Cancel

Open app

Search

Pie Five Pizza

3.8 (60 reviews)
InexpensiveItalian, Pizza, Vegan
Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Pie Five Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Pie Five Pizza Photos

PIE FIVE PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Outdoor seating
Good for groups

Recommended Reviews - Pie Five Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

- Hawaiian pizza on thin crust

Lexington is so lucky to have a pie five pizza. Even though I had to drive this food back to Louisville, I had to stop here for dinner because we LOVE their pizza. Even when I got it home, it was amazingly good. I love their cauliflower crust pizza. Hubby loves their Hawaiian pizza!

Sydney B.

We came here on a friend's recommendation before a movie and it was not disappointing. We arrived right when it opened so we did not have to wait long for the food. The set up reminds me of a Qdoba where you tell the employee what you want and they make it right there. At least you know it is fresh. I went with the combo where you get a personal pizza and a salad. Everything was spot on and you get a lot of food for how much you pay for. If you need a quick pizza fix, this is your place to go.

Olwen C.

I bought a coupon on Xooker to try this place. It was exactly what I expected a build your own pizza place would be like. It didn't disappoint nor did it exceed my expectations. We ordered a 14 inch pizza and a large salad to share. Actually the chicken on the salad would have been very disappointing if it had been meant as an entree because it was little tiny cubes of chicken, not exactly "grilled chicken" like the menu states. But anyway, the pizza was decent. We tried the thin crust and had lots of toppings. Pretty much all the toppings are included in the price, so that is nice. We had some trouble using our Xooker voucher because they redeemed it before they were ready on their cash register, and then we couldn't get the app to open it back up. They sorted it out but it is always frustrating when places offer coupons through an app and then don't know how to redeem them. But it let us try the place at a discounted price so I can't complain. Would I come back, probably not but I would still recommend trying it if pizza is your thing.

Wonderful food and Superb service, so no excuse.......Duh! Best decision you've made in awhile.
Carey H.

Built to perfection every time we have been in for solid prices and best taste around. This come from an ac reefer tech moved to Georgetown and retired that had 24/7 access to 22 chain Pizza joints and serviced numerous other restaurants in my 40+ years of service. You seriously need to truly try....... You will return time after

From inside the mall.
Laura N.

After hearing a lot about Pie Five through Yelp and friends, my husband and I grabbed a late lunch here before some people-watching at the mall a few days ago. We don't like the mall, but Pie Five has an outdoor entrance in addition to a mall entrance. Despite the crowds finding last-minute holiday gifts, we were able to grab a parking spot not too far from the doors of Pie Five. Win! Once inside, we quickly scanned the menu -- with their classic offerings or make-your-own options, and decided to go for some of their creations. I ordered the Farmers' Market pizza (cheese and veggies on a wheat crust) and my husband had the Buffalo Chicken pizza (buffalo chicken stuff on a crust.... don't ask me, I don't like buffalo chicken). Both pizzas were made super-quick and tasted great! Fresh and filling but not too heavy. My husband also added a caesar salad, which he said was "normal." For fun, I had a beer, but was really disappointed to recieve it in a can, and not a bottle. Especially for nearly $4. Note to self: never get beer here again. BUT, $7 for a quick, hand-made personal pizza that more than satisfies? Yes, please!! If we ever come back to the mall and get hungry after all the walking around, Pie Five is staying in our rotation of places to eat (and there aren't many places here that appeal to us).

Destiny B.

My daughter loves this place! We go back because of an employee named LP. He goes out of his way to interact with kids and make designing a pizza fun. The restaurant is clean and well kept. We love that you can build your own pizza. Their Greek salad is amazing. If you ask nicely, they'll give you extra olives and artichoke hearts. My husband loves the garlic sticks and classic pepperonis.

Menu
Michelle R.

There are a lot of these fast Pizza places in Lexington these days and you don't have to drive too far to find one. I love pizza, period! I really like Pie Five's their new diet/friendly option for a kid size (4 slice) pizza with a small salad. The pizza has a cracker thin crust which I like and I load up the pizza with a ton of veggies so I don't miss the extra pieces of the 11" pies. They offer a low calorie Italian dressing that you can get on the side to help save a few more calories. If you are not watching calories, I recommend the cinnamon stix! They have a Free Style Coke machine here if you are picky about your soft drink selection. Don't forget to download their app. Scan it as you check out and you earn points toward rewards.

Tina L.

Im taking 2 stars off for false advertisement. Tuesday is kids eat free with the purchase of a an entree and it shows a picture of a kids pizza, drink and dessert BUT when you go to check out, you only get the kids pizza free and not the dessert or drink so all in all, you dont really save by doing the kids eat free deal. If you only get the kids pizza for free, why show a picture with everything the kids meal includes making it appear as though you get everything included. The food is good no doubt but when it comes to kids day, its false.

Jamie M.

