This is one of my favorite pizza shops.. the staff really make it and I'm always looking forward to…read morecoming back for them. The pizza is a bit of a thicker crust and the sauce is really nice and sweet!

This place is one of two pizza places in Hinsdale Plaza, in a city with over 100 pizza places…read more We've been here a few times, and I believe they were both during holidays when everywhere else was closed. On top of being open on Mondays, we were bound to try them at some point. The first time we did half pepperoni, half garlic. The second visit we got a Buffalo Chicken with an order of Honey Mustard wings. Both times were holidays, and we had been calling around for a while trying to find a place that was open. Both times they were friendly and coherent over the phone taking our order. The pizza itself is pretty average. The crust was pretty stretchy, and the pizza didn't really have the flavor or texture to be remembered. The buffalo chicken was made with tenders, and was probably the best thing we ordered. The best part about the honey mustard wings was that they were covered in thick sauce. All in all it wasn't a waste of money coming here, we'll probably keep trying new places and returning to the places we loved.

I was recently in New York for an extended period of time...visiting my mom, family, friends. I…read morealways fly in and out of Syracuse bc 1) my brother lives in Cuse and can pick me up and 2) it's oddly cheaper (usually) than flying into Rochester. I have a sister in Rochester, but she always tells me to "uber it" I always feel the love when I wanna come home from her :-/ Anyway, this past trip, I flew up a little over a week ago and of course, out of Cuse. My brother wanted to treat me to a pizza and we couldn't decide where to go. I always prefer to try places people haven't been to yet. I like it to be a surprise for them as much it is for me. So we called several places. It was a Friday night, I flew out crazy early on Saturday. Naturally, pizza places on a Friday... always busy. Pizza places in a college town...even busier. Syracuse University keeps them busy as hell. Johnny Mac's. So I'm not sure how far or close it is to campus. It's a little bit of a drive from my brothers house. That turned out to be ok bc the wait was only 30 mins, maybe a little less tbh bc the pizza was SLIGHTLY cold when we picked it up. All the other places we called... hour and half for some, 2 hour wait for others. INSANE! For one pizza! Gurl, bye! So we went with this place. One of the best things for me was...my brother had never been. He took one bite and was like .... "It's so good!" Which made going here even better. And yes, the pizza was delicious. Even if slightly cold...it was still amazing and yeah..we have microwaves for a reason lol. The price was decent too. I wanna say $18 and change, if I remember correctly. Don't quote me on that. May have been slightly cheaper. Regardless, the pizza is fantastic and ya can't go wrong. If you've been, you know, if you haven't been, ya need to go. You won't be disappointed. It really is delicious. It's kinda of in a random spot, doesn't look like your typical pizza place, looks more like a little house lol, inside tho ... definitely pizza place vibes. I waited outside with my pup (saw the inside ...bc ya know, windows and stuff lol). It was in and out. Great place. Even tho I said I love to try new places, and I always do, I would absolutely have their pizza again. Wish I had something to say about the staff, but my brother was the one who dealt with them. Great place. I definitely recommend it. Thanks for reading, YelperMac'ers!!! Cheers!

Great pizza - perhaps some of the consistently best pizza I've had in Syracuse. The wings are…read moreequally good, and they let you buy them in 5s, useful if you have multiple people wanting different sauces, or if you just want a smaller order. Their delivery service is great, and seems to be in-house instead of through a third party. Only con is they're closed Mondays, but that's relatively normal, especially considering they're open Sunday. We really love this place, and hope they stick around for a long time to come.

This was so gross. The margarita pizza was mostly sauce and NOT fresh mozzarella, and had no…read morebasil. The cheeseburger fries were inedible.... the meat was charred and it was just a solid mass of fries and cheese. And the grease on the chicken bacon ranch was literally pooling at the bottom of the box. I almost went back to return it but wasn't worth my time.

