P2pi is more than just a pie shop. There is plenty of seating to enjoy your pie, warmed if you wish and the also serve coffee and more. The meat quiche and peach-mango pie were both excellent. The staff was attentive and helpful, without being obsequious. Will I return? Yes, every time I pass thru Dayton. read more

Incredible pie however they run out pretty quickly so you have to go early if you want a good selection. They have a cute little place to sit and eat your pie and sit on some tea if desired. Staff is super sweet and very attentive. My only complaint is the lack of options if you go a little too late. But given that they are homemade probably every day or the day before it is to be expected so go early! read more

I'm such a huge fan of this place. The pies are great. I'm crazy about their quiches, especially when they have chorizo available. BUT my absolute favorite are the chocolate brownies. These are the best brownies in town by far...and yes I've had the famous local ones read more

Partial to Pie - Hours - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

See all

A delightful local spot for PIE! Also available are coffee, quiche and brownies. You can order a whole pie. There are weekly pies with seasonal offerings. They close by 3 most days and noon on Saturday. If they sell out, they close early that day. Hint, get there early if there's a special item you really want. read more

Partial to Pie - Slice of purple sweet potato pie (to go , at home) - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

I stopped By this adorable place Friday at 240pm (on a whim and 20 min prior to closing) and love the concept. A homemade pie is always much appreciated in my tummy any day. The place is on the corner of a busy intersection so Parking is in the back of the establishment. I love the mural in the back. Plenty of parking and easy to get in and out. Handicap friendly. Inside is nice and cool, very old school diner like and you immediately get greeted for help and the gal was super sweet and answered my questions despite being 15 min shy of closing the place. I was saddened by the pie shortage so this speaks volumes of this place already and totally understandable being close to closing. Banana cream and their weekly special, berry sugar cream was available alongside broccoli and veggie quiche for the savory. I got the berry and veggie and took it to go. I had the veggie quiche for supper. Yummy! It was chock full of fresh veggies. I,then, ate the berry cream for dessert and it was very good! I love the buttery crust (no artificial taste at all, they don't use shortening). The berries were fresh and the sugar cream was great. It reminded me of an Indiana sugar cream pie with berries on top. It took me back to my childhood days when my grandmother made a pie like this. Ahh! shucks, that impresses me because this is good pie, folks. Not store bought pie (no offense intended but hopefully you get what I'm saying here). Yes, definitely check this place out if you got a soft spot for pie like I do. You really won't regret it. I can't wait to go back and try the other fruit pies. read more

Partial to Pie - Parking lot / mural in back of establishment. - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

This is a great alternative breakfast spot for quiche, small batch coffee, and of course a slice of pie. Quiche flavors change frequently. They also have some magnificent Nicaraguan 152lb coffee bags on the wall. read more

I've stopped in several times getting the quiche and bakery goods. Everything I've had has been superb. Good coffee and just a down home atmosphere. They often sell out before closing time so get there early Pre order on the pies is recommended read more

I stopped in on a Thursday around 11AM. The mural on the back is so cute! The interior was clean and cozy. I might just stay in rather than taking away next time. I was surprised at the selection... and how much was already gone! Definitely come in earlier if you want the full menu to choose from. The lady I spoke with was friendly and happy to answer my questions and get things boxes up and labeled for me. I bought slices of both the sausage & potato and fancy ham & cheese quiches as well as a slice of apple pie and a brownie. Let me just say, I was hesitant about the quiches. I haven't liked them at all since my mother went through a quiche phase when I was in middle school. These quiches cured me of my distaste! They were both so good! And that crust... it was flakey with lovely buttery flavor. The apple pie was also stellar with, again, amazing crust that balanced perfectly. The brownie was fantastic, but I only gone two bites before my daughter shoved the rest in her face and gave me two thumbs up. And I tend to agree. Will definitely be back! read more

This place has been our go to for quiche brunches and cherry pie. They sell out quickly (after eating them it's obvious why ) so Inrecommend placing an order to make sure you can get a whole quiche. We have had incredible customer service and the shop is clean and cute! read more

