Peter Piper Pizza

Locally owned & operated

Established in 2007

Great service, daughter wanted a spicy pickle pizza and they made it happen. I would order this…read morepizza again for sure.

First time trying it as soon as you walk in the workers were kind and welcoming, being our first…read moretime going there they helped us with the menu and when we got our food in a nice timely manner it was good portions for a really good price. Every first time customer gets their cannolis they were really good definitely a way to treat a first time customer. It's a drive for us but we will definitely be going back!

The best Pizza in AZ

Inside

See all

Caprese Pizza

Palermos Pizza

3.7(119 reviews)

0.5 mi

Great pizza, loved the beer battered zucchini! Customer…read moreservice was top notch! 5 Stars Walmart Distribution loves Palermo's pizza

I had never eaten here before and decided to check it out , we ordered a 18 inch pepperoni and…read moreHawaiian pizza as well as an order of garlic knots and some wings which came out to $80 . I will say the Hawaiian pizza was excellent and tasted great , I feel that the pepperoni pizza could have used more pepperoni but was still good. We ordered over the phone and the staff was fast and friendly when picking it up. The restaurant seemed clean and had tvs with football games on. I think next time I will wait for a special but would come back and eat again.

Entrance.

Chicken parmigiana

See all

Ciao Grazie Pizzeria Winebar

3.7(347 reviews)

4.6 mi

We had lunch at Ciao Grazie in Buckeye and had such a great experience! The service was excellent,…read moreand the pizza was absolutely delicious. Our server, Brady, was especially great. He made thoughtful recommendations, was attentive, and went out of his way to accommodate us. It's always nice when someone genuinely cares about making sure you have a great experience. We'll definitely be back! Highly recommend Ciao Grazie -- and ask for Brady!

Great little spot and worth a try. They have a daily happy hour 3-6pm with items at $8. We tried…read moreone of each happy hour food item. Pizzas were pretty good as was the Caprese and salad. We tried the bruschetta sampler and man those were amazing. The mushroom was my favorite. The old fashion wasn't too great but the blueberry mule was delicious. Service was really good as well. They don't show you the orders on the receipt which I don't get. If the receipt was off you wouldn't know unless you make it an issue. Only critique. Everything else was really good.

Bar

See all

4 for $24 Bruschette

Godfather's Pizza

4.5(10 reviews)

2.1 mi

Had pizza and wings. The pizza was delicious, well topped gooey cheese, it was wonderful. The baked…read morewings were good, could have been served a little hotter, they were fairly cold!

Great pizza as always! So glad a Godfather's was part of the new Love's in Buckeye.read more

See all

Barro's Pizza

2.8(114 reviews)

3.4 mi

Casual dining

Family-owned & operated

Parking can be tricky. Safe area…read more We've stayed tons at the hotel next door and would walk to the restaurant with our children. They keep the lot clean too. The restaurant staff is helpful and friendly. The lines can get long and the wait can be a while but if you go at the right time...the food I always fresh and hot and the salad bar is worth it. We moved to town and go often now.

Love Barro's! I hate the DoorDash delivery ordeal that this franchise has established. So I order…read morefrom a different restaurant when I want delivery. Restaurant is typically clean and pleasant, but I did have a dead fly in my Parmesan cheese shaker... fresh out of their fridge... Thankfully when I showed a staff member they were also mortified and replaced it. Still, I check the cheese thoroughly every single time I'm there lol..

