BEST PIZZA IN STL!! The crust is crispy and not too thin or thick and everything is well balanced. Always get a side of ranch read more

Pretty darn good! You can stop in for a single slice but I usually do carry out, its always a breeze running in to pick up. The 18" pepperoni pizza always feeds us for days - heads up the pizza box does not fit in the fridge. The garlic knots are good, dipping sauce was even better; perfectly spicy. The STL chopped salad is a must every time. They gave us a complementary chocolate chip cookie on one occasion, it absolutely did not disappoint. read more

We ordered takeout, the pizza was cooked perfectly and was so good!! They had the food ready exactly when they told us and it was so easy to check in and grab our order to go! read more

Bought an order to go, and was not disappointed. Got a pepperoni, bell pepper, olives and bacon pizza. First time getting a whole pizza. Wasn't disappointed. Big size, and good big slices. Def something to try out if you're in the Grove read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

This wasn't typical quality we've had in past years when visiting the area. Pizza crust wasn't the right consistency, almost undercooked. Toppings seemed to a lesser quality. read more

When back and had a whole pie. Just cheese, 18", maybe the size of 6 or 8 slices? It was good, really good. IMHO - getting a fresh pizza is the only way to tell what the quality is, slices are fine, but so dependent on when the came out of the oven. The first piece was too hot to get a great taste, but once it cooled off, yummy! I think the crust was the best crust I have tried in St Louis. If we are going to get really particular, I would love a little parmasan cheese in the mix, but the shaker helps heal that wound. I wish the seating was better than picnic tables, but maybe over time? It was a fun scene at the bar next door on a Friday night. read more

I love their pizza!!!! Did you know this pizza is delicious cold, hot or room temperature???? Well now you do. This pizza is absolutely delicious, no matter how you slice it. If you don't want to commit to a whole pie, I highly recommend trying a slice. Their slices are HUGE!!! The quality of the ingredients are evident in the taste. I'm super picky when it comes to sausage on pizza and their sausage was my first ever slice. When I say mind blown. It's not fatty or gritty. It's homemade, locally sourced and tasty. I couldn't get past the sausage for the longest. Then one day I bit the bullet and ordered my trusty go to.... pepperoni after speaking with one of the employees and asking them what they recommended and it was an even toss between the sausage and the pepperoni. When I tell you that I've NEVER had a bad pizza from here, it's the truth. I'm hooked!!! The staff is always soo friendly and informative. During Covid, I've had questions regarding specials before they've opened. I was able to email them and receive a quick response. Whether you order online or in person, it's always quick and easy. My pies are always presented piping hot-n-fresh. I highly recommend trying them!!!! We love their pies!!!! read more

See all

My new favorite pizza in St. Louis! Don't miss out on the hot honey! Service is quick and the pizza comes out so fresh. read more

See all

Great casual pizza spot. Head to the bar and order your favorite NY or Detroit style pizza with whatever toppings you desire! Both styles are great! Get a beer too! Table numbers are like high school sports trophy's, you'll see! Pick a table and they bring the food to you! Great spot for groups. read more

Top 3 pizza in the city of STL. Hands down a must try. Love the option to just walk in, grab a beer and just a single slice. But, I promise you will want more than one slice! Get here asap! read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Great pizza located in the Grove! Pie Guy is a great place to grab a slice of pizza and have a beer (it is connected to Gezellig) which makes it very convenient to have a slice and a pint! Definitely check this place out if you are looking for delicious food in a laid-back atmosphere. Pie Guy also serves vegetarian/vegan pizza by the slice options. read more

See all

This is what be it two places in STL that you can get the closest thing to a real NY slice. Not perfect but it definitely fills the void. Used to have a cool beer bar Nextdoor. That is now run by same people and they do a good job although not quite the same. read more

Large slices. Made fresh to order. Friendly crew. Great for a chilly, movie night in! Thanks Pie Guys! read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

I have been wanting to try Pie Guy Pizza for a while. It came to my attention that they sometimes make a Detroit pizza and that made it move way up on my to do list. Ordered online and picked it up on a weeknight. It was $33 with tax & tip. So the caramelized cheese on the edges was the best part. This pizza was sadly over baked and under sauced to the point of being really dry. I liked the flavor of the dough but it was just charred. Usually the corner pieces of a Detroit pizza are the best part but these were just dry and sad. The middle pieces were slightly more palatable. Service was friendly for the 30 seconds I was inside to pick up the pizza. Parking is not easy if it's busy in the Grove. Gezellig looks like a cool place to hang out. I will be back to try the NY pizza as that's what they seem to be known for and I've heard it's good. read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Detroit Pizza (Pepperoni) - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

