No bells and whistles on appearance. But what the deliver donut wise is bells and whistles. So simple yet fantastic! They were nice and warm, soft and the sugar gave them the perfect crunch. I could have eaten more. Seating was nice. A few picnic tables. Maybe took their donuts and beverages to go. Pricing was very reasonable. The staff were so nice and inviting. Parking can be tricky. Well I guess anywhere in Block Island can be tricky in regards to parking. read more

Our favorite donuts ever been coming here since I was a kid, Payne's will always have a special place in my heart! The scenery is beautiful too, right on the water in a cute little area. read more

Payne's Donuts - Scenery around Paynes - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

See all

Not your average donut shop. A simple food truck serving a small variety of really tasty donuts. The selection is small abc big typical. The service was friendly and they even made a good cup of coffee. The ambiance is parking/dirt lot casual. So, if you should ever find your way to Block Island, I can most definitely recommend the donuts from Payne's. The donuts are always warm and fresh. read more

These donuts were recommended to me as the best donuts on the island. They did not disappoint! So delicious and only $1.50 each (cash only)! Three flavors: plain, sugar, and cinnamon. They come out very hot and fresh and they are so fluffy and perfect. Not dense like your typical cake donut. Fast service! There was no line each time we went this week (we went three times, consistent service and food quality each time). read more

Payne's Donuts - plain donut on top and cinnamon donuts underneath. - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

If you want good donuts come here!! Smaller size but very cheap and delicious!! A couple different kinds- sugar, plain, cinnamon but so good and local to island- made there. Very quick as line wasn't bad and moved a long. A couple tables all out doors as it is a food truck so nice to eat outside but also can grab and go. FYI - small parking lot but Defs worth it. Great in flavor and nice little treat- recommend read more

Payne's Donuts - Cinnamon donut - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

See all

CASH ONLY!! Be prepared. I've heard about Payne's Donuts as a staple for Block Island so on my first trip, I knew I needed to try them. My friends and I walked and I'm not going to lie.....it's a pretty far walk from the ferry. On a hot day, the walk can suck. Payne's is a little food truck next to a kayak renting facility. There are a few tables to sit at with an umbrella. The prices are very reasonable. I believe they are freshly made cake donuts. So the moment of truth. I have waited years to finally try these donuts and do they hold up to the hype? No. They are not the best donut you will ever eat, as other reviews have stated. Maybe they changed the formula over the years but they taste like every other freshly made cake donut I've tried in RI. They're not bad, they are just soft from being fresh, which is nice. I don't think it's worth the walk just to get one. Maybe if you have the bike or moped, but it's just an average cake donut. read more

Payne's Donuts - Menu - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

See all

My mom and I read about this place so when we did the taxi tour of the island, we had to stop. Just basic donuts (plain, sugar, or cinnamon are the only 3 choices), fresh and done right. We got one of each but since they were in the same bag, they all kind of tasted similar (and delicious). It's a food truck that's not on the main street when you get off the ferry. I think it's about a mile if you wanted to walk or bike. I've heard there can be a huge line but we lucked out both times and didn't have a wait. Service was friendly and prompt. The donuts are on the small side so grab a couple!! These are truly a simple pleasure that I've come to associate with a day exploring the island. read more

Avoided the line by getting there early and did not disappoint. Super affordable (especially for the island) and over fresh. We got a dozen of each of their 3 flavors and each one was better than the next. Can't wait for my next trip out to get them again!!! read more

These donuts were delish and seem to have been made to order for the most part, still niceee and warm. There was no line when I went on a Wednesday morning in late June. Only three flavors but you do not need more when they are THAT good. read more

Payne's Donuts - I got the sugar and cinnamon sugar donuts... 6 of each (and a cool sticker) - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

4 STARS ARE BASED OFF THE DONUT: Warm, delicious, soft inside and slightly crunchy outside. Such a win! Glad we walked the almost 1 mile from the ferry to Payne's with an infant and 7 year old! (Nice walk too by the way!) Some of the review it was out of an actual building- it is back to being a donut truck! One thing other reviews did not share... you are in between a kayak rental facility. How convenient if you are interested in hitting the water! And just nice scenery.The ducks were super friendly and loved the donuts too. The woman working the counter supplied my daughter with 2 donuts to feed the ducks- super nice! The bad... My boyfriend and friend had the coffee. They said if they could give it negative stars they would. I heard worst coffee I ever had and the donuts are as good as the coffee is as bad. read more

Payne's Donuts - The view from Payne's (and the ability to rent Kayaks right there!) - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