See all

Papa Paul's Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

4.3(654 reviews)

12.1 mi

If you're staying at the Wigwam Resort and your niece and her husband, who live in the Phoenix…read morearea, drop by and also bring three friends, getting a couple large pizzas and a strawberry & bacon salad from Papa Paul's will save you a bunch of money over treating them all to dine at the restaurant/bar at the resort. Both pizzas were interesting. The Lichfield Park pizza has pesto sauce and corn on it, as well as cheese, so you might get a slice of that after your "guests" scarf their first helping. You better grab a slice of the Brooklyn pizza right away, though, because it's a traditional-looking pizza with pepperoni and sausage. You won't get a second shot at a slice. You'll get to finish the rest of the "adult" strawberry & bacon salad, though, with spinach instead of lettuce, walnuts, strawberries, and bacon bits. It doesn't come with ranch or even ranch-colored dressing, so they might not risk trying a pinkish salad dressing as a dip for their pizza crust. It's a very good salad and helped my vacation digestion, since I'm not used to the 110° August heat. Papa Paul's Pizza is less than a mile away from my room at the Wigwam. Going there would even be walkable in the summer heat if the fences around the Wigwam had pedestrian gates. As it is, both driveway gates on that corner of the Wigwam are slotted through the perimeter fence far from the place where Papa Pauls and the resort are just across the street from each other. I'm too delicate for a 0.9-mile walk in that much sun. I enjoyed a glass of wine at the bar to rehydrate, though, while I waited for the pizzas to come out of the oven.

Came here for date night on a whim after driving by on a busy weekend. We were seated promptly, and…read morethe interior is cute. There were a couple of big groups which was nice to know. Limited wine list for an Italian restaurant. We started with a caesar salad to split - SO much cheese, it was too much. I understand some people like that, but I wish they would have lightened up the amount and just have people ask for more if they want that. I ordered the chicken & broccoli alfredo. Sauce was clearly made in house, but the pasta itself was generic and did not taste like it was homemade. Good amount of protein though. We also ordered the mango and classic cannolis, and these stole the show. Flaky to perfection! If we come back, we might try the pizzas to see how it compares to the pasta.

This guy cooked every pie one after the other, sometime 5-6 at a time, and cranked them all out!

Eggplant caprese

See all

Ricotta and sausage

Taste of Italy

4.3(439 reviews)

9.7 mi

These guys have always been amazing. The pizza is great, flavorful, and reasonably priced. It's a…read morefamily place, and the staff and family treat you that way.

Went on a lunch date with my favorite lunch partner and a rowdy teen boy. We were on the hunt for…read moresomething FAST to eat near Buc-ee's because we knew we needed to fuel up before facing those massive lines and the wait at the new popular gas station. We landed at Taste of Italy in Goodyear, and honestly... solid choice! This is a legit NY-style pizzeria with all the usual suspects. We tried the Meat Lovers pizza, a cheese slice, and a pepperoni calzone -- and every single one landed at about an 8/10. The cheese slice was the first clue that we might be onto something. The crust was crisp and firm but still had that perfect little flop at the tip. True NY style! You could tell the dough was fresh, and the flavor was definitely there. You order at the counter, they bring everything to your table, and the turnaround was quick. Everything came out piping hot, the staff was friendly, and the restaurant was clean. It's not a huge space, but it's a comfortable size for a neighborhood pizzeria. Nothing overly fancy.....just good pizza, good food and good service. Definitely a solid spot to keep in mind when we're in the Goodyear area. Taste of Italy gets the thumbs up from us!

Inside

Wings

See all

Even the salt and pepper is dirty

Tailgaters & IL Primo - Buckeye

3.2(97 reviews)

0.3 mi

Sariah is a great server very friendly and kind we being here so many times we would always come…read moreback the food is great. Thanks for the great service

I've been to quite a few locations, but this one was a first for me. It feels a lot smaller than…read morethe other ones I've been to.. we see them in the bar area at a high top. We ordered a few drinks while he looked over the menu. I opted for the wedge salad. My son got some kind of sandwich and my husband a small pizza and wings service started ok but really tanked around the time we started to get our food. It was like pulling teeth to get the servers attention to get drink refills or anything like that. I will say while the food was still good. The wedge salad is about half the size at this location than the one in surprise that we typically go to, but it worked out cause it was a little bit easier to eat. We'll probably stick to our usual location, but I can't say we'd never come back.