I cannot rave enough about this place! Born and raised in NY, I am forever searching for the perfect slice, and I have to say, I found it right here at Pie Guy. The location we picked wasn't super easy to find. It's actually inside the Taproom and is adjacent to the brewhouse. A little confusing at first, we actually went into the bar at first by accidentally. The Pie Guy Pizza room is actually quite small, with one large table, and then a small table in the corner, nevertheless, that did not stop us from enjoying this pizza. If there was only standing room or counterspace, I would gladly stand and eat this pizza, it was THAT good. You could also eat at the bar if you wanted to (so I heard) and the bathrooms are in the bar so you gotta go there anyways to wash your hands and stuff. We had an 18" with mushroom. It came out rather quickly and we were able to watch them toss the dough and make the pizza from scratch. It gets me every time! The crust was thin, had a crunch to it. It could hold the fold without falling. The sauce was light and delicious. The cheese stringy and not too much. It wasn't too oily that it was dripping off the pizza. There were legitimate bubbles on the crust!! With a little dusting of parmesan cheese and hot pepper flakes for me, the pizza is perfect straight out of the oven. So eat the pizza there if you can! read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Perfect slice (IMO) - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Pie guy pizza has amazing slices of New York style thin crust pizza. It is located next to Gezellig and you can take pizza into there or bring your beer in Pie guy. There are pizza throwing classes in the space on Sunday and I highly recommend them. We took a fabulous class there and walked home with sourdough. The crust is made of amazing sourdough. The pizza has been recommended and described by a number of people and I second that . The other things on the menu are great as well. The garlic knots are buttery garlicky goodness. The chopped salad is also truly delicious as well. read more

See all

Five stars for their pizza (it really is good), zero stars for their customer service. We ordered a pizza for delivery and when it still hadn't been delivered three hours later, Pie Guy Pizza was unable to give us an update, put us in touch with the delivery service, or provide us a refund. I guess we're just out $50 read more

Walked in to buy a slice of pizza and was told I needed to order online and come back. Checked online and was over an hour to pickup so I left. Smelled good inside tho! On their website is says "Walk ups are always welcome" so confused why this isn't the case. read more

The Detroit style pizza from Pie Guy is top tier. It's so amazing that I've been watching for it daily lately because it's often sold out. I went with the standard pepperoni topping and while simple, it absolutely satisfied! If you get your hands on one, you definitely won't be disappointed! The service was also right on time when ordering online and picking up in store. The only issue is finding street parking for quick pick ups but that is totally out of their control! read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pepperoni Detroit Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

I like that you can get pizza by the slice here. The slices were pretty big. The best thing about the pizza was the crust. It was a super fluffy, soft crust that tasted like a homemade sourdough (maybe?) crust. Other than the crust, the only flavor on the pizza was the pepperoni, which was a bit spicy. I couldn't really taste the sauce or any other seasonings. I think more sauce or flavors would boost this pizza up to 5 stars. read more

The pizza was to die for it was ssooo tasty and flavorful ! The staff was super friendly and welcoming ! The ranch is so good with the pizza . The drinks are ok but they are good and get the job done will definitely recommend to anyone who loves pizza and drinks cheers ! 10/10 read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

Excellent pizza slice and STL salad and very reasonably priced. My friend had the garlic knots and really liked them--I found them to be fairly dense/heavier than I like. Very nice location and ambiance. Would've given this a 5-star however found some signage offensive and inappropriate for small kids (of which there were some in there).. Will definitely be back for more. read more

This place may be small, but it sure has a lot of flavor! The pizza here is the perfect balance of saucy and cheesy. The garlic knots are done to perfection. They even offer nutritional yeast to add to your pizza (delicious). The place is attached to what seems to be like a "grab & go" beer/drink place, which adds to the overall fun atmosphere. The service here is always good. Will definitely visit again read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Great pizza place. Casual, fun atmosphere, small by itself but attached to a bar/bottle shop with plenty of seating normally (though pretty packed on a Saturday night). Hilarious decor, I loved the pizza tables and pizza pictures and general pizza obsession. Trophies instead of number tickets. Pizza is a little more expensive than average, but slices are pretty big! I had just one slice with drinks and some garlic knots and was definitely satisfied. I love that they offer slices in additional to full pizzas. Pizza was great, NY style. It wasn't my favorite in St. Louis, but it was close. A little greasy for my taste and a little too baked - crispier than your typical NY. Good seasonings, though. Garlic knots are yummy. I would like to see a vegetarian version of the Knotchos - they looked good. Our entire party was satisfied and had a good time. Service was quick. read more