See all

Tried our second pie today. On our first and only visit i bought 2 pies. Yesterday we tried the butterscotch cream and i wrote a review .. have to say none of us were impressed. We gave the other half away since we didnt like it. We all felt was lacking in flavor. Didnt taste like butterscotch. Today we tried the second pie and it was a world better. The chocolate pie was delightful rich and sweet. We all loved it. Based on this pie i would come here again to get the chocolate again and try something else ..another pie, quich, ect. In all fairness cant say either pie was better than that of mahaffeys in Dayton. read more

See all

This local business is fantastic. Always friendly and helpful. Their pies are amazing and their quiches are delish! Get there early because they sell out quick some days. You can also place special orders for pick up with 48 hour advance notice. Do t forget to order your pies for Thanksgiving!!! read more

It is an alright Bakery common them in this city! Nothing is genuinely over a 3 star rated anything! Is one of the best Bakeries excluding donuts! read more

I love supporting small businesses, and this one is always so fun to be at as they rotate their quiche and pie flavors fairly frequently and the staff is so lovely to chat with. read more

Service is always prompt and pleasant. Love their pies! Quiches too! I end up buying more than I should because it all looks so good.

YUM, my boyfriend bought a 'buckeye' pie from Partial to Pie and I loved it! I have been meaning to try this place out for the longest time. We love fresh, homemade with love desserts and that is exactly what this place offers up to its customers. While I wish they had extended evening hours so it would be easier for me to access while working my 9-5, this was still a very special treat and a fun local Dayton spot to experience :) read more

Partial to Pie - Buckeye pie - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

Excellent food, great customer service and the perfect breakfast nook on a Sunday morning ambiance, everyday of the week!

I came for the apple crumb and coconut crème. The apple crumb was sold out. I got the chocolate pie instead. As pictured the slice had a hair on it. The coconut crème is pretty good. The crust is nice. I also tried the baklava, but it wasn't that great . read more

Partial to Pie - Coconut creme - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

See all

This is a great place to get pie in Dayton. I have been there a few times. Today we picked up 6 slices of pie. It is an excellent value with a whole pie discount in addition to the Frequent Pie-er club. The service is friendly and quick. The pies are delicious. It is hard to choose a favorite because they are all so good. I loved the banana cream pie and the peach pie. The Buckeye pie is exceptional and brings me back on Saturdays in the Fall. The Quiche is fluffy and light and melts in your mouth. You can tell these pies are scratch made fresh with love. If you are in Dayton and craving pie, I highly recommend Partial to Pie. read more

After multiple friends recommending this pie shop to me, I finally stopped in. I arrived around 930 and my selection seemed somewhat limited so I highly recommend going early in the morning if you want a full selection. Everything in the case looked delicious but I choose a piece of apple pie and a piece of the Classic Meat and Potatoes Quiche... The quiche was delightful! It was light and packed a lot of flavor!! I would definitely get it again!!! In fact, it makes me want to try all of their flavors. The herb crust was sooooo good! The apple pie has a nice topping that mixed well with the not overly sweet apples in the pie. I was pleasantly surprised that it was such ab even balanced filling! This place is awesome!! You have got to try them if you are in the Dayton area! read more

Partial to Pie - Apple pie - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

Partial to pies has the best pies ever! And their prices are so reasonable! Over the years, we've gotten at least 20 pies plus baklava and brownies! Everything has always been delicious and their service is top notch! I highly recommend partial to pies! read more

Been hearing such wonderful things about them so had to try. As USAToday said ...the best pie in Ohio. I never got to score a weekly special of Butterscotch. Next time I'll plan ahead and order one. The first time I went I followed a woman who was having a party that night and bought them out mid morning. Why didn't she order ahead? I was able to score several pieces...apple, berry and peach mango. Each better than the last. Since then I've had several others...all excellent. The key is getting there early, or ordering whole pies ahead of time. I was there yesterday at 11 and it was sparse pickings. If anything is left over they donate it to charity. And they use multiple local providers for ingredients. Follow their lead and buy local! And if you ever want to surprise me, my fave pie is mixed berry. Go early...go often. read more