See all

Arizona Pizza Company

4.0(181 reviews)

9.6 mi

LOVE AZ Pizza Company! Amazing service, food is always great, highly recommend! Thank you AZPC!read more

Last Friday, May 8, 2026, I came in to pick up two large pepperoni pizzas for 11:30 a.m. that I had…read moreordered online the night before. When I gave my name at the counter, the young lady told me they were working on a huge order and that my pizzas would be another three minutes. My order was not ready until 11:37. I understand large orders happen, but customers who place orders in advance should still be valued and accommodated. What disappointed me most was that no effort was made to acknowledge the inconvenience. A simple apology or even offering a soda while I waited would have gone a long way toward good customer service. Instead, the manager seemed focused only on the large order and not the customers who were also waiting. To be honest, I already find the pizzas mediocre, and the only reason I chose AZ Pizza instead of Barro's Pizza was because it was what my coworker wanted. Unfortunately, this experience confirmed that I will not be returning.

Pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese with regular crust

See all

Lil Capo Pizzeria

4.5(143 reviews)

18.2 mi

Finally trying this place! We walked in to check the menu and it smelt yummy inside! Service was…read morefriendly, I especially appreciate that pizzas are made to order and I can get it dairy free. Inside and outside seating. We will be back!

Lil Capo Pizzeria 5.0/5 The Closest Thing to New York…read morePizza I've Found in Arizona Growing up in Upstate New York, I admittedly have high standards when it comes to pizza. After moving to Arizona in 2007, I've spent years searching for a slice that genuinely reminds me of home. While there are plenty of decent pizza spots throughout the Valley, very few capture that authentic New York style. Lil Capo Pizzeria absolutely does! Ironically, I first discovered Lil Capo after an Arizona Cardinals game. Like many people, I wasn't interested in paying stadium prices for mediocre food, so I jumped on Yelp looking for something nearby. Lil Capo had outstanding reviews, so we decided to give it a try. I'm glad we did because it's now my benchmark for New York-style pizza in Arizona. The first thing that stood out was the crust. This is exactly what a New York slice should be--thin, crispy on the bottom, slightly chewy inside, sturdy enough to fold, and never overloaded with grease. So many places think "New York style" simply means making a large slice. Lil Capo understands it's really about the balance of crust, sauce, cheese, and texture. Every bite reminded me why I miss pizza back east. The sauce has just the right amount of sweetness and acidity, the cheese is perfectly proportioned, and everything tastes fresh without trying to reinvent what already works. Sometimes simplicity executed well is the hardest thing to accomplish. Pizza: 5/5 Service was equally impressive. The staff was welcoming, friendly, and efficient. After selecting our slices, they quickly reheated them to perfection and had them on our table within minutes. It's exactly what you want from a neighborhood pizzeria--fast, relaxed, and genuinely hospitable. Service: 5/5 I also appreciated the atmosphere. Lil Capo isn't trying to be flashy or trendy. Instead, it has that classic neighborhood pizzeria feel where the focus stays exactly where it should--on making outstanding pizza. It's casual, comfortable, family-friendly, and somewhere you could easily become a regular. The pricing is another pleasant surprise. Considering the quality of the pizza and the generous slice sizes, I found everything to be very fairly priced. Overall Finding authentic New York-style pizza in Arizona has been surprisingly difficult over the years, but Lil Capo delivers exactly what I've been searching for. Authentic New York-style crust Excellent sauce-to-cheese ratio Minimal grease Friendly, efficient service Fair prices Comfortable neighborhood atmosphere I've eaten pizza throughout New York my entire life, and Lil Capo remains the closest I've found to the real thing anywhere in Arizona. Whenever I'm on the west side of the Valley--or heading to or from a Cardinals game--I find myself looking for an excuse to stop in. Next time, I'm skipping the slices and ordering an entire pie. If you're a fellow New Yorker living in Arizona and craving a slice that tastes like home, Lil Capo should be at the top of your list.

Have a seat

Garlic knots. Good, maybe a tad overdone.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Nyree C.

6 years ago

The girls working at the prize pod are very rude!!!!!! They should NOT be working in customer service & especially being rude to children!!!! Who you have working at your company reflects on how people see the company. read more

Audrey R.