My first visit to Pie Five. When I first walked by it seemed to have a long line but it flows pretty quickly for it to be a fix as your order place. I like that you have the option to add what ever ingredients you want and it's all for one price! No charge each topping. I tried the whole grain Neopolitan with ham, people pineapple, mushrooms and black olives. The mozzarella tasted fresh. You can make your pizza as a salad in a pizza bowl as well. They also offer gluten free pizza crust, but for those that are allergic to gluten I'm not sure how well they keep it separated. The employees friendly. Nice seating area inside and out. It's a nice addition to have a restaurant on that end of the mall actually inside the mall. I'd definitely go back again.

Two free pizzas!
Looking Out For The City ..

Pretty sweet deal. I write a review about them and they find a minuscule detail that I did not like and they send me two free pizza gift cards. I needed that. Kind of slow on work with my independent contractor stuff and could use these so I do not starve. Thanks again Pie Five! Also, a shout out to all other businesses in Lexington that have given me free gift cards. It is these businesses that I tend to highlight because customer service is off the charts when I get handouts!

The Five Star
Stephanie G.

I stopped at Pie Five for dinner the other night and it was really good. I like that you get to watch them make your pizza and also the fact that all the pizzas are the same price no matter how many toppings you choose. You can either create your own pizza or pick one from the menu. I tried the Five Star and the Athenian - both with the classic pan crust. They were delicious (I liked the Athenian slightly better). I am excited to go back and also glad there is another location opening in Lexington, since I don't always feel like fighting mall traffic and parking when I'm eating out.

Sierra H.

BEST PIZZA PLACE EVER. Hands down. Best customer service too. I am absolutely in love with their Italian crust, but they also have gluten free crust and other options!!! Their toppings are always fresh. I've been getting pizzas from them for about two months now and I have never been disappointed! I love that they are super friendly and will go that extra mile just to make sure you have had a good experience with them. It's awesome how you can make your own pizza with them and literally get WHATEVER you want on there! Even different types of cheeses for zero charge. Definitely a good bang for your buck. It's absurd that I used to go to smashing tomato and spend $12+ on a pizza when now I only spend $8 and get all the toppings and honestly, even better pizza from pie five. If you all haven't gone... go!

Space man sink in the bathroom!!

See all

Photo of Megan L.
27
30
10

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Ram A.
0
23
5

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Josh H.
118
10
0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Food is great! Price is not, but the staff was rude and uninterested in my business. Won't be returning!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Kimberly T.

Kimberly T.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of P I.
0
5
0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Pie Five Pizza

Verify this business for free

People searched for Italian 1,628 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Pasta Garage Italian Cafe - Chicken Alfredo

Pasta Garage Italian Cafe

4.1(482 reviews)
4.7 mi
•$$

Food, services & atmosphere…read more Fresh ingredients cooked daily. Great venue to hangout or have a formal event.

I came here because if the gluten free pasta. You order at a window and they give you a pager to be…read morecalled back when your food is ready. Then you pick your food up and you bus your own table. The food was fine. I got the gluten-free pasta with Marinara sauce and grilled chicken. My partner got gnocchi with the arrabiata sauce with grilled chicken. It took FOREVER to get our food and it wasn't that busy. In fact the people behind us got their food before we did; which I assume was because of my gluten-free item. When we did get it, it was missing my chicken. He got his chicken but I did not. So they brought that out separately. The meals were steaming hot which was great, but I then had to assemble my meal. And honest to me it was spicy on my tongue. Which I am going to guess was because of the amount of salt in the dish. And really the worst part is we were going to sit outside but the tables were disgusting and not clean from previous people eating out there. And based on the fact we bus our own tables I am guessing they do not get clean often. It is unfortunate. You got to the bathrooms and there is a window looking into the back. You can see them doidishes and the assembly line of pasta to go. They are so worried about all that but cannot keep the resturant clean so people can enjoy the food. They must really rely on take out and to go.

Photos
Pasta Garage Italian Cafe - Interior

Interior

Pasta Garage Italian Cafe - Beef & Gnocchi Tuscano

Beef & Gnocchi Tuscano

Pasta Garage Italian Cafe - Entrance sign and artwork

See all

Entrance sign and artwork

Sutton's - Baked Chicken & Broccoli tossed in a cream sauce. Delicious!

Sutton's

3.7(267 reviews)
4.6 mi
•$$

Wow! I have been wanting to try their Philly Dip, and Chicago Beef sandwiches and I tried the…read morePhilly Dip today which blew me away! The beef was tender and thin and had great flavor. I love the au jus but what really makes it special is the fresh bread! This is my new favorite sandwich. I read another review. It said that it didn't have much flavor, but mine certainly came with huge flavor and was seasoned well.

