We thought this was right off 90 on our way back to Boston- not quite, because we're terrible at maps, but worth every minute! Pizza was excellent- perfectly flaky but soft crust on all three. Our toddlers loved the cheese pizza, the white garlic was perfect with mushroom and crispy bacon, and the combo was tasty. Abundant toppings and the pizzas are enormous- personal was around the size of what we expect from a small, and smalls were large. The rating is based on food but the service would get five stars too- we called ahead and the girl who answered was super sweet and got a table ready for us. The owner (I think) was making our toddlers giggle before we even walked through the door with funny faces through the window, and the friendliness continued while we were eating and went above and beyond what you'd expect for a hole in the wall pizza shop. read more

We ordered delivery from here recently, and the pizza was very good. The dough was fresh and there was plenty of toppings. We also ordered a eggplant grinder that was also very yummy. We will definitely order from here again. read more

Peppo's Pizza - Hamburg and mushroom pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

See all

Owner has changed & now known as "Peppino's Pizza & I'd admit this is under new ownership but at same degree it's pretty good. I will confess with pepperoni that has kick but if you like that no disappointments & still have as good as was before (ingredients, dough, toppings etc) so overall it's still good & okay I might get blowback on that but oh well, nobody is perfect. read more

Great food and service. Had the house special Pizza was really well presented and tastes amazing!

Such thin sliced weird breaded eggplant, literally couldn't tell was eggplant. Could only taste the very blah and not crispy breading/flour. So incredibly dry. Also had a Philly cheese steak that came with no cheese! The salad was ok. Spent WAY too much for meh microwaved food. Even the bread wasn't toasted on the hot grinders. Ate half of the half and then threw it away . 15 dollars a grinder through GrubHub! read more

Peppo's Pizza - Supposed to be eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

Small whole in the wall that is mainly for those looking to pick up and go. Overall fantastic pizza! I picked up a couple pies on the way home the other night- ordered a party size combo and small cheese and we had more than enough for 10 people. The pizza was fantastic but most importantly for me, the crust was light and airy. Happy to have this so close and to know there will always be extra for the next day! read more

Love this place. The people and the food is great! Since we moved to the area it is on our list for takeout food for sure!

The owner is a little rough around the edges, but he is a very nice guy Food and prices are very reasonable Quality is very good too. read more

10 Boneless Wings, Plain Pie, Salad not fresh, low quality cheese. Great soda and chips. Friendly staff and clean restrooms. Busy street for a walk afterwards. read more

We recently ordered a party size combo pizza and small cheese. Our group enjoyed the pizza so much! The toppings were generous, the dough was light and thin, but the crust was nice and crispy. Peppo's was on the way home from work for my husband and some our guests actually asked for the name and menu we brought with us to order again. Would definitely recommend! read more

Found this place on Yelp and we just had to give er a whirl. On mammas instructions I ordered a large sauseeg and we dutifully brought it home to chow on seeing as how we're in the middle of this virus sh#t. The pizza was okay, we had high hopes seeing as it's a solid five star. The crust was soft and thin, not crispy at all, the pie itself was kind of bland, I dressed it up with some Texas Pete hot sauce the missus put salt and pepper on it. The place is easy to find on the main road and easy in and easy out with adequate parking. The gentleman I dealt with was nice and engaging while the establishment was spotless. read more

See all

Great food, wings aren't that great but pizza is bomb! The service is ok . The ambiance is ok it's not that welcoming.

Peppo is Super friendly! As well as the rest of the fellas here! pizza is sooo good!!! Got a Large pizza with 4 toppings $26 bucks id say.. When i say Large it was HUGE u can feed a group with it.. it was 2 of us so we brought the rest home! I will definitely come back here! #Pizzaforthewin read more

Peppo's Pizza - Peppers mushrooms sausage ham.. sooo yummy - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

Great pizza, calzones and wings. While other pizza places in Agawam have closed or gone downhill, Peppo's is always fresh and delicious.

