I've had some really great experiences here! The staff is always smiley and friendly, and personable! The food is always super good! my favorite is the arugula & avocado salad, and I honestly don't even like arugula but it just works well with the other flavors of the salad. The chicken curry salad is also super yummy and filling! They have an excellent selection of drinks to choose from as well. The location of the place is easily found, right off i70. Inside is super cute and cozy. The windows are big and I personally LOVE a nice bright room full of natural light. Overall, I'd say 5/5 cause they fill my needs every time I've went in. I'm not one to ever leave a bad review either, we all have our moments! We're human! But I DO love to leave good reviews so I hope this helps with your possible choosing of Pickled for your eats! read more

Delicious. I had the "Frenchie", it was delicious: baked honey ham, smoked pork shoulder slice, real Swiss, pickled onions, Dijon, on a crusty roll. I was very good. But my husband's sandwich, wow, it was dreamy. Jeff had the "Louisville Hot Brown". If we go back I'm ordering the Louisville. It was openface turkey, thick bacon slices, beefsteak tomato slice, havarti, sauce mornay, on sourdough. It melted in your mouth as you ate it. We will definitely eat here again; if in this area again. read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - The Louisville Hot Brown sandwich. I have already cut it up; so pic isn't as pretty as it was originally. - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Ate their curried chicken salad sandwich and it was very good. It's nice and neat place.

Delicious and Fresh. A new favorite spot. I've met everyone from Eagle, CO to Indianapolis, IN know that they have to go here the next time they're close by. read more

We've been here twice and both times we're excellent. Now anytime we're heading toward Vail we always make it a point to stop. The sandwiches and salads here are top notch, creative, and made with high quality ingredients. They have lots of seating and a nice dog friendly patio. Definitely check it out, guaranteed you'll find something you love on the menu. read more

If you are even remotely close to PICKLED KITCHEN PANTRY in Eagle, CO....DO NOT MISS IT. This is a fantastic restaurant with a menu is innovative and fun. Great beer selection too. Their cold case and pantry section is filled with wonderful, hard to find items all great for an impromptu cocktail party or picnic. We had the Czar salad with smoked CO salmon (so glad I got the dinner roll, delish) and the pastrami on rye with potato salad. A lovely lunch, we sat outside...we will be back. read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - The Czar salad, and yes this is smoked CO salmon. - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

Love it! I am a true skeptic when going to sandwich spots of any sorts because I eat a vegan diet and in my experience, most places will mess up the order or kind of tell you that they can't fully accommodate or that "it's just not the same without (insert meat/cheese) on it". PICKLED IS NOT THAT PLACE! I asked if they could make the Garden sandwich vegan, and the gentleman was like " yes for sure" and recommended the bread to hold all the veggies in. It was one of the best sandwiches I have seriously ever had! SO many veggies and lots of fresh amazing flavors! I am so happy has this spot in Eagle now! Thanks Pickled Pantry for being wonderful! read more

This spot was a perfect place to stop with the family, clean, great vibe, and the foot was phenomenal. We will make this place part of our travels in the future! Seriously a gem! read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - Refreshing beautiful dining space. - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Stopped in for to go sandwiches to have a picnic lunch. We tried the Chi and the Manhattan- both were delicious! They each came with a side. We tried the potato and pasta salad. Don't miss this fantastic deli - great food and nice selection of upscale grocery items. read more

Hands down best place for lunch in Eagle. Amazing food with a variety of options. Owner Michael is very nice and so is the staff!! I got the maui maui tacos and would definitely get again! read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - Maui Maui tacos - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

Clean and elegant!! Food was fresh and good tasting, we order mahi mahi tacos and a gyro and both were awesome. Thanks!! read more

Love the pre-made meals, all the funky food options are fun to try and the fish pho noodles are to die for.

Good sandwich had the chicken with roasted red peppers and mozzarella. Yummy! good portion size. Very gourmet so expect to pay more. Walked in and it's a small euro style market deli. . read more

Food was amazing and great service. I had the chicken salad curry and husband had the Frenchie both of them amazing.

Tried the Mayflower, Chi Town, Rueben, and Da Vino... all were awesome! Highly recommend the place. Potato salad has a nice grain mustard kick. Great staff! Sit outside and enjoy the view. read more

Eat here! Actually considered extending my stay so I might enjoy one more delightful lunch at "Pickled'! Not your average sandwich shop, Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry is in another league. Lovely. Creative. Delicious. Thank you to its proprietor and talented staff. read more

Don't pick up the phone and then tell you they're closed when you arrive 20 minutes before closing time. Not a great start. Looks like a cool concept so I hope they can improve. read more

The BEST sandwiches I have ever had! Thankfully we had a local give us a tip on visiting this fantastic place. Awesome meats, bread, and fresh ingredients on everything. We didn't get to try ALL the sandwiches, so we'll have to go back. :) The Chi-town, Frenchie, Reuben with pastrami & pork belly & Don Vito were amazing, and my personal favorite was the Chi-town. It's worth a stop even if you are just passing through town. read more

Amazing!!! We walked inside and were greeted right away and offered any help deciding on a sandwich, if we needed assistance. I ordered the Chi-town, my husband had the Don Vito and they made the perfect sandwich for my 9 year old. She only wanted turkey on bread, dry, nothing else. They made her sandwich look and feel so special with sides of fruit. Everything was delicious. The bread was crusty, yet soft on the inside and so fresh. I have no idea if the fella helping us owned the shop or not, but he was so helpful and had such a great personality, it was truly just icing in the cake!! Unfortunately we were just passing through Eagle, but will definitely be back when we are in the area. read more

The Pickled kitchen serves amazing sandwiches and authentic European goods and drinks. The staff is super kind and friendly. I definitely will be stopping here all the time. read more

My favorite place in the valley! AMAZING FOOD! Can't wait to go back tomorrow :) A bit over priced but sooo worth it!