Grabbed a small Hawaiian pizza here for a light dinner. The crust was excellent. Crisp, yet chewy…read moreand not overly bready. The sauce, and cheese were also very good. The toppings oddly enough were basically only on one half of the pizza, but, they were also fresh and tasty. This place has an amazing amount of specialty pizzas. Way more than I've ever seen anywhere. You could probably spend a month trying them all. Not only that, but they have wings, calzones, stromboli, breaded mushrooms, burgers, gyros, calamari, and on and on..... They are brave to open a location right across the road from Mario & Salvo's, but I wish them well. I will be back,

give me a bib, a 16in, a coke, and a bit of privacy. i judged a book by its cover at first and they…read morehonestly don't have too many options but it's a nice not overwhelming experience. also this pizza made me like italian people again... NOT, but it was delicious. small storefront not a crazy amount of seating but again get that shit to go cause you'll need to be in your own space.

I finally went to Napoli for dinner rather than lunch, which meant I was able to get their square…read moreGrandma's pie. The dough needs time to rise, hence lunchtime is too early to order one. And a round Grandma's is not a true Grandma's, and not an option. I found Napoli's square Grandma's pie to be an experience. It is beautiful to look at; a true work of pizza art. The taste of the ingredients in your mouth is an explosion pizza greatness; you can taste the quality. The crust is perfect with a thin, crisp sub-bottom that transitions into wonderful airy deliciousness topped by fresh mozzarella and a sauce that brings it all together into a crescendo of pizza nirvana. I am straight outta Brooklyn, Bensonhurst to be exact. Napoli pizzeria IS that good. Want to see an artist at work? Go to Napoli. Picasso the pizza maker is creating masterpieces all day. Napoli Pizzeria. Fughedaboudit!!!

I knew I would like this place before I walked in. They had one of those old school signs that…read moremight be 50 years old. Walked in and was greeted by multiple friendly employees. The inside is just the old school look and familiar feel. It was lunch and they had a bunch of flavors of pie ready. I was lucky enough to have a fresh plain cheese come out of the oven. Sauce was good and a little sweet. It was a little floppy but not enough to ruin it. If I lived in this area, this would be my regular spot.

Well I would call bs on the negative reviews here. We are new to Sherrill, and were given several…read moresuggestions for pizza. Tried them and were not impressed. We ordered from NY pizza and it has been the best we have found in town. Just enough crisp on crust. Fresh mushrooms, not canned, great cheese and the crust had the perfect yeast flavor.Mind you the price is a little higher then we are use to , but that seems typical for all pizza places in town.

Located in the plaza next to Costco. Very clean. Staff was…read morevery welcoming and helpful! We ordered a half-half of the wood fired Margherita and Ricotta Be Kidding Me. As per usual, the pizza was perfection! The ingredients are fresh - the basil in the Margherita was so bright! Can't wait to come back!

It's still incredible. I forgot to take pictures because I devoured an entire large Detroit-style…read morebasilios beehive with extra flat iron hot pepper flakes. Honestly, if I had to pick a last meal, this pizza might be it- I'm not kidding. Go buy one.

Clean Friendly Good…read morepizza by the slice Good safe place for family. Not expensive, well lit.

Stopped to get Gyros and pizza at 8:20 pm on Wednesday June 3rd 2026. They said they just cleaned…read morethe grill and they weren't making any more of anything. They close at 9 they said and even tho there were 3 other customers there to get stuff they weren't going to make anything. They were snotty and crude and mean to everyone. They should never be in busy acting and treating their customers that way! Real pissy and And should go out of business poor!!!. They may have eatable foor but attitudes like that don't deserve to have anything to do with the public. SHAME ON ALL THREE EMPLOYEES!!! BAD BUSINESS!!!

So much better from when they first started which is expected. Great eats! Friendly service, staff,…read moreand the drivers are very good, quick and respectful. Nice place indeed!

Since my first visit to Sissy's, I won't go anywhere else for pizza! Sausage pizza, every time with…read morebbq wings, (bone in), and sometimes French Fries. Not only is the food fantastic, but they also deliver. NOBODY will deliver to us, so Sissy's is #1 with us for many reasons!! Try them