See all

Window for pizza and snacks (including salads, garlic knots, pretzel bites, etc) that is connected to a taproom and bottle shop in The Grove. Tap room has an enormous selection of beer, and has both table and counter bar seating. Have a couple of board games lying around that you can play at your table as well. Counter service, and use trophies as table markers. Limited seating in the area where you order, but tons of seating in the tap room. Pizza is New York-style. Can either get an 18-inch pizza with your choice of toppings, or a $4/5 slice. Also have vegan and vegetarian options. Stay open super late (Midnight T-Th & 3:30 AM F & Sat). My review should be taken with a grain of salt because I grew up outside of NY (and am therefore a pizza snob) but I tried both the sausage and the pepperoni and was not a huge fan of either. The crust was too crunchy and the pizza was too thin. It tasted like an STL pizzeria's take of a NY pizza to me. I tried a salad as well and it was ok, but not great read more

Walk in and place your order or call ahead. Located right next door to Gezellig (beer bar and bottle shop) so you'll have some great drinks available next door while you wait. About 10:30pm on a Saturday night, we waited about 15 minutes in line and then about 5 minutes after ordering for our slices. Served hot and melty! Great crust, great size slices, great value! read more

See all

Friends from NYC suggested this place so we tried it out and it was really good. I'm all about the crust but the sauce was amazing and the toppings were perfect. Seriously this was a really good pizza and I don't even crave pizza but maybe now I will. read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Mushroom and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

A New York style pizza spot in St. Louis and it was amazing! It's connected to gezellig a tap house with a great selection of beer to buy and on tap. Loved the pepperoni pizza and the cheese pizza. Had a nice crust to it. The drinks were really amazing! The Evil Twin Blue Raspberry and the Prairie Punch were my favorite! I will be back for more! read more

See all

Best pizza I have had here (because it's not super thin saint louis style no doubt...) but the pizzas are LARGE. They are usually busy, so we call our order in and just go pick it up. Last time though, we arrived before the estimated "pickup" time and asked if it was ready and were told "your time is 10minutes from now" so just don't go early read more

Please dear lord bring back the Detroit style. I'll beg if I have to! Truly the best Detroit style pizza you can get in stl (no offense Jets). read more

I did not know what to expect when I went here. At first glance, small shop with what appears to be cold pizza in a case on one side but a table full of overlapping order receipts on the other (so there has to be something special about this place). I went ahead and ordered a slice of pepperoni... what came out was the biggest slice EVER of toasted perfection. It was the perfect combo of crust:sauce:toppings. I can say it is best pizza I've had in a while, and I can't wait to eat here again. My friend told me to add hot honey next time ( my fav combo ever and they have it). Garlic knots - also . read more

Best NYC STYLE Pizza in STL! I am so lucky I live close by and can pick up their pizzas when I m crashing a slice. The overall feel to the restaurant is casual laid back and if you are a beer lover they have some cool options too! Definitely go try them Out you won't be disappointed read more

Pizza wasn't the best I've ever had but definitely a solid choice. Garlic knots were quite good but there wasn't much seating. Definitely better for delivery or pickup then dine in. Service was really good and had a cool vibe for to the place read more

This is my favorite pie in town. We have ordered the whole pie a few times now to go and it is huge, it makes us pizza happy for 2 meals.. Should really be like 3 meals but it is so delicious not to have another slice while you can still move.. Their red pies and white pies are both amazing. My husband and I usually get a half and half. Glad they have that option. It's like getting 2 pizzas :) I really appreciate their online ordering system and quick they are to bring out your order when you arrive during your time slot. read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

This some good ass pIzza best I've tasted in a long time knots kinda chewy but the sauce it comes with and the crazy amount of parmigiana they dust on top makes the worth wild read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Garlic Knots with Red Sauce - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

We got slices to-go thru the window around midnight during Moonlight Ramble. It was exactly what I wanted it to be, as far as pizza & a pizza window experience. Order windows were a common thing for me growing up in NY that I miss having in StL. It was a new experience for my daughter. The young ladies working the window get 5 stars in hustle, smiles, and courtesy. The outdoor tables and trash needed some attention, but there were 2000+ people hanging around for Ramble. The pizza line was consistently 20+ ppl deep while we were there. Would easily return for another slice! read more

My girlfriend and I love going to Pie Guy. The pizza slices are huge, and greasily delicious. The service is quick and the staff are friendly, you can buy by the slice or by the pie. The ambiance is good as they have one area for ordering and you can take out from there or you can eat in the other area with lots of tables and some amenities. read more

Great NY style pizza whether you are grabbing a slice or a whole pizza! The service has always been quick and friendly when our family goes on Friday nights. read more

Great, quick service. Pizza was delicious and vegan parent enjoyed his slice too. Would definitely come back. I wish the bar next door hadn't closed, though! read more

Is there a another star to add here???? Incredible. Between the pizza & the salads & the garlic knots & the delicious ranch & hot honey PIE GUY FOR PRESIDENT! Great food great koolaid great people read more