Payne's has been on Block Island since 1963. I'm always a little skeptical of dining establishments that are highly touted in very touristy areas as I've found that nostalgia and limited options can lead to dangerous rating inflation. I'm glad to report that there's no such inflation here at Payne's. The doughnuts are as good as mentioned in other reviews. In a tourist area particularly rife with mediocre food, Payne's stands out even more for their doughnuts. They're served warm. They're so pillowy and soft that yours truly took a bite and half of one of her doughnuts fell on the ground (they were nice enough to replace the doughnut). The doughnuts come in plain, sugar or cinnamon sugar. The sugar and cinnamon sugar add a very pleasant crunch that only heightens this amazing textural experience. I like how Scott M. had said Payne's is his favorite part of BI. I love that-and I agree. Payne's is approximately 1 mile away from the Block Island Ferry stop. It's a little bit of a hike on foot but so worth it. Those doughnuts truly feel like a vacation treat. read more

Island Donut Truck......... Deliciously made donuts, A Must try!!!! The Payne's "Do it Right" on the island. A few tables to sit on, best for grab and go!! read more

See all

I remember when donuts were sacred. Even Dunkin' made them fresh several times a day. Paynes is one of the few places where they still take donuts seriously. It's worth the long trip to the island, and worth getting up early to get the donuts warm first thing in the morning. It's not a summer vacation without a dozen Paynes donuts. read more

I'll go out on a limb and say that Payne's is my favorite part of BI. Find yourself a way to get there; walk, rent a bike, hop on a moped, call a cab...just get yourself there. These are the softest donuts I've ever had. I'm talking pillow soft. Fall apart soft in the best possible way. And they are small so try one of each. They have plain, sugar, and cinnamon(my fav). They are cash only so plan ahead. read more

Payne's Donuts - Sugar donut - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

Here, I am gonna say, the doughnuts are better than Allie's. Probably the best in Rhode Island at least. read more

Beyond delicious. Donuts come out warm and soft and ready to eat. Oh how that was a good bite. No no for dairy allergy. Such a good bite. Love love love. It's a food truck. Cash only. Staff was lovely. Thumbs up. read more

Absolutely astounding. You will not find anything like it. Everything about these donuts is spectacular.

You really can't get just one. Best donuts I've ever had, and I've lived in Rhode Island for 5 years. Get the cinnamon flavor!! They are usually warm right out of the oven. Cash or Venmo only. read more

SO YUMMY! these donuts are to die for. you kind of have to get there early because there might be a line but the warm cinnamon donuts are absolutely worth the wait. service is quick and vibes are great! love the outdoor seating. read more

Donuts and cinnamon buns are so soft! Definitely get the sugar covered ones. We had a couple leftover and they were still soft the next day!

Ugh the BEST donuts I've had! So many different and unique flavors with also options for more traditional old fashioned styles highly recommend anyone who loves donuts to stop by - you don't be disappointed! read more

Payne's Donuts - a person holding a donut in front of a food truck - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

Nice place to stop by if you're riding a bike and need a quick snap. The donuts are baked fresh, and are quite soft. They could use a little more dusting of powdered/sugar, but overall a quality donut read more

Payne's Donuts - a man standing in front of a food truck - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

Best donuts on the Block. Even somewhere else these would be great, but out here it's a whole other experience. The warm donuts right out of the fryer are perfect. Simple and delicious, and while some might complain that "only" 3 kinds are limited, I don't see it that way. These are old fashioned donuts, the kind you simply can't get anymore in the hipster inspired donut places of today. No stupid breakfast cereal toppings, no bacon and jalapeno, no nonsense. Get a dozen and eat one or two on the way back to your family and friends, while the donuts are still hot. And honestly, the coffee here isn't bad. Don't expect Starbucks - it's simple and old-school. Good stuff! read more

This is a cute little food (donut) truck. There is not a ton on the menu. Its mostly just snacks like donuts, brownies and ice-cream. I got a plain and cinnamon donut. Both of the donuts were absolutely delicious. The folks sitting next to me said they were the best donuts in Block Island and I definitely concur. Definitely check this place out if you are in the mood for donuts. read more

See all

Been a frequent traveler here everytime I visit Block Island for their apple cider donuts. There is the store front along with the food truck that people flock to devour these light fluffy snacks. You typically grab these treats early in the morning because they will have sold out if you aren't quick enough. Definitely a stop for anyone that wants to enjoy the local stops here on Block Island. Grab one for breakfast and then take a couple back on the ferry. read more

A small truck and well known gem of the island, the warm donuts are what people come to seek out. They also have other small items here, but people largely come for the fresh donuts. Outdoor benches are available but this is more of a quick grab and go item. Plain, cinnamon, or sugar are your three options you can choose from. Between the size of a small and regular donut, these are the right size for your kiddos to enjoy. read more

All I can say is oh my god oh my god oh my god oh my god there's donuts are to die for. Fluffy and tasty and warm and wonderful. I've been coming to the island for over 25 years and somehow have miss this little gem. Amazing amazing amazing read more