We are so obbsessed with this place. First of all the pies are delicious, every single one of them. We didn't even think we liked fruit pies until we tried these. What makes them special is you could sit down and eat the fillings and crust completely separate from each other and they would both be equally good. I can't say that about any store bought pie. The filling is always over the top sweet and artificial tasting and the crust is bland. Partial to Pie's are perfect. The cream pies are decadent, they use real whipped cream, which makes a world of difference. My kids love the pie pockets because they warm up easily and are eaten without a fork. We all love the quiche with a savory version of their amazing crust. But if you think you're just running in to this place to grab a pie for dinner, you'll be suprised at how inviting the dining room is. I don't know if it's the mismatched vintage kitchen tables or the dishes straight out of my grandmother's 1980 pantry. But the idea of an establishment, devoted entirely to pies (okay, there are some brownies including gluten-free and baklava) and quiche seems genius. Even the beverages are simple: coffee, tea, or glasses of cold help-yourself water. Because seriously, when your pies are this good, you don't need to confuse people with a bunch of extra "fluff". But don't be lazy. People know about this place. I've never experienced a long wait but their selection will dwindle throughout the day and they may even close early because the are sold out. read more

See all

Some of the best pie I've ever had. My go to is the cherry, but the seasonal pie specials never disappoint. Great people, wonderful little spot-- best pie shop in Dayton. read more

Yes I recommend partial to pie highly. My dad knows the grandfather Ralph for over 80 years. Always remember the west side is the best side. In memory of all their classmates that have passed. read more

Partial to Pie - Dad at Red Cross Banquet - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

Was in the neighborhood and decided to have brunch. Stopped in here, first time - ordered sweet chorizo quiche to eat in. Perfect! Going to take home a cream pie to savor. read more

Partial to Pie - Sweet Choizo sausage and poblano chili. Delicous. Mild with a nice tang. - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

Preface: My grandmother was an excellent pie maker, so my taste buds and expectations for pie are very high. I adore this shop. Marie and Mike (the owners) are a wonderful father/daughter duo that obviously love what they do because it shows in the quality of their product. I also appreciate how many local ingredients they use. Their staff is always nice, but, as an extrovert, I have to say I am partial to Laura (get it?) because she is always the most outgoing of the bunch. I have purchased several items, but my absolute favorites are the veggie quiche, ham quiche, the caramel apple pie pocket, and all their crumble pies, which are excellent and have the perfect balance of sweet. The first time I got the cherry crumble, (my #1 of the crumble bunch), I was nervous that it would be sickening sweet (how most are) but if anything, it was the opposite. A wonderful tartness leveled off with the crumb topping. Oh, la la!!! My dad who does not eat quiche loves PTP's quiche. I took the veggie and a slice of the chorizo home to him and was told that the next time I'm home I must bring the other options too. I also took a non-crumble apple pie home, at the same time. His reaction shocked me, as it was his mom, I referred to previously, so he grew up eating her pie almost daily. If he lived locally, I guarantee this would become his regular haunt. My only wish is that the cream pies were made with normal pie crust. They use a graham cracker crust which just makes the whole thing too sweet and a weird texture for my taste. My grandma always used regular crust, so this was a first for me. I know I'm the oddity about this because they sell out fast. If you haven't, you really, really must check them out. They exemplify exactly what a small family-owned business is all about. read more

Five star pie doesn't come along too often, so believe me when I say this is legit delish pie. My fellow Cincinnati Yelpers, you might want to head north to Dayton ASAP and get you some! Leave work early if you have to because the store closes at 3:00PM. Saturday hours are just until noon-- and don't even think about rolling in on International Pi Day on the 14th at 11:55 thinking you will be leaving with a whole pie. Check out Google reviews for more details. I mouthed an inner OMG when I took a bite of the banana cream pie. Now, I love bananas, so if you don't, then maybe choose something else. I hear their quiche is really yummy too. But I must preface, I actually started my visit with a slice of blackberry pie. It was all that, but I'm leaning more towards that banana pie. Of course I had to order two pieces. Don't judge. I at least started with piece one and THEN returned to the pie counter for my second slice.Their coffee is pretty decent too. It's not Starbucks, and you won't find espresso on tap, but it's strong enough to leave you satisfied. They do have a tea selection too if that's your thing. I grew up with pie and coffee, so that's my thing! Please enjoy responsibly. Don't hoard. read more

If you like pie, you will love their pies. Best crust ever. Local ingredients. Unique seasonal selections. Cute place to dine in with very pleasant staff. read more

This is the best pie I have ever had! Marie and her staff are great. I buy these pies as treats for my staff and they rave.