Ordered a large roast beef grinder that was very disappointing for the price. Mostly bread and lettuce with a light layer of roast beef. Not what I expect for the price of said grinder. read more

New owners changed iconic recipe to Spicy halal pizza not an Italian pizza-actually I wouldn't call it a pizza...don't waste your time or money read more

Pizza was great and the sauce is outstanding. Service is good. Restaurant is clean as far as I could see.

I met two members of the Peppo's family one evening. They suggested I try their pizza. I asked what made their pizza special. "the crust.". Tonight I ordered a small pepperoni, sausage and onion pizza. The crust was exceptional. Not to sweet or salty and a slight crunch on the bottom. There was more than enough of the good stuff like cheese and sauce, but they didn't overload the pizza with toppings. Allowing the pizza to breath while it cooked. This allows the crust to cook properly. It was perfect. They delivered my pizza HOT and faster than expected. I ate as much as I could and the other half is in my fridge for lunch tomorrow. Great work guys, I have a new pizza place! Michael Oberther www.clientcyclemarketing.com read more

Peppo's Pizza - Our Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

See all

Great food. Good price. Communication with person who took my order was easy and clear

Was working in town with a few others. We didn't feel like going out for again. Decided too stay in and get something delivered. I called to ask questions about the pizza. The person that answered the phone was very pleasant and helpful! Have to admit, I was taken by surprise. Was not expecting such customer service, it was excellent! I called back to place an order for delivery. Place my order, and when I gave the lady the address we were staying. The lady said unfortunately they don't deliver that far. She placed me on hold (she asked first). Came back on and said that they can make it work. That is outstanding in my book!! Couldn't ask for nicer people! Pizza got rave reviews from my coworkers! I loved it as well! Great all around experience!! read more

First time ordering from Peppo's and I have to say best around the area! Great pizza and I've been spoiled growing up in NY/NJ most of my life. Hats off you got a new customer for life! Appreciate the service and more so the pizza! read more

We visited Peppo's pizza after reading reviews on Yelp. The pizza was delicious and the past reviewers did not disappoint our crew! We thought it was a restaurant with table service but decided to stay anyways. I'm glad we did. The owner was so sweet and helpful. The adults had grinders, fries, onion rings and garlic bread all which were great as well! Enjoy your visit if you are in the area. I know we did and will return if passing through again. read more

So many Pizza places to choose from. How do you know which is good. Peppo's is nondescript and there are no seats in the actual location but the Pizza is phenomenal. Excellent pizza at a great price. Party pizza is a crowd pleaser. read more

Great family run operation. Very friendly people who make you feel very welcome. Their pizza is extremely good. They make each pie with care. The crust is delicious and it tastes like they use quality ingredients. I love their combo pizza! Consistently on point! Great service and great food. You get what you pay for here. read more

Pizza is delicious! The fries are even better!! Crispy on the outside and soft on the in. I've only eaten pizza and fries from here, but the food is great and the prices are comparable read more

Excellent and cheap York Style pizza. The large pie is gigantic, oblong and cut into squares. It fed 5 of us. If you want a pie small enough to cut into manageable triangular slices you need to go with medium or smaller. Only two tables in the restaurant, both of which were thankfully empty when we arrived on a Saturday night, but they were plenty busy with four cooks in the back handling take out orders. They use a technique i have never seen before -- instead or using cornmeal or flour to keep the raw dough from sticking to the peel, they use a something "like a bread crumb." They wouldn't tell me more about this "secret" material, other than that they make it in house. It is barely noticeable in the cooked crust but lends a little airy crunch in parts. read more

I ordered delivery - pizza was good with the crust being the star. Would be four stars if not for the price/gimmick. I called and ordered a large pizza for delivery and the guy shows up with a $26 pizza so I paid $30 with tip for plain pie. It was an oversized party pie with slices cut for kids. Tell people when they call it's not really a large . . . feel like I got hustled here. read more

