it was just how my table was treated. Anyway, if that part gets fixed, it'll be a five. I wouldn't mind too much if the 20% wasn't automatic. I kind of got the feeling that they didn't care about the service as the 20% was already being collected.

Photos
St Vincent Wine - The string lights-laced courtyard

The string lights-laced courtyard

St Vincent Wine
St Vincent Wine

See all

DC9 Nightclub - French Onion burger, comes with garlic fries

DC9 Nightclub

3.6(272 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$

This place rocks, and I'm not saying that because of the music…read more Looking at DC9's reviews over the last 15 years, high praise for the burgers is not hard to find. Funny, though, it is even harder to find DC9 on any "best" burgers lists in the city, at least among the local publications that cover food. Trust in the recommendations from Reddit led me here. I left a little room for disappointment, but it was ultimately filled with a delicious burger and fries. The first floor is a dedicated bar and restaurant with the concert venue upstairs. On a 20-degree Sunday night, it looked spacious. The menu is not large at all. There are six types of burgers and I chose the French Onion - "saucy" caramelized onions, Gruyère cheese, and crispy fried onions on top of a half-pound patty. I give it an "A" presentation. The ingredients were not stacked too high and I loved the caramelized onion flavor in each bite. The burger meat also was cooked at medium. Next to it was a stack of garlic fries. Shouldn't there be bits of garlic all over it? No, just bite into a fry and it tastes like garlic! I don't know how they do it. On the way out, I asked the one bartender that night if DC9's burgers were a huge draw. He said yes, it's a low key place for burgers but people do come here for them and the chicken sandwich as well. DC9 deserves a spot among the greats in the city not only because the burger tastes good, but it is also a great value! $15 for a burger that comes with fries. There are places where that's the price of the burger alone, or it is even more now!

I don't really go "clubbing" much but DC9 was a lot of fun. We attended two performances. The club…read moreis not far from metro. The rooftop bar is not as exciting as I hoped but it is a fun place to grab a drink or have a snack. The bar food is reasonable (average items $3-$10, & up). Happy hour drinks were $3-$6 on average. There are lots of stairs. I am not excited about stairs. There is a bar on the lower level. Guests can grab a bite and a drink and never deal with stairs. If you attend a concert or a show, you will go up a flight of stairs to enter (two flights for the rooftop bar). The schedule is laid back. When a flyer says, "Doors open at 7:00pm," they mean 7:00pm-ish." The stage area is small. There are only a handful of tables. The metal stools are not extremely comfortable. But after you pay the cover charge (varies $15-$20 the night we visited) there isn't a minimum amount of food/drinks. There are complimentary water pitchers. The place is a fun dive. I would enjoy date night without seeing a show. The space is limited but people enjoyed dancing. Independent artists perform and sell merchandise at the counter. Be alert at night. I would have people with me if I were visiting in the evening.

Photos
DC9 Nightclub - Quiet Sunday evening, no concert

Quiet Sunday evening, no concert

DC9 Nightclub - French Onion Burger close up

French Onion Burger close up

DC9 Nightclub - Nerd Nite at DC9

See all

Nerd Nite at DC9

Warner Theatre - Nutcracker

Warner Theatre

3.7(346 reviews)
2.3 mi
•$$

50 Years of Go-Go at the Warner Theatre? Now THAT'S a DC cultural moment!…read more Came out to see The Washington Ballet celebrate 50 Years of Go-Go, and what a beautiful way to pay homage to DC's homegrown sound and culture! The Warner Theatre is a historic gem with plenty of charm, but baby, those seats need some attention! They're uncomfortable, especially when you're sitting through an entire performance. A little more cushion would go a LONG way! Other than that, I enjoyed the experience. There's something special about celebrating DC culture in one of the city's iconic theaters. Great show, beautiful venue, but those seats? Whew!

We attended Go-Go 50, 50 years of The Washington Ballet, featuring Blue until June by Trey…read moreMcIntyre, Configurations by Choo San Goh, Art of War by Edwaard Liang and An Artist's Prayer by Chanel DaSilva and Black Alley. The show was fantastic; this review is for the theatre. The day of, we received a text that no backpacks were to be allowed in the theatre. We were coming from a work event so we had to decide what to do with our stuff (we left it at the restaurant). This info should be included when purchasing tickets. When we arrived, there were two long lines to go thru metal detectors where women had to screen their purses, bags and totes. Bags were given more scrutiny than TSA. They were extremely thorough. This led to a jam as friends reunited right at the doors where people formed lines for Will Call. This was chaotic. The theatre itself, while decorative and lovely, had extremely tight seats (thus no backpacks), and sight lines were not good. While the celebration for the 50 years for The Washington Ballet was sublime, the location was mid.

Photos
Warner Theatre
Warner Theatre
Warner Theatre - Batman Live in Concert at Warner Theater

See all

Batman Live in Concert at Warner Theater

Pie Shop - cafes - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...