I am definitely partial to "Partial to Pie." A quaint, peaceful atmosphere (love the ambient music - "Cantelope" by Herbie Hancock!) tucked away on the outskirts of downtown Dayton. The quiche is fantastic. Huge fan of the "Classic Meat and Potato" slice. Great pies, but order quick or get here early on the weekends. Friendly service and the decor reminds me of being in the ole' home kitchen from my younger days. read more

Best Pie I've ever had! Never knew that we can add some hot sauce in pies. Lovely owner and chill out space here! read more

Partial to Pie - Best Pie I've ever had! Never knew that we can add some hot sauce in pies. Lovely owner and chill out space here! - Cafes Near Me - Dayton, Ohio

This little local pie shop is just awesome. My husband and I went in first thing in the morning to buy a few pies for our offices, we got three total, two fruit pies and a quiche. We may have also gotten a brownie to split. First off, the customer service was outstanding, both of the owners (father and daughter) were there and helped us. They were kind, courteous and fast. Second, the shop looks great, they really cleaned up an old kind of run down building to be cute and so clean. The mix matched tables they have scream shabby chic sustainability as do thier mix matched coffee cups. Third, right on the back of thier menu they let you know what local businesses you are supporting by supporting them, because they use a vast majority of local vendors. If this makes it sound slightly expensive, it is a little more costly than a Kroger pie. But personally I like to vote using my dollars and I would rather pay more for an exceptional local product like this. That brings us to the good part, how was the pie? All three were amazing: The Meat and Potatoes quiche had a deliciously flakey crust, that was super flavorful, I'm not normally a crust fan give me the insides any day, but I will make an exception for this crust. The filling was creamy, flavorful and well seasoned, not at all over baked or tough. The Peach Mango crumble was FAT and who doesn't want a fat pie? It was gorgeously stuffed with filling that held together surprisingly well, piled into a crust that was well baked and flakey, topped with a sweet, cinnamony crumble that went with it so well. The Apple went to my husband's work, so here is what he had to say about it... "The cinnamon was well balanced actually and forward enough for me. Good bite to the apple, not too cooked down, they were really packed in there and held together. I lifted a whole piece out and it kept its shape, no ooze". Overall we really enjoyed it and will be back for more to treat our offices to. read more

See all

Best quiche around! And they have the best baklava! Would definitely recommend their blt quiche.

I'm very sad.......the listing on Yelp says they are open until 5. I stopped by today at 2 to check it out. And the sign on the door listed "til 3" but it was closed. so I'm not sure when I will get to try their wares. New businesses have difficulty with their hours, I understand. But I will probably even quit trying after awhile. read more

Love the atmosphere and warm and friendly staff. It's hidden gem. You can enjoy sweet or savory.

This place has potential. Very simple place, which is ok, clean. I like to support local businesses. Unfortunately, it was disappointing. The quiche was supposed to be warm, it was in some parts, and tasteless. They had 2 pies and half portion of the quiche pie left, no piepockets at 12:00 noon. Maybe a variety of pies and quiches, possibly more then 3. I do wish you luck. read more

Such a cute nostalgic place. With excellent quiche. The decor inside is so vintage and a throwback to the 50s. Anxious to take home a small pie and have it for dessert tonight. read more

This pie shop is a treasure. The quiche and pies are outstanding and the ambiance and service are just right. Our favorite quiche is the BLT (bacon, leeks & tomato) and we've yet to have a disappointing slice of pie - They're not too sweet, like the big name local pie bakers. read more

Everything is delicious! The magic crust is the key! Marie and Mike have the Midas touch with pies and pastries. Always the right balance of sweet/tart or savory/sweet. Fresh every day - they sell out every day! The dining room is vintage and welcoming. Great service! Every ingredient and element of their shop is locally sourced whenever possible. Thanks for supporting your local farms! read more

I can't say enough about how good this place is!! It is all about the crust that they used or their pies and quiches, so flaky and delicious! I have tried many of their choices and my favorites are the pecan and peanut butter cream pies! I love all of their quiches too, I'm hoping to try their chorizo quiche if I can get my hands on one! You do have to either order ahead or get there early but it is well worth it!! Super friendly owners too!! So happy for them that they are a success! read more