7 years ago

Good customer service and Peter Piper Pizza, what else more can I say?! The service here is so great.

Mike S.

16 years ago

$4.99 all you can eat lunch buffet is a pretty tough deal to beat.

Jenny D.

3 years ago

it is the best restaurant ever

Peter Piper Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Restaurants near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Desserts near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Coffee near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Things to Do near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Breakfast near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Dinner near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Burgers near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Movie Theatre near Peter Piper Pizza

BEST of Buckeye, Arizona Shopping near Peter Piper Pizza

Related Cost Guides

Boat Charters

Golf Cart Rentals

Karaoke Rental

Officiants

Party & Event Planning

Photo Booth Rentals

Valet Services

Venues and Event Spaces

Service Offerings Nearby

Fundraising Events

Birthday Parties

Non-profit Events

Best of Buckeye

Things to do in Buckeye

Browse Brands

Peter Piper Pizza

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Peter Piper Pizza also viewed

Texas Roadhouse

3.1

(554 reviews)

We decided to go here for a birthday dinner and nothing like getting those nice warm rolls with the…read morebutter just so good and had to get several more baskets of them. We tried the blooming onion and fried pickles which were really good as well . Almost everyone got some sort of steak , chicken and ribs and everyone seemed to clear there plates pretty good the steaks were cooked to the right temps. So many different sides from steak fries , mashed potatoes, veggies , Mac n cheese . I did hear someone say they did not like the green beans but other than that all was good and our server was really nice and attentive. It definitely can get loud inside but this evening wasn't to bad at all

Hadn't eaten at the one in Goodyear in a couple of years, but went back with my family today for my…read morewife's birthday. Cheeseburger was horrible ( nothing like Chili's ). Fries saturated in oil. sampler appetizer plate not like ordered - nothing like BJ's sampler ( tiny ). VERY DISAPPOINTED.

BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

3.5

(239 reviews)

Let me start off by saying the food is good and if didn't want this I shouldn't have ordered it…read more Now, I order on Uber Eats and it's not the same as eating it there. I'm not the happiest because I ordered the crispy chicken sandwich and all I wanted was a crispy chicken sandwich. You can not order that on Uber Eats. The crispy chicken sandwich must come smothered in the sauce weather you like it or not. There is no selection for no sauce. If you order it in the restaurant you can get it with no sauce. Make this make sense. Next is the side order of broccoli. I know you pay more for delivery or even eating in the restaurant, but really $6.99 for this. It fits in the palm of my hand. I know the economy sucks but come on. If I'm going to have something delivered and pay like $75 dollars for 2 people not including the taxes, fees, and tip, I think the options should be the same as if you were dining in the restaurant. I get that I'm paying not leave my house but it's not even a whole chicken breast let alone it's completely drowning in sauce that you can't even opt out of having. Sorry for the rant but look at the pics and judge for yourself. And yes I did wipe all the sauce off the best I could and eat it. It is good food, but you are forced to eat it how they want you to if you want a crispy chicken sandwich.

It's hard to find a happy hour in this city, especially one where you feel comfortable pulling out…read morea laptop and working while enjoying a glass of wine! I walked in on a weekday and it was unknowingly happy hour - great! It was open seating at the bar and pretty busy inside. The bartender was friendly and attentive during my whole visit. I got a glass of their chardonnay and the summer strawberry salad with chicken. The salad was fresh and chicken was grilled to perfection. I got my cookie to go and it was just as yummy at home. Will be coming back to work!

Denny's

3.3

(93 reviews)

You guys knocked it out of the park this last service! Food was perfect and service was on point,…read morefunny and fast! Usually this location has greasy food (been here 3 times) but this last time was immaculate. The crew on the date 10/10/26 at 3:00 PM deserves a raise or promotion!