We stopped into Sutton's on Valentine's Day last minute, which is basically the restaurant…read moreequivalent of showing up to a wedding without RSVPing. So first -- major credit where it's due: the service was fantastic. It was busy, it was chaotic, it was love-in-the-air level packed... and our server was still kind, attentive, and genuinely great. It was a little slow, but honestly? On Valentine's Day? Totally understandable. Now, let's talk food. The meatball appetizer? Outstanding. If the whole meal had that same energy, this would be a different review. Those meatballs came in like the confident main character. I ordered the Chicago beef (hot instead of sweet), expecting bold, juicy, maybe-a-little-spicy goodness. Instead... it tasted like someone whispered "beef" from another room. I kept waiting for the flavor to arrive. It never did. I'm not saying it was bland, but salt might have been an optional add-on. My husband ordered the Manzo Parmesan pasta. He eats medium rare. This steak was blue. Not "a little under." Not "oops." It was grazing-in-a-field-five-minutes-ago rare. If it mooed, I wouldn't have been shocked. BUT -- we need to talk about the music. The playlist was elite. Every song that came on was something off my Apple playlist. At one point I genuinely wondered if they'd somehow tapped into my phone. 10/10 vibes. I was half expecting my "On Repeat" playlist to start playing next. All that said, the staff truly did their best on one of the busiest nights of the year, and we appreciated that. The bones of a really good experience are there especially if the kitchen can bring the same magic to the entrées that they brought to those meatballs. Would we try it again? Maybe but next time I'm ordering whatever the meatballs are having... and asking for the playlist.

Photos
Sutton's
Sutton's - Italian meat lovers pizza

Italian meat lovers pizza

Sutton's - French Onion Soup

See all

French Onion Soup

Carrabba's Italian Grill - The Johhny Trio

Carrabba's Italian Grill

3.9(166 reviews)
6.4 mi
•$$

I wish we had a Carrabba's close by. But since we travel to Tennessee and Georgia a lot, we…read morefrequent this location. I lived in the area in the early 2000's and fell in love with Carrabba's while living there. Was always packed. Fast forward to now... it's never been what I would even call close to busy when we've gone. I'm not sure why. Our service has always been excellent and we have enjoyed our meals in a quiet atmosphere. Perfect. We. Love. Their. Chicken. Marsala! Their Caesar salad is our favorite. The bread is great, but that Chicken Marsala never misses. Great meal for a decent price.

We dined here for lunch and everything about our visit was awful. We were greeted by the hostess…read morewho had her mouth full of food. Our waitress was very inattentive. She spent most of her time standing around with other waitresses talking. We were seated as far from the kitchen as you could be and she was so loud yelling that we could hear every word. There was a small child sitting at a table alone that the wait staff kept checking on. Not sure if this was an employee's child that they brought to work with them. As we were about to eat, the hostess seated a man and his dog across from us. It was not a service dog. As the waitresses surrounded the puppy the owner explained it was 8 weeks old and he just got it yesterday. He sat the dog in the chair, on the table, and walked it across the restaurant, in which the wait staff pet it then went back to waiting tables. Our waitress then sat at the table with the child (close to the hostess podium) and other waitresses and yelled across the restaurant to the kitchen to order herself an Italian salad. The food was awful. We ordered the chicken parm and mezalluna. The chicken was beaten paper thin and the pasta was room temp and flavorless. We added the spices they bring for the bread to the dishes in an attempt to add some flavor. $50 for water, two entrees, and a very disappointing lunch service. Based on our dining experience, we do not recommend this restaurant and will not return.

Photos
Carrabba's Italian Grill - Pepperoni Pizza available at lunch & Wednesday Pizza & Pours

Pepperoni Pizza available at lunch & Wednesday Pizza & Pours

Carrabba's Italian Grill - Chicken Caprese Pizza available at lunch &  Wednesday Pizza & Pours

Chicken Caprese Pizza available at lunch & Wednesday Pizza & Pours

Carrabba's Italian Grill - Filet & Shrimp Pasta Toscana

See all

Filet & Shrimp Pasta Toscana

Tony's of Lexington - Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

Tony's of Lexington

4.3(590 reviews)
4.6 mi
•$$$$

This is our favorite restaurant in Lexington! I love their steaks and the sides are incredible. My…read morewife doesn't order crab cakes at any restaurant but here anymore. Once you have had a Tony's crab cake, nothing else comes close. Their sides are incredible. We have to get the potato wedges every time we go. They are so crispy on the outside, I believe that they are double fried. The cheese crumbles and the aïoli really make them amazing! The sweet potatoes are to die for and brussels sprouts are good. You can't go wrong with their salads either I love the Caesar and the Greek. I always like to try some of the other dishes as well. They have good pasta and seafood, and the short ribs are delicious in summary. Everything is top-notch at this place. We love it.!

The food and service was good as always! I had a smoky rosé cocktail that was very light and…read morerefreshing. My date got the 9 ounce filet mignon and I got the Sea bass. We split the asparagus and truffle wedges. The sea bass need a little more flavor. The sauce that came with it was more sweet, which I was not a huge game of. I would highly recommend the truffle wedges perfect amount of salty and truffle (the truffle is not too overbearing). The service is really good. Our server gave us the specials and a good explanation of all the food. He was friendly and not too distracting. I will say it was dark in there, but it helped to create the ambience. Definitely recommend a reservation. There are lots of people waiting.

Photos
Tony's of Lexington - Entrance

Entrance

Tony's of Lexington
Tony's of Lexington

See all

Pie Five Pizza - italian - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...