Stopped by Peppo's Pizza on our way down from skiing at Killington heading to NYC. I found this restaurant on google maps as I was searching for nearby places along the route. Based on the great reviews we decided to stop in and it was the best decision! The pizza was delicious, especially the crust. It was flakey, not too thick not too thin and reminded me of the pizza from Italy. Would definitely recommend and will be returning! read more

Great Pizza in Agawam! The location for me is perfect and the food is good and it's a cool place. I would recommend to any friend. read more

Peppo's Pizza - Combo pizza - $22 - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

This place is very small but the pizza is definitely excellent. A small is enough for 3 people and a large means you need a gastric bypass...You can eat at the place but the best is to take it with you. read more

The food here is absolutely amazing, pizza is great, flavor is awesome and best of all no grease. You defiantly would not be disappointed. Homemade motz is the best!!!! The crust on the pizza has so much flavor. read more

See all

Peppo's was excellent. We had the pizza and the crust was perfect. The medium pizza was big enough to feed the three of us and have leftovers. We also ordered the meatball parm grinder to go. The bread was warm and crispy. The meatballs though were the best we ever had. Obviously made by hand and not using a mixer because they had a lighter consistency. This is mostly takeout but there are 3 tables and we ate there watching the owner greet most people by name and there were a lot of people picking up their orders. Even though we live 1.5 hours away we will definitely be going back read more

My family and I had a craving for pizza tonight but we wanted a REALLY GOOD PIZZA! I yelped as I usually do and found this place! YAY!!!! I called and ordered a half cheese, half meatball and ricotta (bc of the pic i saw here). I was automatically greeted well (on the phone) by who i think is the owner. SUCH A NICE GUY! He quoted me 25min for pickup and 25min later I came with my daughter! The owner again, greeted us warmly and was SO NICE to my daughter and myself. He even gifted her a bag of chips!.... we got home and enjoyed the best pizza I've had in a long time! Soooooo good! We have officially decided that THIS will be our pizza spot from here on out! P.s. a small was perfect for us! Two adults and one hunger toddler! So happy to have found a delicious, super friendly place just 6min away from home! Thanks! read more

Peppo's Pizza - My daughter w/ her gifted bag of chips (she was so excited about the gift) & our delicious pizza!(small, 1/2cheese 1/2ricotta and meatball) - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

We've lived in Agawam for 5 years now, but we just recently started going to Peppo's. Peppo behind the counter is the nicest freakin man I've ever met-- and that alone is worth going back to. Bonus: the food is awesome. The chicken tenders are always crispy and moist on the inside, and the pizza is always delish. They do a little extra cornmeal on the bottom that gives the crust a little extra crunch! Every time we've called in for a pick up, the food is always hot and ready! We've never eaten in the restaurant, but I would imagine it would be fine for small groups of people. read more

We love Peppo's!!! We do mostly take out/delivery. The pizzas are great! Our favorite is the special pizza that has a garlic oil, house made sausage and ricotta cheese! We order the trust thin! It's so crispy. read more

Peppo's is the best pizzeria in this whole area. The food is excellent, staff is very polite and friendly, and their delivery is always faster than they say. I have recommended Peppo,s to many people and they have agreed. read more

Peppo's Pizza - Rocky likes the pizza too, especially the peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

This pizza is amazing! The get their meat from a local butcher shop! I ordered it delivery and it came hot and ready to eat. I shared with my friend and her kids, they loved it to. They could tell the difference. read more

Yumm yumm yumm!!! Fabulous pizza excellent friendly service. This was our first time here and we will definitely be going back.

The grinders were awesome! Will definitely have to try the pizza soon! The staff is very friendly as well! read more

Phenomenal pizza. The crust is great and has some semolina flour baked into it giving it a great texture and bite and is a little different than pizza I've had before, but definitely in a good way. The staff of this family restaurant was super friendly and accommodating. I've lived in New Jersey and New York and know great pizza. This place stands up to both. One tip is that the large pizza is a monster, and square- so not all slices will have crust. If you want a round pizza get a medium (or 2). read more