I've been here three times, eaten here once. During my first visit, I was seated, but then no one…read morecame to my table for a long time, so I left. Today, my wife, granddaughter and I were waiting to be seated for more than 5 minutes. There were people in the kitchen and they looked at us, but no one so much as said "Hello". I finally asked another diner if they were being served and they said the kitchen wasn't open yet because of a power outage. The other time my son and I came here. Fairly typical Denny's experience. We'll chose another place to eat from now on.

Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews

3.4

(48 reviews)

I haven't been to a Red Robin in probably over 12 years, but this is where my grandson wanted to go…read morefor his birthday, so there we went! This location has a different set up than a typical Red Robin, and I liked it. It was really modern, and the service was really excellent. My husband and I shared the bacon blue burger with the garlic parmesan fries. The burger and fries were delicious, but the fries were a bit too greasy for me. We also ordered the fried pickles. They were good, but we really didn't care for the sauce they are served with. I would have just preferred ranch. Definitely stop in if you're looking for a good burger! Still a super family-friendly restaurant just like I remember from my last visit years ago!

I love this location. The hamburger with endless fries is such a good deal. The service is fast…read moreand friendly. The ambiance is inviting and your perfect neighborhood hamburger joint.

NYPD Pizza

4.0

(390 reviews)

Stephen S. Is the absolute GOAT. Some say the LeBron James of service! Friendly domineer, positive…read moreand attentive service truly brings this place to the next level. Ask for Stephen and expect a smile when leavin'.

This is the extra celery I paid for to have with my wings. Disappointed is understatement.read more

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.4

(372 reviews)

First of all, our server Demi was amazing! She was on it from the start! There was no wait when we…read morewalked in the door, food was super fast but delicious! The ambiance is the traditional Olive Garden setting/environment. I give it an A+

If your party allows for it, try to sit at the bar. We were able to bypass the long line/wait for a…read moretable. The bartenders were very friendly and attentive. We got the new Calabrian bucatini (which had a good kick/spice to it) and the light portion of eggplant parm (which was the perfect size). The salad and breadsticks were great as usual.

Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen

3.5

(426 reviews)

Whenever we're in town (Goodyear) my daughter likes to eat at Cheddars for the chicken pot pie. She…read moreswears it's the best she's eaten. Five stars for the chicken pot pie alone. Her sister ordered the respectable spaghettini. I ordered the phenomenal meatloaf (smoked then slathered with brown gravy oh yes). Yummerlicious. No one needed a container to go. Nice little neighborhood restaurant. Clean. Good service. We'll be back.

I really wanted to enjoy this place, but unfortunately the food was a major disappointment. It…read morehonestly tasted like something pulled straight from the freezer and warmed up in the microwave. For the price, I just didn't feel like we got our money's worth. The croissants were complimentary, but even then, they were dry and underwhelming. I honestly would've preferred some warm cheddar-baked biscuits with little bits of cheddar throughout, brushed with a little honey butter. Now THAT would've been something! The ambiance didn't impress me either. The one bright spot was our waiter--he was absolutely awesome, attentive, friendly, and gave excellent service. Great waiter, but unfortunately the food and overall experience missed the mark for me.

A1 Pizza & Wings

3.6

(99 reviews)

Fresh high quality food. My family and I's favorite pizza place. Great customer service. You should…read moretry this place

This place is really hit or miss, sometimes their food is good and fresh... sometimes you'll get…read morethe opposite. Tonight i ordered a burger and fries. The fries were decently warm but the burger tasted old and the buns were definitely stale.

Ono Hawaiian BBQ

3.3

(239 reviews)

Omg! Such decisions to make. Once I finally picked what I was going to eat, it was delicious. That…read morestaff was courteous and the restaurant was clean.

The experience was just okay overall. The food was decent, but it didn't really stand out compared…read moreto other Hawaiian restaurants we've tried. Some of the dishes were flavorful, while others felt a little underwhelming. The service was friendly enough, but it could have been more attentive, and the overall experience felt a bit average. Nothing was necessarily bad, but there wasn't anything that made us especially excited to come back. Hopefully our next visit is a better experience.

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

3.1

(245 reviews)