The sandwiches were delicious, and the staff was fantastic. We went right before a hike at Hanging Lake.

The pastrami is delicious. Also recommend the Frenchie. Great selection of gourmet goodies. The staff is kind. The owner told me to feel better after I told him we were taking a trip to Denver for a medical procedure. Fabulous. Support local business and grab a great sandwich, salad or grilled cheese. read more

Best Reuben ever!!! Highly recommend. Short rib tacos were out of this world also. Thank you David for a great service. read more

These sandwiches are amazing.... Also the spicy Napa cabbage green bean slaw was crazy good, can't wait to come back.

This place is amazing. I ordered the Korean BBQ tacos to go that were 1+ hours old and still unbelievably amazing. We've all had our share of tacos, but the sauce was not overpowering (great proportions), the taco was well balanced proportion wise, manageable size (especially with the well thought out skewer) with plenty of ingredients. The side pad Thai was a bit spicy (my preference), but the heat would blow anyone out of the water - again, great idea as a side just too spicy. I might go back again tonight! Haha. Would really like to see who their original chef was! Eagle's needed a mid-tier priced, well thought out decor/interior restaurant since the pasta restaurant closed. This fills a great niche in town and I hope it stays around for years to come! read more

Such a cute friendly little place! The decor is awesome the cooks in waitstaff absolutely the friendliest! And the food is fresh and amazing! read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

We have tried half the menu and everything is so good!! This Garden Veg Sandwich, Cheesesteak, Italian Sandwich, Salads, Manhattan, everything! I buy the curried chicken salad by the pint! Delicious, clean, friendly, etc. Love this place! read more

Pickled. Kitchen & Pantry - The Garden Veg Sandwich - Salad Near Me - Eagle, Colorado

See all

What a refreshing, deli gourmet food shop to grace our valley. Food and goodies just fantastic ! I'm very picky and have traveled around the world seeking culinary goodies. We finally have an awesome place , and the prices are quite reasonable for this over priced valley. A MUST TRY ! read more

Absolutely the best, top notch in verity and quality of food, service and the staff, ambiance and decor, even beer selection is on point. The pantry as stocked with specialty foods from around the world. Even meal prep options to buy by the quart and take home. From top to bottom this place has earned high grades in my book. And I've done my due diligence, I have had everything on the menu, many twice and they are consistent in their execution. Do yourself a favor and come see what this place has going on you will be happy you did so, maybe suggest a regular customers punch card, you'll be back. read more

This is easily my new favorite lunch spot in Eagle! I ordered the Reuben and it was extraordinary. The addition of the melt in your mouth pork belly really bumped it over the top. read more

The food was amazing with minimal wait and awesome service. Employees were friendly and helpful. Would eat here again! Highly recommend.

Great menu with a variety of choices to include a range of drinks to choose from. I had the Mountain Christi and it was perfect! Friendly service always helps. Highly recommend. read more

We were headed out for a 6 mile hike after dropping friends at the airport, totally unprepared so we stopped here grabbed a sandwich, chips & macaroni salad. Probably one of the best sandwiches we've had in years. Roast beef with au ju & horseradish. Yummy with lots of meat. try this place they also have a nice indoor & outdoor seating. read more

This is a beautiful place, spotlessly clean and well thought out. Shelves full of gourmet goodies, beautiful cheeses, and tinned goods. Our food was incredible: rivals anything I have had anywhere in the world. Why only 3 stars then? The staff was weirdly unengaged. Perhaps they had a bad morning but we didn't feel any connection with them. Not exactly rude but certainly not friendly. They weren't particularly busy so it is a mystery. I will definitely give it another chance, the food is that good. read more

Great vibe for a specialized deli like experience. Folks that run it are great and you can tell they care about quality. Highly recommend for a great sandwich read more

Quality food that is so delicious! Everyone that works there is so kind as well. Best deli in town!

Best food in Eagle Period!! The flavors these guys have conjured in their food leave you feeling saisfied. These guys use high quality ingredients in their food. Try the Korean short rib tacos fire!!!! Oh and the BLT sliders, as simple as they sound are sticking awesome!!! Again when you use high quality ingredients the food will speak for itself. Give this place a try and I promise you'll go back. read more

Nice little place to stop for a quick tasty bite while traveling through. The restaurant is inviting with colorful decor and food displays as well as being very well maintained. read more

Definitely stop here if you're driving through town. The chicken salad sandwich was insane!