OK, don't get me wrong, their donuts are good. But I don't exactly think they deserve their "killer" distinction. Yea, I get it. There aren't many donut shops on the island. Payne's only makes three types: plain, sugar and cinnamon. That's understandable when considering the small size of the shop and the small size of the island. If they offered more flavors they'd probably just go to waste. Here's one recommendation for you...you will likely need to purchase a drink or beverage to wash them down. That's not a bad thing... I'm just pointing this out because I tried to get away without purchasing one and I couldn't do it. By the way, their roadside location makes for a great pit stop while riding a bicycle. They have a nice outdoor deck to sit and relax, and watch the entire world go by. read more

Payne's Donuts - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

I haven't had one of their donuts in like 6 years but I still think about them on a weekly basis. I have been searching for a donut shop that is even just 3/4ths of the donut shop that Payne's Donuts is and have yet to be satisfied. read more

i would NEVER recommend this place. for starters, trying to find the place is a wild goose chase because there are two addresses. the one on google is incorrect. once you finally do get there the selection of goodies is wildly underwhelming. while the donuts were good, they were not great or "killer." the staff was nice but didnt know what they were serving. couldn't even name all three muffin choices. stop by for a donut if you happen to pass the place, but do not go seeking it out. Step up your donut game Payne. And please fix the address issue. read more

Quite simply the best donuts I've ever had. I know, a statement like that seems too exuberant to be believed, but... dang, it's true. I'd buy a round-trip ferry ticket to Block Island just to enjoy some of these donuts again. Payne's is a small kitchen with a walk-up window, and a patio outside where happy donut-eaters can enjoy the crisp morning island air as they fulfill (or exceed) their carb quota for the day. We arrived before they opened, soon after sunrise, and were not the first in line. By the time Payne's was ready to serve, there were many other folks waiting patiently behind us, and with good reason. We were served a bag of sugar-coated cake-style donuts, still quite hot from the fryer. Don't expect an array of toppings here. Payne's is not Dunkin' or Krispy Kreme, no sir. You get plain or sugar. Anything more would just be a distraction. The donuts are small and light, making it too easy to wolf down a dozen without thinking too much about it. read more

I'm a fan of food trucks and this place just sells simple donuts which are delicious. A must go to place if you're ever at Block Island.

We stumbled upon this place while riding our bikes on Block Island. Oh boy what a treat! Truly delicious donuts! I am not a huge donut fan but these donuts were fresh, warm and extra sugary! If you are visiting Block Island - go have a KILLER donut! Thumbs up from me! read more

Payne's Donuts - Simply delish - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

See all

These are the ABSOLUTE BEST donuts EVER!!! Every time we visit BI we get Payne's Donuts at least twice! I send my husband in on the dinghy and can't wait for the deliciousness of these donuts. Note: They don't keep very well, so if you buy a lot in hopes of storing them for another day, they do not taste nearly as good the next morning! read more

Totally agree with the previous Yelper. This donut shop is not to be missed. It is kind of like those hostess cake donuts but way better. The dough is so light with perfect balance of sweetness. I regret trying them on the day before my departure; had I tried them on my first day of my stay, I would have eaten one every day. I really miss BI, and I miss those donuts just as much. read more

Fairly new establishment pumping out tiny diet killers. These doughnuts are pretty fantastic. Although, I am cognizant that waking up on the water and rowing to this place probably added to the overall experience. This place is located right by the dock so if you are in a slip or anchored over night you pretty much have to pass it to get into town. Unfortunately, I was on my way to the 1661 for brunch so I needed to limit my doughnut consumption. The doughnuts are cooked perfectly. Doughy interior with a nice bite through crunch on the Outside. Have to stop here! read more

Payne's Donuts - Donuts Near Me - New Shoreham, Rhode Island

See all

Good donuts. Surprisingly inexpensive on this wildly overpriced island. But killer? Probably not. I will say that the donuts are definitely best when fresh and warm. They have a crispiness to the outside and the inside is soft. I like that they keep it simple with only 3 flavors: plain, cinnamon, and sugar. But the flavor of the dough itself is fairly bland. But if you want some warm, fried, sweet goodness and a treat you can actually afford, definitely hit up Payne's! read more

Hot and fresh. Lotsa kids on sugar buzz. A tradition on block island. I like the cinnamon ones.

The donuts were tasty, but they only had 3 traditional flavor a: sugar, cinnamon sugar, and plain. It must be a family run business because the girl who helped us was very young, though sweet. They have great reviews, but it would be fun if they had more of a selection or maybe even a "donut of the day" type of system in place It's located right next to a docking area and down the street from Chaplains - where we were staying. The views are nice! read more

Payne's Killer Donuts lives up to its slogan that it is 'worth the wait.' My husband and I walked a mile to try these and we were not disappointed. We were given fresh and warm homemade donuts rather than the ones that we were expecting to get from the display case. I should add that I don't like donuts, so I had a bite of my husbands and ended up devouring the whole thing! This is definitely worth it. read more